Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

If they were all non-English speakers they would not be able to understand her reading, let alone tell Bill Bixby how accurate they thought it was.

For that matter, they wouldn't have been able to understand Bill Bixby in the first place, so it's a pretty silly point.
 
Susan and I got married on Friday, and we left Saturday for a day trip out of town, which is why I am only now responding to much of this thread.

Excuses, excuses! Seriously, congratulations and much, much happiness! :)

SylviaRox, I've read through to the end of the thread, and have seen that you have modified your position. I respect both your ability to have done so, and the intestinal fortitude it took to admit it.

I just couldn't keep up with this thread but SylviaRox met a what I would think of as an immovable object of withering verifiable evidence against his misconception. I really feel for these people because coming to a realization that your credo is flawed is intensely disillusioning. (Been through it meself.) Yet, SylviaRox seems to be an honest and intelligent person who has now been presented with the evidence.

What we do know with certainty now, RSL, is that what you are doing is, to put it lightly, effective. These threads will probably increase in the future and signals only that Sylvia's followers are finally getting the message. Great work!
 
Interesting that the claimed success rate jumps around---87%, 85%. What sort of data did you use to calculate the 85% figure you use, SylviaRox?
It's a figure bandied about by Browne, and it changes from time to time (as would be expected even were it an actual, accurate figure).

Also, in your original post you said that Gosylviabrowne is a fan site.
You do realize that Heather Brown is hardly just a fan, right? You are aware she admitted on her site she is Chris Dufresne's girlfriend.
Paul Dufresne's, not Chris Dufresne's.

I get spam in my email all the time.

Damn you Lancaster!! :mad:
Just buy the aluminum siding, and it will stop.

Robert has posted about 30 articles on his site, and you only have a problem with this one small issue. So maybe he's not that bad after all.
Actually, I believe it is currently 48 articles!

How do you know it wasn't explained to them in the beginning, or they didn't have to sign a form?
This is a good question, and one I have considered. I know that audience members sign some forms (which will be going up on the site soon) which basically say they won't sue no matter what Browne says to or about them. But I have yet to hear of any written or oral statement given to guests, stating that Browne isn't always right, etc. What few people I have been in contact with who have been guests on the show say that no such statement was made to them, but that is no proof that it wasn't saiud to others.

As a Gnostic I prided myself on thinking outside of the box. It took a trip through the many discussions in JREF to realize that I wasn't. So I thank you.
What an incredible compliment that is to this forum. Thank you.

I think it ("Michael") has to be counted as a hit, of course chance demands that we get our fair share of hits from any psychic. One that gets everything wrong all the time is almost as supernatural as one that never gets anything wrong.
I agree, which is why I counted it as a hit in the article.

My friends family has Mr.Lancaster in their prayers everyday. Yeah, they PRAY for this man, because they are so happy he is taking these people on.
Again, thanks, Kitty. This family's story moved me deeply when you first shared it with me. Please give them my best.

Amazingly to me, she was outright rejected by everyone of any significance at the meeting, and her track record was discussed - at length. You think skeptics villify SB? Forget it. We're kind and forgiving compared to the Pagan community - which, of course, feels largely betrayed and misrepresented by SB.
Yes, I hear from many in the pagan/wiccan/NewAge/psychic community who vilify Browne.

And, amazingly, Rob's name was brought up in connection to SB! Well, sort of... I believe the comment was, 'There's even some cynic, what's his name, Ronnie Lanchester, who runs a website to expose that [rule 8]'s fraud! MakeSylviaStop.com or something...'
Well, close enough.

English. Furthermore, the man even said he understood 'not so good', indicating he cannot understand English well either.
But in doing so, he indeed spoke English. And yes, I speak one sentence in Frnech, but that does not mean I "speak French." This German man however, responded to Browne's questions with appropriate English sentences, which indicates to me that he understood much of what she was saying.

The debate was re-raised by many other people and I feel I must defend my point. What bothers me is that no one will concede that my viewpoint is even at the very least slightly reasonable.
I understand your point. And I am considering if I could have phrased it more clearly. I believe that everything I said was accurate, but perhaps it could be clearer and more specific.

at what time index does Banner turn green and rip Browne to pieces?
Made me laugh! :D

He does not say "I understand your words". I challenge someone to make an audio file of that exact moment and upload it, and let's see if other people nearby hear "I understand your words".
I'll listen to it again. I transcribed it as best I could, but it is altogether possible I made errors in doing so, and I am open to corrections of any such errors. Perhaps I should mention whenever I transcribe something that I would appreciate any corrections. That is true of anything on my site, but perhaps it would be wise to put in a disclaimer. I believe I did in the earlier articles on the site, but have neglected to do so of late.
 
Lisa, could you possibly embed that video here? If everyone who listens that clip and at approx. the 3:23 mark hears the German man say clearly "and I understand your words". Then I will concede that you are right. I, personally, cannot understand it and hear something like "what" (definitely a t sound) where the word "words" is supposed to be in Lancaster's transcript. I also don't hear the "your" part, it sounds vaguely like "and I understand a little what"
Sorry, but Lisa quoted it exactly - it was quite clear once I turned up the volume.
 
I had a look (and listen) to that YouTube video. As far as I can tell, the German man says, "...I understand all those words."

Which doesn't really make a great difference to how people here are interpreting things.

I'd also like to point out that an suggestion that "it was a setup, they were all German" is clearly bull-doody. Sylvia did readings for five people on that show, and only ONE was a German.
 
I can see where SR comes from after watching the video. What the man says isn't clear and without Randi's statement about talking to the guy after the show I would be 50% 50% on whether the guy spoke enough english to be able to participate in the show. So if you do not trust Randi, you can say that it is not possible to know from the data whether the german's english is good enough. The video does not prove that the man does not speak english as you maintian, but your view is not completely moronic. RSL does trust Randi, which is why he puts Randi's statement and his analysis on the site. The video and the transcript are not the only data used by Robert in drawing his conclusions.

The bigger issue is how this demonstration utterly destroys any notion of SB having supernatural or paranormal powers. She does a really poor cold reading performance with little to no success. Most of her predictions cannot be validated as false because "they are about the future" but it is pretty clear from the audiances reactions that the premises of these predictions are very shaky. SB says that it didn't work because the audiance was German, a fact which is demonstrably false.
 
Oh geez it says 666 replies so this one should get us past the danger zone.

Impossible to read through this entire thread, it exploded too quickly.

Did SylviaRox RETRACT all of the nasty comments about Mr. Lancaster?

This is a skeptic's site and so I am skeptical of this turn-on-a-dime change of position by SR. All that vitriol - then "oh gee shucks I guess I was wrong" in just 24 hours? Seems too good to be true.

But I could be being overly skeptical/cynical. Just does not seem to wash...
 
Oh geez it says 666 replies so this one should get us past the danger zone.

Impossible to read through this entire thread, it exploded too quickly.

Did SylviaRox RETRACT all of the nasty comments about Mr. Lancaster?

This is a skeptic's site and so I am skeptical of this turn-on-a-dime change of position by SR. All that vitriol - then "oh gee shucks I guess I was wrong" in just 24 hours? Seems too good to be true.

But I could be being overly skeptical/cynical. Just does not seem to wash...

Most have been retracted for the most part. Presently there is a semantical forest/trees debate regarding whether Robert lied when he said "the guy spoke reasonable English".

Or....in simpler terms:

:deadhorse
 
Most have been retracted for the most part. Presently there is a semantical forest/trees debate regarding whether Robert lied when he said "the guy spoke reasonable English".

Or....in simpler terms:

:deadhorse
It's just odd. I read that Opening Post and determined that this person essentially kisses the ground Sylvia Browne walks (or floats) upon. And basically is jealously shielding Browne from any how-dare-you dissenting views - that she is the real McCoy. Such behavior indicates a big investment - years of devotion. I dunno. The conciliation came too much and too fast, for me anyway. But then I'm naturally suspicious...:cool:

This is the big problem with the Internet. Ya can't look 'em in the eye when they be speakin' their piece...
 
Last edited:
It's just odd. I read that Opening Post and determined that this person essentially kisses the ground Sylvia Browne walks (or floats) upon. And basically is jealously shielding Browne from any how-dare-you dissenting views - that she is the real McCoy. Such behavior indicates a big investment - years of devotion. I dunno. The conciliation came too much and too fast, for me anyway. But then I'm naturally suspicious...:cool:

This is the big problem with the Internet. Ya can't look 'em in the eye when they be speakin' their piece...

There's nothing wrong with skepticism here at JREF!
 
There's nothing wrong with skepticism here at JREF!
Yep! :)

So I'm scrutinizing this Opening Post again.

This OP was NOT something slammed out in a fit of righteous passion, as I think some of us are wont to do here occasionally. I've done that. Then I come back a bit later, somewhat calmed, and say to myself: What the living hell? No, this was a very carefully constructed statement - almost like a position statement. Almost canned. In any event, this entry was no fit of spitting passion. Exceedingly deliberate.

To buttress the supposed outrage we are all apparently to feel for the esteemed Robert Lancaster, a "Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen" and "Montel Williams" are presented as victims. That's to take the heat away from Browne and to suggest that Robert will prey upon anyone in his "campaign of terror". Tacky, at the very least.

I'm also going by my own journey from the dark side to the light of skepticism, back there in my late teens / early twenties. It took lots of time. The investments in the enfolding comforts of woo aren't tossed aside so frivolously. This OP author is absolutely firmly in Sylvia Browne's corner all the way. She is, after all, a "great spiritual leader". You don't shuck that attitude in a day.

Perhaps this person sensed danger from exactly what he and/or she accused the esteemed Robert Lancaster of: Libel, slander, defamation. And decided to withdraw from this particular battleground. Well, that's something at least. But I, for one, am not going to be getting all lump-in-my-throated weepy over this miraculous "conversion".
 
And of course there's always the chance this person doesn't even believe in Sylvia, and this whole thread was mostly made to get about 670 posts from us..

Actually I would not be surprised at all if that's the case.
 
And of course there's always the chance this person has never even believed in Sylvia, and this whole thread was mostly made to get about 670 posts from us..

Actually I would not be surprised at all if that's the case.
Roger that, I would not be surprised either. It's happened before, especially over in the 9/11 Woo Theory forum.
 
ConspiRaider said:
But I, for one, am not going to be getting all lump-in-my-throated weepy over this miraculous "conversion".
Nor am I, but I'm glad SR made his apologies.

What does make me a little bit lump-in-my-throat weepy are some of the comments made by the former Browne fans (PBF, Seeking Truth, and others) who have stated that they have felt welcomed here among us (mostly atheist) even though they are gnostics.

I'm particularly proud of those forum members that made initial contact with these folks and treated them with respect. I think these former NS members are returning the respect in kind.

Together, we can sorta "join forces" to help RSL improve his SSB website.

We can argue religion with them at a later date. :D
 
The replies that were responded to were carefully hand-picked, as well. But, then I have to ask, to what gain? It seems there was none, if there was, indeed, an ulterior motive. In any event, the end result seems beneficial, to one degree or another.
 
Even if SR is not now above board, this does nothing for SBs side.
 
This OP was NOT something slammed out in a fit of righteous passion, as I think some of us are wont to do here occasionally. I've done that. Then I come back a bit later, somewhat calmed, and say to myself: What the living hell? No, this was a very carefully constructed statement - almost like a position statement. Almost canned. In any event, this entry was no fit of spitting passion. Exceedingly deliberate.
{sheesh} Conspi, I think you are full of, well, [rule8]. Sylvia Browne spies are not likely to go through such an elaborate game but even if they were, even if they did, so who the "F" cares?

Oh no, someone pulled the wool over our eyes.... nooooooooo.....

For crying in the dark, grow up people. Show a little class. Watch Jame Randi. Watch Robert Lancaster. Note the mature and rational approach.

I've got to ask the same question that I've been asking over and over and no one seems to want to answer. What exactly is at stake to make people so cynical? What do you stand to lose? What is this posters possible grand scheme and how will it possibly damage the cause of skepticism?

Your analysis is silly and childish. You could be right but I find it unlikely. But even if it is true it really makes no difference. There is nothing to be gained. If this person is doing this he will only look like an idiot in the end.

In any event, the OP makes perfect sense from a true believer's stand point. I've been there. I've made similar arguments.

Hang in there rox. We're not all paranoid.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps to settle the point for good, do you think we could identify and locate this German chap, and ask him directly what he thought of and perhaps said at the event?

Let's be skeptics! Do our research!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom