Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

It looked a little looser to me than it did to you. The structure was sequential, but the prose wasn't tight. WIth a couple of edits, it would have been both shorter, and more powerful (absent the small problem of facts versus supposition/accusation.)

Appeal to fame? WTF?

Appeal to a popular media persona? I answered this in detail on page 16 of this thread.

Hyperbole, emotion, and nice dose of error. Loose prose, emotion driven.

As you noted, the red herrings/derail in the last paragraph hardly added to support of Sylvia B but were instead meant to buttress support for the idea that RSL was a walking, talking, web hosted ad hom machine. We agree on that.

Why do you consider his giving his name as Gary Richardson is a deliberate falsehood? No value added in that.
Hiya Darth -

Good comments.

Oh wait you're an officer. Sir, Darth sir!!! Sir, respectfully your fly, sir, is open sir! :)

(bolding mine above)

Since (to me) there is a hinkiness to this person's intent and sincerity, then the gender and/or name given must also be subjected to hardnosed scrutiny.

This SylviaRox may not be male, that's just an assumption based, I think, on the name given. The style seems male, which is typically more challenging and confrontational than a female's style.

The name is what drew my scrutiny, although I didn't mention earlier. Gary Richardson. GARY RICHARDSON?!? Can anyone think of a more generic male name than Gary Richardson? And then the "admirer of Sylvia Browne" right after it. That's about as much overkill as can be imagined, considering the content of the preceding paragraphs. To me it says:

"See, my name REALLY IS Gary Richardson and I REALLY DO love Sylvia Browne, yep yep!"

As I said - hinkiness abounds.
 
ConspiRaider said:
This SylviaRox may not be male, that's just an assumption based, I think, on the name given. The style seems male, which is typically more challenging and confrontational than a female's style.

Who knows? You just might be getting interference on your gaydar.
 
With all due respect, isn't this something more appropriate for a PM? And for what it's worth, I don't think it's a particularly mature comment to make. It certainly has nothing to do with this thread.

Just my two cents (and yeah, I know nobody asked).
Well, Rand publicly stated - not in a PM but for all to see - that I was full of you-know-what. So I felt I publicly had to knock him down a few pegs.

You're right and correct to point it out. Both of our statements (plus that other winner who called me 'lazy' and my lashback) weren't exactly appropriate.
 
Actually, the British Royal Family tried to distance themselves from the Germans a bit earlier than that. George V (he of the famous last words) changed the famliy name from Saxe-Coburg-Gotha to"Windsor" in 1917, as a result of a minor family tiff with one of his cousins.

While you are factually correct, my way is funnier.

You are all a bunch of brown-nosing suck-up-to-the-deputy-admin losers! ;)

I found Mojo's subtle, British humour much more funny. :eusa_snooty:
 
The name is what drew my scrutiny, although I didn't mention earlier. Gary Richardson. GARY RICHARDSON?!? Can anyone think of a more generic male name than Gary Richardson?

You're right, such a bland and generic name couldn't possibly be real. It's almost as bad as Michael. Oh, wait...
 
I'm sure this means something. What? Gaydar? Explain.

As in:

gaydar5230kh4.jpg
 
...You've never heard of "gaydar"? Seriously?

Uh. I'll tell you when you're older.
I'm older now.

How about this: Rephrase. Assume, if you are able, that I don't know what "gaydar" means and that your usage of "interference" with same just flew right over my head. English is a rich language. Put it in simpler terms. If you can.
 
I'm older now.

How about this: Rephrase. Assume, if you are able, that I don't know what "gaydar" means and that your usage of "interference" with same just flew right over my head. English is a rich language. Put it in simpler terms. If you can.

If I do, I sacrifice my funny.

I think I'll let everyone else figure it out first. :)
 
If I do, I sacrifice my funny.

I think I'll let everyone else figure it out first. :)
Cool.

Lemme see, I'm 49 years old and have never used the term "gaydar" once. Must be a kid's thing. You're a whippersnapper, right?
 
Hmm... You mean these bell-bottoms are out of style, too?

M.

I'm no fashion expert, but I think the bell-bottoms would've looked out of place in 1989 as well--at least among the general public.

But maybe that shape acts as a wave guide funneling probability waves of future events up to. . . .well whatever organs you've got that are precognitive.
 
Cool.

Lemme see, I'm 49 years old and have never used the term "gaydar" once. Must be a kid's thing. You're a whippersnapper, right?

It started to come into use in 1992. It was old by the time I was young. But yes, I'm 22. It came into use when I was 7.
 
Cool.

Lemme see, I'm 49 years old and have never used the term "gaydar" once. Must be a kid's thing. You're a whippersnapper, right?

I'm surprised. If you live in Tinsel Town (assuming you really live in L.A. and aren't joking about that part) and have never heard the term Gaydar. I live in Orange County, I'm 40 years old and I've heard it LOTS.
 
I'll repost this, ConspiRaider, it seems to have slipped past your notice.

Who are you calling lazy? I realize you are from Texas, so read this like you normally do. S-l-o-w-l-y...

First, you really don't know - don't even have a clue - of the meaning of the word skeptical, right? I didn't think so.

A: Someone professing their deep and passionate devotion to Sylvia Browne posts a very carefully constructed hit piece against one of her major critics. Relentless, but planned, attack from top to bottom of that post. Don't believe me? Read it again!

B: A day later, contrition? Conciliation? Shucks let's have a cry and everything is peachy now?

Sure, who could possibly be skeptical of that kind of turnaround? Totally unreasonable, of course you are correct.

Nope, not from Texas. I'm a Yank, speak as fast as you like. Nice ad hom, though.

You said, "Impossible to read through this entire thread, it exploded too quickly." Then you immediately followed this up with (lets count them) 4 posts in row expressing doubt it was a legit turn around.

My point is, someone who can't be bothered to even read the thread isn't entitled to strong opinion either way. It is far from impossible to read through this entire thread. You've just declared it so and been to lazy to do it.

I am a good enough skeptic to know that leaving available evidence unconsidered is no way to start. Apparently, you're not.

Lets look at your retort. I point legitimately where you are falling short. You respond with nothing but name calling and a re-iteration of your ignorant (I say ignorant because it is not informed by the actual contents of the thread) opinion. Yep, you've got me beat hand down, I tell ya.

If you still want, we can still compare our 'skeptic badges' later, though. :rolleyes:
 
ConspiRaider said:
Who are you calling lazy? I realize you are from Texas, so read this like you normally do. S-l-o-w-l-y...

1) Ad hominem.

2) Extremely childish.

3) Asshat.

4) There is no four.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom