Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Great stuff. I'd like to throw in this:

Sylvia Rox suggests that perhaps psychics aren't correct all the time because of the "radio station" example he gave.

So then, where are the WRONG answers coming from? I mean, it would be one thing for a psychic to say "I can't always pick up a signal" versus just coming up with fiction out of thin air.

So, I take this assumption to mean "Psychics can't be right all the time, so sometimes they are truly psychic, and the rest of the time they are lying/making it/deluded".

The wrong answers would be coming from other signals in the air. That's what I meant by the radio example. Wrong answers can indeed by psychic, just not from the person the psychic thinks they are from. I'm speaking hypothetically, of course.
 
Cool, my mistake then. See he's got like 11,000 posts or so plus he's a dictator so naturally I assumed "mod". They told me when I joined JREF forum that after you do 10,000 posts or more that you become a mod by default. Like squatter's rights, or common law marriage or honorary degree from Yale for POTUS. Like that. Come to think of it, Tricky was the one who told me that stuff!!!11one!!1111!!!
What the hell??!!

So I should be a mod twice over, at least! OK, admins! I want at least a star next to my name!



Oh shoot - that means Claus would be a mod too. No - bad idea. Lalalalalala!
 
What the hell??!!

So I should be a mod twice over, at least! OK, admins! I want at least a star next to my name!



Oh shoot - that means Claus would be a mod too. No - bad idea. Lalalalalala!

So would t'ai--
very bad idea
 
If there were a smoking gun (i.e.: getting the name and location of a murderer, or finding a child before the police could do it) which absolutely proved Sylvia was a true psychic, then I would stop any doubt, even if she got dozens of other cases dead wrong. I just kind of presumed that at least some level of strong evidence existed before.
So, one right guess out of tens of thousands of wrong guesses, and you'd throw all logic out the window and consider the case closed?
 
So, one right guess out of tens of thousands of wrong guesses, and you'd throw all logic out the window and consider the case closed?

If that guess were nearly impossible to get any other way (i.e., Sylvia accurately predicts the hour, day, month and year of the death of the Pope, and the prediction is made public before the event).
 
The wrong answers would be coming from other signals in the air. That's what I meant by the radio example. Wrong answers can indeed by psychic, just not from the person the psychic thinks they are from. I'm speaking hypothetically, of course.

Before we consider filtering right signals from wrong signals, should we not first consider whether there as any signals in the first place?
 
Even a 5% success rate would be spectacular and easy to document. 5% success rate is plenty high enough to NOT be wasting law enforcement's time.
I agree with this and would say that Sylvia deserves the million dollars if she could do this.

But if Sylvia knows that she "can't be right all the time", why does she make her pronouncements with such an air of certainty? Several times I have watched that segement where she told Shawn Hornbeck's parents that he wasn't alive, and there wasn't a trace of hesitation or an inkling of doubt. I saw her declare the miners alive without a trace of doubt and then change her declaration as soon as she heard that she was wrong, also without a shade of doubt or acknowledgement that she had been wrong. She doesn't lead in with "I don't think..." or "As far as I can tell..." or even "Probably..." With the Hornbecks, she just let fly with a definite "no" like she was talking to Shawn in heaven at the time. Every sideshow carney knows that a show of confidence is the way to sucker the rubes. It has nothing to do with honesty and everything to do with selling your BS.

Apparently her great training in Christianity completely missed the part about being humble.
 
Last edited:
If that guess were nearly impossible to get any other way (i.e., Sylvia accurately predicts the hour, day, month and year of death of the Pope, and the prediction is made public before the event).
And how many wrong guesses would it take before you just gave up and turned your back on her? Give a number, and I'm sure we could show them to you.
 
If that guess were nearly impossible to get any other way (i.e., Sylvia accurately predicts the hour, day, month and year of the death of the Pope, and the prediction is made public before the event).

Any guess has a chance of being right. Any guess; no guess is impossible. And the more guesses you throw out there, the more the likelihood any one guess will have of coming true. If I throw a million guesses out there, then the one guess that I get right could easily have a one in a million chance of being right; that IS part of the point of shotgunning predictions. Make five predictions, and if one seems even a little right, well, let's go with that!

But okay, anyways, that's regardless of my main point. Here's my main point:

A psychic gets hundreds of guesses wrong, but the one guess she gets right is incredibly specific? I mean, hour, day, month, and year of the death of a single person, made public before the event? It raises an intriguing question:

If her psychic predictions are incredibly accurate, why are they so inaccurate all the other times?
 
If that guess were nearly impossible to get any other way (i.e., Sylvia accurately predicts the hour, day, month and year of the death of the Pope, and the prediction is made public before the event).


The pope prediction didn't happen the way you are suggesting. Please read this thread for more information (warning, a lot of the thread linked here is fluff, but there is good information as well).

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448080#post2448080
 
The wrong answers would be coming from other signals in the air. That's what I meant by the radio example. Wrong answers can indeed by psychic, just not from the person the psychic thinks they are from. I'm speaking hypothetically, of course.
No. Wrong answers can indeed NOT be psychic. Not even hypothetically.

To use your radio analogy:

I'm at a tower, broadcasting my annoying voice via a medium range AM signal at 930 Khz.

You have a radio tuned to 930 Khz.

Guess what you'll be hearing? Exactly what I'm broadcasting at that particular frequency.

If Slyvia Browne is honed in on a particular person - that person is "sending" her psychic signals - then that is all she'll receive. She'd not going to be skipping around the dial. She's focused in - tuned in - to that particular person's psychic vibrations. ONLY.

Otherwise what good is her talent? She's got God on her side, right? Wouldn't he keep that "station" tuned in until such time as Slyvia dropped it out?
 
SR,

There are many of us on this board, and even more scattered about, who have tried for years to defend SB, uphold what she says, and have, at times, been outright rabid in upholding her and what she teaches.

If you were to take all NS members and Study Group members and line them up, and then line up all of the ex-members, you would find that the latter far outweighs the current members.

Publicly I praised SB, taught only her materials, devoted a lot of time, and money, to spreading her "message", defended everything she did and said, and always looked for reasons to believe her, but privately I spoke with other NS people and compared what we really saw and experienced. It was very hard to come to the realization that what we had invested our emotions, time, efforts, money, dreams, aspirations, etc... was really a huge fraud.

SB is a master hypnotist, so it is very possible that she can make suggestions that most would not pick up on (now, for everyone here, this applies to those who believe in hypnosis), so would have a leg up on mind control (again, if one chooses to believe in that). And from dealing with those on the inside of NS, it is not a pleasant thing.

I will present FACTS and TRUTH, and I will back up everything I say. SB may call me a liar, may call me Evil, may call me Dark, but as long as I stand on the Truth, then she can not refute that information. Plus, it helps when her closest people love to talk.

It is hard to really look at facts, but if you felt that the philosophy of NS rang true to you, then you do not have to abandon everything, just begin seeking out the truth, finding your own truth, and searching and researching everything you can.

There are others out here who have gone through the same processes, and we have continued on.
 
The pope prediction didn't happen the way you are suggesting. Please read this thread for more information (warning, a lot of the thread linked here is fluff, but there is good information as well).

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2448080#post2448080
I don't think Rox was suggesting that Browne made that prediction. I believe that was a made-up example on his part of a prediction which, if made, would be impressive. Note that he phrases it in future tense:

SylviaRox said:
"If that guess were nearly impossible to get any other way (i.e., Sylvia accurately predicts the hour, day, month and year of the death of the Pope, and the prediction is made public before the event)."
 
Any exact correct prediction, such as the death of the pope to the exact minute, should be enough to win the million. I'm not sure you'd want to pick death of a public figure--what if the pope were assassinated at the time she called?

I have never understood people who think that if psychic powers work they should work all the time. Why should they? We have no known mechanism for how the powers should work, so it is easy to imagine that they don't work all the time.

(Remember the guy who drank Red Bull and did push-ups to improve his accuracy rate? True, he bombed even with his Red Bull, but there is nothing implausible about the idea that mind reading requires physical stamina.)

Most importantly of all, if we could establish that psychic powers work but only under some conditions we'd have a powerful tool for studying this incredible new scientific phenomenon! The first thing we'd do would be to test psychics under every possible set of conditions to figure out which ones work.

And even a one time in a hundred power that is capable of doing things mundane things on demand, like guessing a playing card is easy to test and capable of winning the million. It just requires a lot trials.
 
I don't think Rox was suggesting that Browne made that prediction. I believe that was a made-up example on his part of a prediction which, if made, would be impressive. Note that he phrases it in future tense:


Going back and re-reading his post, I think you are correct. It probably was simply an example. However, I would recommend that thread for any lurkers who may believe that Ms. Browne did predict the Pope's death.

SR, if you meant your post to be hypothetical, I apologize for misunderstanding.
 
Any exact correct prediction, such as the death of the pope to the exact minute, should be enough to win the million.
I'd agree with you, if that was a lone prediction put forth for the MDC. But if you put out tens of thousands of predictions and then cherry-pick that one to put forward, I say you should go home empty-handed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom