Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Here is what is bothering me:

There appear to be practically no defenders of Browne or her reputation besides herself and affiliated websites. This just seems odd to me.

By the way...another thing that's bothering me somewhat: http://www.novus.org/home/hivaids_reg.cfm

There used to be alot of defenders but then they found the truth.
Maybe if Sylvia acted as if she thought she did anything wrong or if she did anything to humble herself, people might have backed her a little longer but she never did. Instead she kicked many of us who spent a long time working toward her supposed goal and defending her nearly imperfect record.

What bothers you about the hypnosis/self healing for HIV/Aids?
Do you think that if Novus crumbles that there won't be humanitarian acts that will still go on? (They Will)
The fact that it's free for a $25 donation?
What?
 
Here is what is bothering me:

There appear to be practically no defenders of Browne or her reputation besides herself and affiliated websites. This just seems odd to me. If you Google Sylvia Browne, or Sylvia Browne proof, etc., the great majority of sites you see are skeptic's sites, blogs and other material, much of which is a good deal more acidic than Lancaster's site.

[/url]


Could this be because anyone who takes a fair look at SB, the evidence and her claims could only conclude that she is indefensible? If nothing else, the Hornbeck reading alone should have made SB supporters begin to question what she was claiming verses what actually occured.

BTW...and I ask this sincerely...earlier on you argued, as SB has, that psychics can't be 100% accurate? Why not?

How woud they know when they are wrong? And if they don't know when they are wrong, what is the difference between psychic ability and a very educated guess or a good cold reader?
 
Here is what is bothering me:

There appear to be practically no defenders of Browne or her reputation besides herself and affiliated websites. This just seems odd to me. If you Google Sylvia Browne, or Sylvia Browne proof, etc., the great majority of sites you see are skeptic's sites, blogs and other material, much of which is a good deal more acidic than Lancaster's site.

So if you are asking me to state my current position on Sylvia or Lancaster, I really can't do it. It would be like asking me to state my opinion on God after reading only the Bible (or, in this case, Sylvia-related material) and then directly after, reading Richard Dawkins (in this case, Lancaster's site). I need to see the best possible arguments for Browne, and given she is such a public figure and intelligent people everywhere try to defend some pretty difficult to defend people (Hitler and Stalin, for example), one would think there would be more apologists, given her popularity. And as I said at the beginning I am not schooled enough in these subjects to try to defend her myself.

By the way...another thing that's bothering me somewhat: http://www.novus.org/home/hivaids_reg.cfm

That's still an answer, and it's one I appreciate.

Obviously a skeptic would infer that there isn't much defense of her, because there is no evidence other than cold reading. This comes from someone who was a cold reader herself, by the way. Someone who truly believed it was real. I think I did a better job than Sylvia, btw.

The link you gave bothers me as well. I lost a brother to AIDS and my oldest friend has transitioned from HIV to AIDS. He tries all manner of stuff like this to try to help himself, and sometimes he believes in them so firmly he quits taking his medications. As much of a skeptic as I am, I only push when he chooses "woo" over his medications. I don't criticize his beliefs.

Can you share what bothers you about it to help along the discussion?
 
Could this be because anyone who takes a fair look at SB, the evidence and her claims could only conclude that she is indefensible? If nothing else, the Hornbeck reading alone should have made SB supporters begin to question what she was claiming verses what actually occured.

BTW...and I ask this sincerely...earlier on you argued, as SB has, that psychics can't be 100% accurate? Why not?

How woud they know when they are wrong? And if they don't know when they are wrong, what is the difference between psychic ability and a very educated guess or a good cold reader?

No...no I don't think so, because so many seemingly indefensible ideas and people have been defended endlessly over the years by many brilliant minds. One would think that at the very least there would be some false testimonials, and fake evidence presented to support her.

As far as why psychics can't always be right: hypothetically, for the same reason that you can pick up two different radio stations at the same time while flipping through channels (forgive the crudity of my 'science'), or it could be subconscious influences from your own life, or personal biases filtering the vision. It doesn't bother me conceptually. The difference between a psychic and someone good at extracting information without you knowing would be that many of their predictions would have to come out true and have been affirmed to them.
 
Headscratcher,
That's exactly right. Before stumbling on Lancaster's site alot of what I heard was rumor but you just can't argue with cold hard facts.
After reading the things that Robert has consolidated and the things I've learned in here, it's virtually impossible to NOT question everything about Sylvia Browne and Novus!

And there has been no proof to the contrary, i.e. validations regardless of how many open invitations there have been for those who have stories or validations to come forward!
 
Here is what is bothering me:

There appear to be practically no defenders of Browne or her reputation besides herself and affiliated websites. This just seems odd to me. If you Google Sylvia Browne, or Sylvia Browne proof, etc., the great majority of sites you see are skeptic's sites, blogs and other material, much of which is a good deal more acidic than Lancaster's site.

So if you are asking me to state my current position on Sylvia or Lancaster, I really can't do it. It would be like asking me to state my opinion on God after reading only the Bible (or, in this case, Sylvia-related material) and then directly after, reading Richard Dawkins (in this case, Lancaster's site). I need to see the best possible arguments for Browne, and given she is such a public figure and intelligent people everywhere try to defend some pretty difficult to defend people (Hitler and Stalin, for example), one would think there would be more apologists, given her popularity. And as I said at the beginning I am not schooled enough in these subjects to try to defend her myself.
The strongest case that exists is right there on Sylvia's website. The strong case you are looking for does not exist. Do you suppose that Sylvia would not be singing from the roof tops about ANY truly confirmed cases, if she had some?

I challenge you to suggest a (reasonable) explanation for her not publishing a verifiable account, if she had one. I suspect, you will find (like every other person who has considered this before you) that there is no reasonable explanation. You must realize, if she had a real success, it could not be kept out of the news. It would be the biggest story of the century (really, no exaggeration).

By the way...another thing that's bothering me somewhat: http://www.novus.org/home/hivaids_reg.cfm

I would hope it is bothering you more than somewhat.
 
The strongest case that exists is right there on Sylvia's website. The strong case you are looking for does not exist. Do you suppose that Sylvia would not be singing from the roof tops about ANY truly confirmed cases, if she had some?

I challenge you to suggest a (reasonable) explanation for her not publishing a verifiable account, if she had one. I suspect, you will find (like every other person who has considered this before you) that there is no reasonable explanation. You must realize, if she had a real success, it could not be kept out of the news. It would be the biggest story of the century (really, no exaggeration).



I would hope it is bothering you more than somewhat.

There are plenty of 'verifiable accounts' for things like male penis enlargement pills. They pay people to say things work all the time, so why doesn't Sylvia? Does she have more moral scruples?

Do you acknowledge that it is conceptually possible, if HIGHLY unlikely almost to the point of impossibility (in your view), that Sylvia does not care about authenticating her powers in any sense, but has them?
 
Last edited:
Here is what is bothering me:

There appear to be practically no defenders of Browne or her reputation besides herself and affiliated websites. This just seems odd to me. If you Google Sylvia Browne, or Sylvia Browne proof, etc., the great majority of sites you see are skeptic's sites, blogs and other material, much of which is a good deal more acidic than Lancaster's site.

Well, there's "gosylviabrowne.com," but I guess that falls under "affiliated" given that the webmaster is living with Browne's son.

Robert had this to say in one of his articles:

When starting StopSylviaBrowne.com, I was surprised to find almost no Sylvia Browne "fan sites" out there. She is obviously a very popular psychic - I wondered why so few sites supporting her?


I soon found oblique references, and later, received specific emails, stating that Browne had a reputation for shutting fan sites down with threats of litigation.

Given that Browne tried to sic her lawyers on Robert for using her "trademark" (referring to her by name), I don't find this hard to believe. It's also in line with what some of the ex-NS members have said about the way the church is run.

So if you are asking me to state my current position on Sylvia or Lancaster, I really can't do it. It would be like asking me to state my opinion on God after reading only the Bible (or, in this case, Sylvia-related material) and then directly after, reading Richard Dawkins (in this case, Lancaster's site). I need to see the best possible arguments for Browne, and given she is such a public figure and intelligent people everywhere try to defend some pretty difficult to defend people (Hitler and Stalin, for example), one would think there would be more apologists, given her popularity. And as I said at the beginning I am not schooled enough in these subjects to try to defend her myself.

Fair enough.

By the way...another thing that's bothering me somewhat: http://www.novus.org/home/hivaids_reg.cfm

Ugh...As it should. Wow.
 
The difference between a psychic and someone good at extracting information without you knowing would be that many of their predictions would have to come out true and have been affirmed to them.

I'm confused by your wording. Whose predictions would come out true, the psychic's or the extractor's?
 
From what I have heard SB goes after non afiliated fan sites with legal action. The lack of external defenders is due to her trying to keep other outlets for NS materials from cropping up.
 
I'm confused by your wording. Whose predictions would come out true, the psychic's or the extractor's?

Well..the original question is difficult. I guess you can phrase it this way:

1. Psychics do not use cold reading techniques in their predictions and readings.

2. Cold readers use cold reading techniques in their predictions and readings.

I realize this is self-referential. It is hypothetically possible to do both 1 and 2.
 
There appear to be practically no defenders of Browne or her reputation besides herself and affiliated websites.
This may be partly due to her evidently shutting down pro-Sylvia sites, as Cleon referenced.

It also may be due to the lack of any actual, confirmablel evidence of her "abilities."

It may also be due to the fact that her fan base requires no more evidence than the non-confirmable stories she tells about herself, and the "she's on the Montel show, so she must be legit" point of view.

This just seems odd to me. If you Google Sylvia Browne, or Sylvia Browne proof, etc., the great majority of sites you see are skeptic's sites, blogs and other material, much of which is a good deal more acidic than Lancaster's site.

I need to see the best possible arguments for Browne
I think you already have. If you find any better, please let me know, and I will put them up on my site.

and given she is such a public figure and intelligent people everywhere try to defend some pretty difficult to defend people (Hitler and Stalin, for example), one would think there would be more apologists, given her popularity.
If you find any, please let me know.

By the way...another thing that's bothering me somewhat: http://www.novus.org/home/hivaids_reg.cfm
[/quote]... as well it should. It is not clear whether they are claiming to cure HIV/AIDS, or just what.

Two other quick points:

1. You can search the contents of an entire thread by using the "Search This Thread" link on the upper right portion of the screen when viewing a thread.

2. If you haven't already , please check your PMs.

Edited to add: I see you've checked them. Never mind!
 
Last edited:
There are plenty of 'verifiable accounts' for things like male penis enlargement pills. They pay people to say things work all the time, so why doesn't Sylvia? Does she have more moral scruples?
No, she doesn't. In order for someone to be paid to validate one of her readings in the manner that people validate penis enlargement pills, Sylvia would have to pay them. Firstly, she's not stupid enough to take the risk that this person will later reveal the fact that he/she was paid to lie, and secondly, Sylvia doesn't pay for anything, she's just too greedy.

Do you acknowledge that it is conceptually possible, if HIGHLY unlikely almost to the point of impossibility (in your view), that Sylvia does not care about authenticating her powers in any sense, but has them?

No, I can't acknowledge this because on the follow-up to the Cooper Anderson show where she was torn to pieces, Browne trotted out Linda Rossi with a whole video and story trying to authenticate and validate Browne. The video actually added to the argument against Browne doing good.

So she does care about authenticating her powers. After all, it is her 'powers' that keep the greenbacks rolling in.
 
I am sure an admin will delete this message because it disagrees with the stated goals of the JREF. I feel I must post it anyway.

Not deleted yet.


...as well as help to police departments

Police departments questioned about this often disavow having her help. Why is that?

...has been treated in a fashion completely and utterly shocking to any civilized person.

Doesn't shock me; she's a charlatan and deserves what's on the SSB site. And don't try a No-True-Scotsman argument on me.

Browne's success rate of 85% is ignored,

Prove this 85% success rate.

This is again IGNORING her 85% success rate.

Prove this 85% success rate.

There are thousands of positive testimonials in favor of Browne and it is clear from a simple reading of Amazon.com reviews of her books that she has helped INNUMERABLE people.

Testimonials are not proof. Her participation in a proper double-blinded experiment would be proof.

This man who has so little positive to contribute to the world has instead set his sights on Mrs. Browne, a great spiritual leader.

Lancaster is doing the world a service, while Browne is just sucking the life out of it. You have this backward.

Mr. Lancaster has apparently also started a campaign against Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen, a 9/11 survivor and inspirational speaker,

Another good job Lancaster!!

...and a descendant of famous film director Cecil B. Demille.

What does this have to do with anything?

He has also insulted and questioned the honor of Montel Williams

With good reason. I saw him trying to help Sylvia out of a hole she dug herself into with a particularly bad reading.

...a navy hero, who is currently suffering with multiple sclerosis.

What does this have to do with anything?

- Gary Richardson, admirer of Sylvia Browne

:( I really have a deep pity for Gary, and the fact that he's been so taken in by Sylvia.
 
There are plenty of 'verifiable accounts' for things like male penis enlargement pills. They pay people to say things work all the time, so why doesn't Sylvia? Does she have more moral scruples?

Do you acknowledge that it is conceptually possible, if HIGHLY unlikely almost to the point of impossibility (in your view), that Sylvia does not care about authenticating her powers in any sense, but has them?

Well, male penis enlargement pills doesn't work, which is why they have to pay people to say the pills work. Besides, anecdotal evidence is not evidence that something really works.
You can find people that say SB has psychic powers, but you won't find any evidence that she actually has them.

Do you acknowledge that it is conceptually possible, if HIGHLY unlikely almost to the point of impossibility (in your view), that pigs does not care about authenticating their ability to fly in any sense, but has them? :rolleyes:
 
There are plenty of 'verifiable accounts' for things like male penis enlargement pills. They pay people to say things work all the time, so why doesn't Sylvia? Does she have more moral scruples?

Do you acknowledge that it is conceptually possible, if HIGHLY unlikely almost to the point of impossibility (in your view), that Sylvia does not care about authenticating her powers in any sense, but has them?

So, you don't think claims of 80+% accuracy, claims of working with multiple law enforcement agencies, claims of solving missing person's cases aren't exactly like the claims in most penis enlargement spam? She spouts them, has Montel spout the, gets Larry King to spout them, etc etc. But, those aren't 'verifiable accounts'. Why? Because they can't actually be verified (as you've recently discovered).

I acknowledge that is is conceptually possible that she doesn't care about authenticating her powers. But, every word she has ever uttered in public makes me think that interpretation is bunk.

She appears to be intensely interested in impressing people, especially people who might give her money. Re-read the about Sylvia section of her website (http://www.sylvia.org/home/about.cfm) to refresh your memory about who we are talking about here.

Now, what could be more impressive that a documented accurate reading?
 
There are plenty of 'verifiable accounts' for things like male penis enlargement pills.

Whoa! Are you saying they don't work?????????? :eek: Are you totally sure?

Seriously, though, it's really amazing what people will believe without checking the facts if it comes from an authority figure or famous person (like Oprah or Montel) or a situation where you ask yourself "Who would dare make that up?" For the latter, check out the StopKaz site - it's chock full of that.
 
Well..the original question is difficult. I guess you can phrase it this way:

1. Psychics do not use cold reading techniques in their predictions and readings.

2. Cold readers use cold reading techniques in their predictions and readings.

I realize this is self-referential. It is hypothetically possible to do both 1 and 2.

So a cold reader's predictions can come out true?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom