Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Quotes from Randi:

Only one member of that audience of 140 persons was German, though he spoke English, and you spent a full one minute and seven seconds rattling off wrong guesses for him, then found out he was German, only after he told you that — in English!

Robert: re the Bixby/Browne video, it should be said that I mixed with that section of our audience following the incident, and as far as I could tell, all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

Quotes from RSL, bold mine:

Here then is the German gentleman Randi mentioned in his commentary. He seemed to speak reasonable English, but could not validate anything Browne said, since it was all future-related.

All of them spoke English.

RSL does not say they were all English speakers. He said they spoke English. Our German friend didn't say "Ich spreche nicht Englisch. Ich verstehe nicht." He said words in English. What words he said can be argued until the cows come home.

He said words in English. Therefore he spoke English in the video.
 
People, people... what sort of skeptics are you, anyway?

Consider--what evidence do we have that the man was, in fact, German to begin with? Merely his own word. And we know how unreliable that can be. What is more, let us examine his own testimony. He says he is "German", yes? Oddly enough... that's an English word, not a German word. It's true; I looked it up. In fact, other than the unintelligible word, which may or may not have been German, every single word he speaks is English. What evidence do we have that this man speaks anything but English?

:D :D :D

:D
I know your post is light-hearted, but it makes me think of this thread.

As you say, from the TV clip, the only evidence that he speaks German is his assertion in English and perhaps his accent. Some people say that all claims require the same evidence, but it just isn't so. In this case, most of us are happy to accept that he speaks German with virtually no evidence. The claim is not extraordinary. It doesn't require rewriting any major branches of science. It doesn't raise more questions than it answers.

I do like your point for this discussion though--Robert's statement that the guy speaks English is obviously true simply because the guy speaks English on this clip. In fact, it's the only language he speaks in this clip.
 
If it'd been me, she would have got only this from me:

"Million Dollar Challenge." :D

M.

 
Last edited:
:D
I know your post is light-hearted, but it makes me think of this thread.

As you say, from the TV clip, the only evidence that he speaks German is his assertion in English and perhaps his accent. Some people say that all claims require the same evidence, but it just isn't so. In this case, most of us are happy to accept that he speaks German with virtually no evidence. The claim is not extraordinary. It doesn't require rewriting any major branches of science. It doesn't raise more questions than it answers.

I do like your point for this discussion though--Robert's statement that the guy speaks English is obviously true simply because the guy speaks English on this clip. In fact, it's the only language he speaks in this clip.

I was thinking largely along the same lines. Thanks for saving me the effort phrasing it this well.
 
If it'd been me, she would have got only this from me:

"Million Dollar Challenge." :D

M.


Moochie--since this took place in 1989, before the challenge was up to a million dollars (I think), are you making a claim of precognitive ability?
;)
 
For Lancaster to not have been lying/mistaken, you must believe in that definition.
We all seem to agree the man was speaking.
If the man was not speaking English, what language was he speaking?
 
SR, like I've already mentioned before, Robert made it pretty clear that the German isn't an English speaker when wrote this part in the article:

"He seemed to speak reasonable English, but could not validate anything Browne said, since it was all future-related. "


If it said that the German spoke perfect English on the show, then I could see why it would bother you.. but that part in the aricle sounds pretty honest to me. And notice that he also put the word "seemed" at the beginning, so that the readers would not take it as a fact.
 
Last edited:
He does not say "I understand your words". I challenge someone to make an audio file of that exact moment and upload it, and let's see if other people nearby hear "I understand your words". Please respond directly to the audio of the video file itself, Randi's testimony is based on exactly what we see in the video, he knows no more than we do.

WRONG.

This above post is making me question whether you read/understood the article and Randi's particpation in the tv show.

1) Randi was there and knows more than we (who are just watching a video) do.

2) Randi spoke to the German, and signed an autograph:

all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml

So its your word, which appears idiosyncratic/biased and based on a video vs Randi's who was there and spoke to the German.
 
Last edited:
First, thanks to all for the kind words, and the defense of the article in question. As has been leaked by Juliette, Susan and I got married on Friday, and we left Saturday for a day trip out of town, which is why I am only now responding to much of this thread.

SylviaRox, I've read through to the end of the thread, and have seen that you have modified your position. I respect both your ability to have done so, and the intestinal fortitude it took to admit it.

Here I will respond to your post where you stated your modified opinion. In a subsequent post, I'll respond to and comment on other things in the thread.

1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.
Apology acecpted.

Earlier in the thread you indicated (forgive me, I've lost the quote) that you felt I had every reason to want to cause problems for the webmaster of the GoSylviaBrowne site.

This is not the case. I was (and still am) anxious to see what Heather comes up with in the way of supporting evidence. And people causing her problems on her forum and guestbook just gives her one more excuse (true or not) for not having posted any such evidence up to this point.

You have been shown links to my posts in the GoSylviaBrowne web thread, where I tried to discourage trolling. That was not posturing for legal reasons, that was (and is) my strong opinion on the subject.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.
Apology accepted.

I am not an attorney, but rest assured that I have gotten lots of legal advice on copyright issues as they relate to what I do on the site.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.
Yes, she did say "Michael," and I acknoledged this as correct in the article. How unlikely is it? I do not know. But I do know that the popularity of the name makes it less impressive than it would otherwise have been. Had she guessed a much rarer name and been correct, it would have been much more interesting. Similarly, if she got his last name right (or substantially right), it would have been interesting. But we currently do not know whether she did or not.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.
Thanks for acknowledging that last part. You seem to take most exception to my statement "They all spoke English." While I still feel it to be accurate, if you feel there is a way it could be phrased better, I am open to hearing it.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.
I agree.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.
As many others have stated in this thread: if you find proof of her getting any documented reading correct, please let me know.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.
Yes, please judge the site on its own merits (or lack thereof). I am always open to criticism of the site. If you feel that I have been unfair, inaccurate, misleading or untruthful in any point I make in any article on the site, PLEASE let me know.

I am by no means infallible. I try to get things right in an article before releasing it, but have, on more than one occasion, been corrected on a problem within an arrticle. I correct these when they are pointed out to me.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.
Indeed.

And again, my thanks to all here who kept it (mostly) civil and to the point.
 
SR - What can I say, seems very clear to me he says "I understand your words" with "your" sounding more like "ver".

You are of course welcome to your opinion...but seems quite a up-hill battle on your part to convince folks here regarding your point of view.

SB was wrong about everyone being German, and about nobody being able to understand her and has no proof of these claims. The video, and other first hand "testimony", and the education system within Germany seems to indicate otherwise.

I've listened to that clip about10 times now and it sounds to me like he's saying "I understand your words" but the "your" is pronounced like yer-er (2 syllables). (Think Fuhrer but pronounce Yuhrer - Hey have I Godwinized this thread?) :D
 
Hi Fran,
Thanks...I'm still new here and am a little intimidated.

Me too :)

Afraid to be both skeptical and spiritual and seeming flaky. :redface1
I'm alot like you. I basically live a simple, peaceful life. I don't want to be banged over the head with religion (can't stand that) nor do I really want to have to prove everything like whether my NDE was a spiritual or a scientifically explained event. To me it was both. But, in here it makes for a great discussion, huh? Could it be both? <rhetorical> I think so... :)

Yes, I guess most people on here are like that, just living their lives respecting others as long as others respect them. It might seem different on here now and then, but then this is a forum made to discuss such things, so that would be natural, yes :) And yeah, this forum would soon lose its dynamics if everybody thought exactly the same, wouldn't be much to discuss then.

I don't agree with you on the things you mention, but based on my (personal) definitions of a woo above, you are not one, and I respect you for that!
 
Sylvia approaches the man. She starts to make her predictions. After it, he says, "I understand not so good. I am a German."

and you are taking his comment out of context. she was making predictions; that's it

in some people, they dont understand what a prediction is or how it relates to them in general. If someone said that a person named BOB has some influence in my life, of course I wouldn't understand what that person is referring to (i dont know any bobs, roberts or anyone of that variation of name personally).

becaues of the nature of cold reading, the "scam" is in making sure that the person is not able to validate or invalidate the claims made by the "psychic".

You need to brush up on the modus operandi of fake psychics.




All of the words that he speaks are related to him not being able to understand her. His English is very broken. He says finally says 'yes' to get her to move on, which she does. He is embarrassed and uncomfortable and doesn't look her in the eye. I do not consider this man to be an English speaker. Therefore, Lancaster's statement that "All of them spoke English" is incorrect, or at the very least is drawn well into the realm of reasonable doubt.

that is YOUR assumption. You have to seperate what yOU assume from what is the facts

1) the MAN spoke english to both SYLVIA and the camera.
2) that is Lancaster's assertion; the man spoke english

If you are taking more from what is presented on the video and from his statement, then you are MAKING AN ASSUMPTION.


Now, you are playing a double standard; why do you continue to ignore that Sylvia stated that the ALL of them didn't speak english? THAT ALL the audience members were german?


Im not making any assumption from her statement.

It comes down to this, when we say someone speaks English, do we mean:

a) that person spoke at least some English words at some point in the past (apparently, Lisa's notion) or

b) that person can speak English on a relatively comfortable level (beyond the 'I understand not so good' phase)

why on those three? Again you are assuming something that isn't even there to begin with

Lancaster made this statement : the man spoke english

that's a fact. HE SPOKE english.


I dont take anything else from that statement; the reason why Lancaster pointed this out, is to REFUTE the Sylvia;s clkaim that NO One spoke english and that they wERE ALL german.
 
First, thanks to all for the kind words, and the defense of the article in question. As has been leaked by Juliette, Susan and I got married on Friday, and we left Saturday for a day trip out of town, which is why I am only now responding to much of this thread.

Congratulations RSL!! Many, many happy years to you both.
 
Please respond directly to the audio of the video file itself, Randi's testimony is based on exactly what we see in the video, he knows no more than we do.


Actually, Randi's testimony is based on far more than just what was in the video. He makes it clear he mingled with the audience after the segment, and talked with them enough to evealuate the Gereman fellow's English ability. Note that he talked directly with the German fellow:



Robert: re the Bixby/Browne video, it should be said that I mixed with that section of our audience following the incident, and as far as I could tell, all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

James Randi


So regardless of what we can or cannot make out in the video, Randi's account is additional info that must be considered.
 
okay so out of all the articles on the SSB website, this is the only thing that SR had a problem with? and its not even a major problem (its just semantics thing).

So, no other claims by SR to prove his claims?
 
Think Fuhrer but pronounce Yuhrer - Hey have I Godwinized this thread?) :D

No. You have to compare someone or something to the Nazis without a very good reason for doing so. And "Führer" simply means "leader" in English, (though the Nazis banned use of the word as a reference to anyone other than Hitler, except in compound words, and for obvious reasons it has fallen into disfavor in modern German).

Further, even if you did, we'd have to apply Quirk's Exception to you. :p
 
Sorry if this has already been said, but I must admit I'm a bit puzzled by this whole issue of whether the audience could speak English. It's clear that the German guy in the audience could speak English at least to some extent, so RSL's comment that "he seemed to speak reasonable English" is clearly not a lie.

But what's really puzzling me is Browne's suggestion that a non English speaking audience was "a setup".

Why would a non English speaking audience cause her problems? Surely she could just give her "psychic" readings, and if necessary they could be translated and verified later if they weren't understood.

The only way I can see the language issue causing her to fail would be if she for some reason needed to communicate with the people she was giving readings for, rather than getting her information from the "spirit world".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom