Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

I'd agree with you, if that was a lone prediction put forth for the MDC. But if you put out tens of thousands of predictions and then cherry-pick that one to put forward, I say you should go home empty-handed.

Good point. I was thinking Browne should only share this prediction (death of a pope) with Randi himself, as it would cause considerable public alarm.
 
Any exact correct prediction, such as the death of the pope to the exact minute, should be enough to win the million. I'm not sure you'd want to pick death of a public figure--what if the pope were assassinated at the time she called?

I have never understood people who think that if psychic powers work they should work all the time. Why should they? We have no known mechanism for how the powers should work, so it is easy to imagine that they don't work all the time.
Well first of all it's pure madness to think that if someone could ever discern exactly when a particular person will die - that person is always a public figure. Such as Jeanne Dixon's "blue-eyed Democrat" bogus prediction about JFK.

Why not predict the exact death date/time of a 7-year old girl who succumbs to dysentery in Nepal? Who decided that the death of this girl is less important than the death of a pope? The psychic, that's who. Because the "predicted" death of the pope is an attention getter to the gotta-believe flock.

If someone has psychic powers - whatever the hell that means - then they HAVE TO BE right all the time when making an extremely specific prediction. Look at this: Red. I just communicated a very specific word to you and you absolutely nailed it. No doubt. If you are asked about this and report the word as Mauve, any rational person will conclude that you do in fact have a leak in your attic.

That standard must be applied to psychism. Dead on accuracy. Just as soon as you open the door of "false positives" or "interference" or "I don't feel strong" - well I can hear those cash registers a ringin' already...
 
No. Wrong answers can indeed NOT be psychic. Not even hypothetically.

To use your radio analogy:

I'm at a tower, broadcasting my annoying voice via a medium range AM signal at 930 Khz.

You have a radio tuned to 930 Khz.

Guess what you'll be hearing? Exactly what I'm broadcasting at that particular frequency.

If Slyvia Browne is honed in on a particular person - that person is "sending" her psychic signals - then that is all she'll receive. She'd not going to be skipping around the dial. She's focused in - tuned in - to that particular person's psychic vibrations. ONLY.

What if you can't read you dial any more? You hear stuff, but you aren't sure if you are on the right station.

He is postulating an 'unreliable reception'. It was be a fine idea of there was any evidence for it. Any evidence at all.
 
Worthwhile in what sense? If it could be proven definitively that in 1 out of 100 times a psychic is right (in a way that would be impossible through guessing or cold reading), then that would change our conception of the laws of physics (that last part is a cliché isn't it?). It just wouldn't be particularly 'useful' in a practical sense.

Yes, I meant practical sense, like helping the police find a missing child, or giving advice. I wouldn't want advice from someone who was wrong 99 out of 100 times. But yes, I wouldn't rule out that someone could actually read minds 1 out of 100 times, if "proven definitively," and cold reading etc. was ruled out. It definitely would be worthwhile to test and prove that.
 
I have never understood people who think that if psychic powers work they should work all the time. Why should they? We have no known mechanism for how the powers should work, so it is easy to imagine that they don't work all the time.

If someone has psychic powers - whatever the hell that means - then they HAVE TO BE right all the time when making an extremely specific prediction. Look at this: Red. I just communicated a very specific word to you and you absolutely nailed it. No doubt. If you are asked about this and report the word as Mauve, any rational person will conclude that you do in fact have a leak in your attic....

What if you can't read you dial any more? You hear stuff, but you aren't sure if you are on the right station.

He is postulating an 'unreliable reception'. It was be a fine idea of there was any evidence for it. Any evidence at all.


Here is the thing, IIRC Ms. Browne has explained how her psychic predictions work. Her "spirit guide" Francine gives her the answers. (Someone with more knowledge of SB, please feel free to correct me.)

So to argue against ChristineR's position, it should work all the time.

To argue somewhat for and against ConspiRaider's position, any miscommunication could only happen between Francine and God, or Francine and SB.

(Would you people please get different initials! You are making me type more than I like.)

And finally, to argue against Scotth's position, this would apply to a discussion of psychics in general, but I am not sure it applies to SB.
 
Yes, if SB's predictions are only right a certain percentage of the time, she should specify that in a disclaimer. Like drug companies have to disclose potential side effects, etc.
 
Yes, if SB's predictions are only right a certain percentage of the time, she should specify that in a disclaimer. Like drug companies have to disclose potential side effects, etc.

Yes indeed.

"Before I take your credit card number and charge it for $700, I'd like you to know that sometimes the signals are inaccurate. That's right, my spirit guide, Francine, knows what it is like on heaven and tells me everything, but, she cannot understand who it is I'm talking about all the time."

But no. She doesn't do that. Thus, I enter rantville.

Instead she tells people that their child, having been murdered, is actually a sex slave in Japan. Or crushes people by saying their child is dead, while the child is actually alive. I saw a Montel episode in the late 1990's where Sylvia told a woman about the person she was going to marry, a tall, dark and handsome man. Only the woman was a lesbian. The list goes on and on and on.

If she cannot be correct all the time, she should say so. That would be the only decent thing to do. Why does she know when Britney Spears is going to get divorced, but had no warnings for people working in the Twin Towers? Why are these mistakes just "human errors", but she won't admit to human error before taking people's hard earned money or presenting details as absolute fact, to the horror and pain of those with missing loved ones?

The answers? If Sylvia were psychic and just experienced "normal" misses, then she isn't a good or ethical person because she doesn't advertise this. If Sylvia were connected to the spirit world, and a deeply beautiful spiritual person, she might want people to know that she cannot always be correct before she bills them a month's rent. But, alas, no evidence whatsoever she is a psychic.

The evidence points to greed and deceit.
 
Last edited:
And finally, to argue against Scotth's position, this would apply to a discussion of psychics in general, but I am not sure it applies to SB.

I agree with that completely..... but earlier, SylviaRox had been throwing around the 'hypothetical' word a little.

For hypothetical psychic powers, who's to say how they would work? Who would have guessed that quantum mechanics would work the way it does (or that there would be anything like quantum mechanics at all)? But, it (figuring it out) sure has taught us (humans) how winnow out the most subtle effects, though.
 
Yes, if SB's predictions are only right a certain percentage of the time, she should specify that in a disclaimer. Like drug companies have to disclose potential side effects, etc.

But, she does.... 85% or accurate, or numbers in that region.
:D
 
I agree with that completely..... but earlier, SylviaRox had been throwing around the 'hypothetical' word a little.

For hypothetical psychic powers, who's to say how they would work? Who would have guessed that quantum mechanics would work the way it does (or that there would be anything like quantum mechanics at all)? But, it (figuring it out) sure has taught us (humans) how winnow out the most subtle effects, though.


Ah, I see. I apologize, I had only read your quote in the context of the post by ConspiRaider you were responding to, rather than traling all the way back up this thread.

I guess the main problem I have always had with "hypothetical" examples of how psychic powers could work, is that they always seem to be excuses for why they don't work, rather than helpful suggestions how how to prove or disprove that they actually work in the first place. [End Grumpy Voice]
 
Well, yeah, it does sound pretty stupid to say that Francine is lying to Sylvia. But then Francine is a pretty silly idea to begin with. If she could demonstrate the existence of Francine at all, then we could figure out why Francine is such a tease when it comes to missing children. Who are we to say that spirit guides have to be sincere all the time?
 
Well, yeah, it does sound pretty stupid to say that Francine is lying to Sylvia. But then Francine is a pretty silly idea to begin with. If she could demonstrate the existence of Francine at all, then we could figure out why Francine is such a tease when it comes to missing children. Who are we to say that spirit guides have to be sincere all the time?
Right, they don't have to be ever sincere.

For example my spirit guide is an upside-down billy goat with 3 lips and a tail resembling a cocktail napkin dispenser who wears a babushka every seventh Wednesday and calls himself Ernie. On Thursdays, he's Your Royal Blokessness Gabriel.

There are times when I just don't take Ernie seriously. Beats me, why.
 
Well, yeah, it does sound pretty stupid to say that Francine is lying to Sylvia. But then Francine is a pretty silly idea to begin with. If she could demonstrate the existence of Francine at all, then we could figure out why Francine is such a tease when it comes to missing children. Who are we to say that spirit guides have to be sincere all the time?
Or even competent. Francine might just be a lunatic. What kind of self respecting emotionally stable spirit would hang around SB anyway?
 
Quote:
How can you be such a big believer and then suddenly change your mind.

Originally Posted by SylviaRox
You know...some people (uh oh, I said "some people" again) have seemed to suggest that Sylvia or NS is a cult...I really have to disagree. If you look at the basic tenets of the group as listed on Sylvia's website, they are pretty positive and affirmative ideas and don't have the standard 'closing you off from the real world' characteristics of cults. But it was the strength (unproven, yes) of her psychic powers which made me take her religious ideas much more seriously than I otherwise would have

Hi,
I wanted to respond to these two different quotes from this thread.
My response actually encompasses both quotes, so let me try to articulate this, and preface this by saying, I have a lot of respect for how this thread, and the entire forum has dealt with us, the former NS members. That being said, please don't jump all over me for this post. OK? :)

My journey through this life, has found myself investigating many religious philosophies, beliefs, etc from A to Z. I dabbled or "tried out many", found that they just didn't ring true. Eastern thought is a comfortable one for me, and throw in a bunch of other stuff....and voila, the bouncing ball, called me, that my family never knew what holiday card to send.

I have always been a questioner, and spent many a day after school or sitting outside on the bench at church for "daring" to question "truths".

I finally settled into a thought system that was actually quite unique for me....hey, just be the best that I can be, and treat others with the same respect and regard, all else is gravy.

When I attended my first lecture almost 20 yrs ago, Sylvia happened to be talking about the Novus philosophy, and what that entailed. I sat up, for I was just expecting something else to come from a 'psychic', you know.

Well, my first thought was, "My Gosh, She is saying the same things that I have been saying or thinking for years". So, that is why I came to Novus, for the philosophy. Did I like her? Absolutely. She was earthy, funny and as others have pointed out, made you feel like you had known her forever.

I still believe in the philosophy (this is the part where you need to not throw heavy objects), and respect that you probably won't understand that, and I won't defend it. But, I can no longer believe in or defend a person who I have come to understand (gratefully from all the factual information on this forum and RSL's) has such a callous disregard for human feeling. Sylvia tells a story about a reading done when she first started out, and a woman came and during the course of her reading, asked when she was going to be reunited with her recently deceased husband. Sylvia responded to her along the lines of 'it won't be long' or some such. The woman was distraught, and ran out of office. When Sylvia asked her guide Francine, if the information was correct, Francine couldn't understand why she was distraught for it was going to be years. For to the other side, time is but an illusion. Sylvia states that she told Francine, that her information had to be clearer so that people weren't scared to death (paraphrasing a lot here guys). I think of that now whenever I read the sad stories of comments made to people who have asked her for help. Unconscionable is how I describe Sylvia now, and I can not believe in someone who is like this. If I had known all these stories before, I would have left sooner.


As to cult....well, I was in Scientology for sometime, and escaped from that loony bin. Novus through it's office operations does use some of the same techniques that Scientology uses. "If it isn't written, it doesn't exist", is a prime example. What is sad, is that the very philosophy that Novus supposedly promotes (which they could care less about, it's all about the money garnered from those who do believe) is totally contrary to how they behave and treat others. Their public lecture faces are very different than the ones you will find if you volunteer long enough at lectures, volunteer in the office (which few are allowed), or find yourself on the list of "they still think for themselves", but they help and donate, so we will just keep a tight rein on them.

Her sanction of the GSB website is further evidence of control. They are posting that members should stay over there and NOT go to other sites, or read anything contrary (negative), and just stay there and 'be happy'.

THIS IS SO CONTRARY TO WHAT THE PHILOSOPHY IS, and it makes me sick. I don't expect anyone to understand that those of us who left the group did so because of just this behavior in particular. Sylvia uses this as a way of getting people to buy more. IF you question their behavior...it is YOUR ego that is out of whack.

Thanks for listening to my responses, emotional that they are. I know that Sylvia has been making calls to some of the ministers and group members who left. I can tell you that if she calls me, it will be an earful that she hasn't heard from anyone in a while.


Ok, I have pulled the steel blanket over my head, so if you MUST through objects it won't mess up my hair.
 
I still believe in the philosophy (this is the part where you need to not throw heavy objects), and respect that you probably won't understand that, and I won't defend it.

Ok, I have pulled the steel blanket over my head, so if you MUST through objects it won't mess up my hair.

AB, I don't think there's a rule for skeptics to convert other people. My view of skepticism is that they take an evidence-based approach to belief. There's nothing in there about making anyone else do it. Yes, we whine and moan when we see damage done by others' lack of skepticism but that's because we're also human.

Anyway, I fully appreciate your need to believe in something, to have a guiding principle. However, I don't understand why you need a church and all. Won't a small group of like-minded people do? (You can see that I'm not much of a joiner.)

I've always felt that, in theological terms, a large organization is doomed to failure due to the laws of the universe. That is, once you exceed a certain size, you bring in things like logistics and committees and rule-making and all that rot which is what most people wanted to escape by believing in a system that would get them away from all that stuff. Also, the larger the group of people, the more politics and corruption your credo will be exposed to. Why do you want to draw that into your spiritual life?

Seriously, save yourself a lot of turmoil and try to cut out the middleman if you can. You are seeking an understanding of life by communicating with a deity, yes? Then, why the **** do you need a Sylvia, a pope, a minister, a duchess, a psychic, etc to accomplish those goals? I'm sure you've met a few people who believe like you do at your old NS church. If you've found a path you're happy with, put on your own show.

My two cents. I'm sorry if I offended but those are my personal observations.
 
Or even competent. Francine might just be a lunatic. What kind of self respecting emotionally stable spirit would hang around SB anyway?

Agreed! Sylvia does indeed have psychic powers! She does not lie ever. It's Francine who is evil! Wow, I get it now. It all makes sense. And Gallagher is funny!
 
If that guess were nearly impossible to get any other way (i.e., Sylvia accurately predicts the hour, day, month and year of the death of the Pope, and the prediction is made public before the event).

This seems to be something that believers in psychics never seem to understand. If someone knows something about a crime, the most likely explanation is not that they are psychic, it is that they were somehow involved with it. If any psychics ever does provide details about a case that they should not have known they will not be celebrated for helping the police, they will be arrested as a murder suspect.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom