Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

And finally, you don't seem to see the difference between skepticism and cynicism.

Is it cynicism or skepticism to be unimpressed by impassioned, sincere-seeming statements of belief, and to require some fact-checking?
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.

My first post here on this thread...I'm only through page seven, this may have been dealt with at this time...if she gets things wrong, how is she psychic?

Especially if she gets a lot of things wrong? Saying she got the name Micheal is meaningless. She was wrong about every other aspect of the case. Do you think there would be an issue if she had called the guy "Gary" and gotten every other thing right...looks, location, status, etc? One for five indicates about an average guesser, not a psychic.
 
I see, Rand. Sure you aren't just getting in some digs at me because you lost all the wars we've fought over in the Politics forum?

With all due respect, isn't this something more appropriate for a PM? And for what it's worth, I don't think it's a particularly mature comment to make. It certainly has nothing to do with this thread.

Just my two cents (and yeah, I know nobody asked).
 
That's what I thought, that he was saying "I don't understand [what the heck you are on about]" rather than "I don't understand [the English language]. I thought the [unintelligible] word might be German, but the only German words passed down from my German great-grandparents are swear words. It doesn't sound like one of those words.

Still working my way through...only on page 7.

Of course, regardless of the man's ability to speak English, it doesn't justify Sylvia's statement that the whole audience spoke German, when several people were shown to be speaking perfectly good English.

Want to weigh-in on this whole german business. Not only was SB wrong...others in the audience clearly are not german. And, of course, Randi contended that the German spoke english...so, it is Randi's word against SB? And we know SB has trouble witht he truth


But, it seems to me that it is a pretty good bet that the German spoke english...and understood it. THis isn't a logical or provable argument...but gernally speaking if you are going to a TV show as part of the audience...wouldn't you be able to speak the language of the TV show? Otherwise it is a pretty useless exersize and couldn't be particularly entertaining. Besides, the number of Germans who speak a second language and well (like English) is far higher than the number of Americans who do...just an observation.
 
As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.

You have "no knowledge" and yet you continue to say she has more than 85% accuracy...what could that conclusion possibly be based on?

Now on Page 8.
 
headscratcher, I would advise you to *not* comment until you are further on in the thread. There have been surprising developments concerning SylviaRox' position. Your comments are not only repeats, they're responding to positions that nobody now is supporting. AFAIK, the only issue still under debate is the precise degree of English language knowledge of the German man.
 
Browne chose the German guy. She wasn't asked to read him. So why didn't Francine tell Browne that the guy was German?

Still on page 9...

Indeed, in fact, she should have known he was German (if she were psychic...she picked him, after all) and why wouldn't the spirit guide or whoever was psychically whispering in SB's ear have given Sylvia at least phonetic German to tell the guy? What a way to shut up the critics? SB starts speaking a language she is not known to know to a man who she claims doesn't speak english. IT would have been amazing...instead it feels like post-hoc covering up for a mistake.
 
I still don't understand that if Sylvia gets her "psychic" information from God, then why isn't she right ever?
God doesn't speak German?
God got Devlin's physical description wrong along with all of the other horribly wrong information she spews?
Or is Sylvia too high on her pedestal that God said it right to her but she decided to over rule God's words?

Seems to me that it calls into question not only if there is a God or if she truly has any ability to hear God but nobody who follows her closely ever catches on to that.
 
I am sure an admin will delete this message because it disagrees with the stated goals of the JREF. I feel I must post it anyway.

Snip...

Hasn't been deleted, has it?

You haven't been banned, have you?

People here would rather talk about things and leave the facts in plain sight rather than delete the records and hide from reality.

ETA:
Ah, crap. Shoulda read the whole thing. Moot point, dead horse, foot in my mouth.

Sorry.
 
Last edited:
:D

I'm curious as to how much of this has made it into the GSB board.
I bet none since it shows not only how open minded this group is and how JREF doesn't ban anyone who has opposing opinions (as if there was one thing in the world that everyone agrees on) and what with all of this compelling evidence against Sylvia, I would think they'd never want anyone to read this thread or have any reference to JREF on GSB, huh?
 
1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.


Only at page 12. Well done. This took courage. Is it possible to explore, calmly, what you believe and why versus the questions that skeptics would ask? It seems to me that being able to answer the quesitons...could improve and make your belief's stronger...or not being able to answer them, could help clarify issues for you. Just a thought.
 
The original post. It's all laid out very efficiently, almost appearing to be a stock statement about combatting RSL. D'ya think this was pasted in from a source other than SylviaRox? Seems very prepared and fine-tuned, to me anyway...
It looked a little looser to me than it did to you. The structure was sequential, but the prose wasn't tight. WIth a couple of edits, it would have been both shorter, and more powerful (absent the small problem of facts versus supposition/accusation.)
Gary R said:
Mr. Lancaster has apparently also started a campaign against Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen, a 9/11 survivor and inspirational speaker, and a descendant of famous film director Cecil B. Demille.
Appeal to fame? WTF?
Gary R said:
He has also insulted and questioned the honor of Montel Williams, a navy hero, who is currently suffering with multiple sclerosis.
Appeal to a popular media persona? I answered this in detail on page 16 of this thread.
Gary R said:
Lancaster is also a vigorous copyright abuser (posting both clips of Montel's show, transcripts, images of Sylvia, quotes from her books, and the Hay House logo), as noted by Browne's lawyers. Let's hope they pursue this case to the fullest extent of the law and stop Robert S. Lancaster's campaign of terror..

- Gary Richardson, admirer of Sylvia Browne
Hyperbole, emotion, and nice dose of error. Loose prose, emotion driven.

As you noted, the red herrings/derail in the last paragraph hardly added to support of Sylvia B but were instead meant to buttress support for the idea that RSL was a walking, talking, web hosted ad hom machine. We agree on that.

Why do you consider his giving his name as Gary Richardson is a deliberate falsehood? No value added in that.

DR
 
I would concede that SylviaRox has a valid point: the man clearly was having trouble understanding the reading. Maybe he was just trying to get Browne to go away, but if he was faking it, we can't blame Browne for being fooled.

But there remain two basic facts:

"He spoke English" is literally correct.
Although that comment could be interpreted to mean "he speaks English better than he does," RSL gives the transcript and the original video, so it is easy to understand the situation.

You have to contrast this to Sylvia's claim, which is not literally correct, and does not provide context to help us understand what really happened.

Let's say that we concede that the man did not understand Sylvia and that he should not have been in audience. The majority disagree with you, but I don't think anyone thinks you're unreasonable for believing that.

I suggest you ignore the reading for the German gentleman, and look at the readings for the native English speakers and compare those readings to Sylvia's account. Remember, Sylvia claimed they were all German and none of them could understand a single word.

On page 13 or 14....Srox seems caught up in trying to salvage something of his original point. It seems that it could be conceeded. Possibly (though I do not think so, IMO) Robert could have been more exact. But, it is a really small point. It does nothing to rehabilitate SB or prove her claims of psychic power. Indeed, the rest of the tape and her claim that they were all german is not just a lie, it is an easilly refuted lie. So, at best, SRox is right only in that it is unclear that the German spoke anything but the most rudimentary english with little understanding. However, at best it is also clear that SB is a liar -- at least with respect to the Tape and that Robert's overall point about the tape is essentially correct.

So, why worry about the small pebble that maybe in the corner when the Pink Elephant is playing air-guitar and dancing about the dinning room table singing Jimi Hendrex standards?
 
If they were all non-English speakers they would not be able to understand her reading, let alone tell Bill Bixby how accurate they thought it was.

For that matter, they wouldn't have been able to understand Bill Bixby in the first place, so it's a pretty silly point.

Besides...from page 16 or 17...a psychic should have known they couldn't understand english...either the voice whispering to her should have told her or whispered to her in that language...it seems to me. However, if it was a set up...why not an audinece of people most of whom would simply tell SB in english that she was wrong? Why stack the audience with Germans (clearly not the case, btw) when you could stack it with skeptics?
 
Wow...caught up. Interesting discussion.

SRox...after reading it all...stick around. No one, I think, wants or expects, "conversion" ("conversion" to what?). The discussion has been interesting and mostly civil...always a good thing. I think that people want to discuss facts or alleged facts and analyze why people believe what they believe. You don't have to be a skeptic or a cynic to hang around...you should however, be willing to change your mind...or try to change minds if the facts and the arguments force the conclusion. Anyway, a great waste of time...I mean that in the best way.
 
God did speak German, but much like the British Royal Family has wanted to hide that ever since that whole Nazi debacle.


Actually, the British Royal Family tried to distance themselves from the Germans a bit earlier than that. George V (he of the famous last words) changed the famliy name from Saxe-Coburg-Gotha to"Windsor" in 1917, as a result of a minor family tiff with one of his cousins.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom