Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

I had always thought that Sylvia clearly stated that she gets her "prophecies" from God and that the information about heaven and stuff came from Francine.
I could be mistaken though as I admittingly used logic to slide over many of Sylvia's inconsistancies. As time went on I stopped reading every word she wrote and took the core beliefs and logic so if she said something illogical that contradicted something she previously wrote (which became more frequent), it went right over my head.

I find it interesting what Sylvia writes in "Prophecy" on page 73.


  • Any prophet who feels your attention and adoration should be divided equally between God and the prophet is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who claims to have a closer relationship with God than you do, or to be more special in His eyes than you are, is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who claims you need him or her in order to communicate with God is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who insists that you embrace the prophet's thoughts and opinions rather than exploring and forming your own opinion is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet whose power depends on isolating you from those who've loved, supported and been honest with you is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who asks you to jeapordize or sacrifice your stability or your financial security, especially in the form of a "donation" to the prophet or his or her "church", or whatever the organization is called, is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who tells you that only he or she knows the truth of what God has in store for you, for your future or for humankind is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who believes that anyone who criticizes or disagrees with him or her is evil or deserving of retribution is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet whose ultimate goal is accumulating adoring followers more for the prophet than for God is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who believes he or she is exempt from the laws of God and society and somehow in a position of divine immunity from consequence is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who claims to be infallible is a false prophet.
  • Any prophet who financially gains from his or her gift without seeing to it that worthy causes and the less fortunate are enriched as well by those financial gains is a false prophet. Selfishness, ingratitude and any other form of arrogance, financial or otherwise, toward the very people a psychic, medium, clairvoyant or prophet is here to serve is a guarantee that either the God-given gift will vanish or that there was never a God-given gift to begin with.

Sylvia's own words.
 
Last edited:
Ah, I see. I apologize, I had only read your quote in the context of the post by ConspiRaider you were responding to, rather than traling all the way back up this thread.

I guess the main problem I have always had with "hypothetical" examples of how psychic powers could work, is that they always seem to be excuses for why they don't work, rather than helpful suggestions how how to prove or disprove that they actually work in the first place. [End Grumpy Voice]

I could have been more clear, no doubt.
 
1. The man demonstrates he does not speak or understand English on the level of what we generally consider an 'English speaker'.

2. Lancaster says the man speaks English.

3. I find that questionable.

I don't really see how you can't at least acknowledge that I am using logic on some level, even if you disagree with my general conclusion. I am hardly saying pigs fly.

I think the original accusation that RSL was lying was incorrect, however, I don't think it would hurt for the text in question on the site to be clarified slightly, if for no other reason than to avoid the need for a similar debate at sometime in the future (Sorry if this has been covered, this thread is moving rather fast and I'm playing catch up!)
 
Novus through it's office operations does use some of the same techniques that Scientology uses. "If it isn't written, it doesn't exist", is a prime example. What is sad, is that the very philosophy that Novus supposedly promotes (which they could care less about, it's all about the money garnered from those who do believe) is totally contrary to how they behave and treat others.
I suspect you will find that this "philosophy" actually means that if they want to hide anything, don't write anything down. And if they need to remind people of this, it means they have stuff to hide!

Too easy?
 
I agree that the real question here is will SR ever answer the questions that he himself opened up?
Including why the Novus Hypnosis/Self Help for AIDs/HIV bothers him?

(I had not considered that there ARE some of these "classes" who tell their students to go off all meds and to trust explicably the spiritual practice although I am not aware if this is Novus' practice. I'm not against the power of positive thought ALONG WITH a good doctor but someone ealier in the thread reminded me of how many of these sort of things test the students faith by making them go off their meds. Still learning! ;) )
 
Just a suggestion...with over 1,000 posts and with the topic drifting from the original; perhaps starting new threads on specific topics would be in order?
 
Last edited:
Great stuff. I'd like to throw in this:

Sylvia Rox suggests that perhaps psychics aren't correct all the time because of the "radio station" example he gave.

So then, where are the WRONG answers coming from? I mean, it would be one thing for a psychic to say "I can't always pick up a signal" versus just coming up with fiction out of thin air.

So, I take this assumption to mean "Psychics can't be right all the time, so sometimes they are truly psychic, and the rest of the time they are lying/making it/deluded".

Indeed, arguably SB's even worse, ethically, morally challenged because she didn't tell the Hornbeck family, for example, "I can't always be correct" or "I can't get a reading here there's too much disturbance in the ether..." she stated boldly and confidently her prediction which turned out not only incorrect but egregiously incorrect.

So, SRox, why give her any credibility at all. RSL has shown in notable cases she puts herself out, unqualified, and boldly asserts she's making accurate predictions...when she is clearly, verifiably not.
 
The wrong answers would be coming from other signals in the air. That's what I meant by the radio example. Wrong answers can indeed by psychic, just not from the person the psychic thinks they are from. I'm speaking hypothetically, of course.

So, if you can get wrong signals, how do you tell the differnece. What psychic should go to the police, or a family or on TV and assert the value of their power when they clearly can't distinguish between right or wrong signals. HOw is this a special or unique power when what you are discribing is not better indicator than sticking your finger up in the air and paying attention to your joints when predicting the weather (which may be more accurate a predictor).

Don't you see the power with asserting the existence or value of a "power" that is not only unverifiable but subject to rules that make it useless?

Take SB...what if she is a psychic? IF she is wrong most of the time, if she can't distinguish between good signals and bad signals what is the value of it? Why share it? Every time she has shared her powers on Montel, where it can be verified, she's wrong. More than wrong, as with the Hornbeck's, she hurtful and destructive. It seems to me that her ego and her wallet is more important to her than any power she might have...
 
headscratcher4/Miss Anthrope/SylviaRox – In terms of accuracy I’d have to ask why can’t a true psychic be 100% right?

Eliminating for a moment the "there's too much disturbance" excuses....SB has clearly stated on numerous occasions she gets her insights from her “spirit guide”. As spirit guides are suppose to have "direct access to God's divine knowledge" (reference: http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/contradiction_doangelshavewings.shtml)
…how could SB EVER being wrong when she gives a reading, given these readings, by extension, are the word of God (an omnipotent, all knowing being)?
 
Last edited:
headscratcher4/Miss Anthrope/SylviaRox – In terms of accuracy I’d have to ask why can’t a true psychic be 100% right?

Eliminating for a moment the "there's too much disturbance" excuses....SB has clearly stated on numerous occasions she gets her insights from her “spirit guide” (aka angel). As angels are suppose to be messengers from God…a omnipotent, all knowing being…how could SB EVER being wrong when she gives a reading, given these readings, by extension, are the word of God?
I agree completely, there is no reason at this time given why a "psychic" can't be %100 right...until alleged "psychic" present themselves for testing and analysis with scientists willing/able to set conditions that can't be fooled (a'la the Randi challenge), there is no way to determin anything SRox proposes...maybe it is %100 maybe it is %5? When, how, why? You can't know until you can nail down that the phenomenon exists...and those who claim the power won't let themselves be nailed down...

I love the excuse..."why do I have to?"
 
headscratcher4/Miss Anthrope/SylviaRox – In terms of accuracy I’d have to ask why can’t a true psychic be 100% right?

Eliminating for a moment the "there's too much disturbance" excuses....SB has clearly stated on numerous occasions she gets her insights from her “spirit guide” (aka angel). As angels are suppose to be messengers from God…a omnipotent, all knowing being…how could SB EVER being wrong when she gives a reading, given these readings, by extension, are the word of God?

According to Sylvia (from many of her books), spirit guides and angels are NOT the same. A spirit guide is one who has been in physical body and lived life as a human being.

Angels do not have a physical body, are not human and have never incarnated as they are a different phylum.
ST
 
This isn't really related, but I just noticed somebody has registered StopSylviaBrowne.org and it redirects to a psychic reading website.
 
This isn't really related, but I just noticed somebody has registered StopSylviaBrowne.org and it redirects to a psychic reading website.

yep.

Domain ID:D142455914-LROR
Domain Name:STOPSYLVIABROWNE.ORG
Created On:28-Mar-2007 19:28:31 UTC
Last Updated On:28-May-2007 03:50:03 UTC
Expiration Date:28-Mar-2008 19:28:31 UTC
Sponsoring Registrar:Basic Fusion Inc (R1329-LROR)
Status:OK
Registrant ID:bfc-863vym4a
Registrant Name:Navigation Catalyst Systems, Inc
Registrant Street1:2101 Rosecrans Ave.
Registrant Street2:#2000
Registrant Street3:
Registrant City:El Segundo
Registrant State/Province:CA
Registrant Postal Code:90245
Registrant Country:US
Registrant Phone:+1.3106471592
Registrant Phone Ext.:
Registrant FAX:
Registrant FAX Ext.:
Registrant Email:[email protected]
Admin ID:bfc-x9gcg8yk
Admin Name:Navigation Catalyst Systems, Inc
Admin Street1:2101 Rosecrans Ave.
Admin Street2:#2000
Admin Street3:
Admin City:El Segundo
Admin State/Province:CA
Admin Postal Code:90245
Admin Country:US
Admin Phone:+1.3106471592
Admin Phone Ext.:
Admin FAX:
Admin FAX Ext.:
Admin Email:[email protected]
Tech ID:bfc-6v3nat89
Tech Name:Navigation Catalyst Systems, Inc
Tech Street1:2101 Rosecrans Ave.
Tech Street2:#2000
Tech Street3:
Tech City:El Segundo
Tech State/Province:CA
Tech Postal Code:90245
Tech Country:US
Tech Phone:+1.3106471592
Tech Phone Ext.:
Tech FAX:
Tech FAX Ext.:
Tech Email:[email protected]


ETA:

It seems Fusion Inc. registered by proxy for someone.
 
Angrybeliever--

Didn't see anything to cause you to need that steel blanket.

Me, either, and thank you for sharing that. It gives me even more insight into the people who were drawn in close to Sylvia. I'm so glad you and the others here got out!
 
The wrong answers would be coming from other signals in the air. That's what I meant by the radio example. Wrong answers can indeed by psychic, just not from the person the psychic thinks they are from. I'm speaking hypothetically, of course.
So if the radio signal and receiver analogy is correct, then wouldn't there be MANY psychics getting the same signal, at least some times? Especially if a lot of these signals come from one source (God)?

Also, in the bad old days when AFC wasn't common and radio tuning did drift around, it was readily obvious when you lose one station and start getting another. How could a psychic signal change and still sound like the same spirit guide and still somehow apparently be answering the questions in context? In other words, wouldn't it be obvious when the information coming in doesn't make sense? Yet, by their track records, apparently psychics are on the wrong signal far more often than they're on the correct signal.

Yes, Sylvia admits to less than 100% accuracy, but only when she is confronted with examples of her misses. I've seen her performances on Montel, and I have never seen her indicate in any way that she doesn't somehow have a pipeline to the truth. It's a bunch of play acting, and the woos seem to eat it up. The whole allure of these performances is that she somehow knows. It's key that she never admits to being wrong.

I've never heard her say something like, "Your daughter was shot, but I could be wrong about that."

I see plenty of backpedaling, where "she was shot" becomes "something hit her in the chest" and then "it could be her heart" and eventually agreeing that it could be Toxic Shock Syndrome. So from an absolute, unqualified pronouncement of "she was shot" (due to completely misunderstanding the question being asked--again she was playing the odds on what she thought was a case of a child missing for 5 years) becomes somehow that she could've died of Toxic Shock Syndrome.

In fact, she is guessing and making things up (when she's not eliciting information from the subject by cold reading techniques).

She repeatedly claims that she has helped police with missing person cases, yet there is not one single example where anything she said actually helped any of these cases. So, in regards to that claim, she is at 0%. (Let's face it, getting a lucky hit on something now and then when her readings usually play the odds is no actual help to police. They're aware that in most cases when a child is missing for a long time, the child is probably dead. In an investigation, though, it's much better to keep an open mind unless or until the evidence points to a conclusion.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom