Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

No, I can't acknowledge this because on the follow-up to the Cooper Anderson show where she was torn to pieces, Browne trotted out Linda Rossi with a whole video and story trying to authenticate and validate Browne. The video actually added to the argument against Browne doing good.
Good point, Reno.

Rox, if you haven't already done so, please read the following article on my site:

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/ac360_brownesbestevidence.shtml

Make sure you watch the linked video as well.
 
Almo, please read through at least the more recent posts on this thread; Sylviarox has moderated his position somewhat, and replying directly to the OP at this point is a bit counterproductive.

[/delurk]
 
So a cold reader's predictions can come out true?

Of course they could. Even a stopped clock is right twice a day. I'm not saying they would be very accurate, but if they are good, there's nothing saying they won't get one or two things right.
 
Lemme see, I'm 49 years old and have never used the term "gaydar" once. Must be a kid's thing. You're a whippersnapper, right?

I'm 50. Gay. Have gaydar. Know its limitations (false negatives - often reports "straight" when it should report "gay").

"gaydar" has been around for decades.

Unfortunately, so have I.
 
ConspiRaider, you were the 911th reply in this thread. 911!

Surely that's no coincidence! And your user name refers to conspiracies! What more proof do you need!?

Of course, it's overall post number 912. . . .


TruthBeTold, your post was post number 911! 911!

Surely that's no coincidence! And your user name has "Truth" in it! What more proof do you need!?


Oh sorry--wrong forum.
Joe I think you're onto something. If you check page 17 of this enormous thread and look at post 668, there I am too. Mentioning that I saw the post count from the main page was 666 and I had to jump JREF through that, but quick.

So 911 and 666, plus a 15-yard penalty against the JREF defense for piling on (me), plus an almost complete rejection of the heartrending Hooftie The Buckling saga at the Forum Community May TLA awards thread.

SYLVIA (Calgon) TAKE ME AWAY!!!11one!!
 
SylviaRox, I'm curious as to what inspired your original post in the first place, especially given the fact that you expected it to be deleted. Although it may not have been scripted, it did appear to be well thought out with the references to Kaz and Montel.

Was there something that happened recently, or any other particular trigger for your post?
 
Well SR in regards to your original post, i am sorry you feel so negative about Robert Lancaster bringing down the not so talented cold reader Sylvia Brown....(i say this because all the evidence points to this if you disagree please have supporting evidence to show me other wise).

Mr. Lancaster's first web site was about Kaz the person who traveled the country claiming to be a 9 -11 survivor, but we know (it's an evidence thing) that Kaz was nothing she claimed to be.

And you are aware that Montel doesn't believe Sylvia can talk to the dead???? He has said it many times.....
 
You know...some people (uh oh, I said "some people" again) have seemed to suggest that Sylvia or NS is a cult...I really have to disagree. If you look at the basic tenets of the group as listed on Sylvia's website, they are pretty positive and affirmative ideas and don't have the standard 'closing you off from the real world' characteristics of cults. But it was the strength (unproven, yes) of her psychic powers which made me take her religious ideas much more seriously than I otherwise would have.

I really can't think of any cult that actually advertises that they use cult tactics. If you look at the Church of Scientology, it too has positive and affirmative ideas. It's a bait and switch operation, like most cults, they lure you into thinking that it's a harmless religion that can only help, then the next thing you know, you're locked in a room, starving to death to get rid of the evil thetans in your body.
 
I'm 50. Gay. Have gaydar. Know its limitations (false negatives - often reports "straight" when it should report "gay").

"gaydar" has been around for decades.

Unfortunately, so have I.
No it's fortunate yer still around. I didn't even do anything wrong either and they want to insist that I'll be 50 this year. Smart alecks.

I've gotten around in the world rather well but nonetheless, there are still shocking gaps in my knowledge, and some kind folks wised me up in a NY minute about "gaydar". While I still insist that it's a stupid word at least I'm now clued in as to its correct usage and meaning. Apparently there's a whole family of related words:

GuinDar: "Let's find another bar, I doubt they have Guinness on tap."

GrayDar: "Nobody struts Santa Monica Boulevard with a Warren G. Harding tattoo. Betcha she's ain't no natural blonde."

GoreDar: "See that flock of pigeons flying in Al's shadow? That's a lotta pasta. He ain't running in 2008..."

GillDar: "So when I finally meet the right someone, I found out she's... She's a fish. (Tom Hanks from the movie Splash!)"
 
Sylviarox said:
As far as why psychics can't always be right: hypothetically, for the same reason that you can pick up two different radio stations at the same time while flipping through channels (forgive the crudity of my 'science'), or it could be subconscious influences from your own life, or personal biases filtering the vision. It doesn't bother me conceptually.

Let's say some people do have psychic power, but it doesn't always work for one of the reasons you hypothesized about above (or another similar reason). Would it be worthwhile if it only works 1 out of 5 or 10 or 20 or 100 times? Or if the reliability of the power isn't or can't be known? Someone like Sylvia shouldn't be telling the police she can help the if her powers or unreliable--it's a waste of their resources. Or if she gives anyone advice.

With science you specify reliability whenever possible (polls that have a 3% margin of error for example). If psychic power is real, maybe we can test it and determine how reliable it is. From the evidence however, it sure sounds like it only exists in our imaginations.
 
1. Just because only one person explicitly stated they believed I'm Sylvia's manager does not mean only one person believed it (or "said it", who knows what goes in on PMs?).

But you said some people said it, not some people suspect it or believe it. (How do you know what people believe if they didn't express that belief? Surely you're not psychic? :) )

Or are you saying that you were responding in the thread to allegations made in PMs? If that's so, I completely misread what you said. In the thread no one explicitly said that. One person implied it by addressing a message to "Linda".
2. This thread grew massively and certainly it is possible to get things jumbled. Would you suggest that I should have gone through all 20 pages or so, and used Firefox to search for the word manager or Linda just to make sure it was 'some people' and not 'one person'?
I don't follow this. I am suggesting that you don't make a mountain out of a molehill--or better yet, that you don't make false statements. You made it sound like there were several people accusing you of being Sylvia's manager in a false disguise. That's not true. If you are going to make the claim, then yes, I expect YOU to check first to make sure the claim is true.
4. You are reading too far into it. You are no expert on my thinking patterns. I know you are going to throw the German thing back at me ("well you made such a trivial point such a big deal, too"), but this is different, as the context of my 'some people' statement was much more casual.
Again, I said twice before that I recognize that it's a trivial thing. It's more about how exaggeration can become a flat out falsehood very quickly. I was ready to let it pass, but then you made that little parenthetical dig as if I was criticizing you for using the words "some people" in any context at all.

As for your thinking patterns:

Please, please, in the light of your current understanding, go back and read your OP, and ask where all that came from. You thought you knew that Robert Lancaster was distorting the truth about Sylvia. You thought you knew that Sylvia's Hornbeck reading was mostly accurate. You thought you knew that Sylvia was correct 85% of the time. In fact, you didn't know any of those things.

You've backed off a little on your more egregious claims, but you still seem stuck somehow with Sylvia.

I'm not sure what your current drift is. The fact that Sylvia has many critics and few apologists (on the web, that is) somehow makes her more credible?

Again, most of us on this forum would love to discuss the content of claims that Sylvia is a psychic. How many people believe her claims is irrelevant--and I would say the same even if no one in the whole world believed her. What is relevant, is that no one seems to be able to produce any evidence at all that Sylvia has ever helped the police in a missing person case.
 
Sylviarox said:

Let's say some people do have psychic power, but it doesn't always work for one of the reasons you hypothesized about above (or another similar reason). Would it be worthwhile if it only works 1 out of 5 or 10 or 20 or 100 times? Or if the reliability of the power isn't or can't be known? Someone like Sylvia shouldn't be telling the police she can help the if her powers or unreliable--it's a waste of their resources. Or if she gives anyone advice.

With science you specify reliability whenever possible (polls that have a 3% margin of error for example). If psychic power is real, maybe we can test it and determine how reliable it is. From the evidence however, it sure sounds like it only exists in our imaginations.

Great stuff. I'd like to throw in this:

Sylvia Rox suggests that perhaps psychics aren't correct all the time because of the "radio station" example he gave.

So then, where are the WRONG answers coming from? I mean, it would be one thing for a psychic to say "I can't always pick up a signal" versus just coming up with fiction out of thin air.

So, I take this assumption to mean "Psychics can't be right all the time, so sometimes they are truly psychic, and the rest of the time they are lying/making it/deluded".
 
I've read just about every post in this thread, and would like to add my 2p.
Please keep in mind, that these are only my opinions.

Maybe it's the Guinness I've had tonight, but I'm not sure I fully understand this thread.

SylviaRox has made their points from the start: They feel Rob's site is somewhat slanderous (or, at the least, full of misinformation), that Sylvia has a distinguished record with police agencies and has a 85% success rate, etc.

However, every time someone asks for some verification to 'Rox's claims, the same mantra comes out again & again; "That's NOT what this is about". Well, why not? Why make claims that seem rather outrageous, but offer no proof to back them up? Rob DOES offer proof to his claims and statements: links, direct quotes, videos, etc. All 'Rox has done, is just state the same thing whenever asked to cough up even the smallest proof (verifiable or otherwise). Anyone can make a statement claiming anything; proving it, though, is what's really important.

That's why I think this isn't going anywhere. Rob's proof is there, for any and all to see; Sylvia's, however, is only what she says it is, and she expects us to take her word for it. If we don't, well then, we are the ones with the problems, not her.

The burden of proof isn't on Rob...it's on 'Rox. Saying "That's NOT what this is about" anytime anyone asks for some type of conformation isn't really helping 'Rox's argument any. It's just going in circles, and that's the reason I feel this thread is just spinning its' wheels.

I know this post will probably be dissected and have flaws pointed out in it; that's fine. I expect no less. :D

Oh, and by the way..."That IS what this is about."
 
The burden of proof isn't on Rob...it's on 'Rox. Saying "That's NOT what this is about" anytime anyone asks for some type of conformation isn't really helping 'Rox's argument any. It's just going in circles, and that's the reason I feel this thread is just spinning its' wheels.
If you're expecting a conversion to skepticism for SR, then yes, the thread is probably (though not definitely) spinning its wheels. But you know, in every thread like this one you hear some great stuff. You get some great stories. You may even do some introspection and learn something about yourself.

So maybe we can simply lower our expectations for this thread and glean the great stuff that so many here have posted. Heck, we've had at least one Language Award nomination. Whether or not SylviaRox experiences a catharsis or an intellectual awakening is not the only important thing here.
 
If you're expecting a conversion to skepticism for SR, then yes, the thread is probably (though not definitely) spinning its wheels. But you know, in every thread like this one you hear some great stuff. You get some great stories. You may even do some introspection and learn something about yourself.

So maybe we can simply lower our expectations for this thread and glean the great stuff that so many here have posted. Heck, we've had at least one Language Award nomination. Whether or not SylviaRox experiences a catharsis or an intellectual awakening is not the only important thing here.

Well, my expectations aren't that high to begin with... :D
 
Sylviarox said:

Let's say some people do have psychic power, but it doesn't always work for one of the reasons you hypothesized about above (or another similar reason). Would it be worthwhile if it only works 1 out of 5 or 10 or 20 or 100 times? Or if the reliability of the power isn't or can't be known? Someone like Sylvia shouldn't be telling the police she can help the if her powers or unreliable--it's a waste of their resources. Or if she gives anyone advice.

If I thought Sylvia was right even 5% of the time, I would expect her to be at the police station every single day.

When I say 'right', I mean significantly right, as in busting a murder/missing person case wide open on the spot. That is what Sylvia says she does. But there has never been a case when she has contributed anything even slightly useful.

Back to that 5% figure. Even a 5% success rate would be spectacular and easy to document. 5% success rate is plenty high enough to NOT be wasting law enforcement's time. Do 100 case readings, and break just 5 cases open and I'd be absolutely convinced there was something to it and completely support the police checking out every utterance from her lips.


This returns me to SylviaRox....

Sylvia has busted open a grand total of zero cases. That is the bottom line. She is a fraud.
 
Last edited:
Sylviarox said:

Let's say some people do have psychic power, but it doesn't always work for one of the reasons you hypothesized about above (or another similar reason). Would it be worthwhile if it only works 1 out of 5 or 10 or 20 or 100 times? Or if the reliability of the power isn't or can't be known? Someone like Sylvia shouldn't be telling the police she can help the if her powers or unreliable--it's a waste of their resources. Or if she gives anyone advice.

With science you specify reliability whenever possible (polls that have a 3% margin of error for example). If psychic power is real, maybe we can test it and determine how reliable it is. From the evidence however, it sure sounds like it only exists in our imaginations.

Worthwhile in what sense? If it could be proven definitively that in 1 out of 100 times a psychic is right (in a way that would be impossible through guessing or cold reading), then that would change our conception of the laws of physics (that last part is a cliché isn't it?). It just wouldn't be particularly 'useful' in a practical sense.
 
I've read just about every post in this thread, and would like to add my 2p.
Please keep in mind, that these are only my opinions.

Maybe it's the Guinness I've had tonight, but I'm not sure I fully understand this thread.

SylviaRox has made their points from the start: They feel Rob's site is somewhat slanderous (or, at the least, full of misinformation), that Sylvia has a distinguished record with police agencies and has a 85% success rate, etc.

However, every time someone asks for some verification to 'Rox's claims, the same mantra comes out again & again; "That's NOT what this is about". Well, why not? Why make claims that seem rather outrageous, but offer no proof to back them up? Rob DOES offer proof to his claims and statements: links, direct quotes, videos, etc. All 'Rox has done, is just state the same thing whenever asked to cough up even the smallest proof (verifiable or otherwise). Anyone can make a statement claiming anything; proving it, though, is what's really important.

That's why I think this isn't going anywhere. Rob's proof is there, for any and all to see; Sylvia's, however, is only what she says it is, and she expects us to take her word for it. If we don't, well then, we are the ones with the problems, not her.

The burden of proof isn't on Rob...it's on 'Rox. Saying "That's NOT what this is about" anytime anyone asks for some type of conformation isn't really helping 'Rox's argument any. It's just going in circles, and that's the reason I feel this thread is just spinning its' wheels.

I know this post will probably be dissected and have flaws pointed out in it; that's fine. I expect no less. :D

Oh, and by the way..."That IS what this is about."

I was saying "that's not what this is about" to those who were asking me to prove Sylvia is legit. Even if Sylvia is a total fraud, it is still possible to lie or misrepresent information about her in an attempt to further defame her. Sort of like how the Nazis can have been butchers, but it's still not true they made lampshades out of human skin. Her legitimacy was irrelevant to my general point, which was anti-Lancaster, and which I have now recanted.
 
But you said some people said it, not some people suspect it or believe it. (How do you know what people believe if they didn't express that belief? Surely you're not psychic? :) )

Or are you saying that you were responding in the thread to allegations made in PMs? If that's so, I completely misread what you said. In the thread no one explicitly said that. One person implied it by addressing a message to "Linda".

I don't follow this. I am suggesting that you don't make a mountain out of a molehill--or better yet, that you don't make false statements. You made it sound like there were several people accusing you of being Sylvia's manager in a false disguise. That's not true. If you are going to make the claim, then yes, I expect YOU to check first to make sure the claim is true.

Again, I said twice before that I recognize that it's a trivial thing. It's more about how exaggeration can become a flat out falsehood very quickly. I was ready to let it pass, but then you made that little parenthetical dig as if I was criticizing you for using the words "some people" in any context at all.

As for your thinking patterns:

Please, please, in the light of your current understanding, go back and read your OP, and ask where all that came from. You thought you knew that Robert Lancaster was distorting the truth about Sylvia. You thought you knew that Sylvia's Hornbeck reading was mostly accurate. You thought you knew that Sylvia was correct 85% of the time. In fact, you didn't know any of those things.

You've backed off a little on your more egregious claims, but you still seem stuck somehow with Sylvia.

I'm not sure what your current drift is. The fact that Sylvia has many critics and few apologists (on the web, that is) somehow makes her more credible?

Again, most of us on this forum would love to discuss the content of claims that Sylvia is a psychic. How many people believe her claims is irrelevant--and I would say the same even if no one in the whole world believed her. What is relevant, is that no one seems to be able to produce any evidence at all that Sylvia has ever helped the police in a missing person case.

It is impossible to not make the occasional false statement in casual conversation. I also didn't say the accusation was explicit. I merely said it had been said, and indeed, I consider Ground's statement to have been an accusation.

If you read my last few posts more closely, you will see I was suggesting that her lack of defenders made it more difficult to make a decision regarding her legitimacy, as I have only seen two polarized perspectives (Sylvia and her organization, or StopSylviaBrowne.com). I was not suggesting it made her more legitimate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom