Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Did SylviaRox RETRACT all of the nasty comments about Mr. Lancaster?
I'm answering out of order..... Pretty much, he did. There were some provisos. Some of those are still in play.
Impossible to read through this entire thread, it exploded too quickly.
Well, you're gonna have to if you want to really know.
This is a skeptic's site and so I am skeptical of this turn-on-a-dime change of position by SR. All that vitriol - then "oh gee shucks I guess I was wrong" in just 24 hours? Seems too good to be true.
When you experienced it posted in real time, the pauses that came as things started to be reconsidered, etc.... It seems like it could be genuine. I could be wrong, the evidence is still thin, but I believe it is a genuine change of heart. (that might still be continuing)
But I could be being overly skeptical/cynical. Just does not seem to wash...
I say you'll have a lot better basis to hold that opinion after you've read the thread.
 
ConspiRaider, reading a few more of your posts after the one I just responded to.....

I want to reinforce what I said at the end of my previous post.

You seem to be strongly of the opinion that SylviaRox's 'conversion' is fraudulent, and yet you admit you have not given any consideration to large amounts of evidence that is freely available to you. And you call that being skeptical?

ETA: I'd call it lazy.
 
Last edited:
I'm glad warheit weighed in. I was about to suggest we find one of our German posters since to me it sounded like he slipped into German for a bit. When I try to speak another a language, sometimes I speak in my native tongue and then translate. That way I'm still talking, but I buy myself time to organize my thoughts.
 
I've been out of town and cut off from an Internet connection since Friday afternoon so I totally missed this! :D Look what happens when you're gone for 2 days!

Robert,
Congratulations!!!!

So..how are you finding married life?! :D
 
{sheesh} Conspi, I think you are full of, well, [rule8]. Sylvia Browne spies are not likely to go through such an elaborate game but even if they were, even if they did, so who the "F" cares?

Oh no, someone pulled the wool over our eyes.... nooooooooo.....

For crying in the dark, grow up people. Show a little class. Watch Jame Randi. Watch Robert Lancaster. Note the mature and rational approach.

I've got to ask the same question that I've been asking over and over and no one seems to want to answer. What exactly is at stake to make people so cynical? What do you stand to lose? What is this posters possible grand scheme and how will it possibly damage the cause of skepticism?

Your analysis is silly and childish. You could be right but I find it unlikely. But even if it is true it really makes no difference. There is nothing to be gained. If this person is doing this he will only look like an idiot in the end.

In any event, the OP makes perfect sense from a true believer's stand point. I've been there. I've made similar arguments.

Hang in there rox. We're not all paranoid.

That is exactly what I meant. Don't look at any of these debates as saving people or convincing people. Don't become invested in what really happens inside SR's mind. It is about discussion, which at times does change people's beliefs. Take the high road because the people who benefit are not the raving belivers who post here. Most don't get it and never will listen to any argument that you make. If SR did anything it was listening, and that should be applauded, but I'm not concerned about SR's beliefs. If people who believe in or are on the fence about SB come here they will see this thread and the arguments we make. The exNS people here are a testament to that.

Also Randfan - SB pays me on the first and third weeks of the month, which is nice because it keeps me drunk on name brand whiskey and away from that devilish cough syrup. Without her I'd have to ration those quarterly NWO checks and everyone knows that means blowing it all at once on speed and loose women and spending the rest of the month curled up with tussin and harry potter mpreg slash fiction.
 
Congratulations, Robert!

Perhaps to settle the point for good, do you think we could identify and locate this German chap, and ask him directly what he thought of and perhaps said at the event?

Let's be skeptics! Do our research!

Again, this is where extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence--and ordinary ones really don't. This incident took place in 1989. The bit of video is enough for me to accept that the guy seemed to speak at least some English. His response was pretty canny, really, since he was trying to avoid saying "yes" in a way that can be taken to mean he agreed with her psychic reading. It is definitely not worth the effort of finding the guy after all these years.

We know for sure Sylvia lied when she said the entire audience was German and that none of them understood one word of English. She lied when she said it was a set-up.

Though it was sort of a set up in a different way, since they were coached not to give information to her as in most cold-readings. In that way, I wish all audiences could be "set up". . or rather educated. If this is what Sylvia meant (rather than the wild notion that no one there could speak English), then let's talk about what's fair in prepping victims subjects before a cold reading. FWIW, we have several reports of guests on Montel saying that they were coached to agree with Sylvia and never say that she is wrong--so those readings are all "set up".

So the story really is simply, Sylvia is caught lying again.
 
I have not posted on this thread, but I have read all the way through it, so I believe that this entitles me to my 2 cents worth.

FORGET THE DAMN GERMAN. The discussion is all over semantics now, and appears to have taken up more than half the posts in one way or another.

Norm
 
ConspiRaider, reading a few more of your posts after the one I just responded to.....

I want to reinforce what I said at the end of my previous post.

You seem to be strongly of the opinion that SylviaRox's 'conversion' is fraudulent, and yet you admit you have not given any consideration to large amounts of evidence that is freely available to you. And you call that being skeptical?

ETA: I'd call it lazy.
Who are you calling lazy? I realize you are from Texas, so read this like you normally do. S-l-o-w-l-y...

First, you really don't know - don't even have a clue - of the meaning of the word skeptical, right? I didn't think so.

A: Someone professing their deep and passionate devotion to Sylvia Browne posts a very carefully constructed hit piece against one of her major critics. Relentless, but planned, attack from top to bottom of that post. Don't believe me? Read it again!

B: A day later, contrition? Conciliation? Shucks let's have a cry and everything is peachy now?

Sure, who could possibly be skeptical of that kind of turnaround? Totally unreasonable, of course you are correct.
 
{sheesh} Conspi, I think you are full of, well, [rule8]. Sylvia Browne spies are not likely to go through such an elaborate game but even if they were, even if they did, so who the "F" cares?
I see, Rand. Sure you aren't just getting in some digs at me because you lost all the wars we've fought over in the Politics forum?

Read the OP!

Then try to explain why the Original Poster is not full of [rule8]. What is the motivation for posting a hunk of garbage like that? Thrill us all with your enlightened interpretation. I'll get you started:

The OPer posted a vicious attack upon Robert Lancaster because...

Right Rand, right. The OPer is not full of [rule8], but I am. Is that what you're saying?
 
It's just odd. I read that Opening Post and determined that this person essentially kisses the ground Sylvia Browne walks (or floats) upon. And basically is jealously shielding Browne from any how-dare-you dissenting views - that she is the real McCoy. Such behavior indicates a big investment - years of devotion. I dunno. The conciliation came too much and too fast, for me anyway. But then I'm naturally suspicious...:cool:

This is the big problem with the Internet. Ya can't look 'em in the eye when they be speakin' their piece...

I'm wondering if it actually matters whether SlyviaRox is "sincere" or not? What he wrote (and that is what people will read, they can't read his mind!) was a very controlled and fair apology. So what is stated publicly is a retraction of a former position, aside from the German speaker issue. That's what people are going to read.

Since that is what he wrote, I see no reason not to accept his word for it. Yes, it's quite a change of view, but suspiciously assuming people are not telling the truth is a sort of "bad faith" way of carrying on a discussion, at least to my way of thinking.
 
I've been out of town and cut off from an Internet connection since Friday afternoon so I totally missed this! :D Look what happens when you're gone for 2 days!

Robert,
Congratulations!!!!

So..how are you finding married life?! :D

Really??? Congrats from me, too! I've also been horribly busy lately and have had little time for forum reading but I'm so glad I caught this bit of news. Many many happy years for both of you! :)
 
Ie. Nihongo ga wakarimas-ne. (I think that's correct, I only know a few phrases.)
That's wakarimasen, if you're trying to say you don't understand...
僕は日本語が少しだけ分かります。
It's not a bad place to live, but really expencive to vacation in. A pint of beer at a pub costs around $10.

Oh, and say it like a native! Skål!
The one time I was in Norway, I had a blast. Although one night in Oslo, ALL the locals strongly advised us not to leave our hotel. Saw some odd things that night, and to this day I have no clue what was going on...

One way or another, this is an epic, landmark thread.
 
I'm wondering if it actually matters whether SlyviaRox is "sincere" or not? What he wrote (and that is what people will read, they can't read his mind!) was a very controlled and fair apology. So what is stated publicly is a retraction of a former position, aside from the German speaker issue. That's what people are going to read.

Since that is what he wrote, I see no reason not to accept his word for it. Yes, it's quite a change of view, but suspiciously assuming people are not telling the truth is a sort of "bad faith" way of carrying on a discussion, at least to my way of thinking.
Something is wrong here.

Is this a new way to Win Friends And Influence People?

1. Go to a message board and slam one of its prominent members with a carefully constructed original post. Accuse him of libel, slander and defamation. Use words towards that member such as sham, obsessive, pretended, distorted, frenzied, hatred, extreme, attack, vicious, assault, destroy, Fascists, nasty, condescending, insulted and campaign of terror.

2. Wait for reaction.

3. Back off on some of the tripe, apologize for same.

4. Everybody wuvs you!

5. Discontent caused between longtime members and another who dares question your motives.

6. Your stock increases!

7. Everybody wuvs you even more!

8. And you still get to be a fervent fan of Sylvia Browne!!!
 
I must admit that I am a bit dissapointed in some of the skeptics who reply to the German discussion that the real point is that Silvia Browne told a bigger lie.

I disagree completely, if SRox brings up the issue that in his opinion RSL lied, finding out if he in fact lied is the real point.

Let's first concede to SRox that if someone made the statement "This man speaks English" without context about the German guy that:

1) The most common interpretation of that sentence would be that he could hold a complicated discussion in English
2) The guy may not actually meet these criteria.

So for a certain interpretation of RSL's words they may have actually been untruthful.

However for RSL to actually have lied in his article the next two things would have to hold:

1) This was the intended meaning of RSL's sentence: "They all spoke English".
2) RSL knew this to be untruthful.

I do not think that either assumption can be upheld.

"They all spoke English" can also mean that they all used English to communicate, in this interpretation the statement is completely true. It's my conviction this is what RSL meant. (I mainly believe so because that's basically what RSL said he meant).

Furthermore RSL has allready stated that he is open to changing the sentence to one that could not be misunderstood.

So while I am willing to concede that depending on how you read the sentence it may be false, there is no way it could be considered a lie, much less a deliberate manipulation of information as you originally stated.

Wether Silvia Browne told a bigger lie, is still irrelevant to both the truthfulness of "They all spoke English" and wether RSL intentionally misrepresented the truth. My position is that the sentence in it's most natural interpretation, given the context, is true and RSL is not intentionally misrepresenting the truth.

But I fully understand that what I consider the most natural interpretation might not be the most natural interpretation for you. The above shows that in light of that it's not 100% possible to stick a defenite true or false on the sentence. Luckily we're not trying to determine if the statement is actually true, we're trying to determine wether RSL lied, since that also includes intend and the knowledge of saying something that wasn't true, I think we can defenitally state that RSL was not lying.
 
This is a skeptic's site and so I am skeptical of this turn-on-a-dime change of position by SR. All that vitriol - then "oh gee shucks I guess I was wrong" in just 24 hours? Seems too good to be true.

But I could be being overly skeptical/cynical. Just does not seem to wash...

My take on the quite possibly suspicious change of heart is that Rox may have come on a fishing expedition, or even looking for trouble.

Since what happened was some fairly exemplary behavior, I'm inclined to believe that what Rox learned from this may not affect his beliefs about Sylvia Browne one bit, but may hopefully have influenced his idea about how the members of this forum both think and behave.
 
My take on the quite possibly suspicious change of heart is that Rox may have come on a fishing expedition, or even looking for trouble.

Since what happened was some fairly exemplary behavior, I'm inclined to believe that what Rox learned from this may not affect his beliefs about Sylvia Browne one bit, but may hopefully have influenced his idea about how the members of this forum both think and behave.
Could be. And of course he (and we're assuming he, apparently) has to expect some extremely hardnosed skepticism and doubt. That's where I step in. :)

The original post. It's all laid out very efficiently, almost appearing to be a stock statement about combatting RSL. D'ya think this was pasted in from a source other than SylviaRox? Seems very prepared and fine-tuned, to me anyway...
 
Could be, ConspiRaider, but there's been many a time when I've composed a post off-line in order to gather my thoughts. Especially when it is lengthy and contains many points I want to make.

After reading it over and making all the necessary nuance changes, then I'll post it. (In fact, I should do this more often. :) ) So the fact that it seems to be "very prepared and fine-tuned" has little influence on me regarding its validity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom