Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

I would concede that SylviaRox has a valid point: the man clearly was having trouble understanding the reading. Maybe he was just trying to get Browne to go away, but if he was faking it, we can't blame Browne for being fooled.

But there remain two basic facts:

"He spoke English" is literally correct.
Although that comment could be interpreted to mean "he speaks English better than he does," RSL gives the transcript and the original video, so it is easy to understand the situation.

You have to contrast this to Sylvia's claim, which is not literally correct, and does not provide context to help us understand what really happened.

Let's say that we concede that the man did not understand Sylvia and that he should not have been in audience. The majority disagree with you, but I don't think anyone thinks you're unreasonable for believing that.

I suggest you ignore the reading for the German gentleman, and look at the readings for the native English speakers and compare those readings to Sylvia's account. Remember, Sylvia claimed they were all German and none of them could understand a single word.
 
Throwing my hat in the ring....

I have not read that article and transcript on RSL's website, though I've read others. I watched the YouTube video, and this is my transcription of the relevant section. S = Sylvia, G = German guy

S: Then you're going to get into a lot of marketing and sales work,
and this marketing and sales work has to do with 3 other men that
you're going to be training.

G: I understand (something? work?) because I am a German.

S: I don't care whether you are a German, you still work or not work,
don't you? I mean, we do that in France or in Germany, or wherever,
don't we?

G: (sounds like) I'm up to my seek fen I speak English, and I understand
your words.

S: Ok, 2 years of no working that you like. OK.
(turns to crowd) My German. OK. (turns back) And then you're going
to be doing some telemarketing work, marketing sales.

G: Yes.

S: Yes. Is that yes for me or yes for you?

G: Yes for me

S: OK. Let's see, who else? (goes to another in the audience).


Several points come to mind about this:

It seems pretty clear to me that G is saying "I understand your words", though I may be predisposed to hearing it this way due to the previous conversations in this message thread.

He seems to understand Sylvia's question of "Yes for you or yes for me" when he replies "Yes for me", though I don't know if that means he understands the full content of what she said. Would Sylvia count this as a "hit"?

He appears to be able to comprehend some English, even if his speaking is not so fluid or fluent.

Note that the emcee is speaking in English; the entire context of the show appears to assume an English-understanding audience for both listeners and participants. If the participants couldn't understand English, why would they even be there?

And, regarding "why would they be there", I would bet money that he was dragged to the show by his girlfriend, who I would also bet speaks English better than he does. Being called upon under the bright lights, after being dragged to the show, would be a quite stressful situation.



As an attempt to inject a little humor into all this, here's the "What did Jesse Jackson Say?" game. It's done on a Los Angeles radio station, though it may be broadcast nationwide. It consists of audio clips from speeches given by the Rev. Jesse Jackson, and listeners are invited to call in and try to figure out what he's saying.
http://www.971freefm.com/pages/4627.php
 
Last edited:
SylviaRox: The title of this thread is "stop RL, slanderer of SB." This point about speaking English has been discussed quite a bit. How about some other, more clear cut examples of RL slandering SB?
 
The direct quote from the transcript is: "I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words."

On a slight tangent to this point, the statement in question also highlights another cold reading technique. Sylvia had just made a psychic guess of some sort, and was hoping to get the audience member to fill in the info ("Oh yes, you're referring to my Uncle Fred who died last year--how could you possibly know that!") When, there's a pause, it usually means a complete miss (in this case, it probably means that this audience was coached NOT to help by giving information). The cold reading technique Sylvia used is to follow the pause quickly with "Do you understand?" Most everyone will answer in the affirmative, and that affirmation can be used in the show as a hit on the wild guess that was actually a complete miss.

For instance:

psychic: I'm getting the name Herb and something to do with a check. Does that mean anything to you?

readee: [no response or confused look]

psychic: Do you understand me?

readee: Yes.

[producer cues the "applause" sign, so the audience claps and on TV it looks like a hit--while the psychic quickly moves on to the next person]
 
i feel you are grasping at the "english spoken" as a face saving exercise ....i know because I use this tactic with my husband all the time!!

You have conceded some points so you want someone to concede something to you...I understand,you are only human....

I agree with laura here. If I came in here swinging, got my ass handed to me and had to admit I was wrong and apologize, I'd want SOME vestige of pride ... something face-saving that I could cling to.

Speaking personally, I'd be prepared to concede that the exact words and meaning are open to interpretation, stand by RSL's as being correct, and focus on Gravy's admonition to step back a bit.
 
SylviaRox: The title of this thread is "stop RL, slanderer of SB." This point about speaking English has been discussed quite a bit. How about some other, more clear cut examples of RL slandering SB?

SylviaRox has recanted pretty much all of his accusations now. Go back up the thread a bit.
 
SylviaRox: The title of this thread is "stop RL, slanderer of SB." This point about speaking English has been discussed quite a bit. How about some other, more clear cut examples of RL slandering SB?

I think that general statement has been withdrawn.
 
I agree with SylviaRox that Robert's transcript might not be exact, and perhaps he should consider correcting it on his site. It's quite difficult to hear exactly what this german says, and I don't see how a clear transcript can be provided. I hear it more like "I understand a few words". Of course it's extreme nitpicking, but even minor errors are worth correcting on such a site, so believers won't find faults to hang on to when they try to find excuses to reject the site entirely.
 
People, people... what sort of skeptics are you, anyway?

Consider--what evidence do we have that the man was, in fact, German to begin with? Merely his own word. And we know how unreliable that can be. What is more, let us examine his own testimony. He says he is "German", yes? Oddly enough... that's an English word, not a German word. It's true; I looked it up. In fact, other than the unintelligible word, which may or may not have been German, every single word he speaks is English. What evidence do we have that this man speaks anything but English?

:D :D :D
 
I would like to know what percentage of Hispanics make up the prison population in the US, ie, if she guesses a Hispanic person committed a crime, is she likely to be right solely because Hispanics make up a larger than average part of the prison population.
DOJ website and about three minutes of looking will probably give you an answer, if you are curious.

DR
 
S: Yes. Is that yes for me or yes for you?

G: Yes for me

This bears repeating, because it demonstrates his comprehension. I'm leaving the German conversation in general because I'm about ready to start posting cats.

I repeat my assertion that if this is the only critique that can be put forward, then Robert's site is pretty darned reliable.
 
People, people... what sort of skeptics are you, anyway?

Consider--what evidence do we have that the man was, in fact, German to begin with? Merely his own word. And we know how unreliable that can be. What is more, let us examine his own testimony. He says he is "German", yes? Oddly enough... that's an English word, not a German word. It's true; I looked it up. In fact, other than the unintelligible word, which may or may not have been German, every single word he speaks is English. What evidence do we have that this man speaks anything but English?

:D :D :D

Excellent analysis!

M.
 
We may never settle this, but I believe he says "I must in my (unintelligible)-er speak English, and I understand your (or more) words."

That is not the way a native English speaker would phrase it, but that's a very German construction. It could mean something like "I have to practice more at work, so I'll understand English better."

It's not really relevant, in my opinion. Sylvia did poorly all around, and she misrepresented the situation. If she'd done better with the other readings no would care that she couldn't make this man understand her.
 
We may never settle this, but I believe he says "I must in my (unintelligible)-er speak English, and I understand your (or more) words."

That is not the way a native English speaker would phrase it, but that's a very German construction. It could mean something like "I have to practice more at work, so I'll understand English better."

It's not really relevant, in my opinion. Sylvia did poorly all around, and she misrepresented the situation. If she'd done better with the other readings no would care that she couldn't make this man understand her.

Thank you for being level-headed Christine...
 
SR - I think many on here have been "level-headed".

I clearly hear him say "...I understand your words"; then again I've spent time in Germany and their accent does not bother me.

I mention again, as you disagree and are in the minority (wrt the German guy and what he says) I think the burden of proof is on you.
 
I had to listen about ten times... here's what it sounds like to me:

"I must in my field speak English, and I understand your words."

The part in lime is very difficult to make out, however, and I could be wrong; the rest, though - including 'I understand your words' - is clear enough. Further, you can lip-read his last few words there, and he clearly says 'I understand your words.'

That he can say even this much means he speaks English, since that's not likely a stock-phrase someone's going to use if they DON'T speak the language.

Plus, looking at his apparent age, he learned English in school - though, like many Americans learning a second language, he may not have retained much.

His facial expressions suggest he was somewhat hostile toward her - a look of embarrassment and vague bemusement, really.

Man, she bombed badly that whole night, didn't she?
 
I am German, and here are my 2 cents regarding that German guy, for what it's worth:


I finally watched the actual video and it seemed to me that the guy was more embarassed than anything else. To me it was painfully obvious tha he didn't want to be focused on and wanted to get the whole thing over with as fast as possible.

My thoughts exactly.

It sounds sort of like "I understand a little what". That makes no sense, but neither does "I understand you well" given the context. There is DEFINITELY a 't' sound.

I can't be sure that he's saying "I understand your words". The 'your' could quite possibly be 'more'. This would also make sense if the unintelligible part was 'learning to'. This would make his sentence something along the lines of; "I'm learning to speak English and then I'll understand more words."

I am quite certain he says "I must do much think[in'] when you speak English ... and [then] I understand one['s] words"

The [] stuff added by me, of course. Reno's "more words" would make perfect sense, too, in my opinion.

Some background info:

This guy, in my opinion, knows English quite well. He can read and understand business letters, and he would understand almost all of a speech given by the Queen of England. He sounds exactly like the men the age of my father, who had not learned English since the age of 11 (as today in almost all German schools), but instead learned Latin and Greek if they went to a secondary school. Their English sounds horrible.

These guys have big problems chatting away in a fluent, casual conversation, especially in American English.

Also, do not forget the situation he was in, during a TV show, suddenly being approached by that woman, and he obviously had no idea what was going on.

The woman next to him, I guess it was a good friend or his wife, seemed much more interested in the fact that Sylvia talked to him. I can not hear what she says (she speaks German to him), but I am quite certain it was _her_ idea to go to that TV show, not his.

I guess he had no idea what was going on, no matter how good or bad his English.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom