Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Could be. And of course he (and we're assuming he, apparently) has to expect some extremely hardnosed skepticism and doubt. That's where I step in. :)

The original post. It's all laid out very efficiently, almost appearing to be a stock statement about combatting RSL. D'ya think this was pasted in from a source other than SylviaRox? Seems very prepared and fine-tuned, to me anyway...
I actually agree with you - it looked to me like a well-planned piece that had some effort put into constructing it just so. Especially in comparison to the follow-up posts, which were much more ad hoc in nature.

I strongly suspected it was a plant from SB's office or even her legal team (would they stoop that low??), and I was trying to figure out what advantage they were trying to gain. I could only surmise that they were trying to make us go ballistic and try to slag off and say something actionable. Or at least nasty enough for them to use as ammunition against RSL in public. And I suspect others here thought the same thing, hence our polite but firm responses.

If so, when they didn't actually get the response they bargained on, they had painted themselves into a corner. Only way out without looking more stupid than they already did - backing off politely...

Is this what really happened? I dunno - it's all my own surmise! But who knows! Perhaps the "channel" for this exercise has been faced with some reality of the situation, and Sylvia has sacrificed yet another pawn to no end.




Hey - was that a good conspiracy theory?? :D
 
I strongly suspected it was a plant from SB's office or even her legal team (would they stoop that low??), and I was trying to figure out what advantage they were trying to gain. I could only surmise that they were trying to make us go ballistic and try to slag off and say something actionable. Or at least nasty enough for them to use as ammunition against RSL in public. And I suspect others here thought the same thing, hence our polite but firm responses.

If so, when they didn't actually get the response they bargained on, they had painted themselves into a corner. Only way out without looking more stupid than they already did - backing off politely...

Is this what really happened? I dunno - it's all my own surmise! But who knows! Perhaps the "channel" for this exercise has been faced with some reality of the situation, and Sylvia has sacrificed yet another pawn to no end.




Hey - was that a good conspiracy theory?? :D

Yep, until I put my skeptic tinfoil hat on that's exactly what I thought:o After I'd put it back on the suspicion remained. It's still there;)
 
Something is wrong here.

Is this a new way to Win Friends And Influence People?

1. Go to a message board and slam one of its prominent members with a carefully constructed original post. Accuse him of libel, slander and defamation. Use words towards that member such as sham, obsessive, pretended, distorted, frenzied, hatred, extreme, attack, vicious, assault, destroy, Fascists, nasty, condescending, insulted and campaign of terror.

2. Wait for reaction.

3. Back off on some of the tripe, apologize for same.

4. Everybody wuvs you!

5. Discontent caused between longtime members and another who dares question your motives.

6. Your stock increases!

7. Everybody wuvs you even more!

8. And you still get to be a fervent fan of Sylvia Browne!!!

First of all, you could not possible be more wrong to suggest that I wrote my original post slowly and deliberately. I wrote it very quickly, literally in a few minutes. I am proud of my English skills. I had heard about Lancaster in the days before on LiveJournal, his own site and seeing him on Anderson Cooper on YouTube, so I had already formed my 'complaints' mentally. I had seen his site linked all over as well.

Second of all, I have not converted to skepticism or anything else. I admit that I was wrong in my accusations towards Lancaster, and I admit that certain things I have read are troubling me (the missing person cases that were linked several times here, Sylvia's incorrect statement about the German audience, the 2000 predictions on her website). Third of all, I am not trying to impress people, you will notice I have not replied to any of the other posts at this forum and I do not want to become a long term member in the sense of participation.

And finally, you don't seem to see the difference between skepticism and cynicism.
 
Last edited:
I must admit that I am a bit dissapointed in some of the skeptics who reply to the German discussion that the real point is that Silvia Browne told a bigger lie.

I disagree completely, if SRox brings up the issue that in his opinion RSL lied, finding out if he in fact lied is the real point.

Let's first concede to SRox that if someone made the statement "This man speaks English" without context about the German guy that:

1) The most common interpretation of that sentence would be that he could hold a complicated discussion in English
2) The guy may not actually meet these criteria.

So for a certain interpretation of RSL's words they may have actually been untruthful.

However for RSL to actually have lied in his article the next two things would have to hold:

1) This was the intended meaning of RSL's sentence: "They all spoke English".
2) RSL knew this to be untruthful.

I do not think that either assumption can be upheld.

"They all spoke English" can also mean that they all used English to communicate, in this interpretation the statement is completely true. It's my conviction this is what RSL meant. (I mainly believe so because that's basically what RSL said he meant).

Furthermore RSL has allready stated that he is open to changing the sentence to one that could not be misunderstood.

So while I am willing to concede that depending on how you read the sentence it may be false, there is no way it could be considered a lie, much less a deliberate manipulation of information as you originally stated.

Wether Silvia Browne told a bigger lie, is still irrelevant to both the truthfulness of "They all spoke English" and wether RSL intentionally misrepresented the truth. My position is that the sentence in it's most natural interpretation, given the context, is true and RSL is not intentionally misrepresenting the truth.

But I fully understand that what I consider the most natural interpretation might not be the most natural interpretation for you. The above shows that in light of that it's not 100% possible to stick a defenite true or false on the sentence. Luckily we're not trying to determine if the statement is actually true, we're trying to determine wether RSL lied, since that also includes intend and the knowledge of saying something that wasn't true, I think we can defenitally state that RSL was not lying.

Thank you for this, it is the post I needed to see at least once.
 
Can I just point out that it wasn't until post 35 that Sylviarox brought up the semantic point of the ONE German guy who may/may not have spoken GOOD English? The OP was all about the across-the-board slander and misrepresentation that Robert Lancaster was inflicting upon poor Sylvia. Contrition notwithstanding, and even bearing in mind the debatably poor English of that ONE German, it has been shown to be baseless accusation.

Besides, the whole point of the article re the Bill Bixby show was that Sylvia had claimed she performed so poorly because the entire audience was German and did not speak English at all! If Robert altering his article to reflect the ambiguous nature of that ONE reading stops Sylvia's followers from having an "in" to semantically pick apart his work, then I'm all for it. The guy did seem a bit non-plussed by the whole thing, but I don't think it can be called either way - he could obviously speak some English, but was struggling with Sylvia's questions as posed (for whatever reason).
 
*snip*Third of all, I am not trying to impress people, you will notice I have not replied to any of the other posts at this forum and I do not want to become a long term member in the sense of participation.

Seeing that you do have potential for critical thinking (which always starts with oneself), I'd like to express the hope that you will stick around. Ignore the knee-jerk reactions, and you can have some very interesting discussions here.

And finally, you don't seem to see the difference between skepticism and cynicism.
While they are certainly two different things, it is difficult to maintain a skeptical position without a certain level of cynicism. For instance, the cynic in me would like to know (I have not read the entire thread): Did you get around to defending the 85% hit rate of SB? Otherwise, that could be the topic of a new thread of yours ;).

Hans

Hans
 
Second of all, I have not converted to skepticism or anything else.

That takes time. Once you come to the realization, if you ever do, that you've been pwned by The Claws, you will probably adopt skepticism in one form or another. How's that for a psychic prediction?

...I am not trying to impress people, you will notice I have not replied to any of the other posts at this forum and I do not want to become a long term member in the sense of participation.

It's fairly difficult to impress anyone in here, SR. The membership here, from what I've been able to determine, is very accomplished so a good post only goes so far. Most of us are going what you're going through. As far as participation, you're welcome to stay and participate, or not, as pleases you. If you leave, you're turning your back on knowledge and information and an opportunity to state your views. We have all types here. As long as you're civil and adhere to the Sacred Rules, you'll be accepted but probably not embraced.

And finally, you don't seem to see the difference between skepticism and cynicism.

Point well taken. Curiousity makes us skeptical. Unfortunately, experience has made us cynical. Or most of us. Luckily, you're immune, yes? ;)
 
Besides, the whole point of the article re the Bill Bixby show was that Sylvia had claimed she performed so poorly because the entire audience was German and did not speak English at all!


I still don't see what point she was trying to make with her comment about it being "a setup" because the audience spoke German. If she really is getting messages from her "spirit guide", why would the audience's language skills have any effect on this? Surely it would only cause her a problem if she needed to get information from the audience rather than "Francine"? It almost looks like an admission that she uses cold reading.
 
I still don't see what point she was trying to make with her comment about it being "a setup" because the audience spoke German. If she really is getting messages from her "spirit guide", why would the audience's language skills have any effect on this? Surely it would only cause her a problem if she needed to get information from the audience rather than "Francine"? It almost looks like an admission that she uses cold reading.
Yeah, good point (since we are now over the the Lancaster issue, I assume we can talk about Sylvia). Also, it is a litle funny that a psychic should hold a reading in Germany and be surprised at meeting a roomful of Germans :rolleyes:. So yes, I think it is an implicit admission of cold reading.

Hans
 
I still don't see what point she was trying to make with her comment about it being "a setup" because the audience spoke German. If she really is getting messages from her "spirit guide", why would the audience's language skills have any effect on this? Surely it would only cause her a problem if she needed to get information from the audience rather than "Francine"? It almost looks like an admission that she uses cold reading.

That's what I thought, but figured somebody said it already.

I mean, it's one thing if your psychic powers can't detect a murderer in the room but a room FULL of Germans!? Heck even I can spot a German dude when I see one walking down the street...the jeans, the hair, the spectacles :D. (No offense to Germans, of course, I think they're great. Lived amongst them for a time. I was born there, even :o ).

On a related note, what language does "Francine" speak? By her name I'm guessing English...otherwise, can Silvia channel another language or, in the words of John Edward, "it doesn't work that way"?

Also, way to go OP.
 
Yeah, good point (since we are now over the the Lancaster issue, I assume we can talk about Sylvia). Also, it is a litle funny that a psychic should hold a reading in Germany and be surprised at meeting a roomful of Germans :rolleyes:. So yes, I think it is an implicit admission of cold reading.

Hans

Sorry, I didn't read the whole thread. This was filmed in Germany?

Aside from casting doubts on her psychic ability that would certainly raise questions about her intelligence too, wouldn't it? I live in Japan and that would be like me going a baseball game and saying, "hey, the announcer's speaking Japanese... that's not what I bargained for!" Sheesh.
 
Judging by what I've seen of Sylvia's accuracy, probably not one that Sylvia understands.

Ha ha ha. I wonder if you can ask for a new spirit guide if yours is defective?

"Dear God, it's me, your least favorite psychic. Can you send me a new guide, mine keeps speaking French. Thanks in advance, Silvia."
 
That's wakarimasen, if you're trying to say you don't understand...
僕は日本語が少しだけ分かります。

Err, yes. And I guess it also proved the point, yes? ;)

The one time I was in Norway, I had a blast. Although one night in Oslo, ALL the locals strongly advised us not to leave our hotel. Saw some odd things that night, and to this day I have no clue what was going on...

I have no idea what that could've been. Maybe there were Swedes about.

One way or another, this is an epic, landmark thread.

I agree!

Even if the OP is not sincere, that's what it will look like to people who read it.

But I do hope he's sincere, just as sincere as I am about buying him a beer :)
 
Second of all, I have not converted to skepticism or anything else. .......snip.......... Third of all, I am not trying to impress people, you will notice I have not replied to any of the other posts at this forum and I do not want to become a long term member in the sense of participation.

Even if you didn't 'convert', please stick around. It's always healthy to have more points of view.

And finally, you don't seem to see the difference between skepticism and cynicism.

Some people have that problem. Ignore them.
 
Last edited:
I have no idea what that could've been. Maybe there were Swedes about.
It was in May/June of 1993, if I recall correctly. If it helps, whatever it was seemed to involve a lot of men in dresses running around...

Lots of good memories of that trip, though. Including my first experience in a karaoke bar, oddly enough. The most surreal memory is of hearing "Deep in the Heart of Texas" on the radio in the bus...being sung in Norweigan.

Back on topic, I remember how hard it was for me to admit I was wrong when I was younger. (I was one of those arrogant "know-it-all" types.) It took me until college (St. Olaf College, 'course) to be able to candidly admit error. I don't recall insisting on something so strongly as people believe in Sylvia et. al. though.

Just admitting that some of your initial assumptions were mistaken is a huge step. Good luck to you, SylviaRox.

(on that Norway trip, one of our group found out he'd been pronouncing his last name wrong his whole life...it had double 'a's innit. That's like the "å", right?)
 
Last edited:
(on that Norway trip, one of our group found out he'd been pronouncing his last name wrong his whole life...it had double 'a's innit. That's like the "å", right?)

Yes, Aa = Å, and is pronounced just like 'awe'.

Double a's are mostly used in older Norwegian words, or when translating words with å in it to English or other languages.
 
Who are you calling lazy? I realize you are from Texas, so read this like you normally do. S-l-o-w-l-y...

First, you really don't know - don't even have a clue - of the meaning of the word skeptical, right? I didn't think so.

A: Someone professing their deep and passionate devotion to Sylvia Browne posts a very carefully constructed hit piece against one of her major critics. Relentless, but planned, attack from top to bottom of that post. Don't believe me? Read it again!

B: A day later, contrition? Conciliation? Shucks let's have a cry and everything is peachy now?

Sure, who could possibly be skeptical of that kind of turnaround? Totally unreasonable, of course you are correct.

Nope, not from Texas. I'm a Yank, speak as fast as you like. Nice ad hom, though.

You said, "Impossible to read through this entire thread, it exploded too quickly." Then you immediately followed this up with (lets count them) 4 posts in row expressing doubt it was a legit turn around.

My point is, someone who can't even be bothered to even read the thread isn't entitled to strong opinion either way. It is far from impossible to read through this entire thread. You've just disclared it so and been to lazy to do it.

I am a good enough skeptic to know that leaving available evidence unconsidered is no way to start. Apparently, you're not.

Lets look at your retort. I point legitimately where you are falling short. You respond with nothing but name calling and a re-interation of your ignorant (I say ignorant because it is not informed by the actual contents of the thread) opinion. Yep, you've got me beat hand down, I tell ya.

If you still want, we can still compare our 'skeptic badges' later, though. :rolleyes:
 
SylviaRox – I’d suggest that the point of this site is not to convert, or try to convert, anyone.

You joined and posted a point of view, participated in the ensuing debate, and drew some conclusions based on that debate – I’d argue that THIS is, at least to some degree, the point of this site/forum.

Participation beyond the thread that you started is, of course, totally up to you. Personally, I’d like to see your participation continue; it would make for rather boring debate is EVERYONE agreed with EVERYTHING.
 
First of all, you could not possible be more wrong to suggest that I wrote my original post slowly and deliberately. I wrote it very quickly, literally in a few minutes. I am proud of my English skills. I had heard about Lancaster in the days before on LiveJournal, his own site and seeing him on Anderson Cooper on YouTube, so I had already formed my 'complaints' mentally. I had seen his site linked all over as well.
That's fine then. As I said above, I was merely speculating on the information available at the time. The point you do need to remember here is that we skeptics CAN change our minds too - all you need do is provide solid evidence and we will happily take your point seriously. We have no problem in admitting we were wrong either. Mistakes are how you learn what is fact.

However that also doesn't mean we agree with each other (or even with James Randi!) all the time. We do like to let ideas contend! So I'd suggest you wear chain mail if you decide to head into the politics subforum, for example! ;)

Second of all, I have not converted to skepticism or anything else. I admit that I was wrong in my accusations towards Lancaster, and I admit that certain things I have read are troubling me (the missing person cases that were linked several times here, Sylvia's incorrect statement about the German audience, the 2000 predictions on her website).
This isn't a conversion process, or an exclusive club. If it were, you would have been banned before your second post. Or not even allowed to post at all, ever. Have you been to any Sylvia Browne forums, by the way? Here, we will help you argue your points, but we won't tell you what those points should be. That's your call!

Third of all, I am not trying to impress people, you will notice I have not replied to any of the other posts at this forum and I do not want to become a long term member in the sense of participation.
That's up to you. You are welcome if you wish to, though.

And finally, you don't seem to see the difference between skepticism and cynicism.
Indeed! It's often tough to make that separation. But then, I'm from a country full of cynics! It's our national passtime;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom