I would concede that SylviaRox has a valid point: the man clearly was having trouble understanding the reading. Maybe he was just trying to get Browne to go away, but if he was faking it, we can't blame Browne for being fooled.
But there remain two basic facts:
"He spoke English" is literally correct.
Although that comment could be interpreted to mean "he speaks English better than he does," RSL gives the transcript and the original video, so it is easy to understand the situation.
You have to contrast this to Sylvia's claim, which is not literally correct, and does not provide context to help us understand what really happened.
Let's say that we concede that the man did not understand Sylvia and that he should not have been in audience. The majority disagree with you, but I don't think anyone thinks you're unreasonable for believing that.
I suggest you ignore the reading for the German gentleman, and look at the readings for the native English speakers and compare those readings to Sylvia's account. Remember, Sylvia claimed they were all German and none of them could understand a single word.