Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Randi's testimony is based on exactly what we see in the video, he knows no more than we do.

Categorically false.

Randi was there and spoke with the guest beyond what is shown on the video, as he so states.
 
Last edited:
SR - What can I say, seems very clear to me he says "I understand your words" with "your" sounding more like "ver".

You are of course welcome to your opinion...but seems quite a up-hill battle on your part to convince folks here regarding your point of view.

SB was wrong about everyone being German, and about nobody being able to understand her and has no proof of these claims. The video, and other first hand "testimony", and the education system within Germany seems to indicate otherwise.

Seconded.

And I'm quite curious about the obsessive level debate on this. If the guy is not fluent, Robert must be a slanderer?

Reminds me of "Pull it".
 
"I challenge someone to make an audio file of that exact moment and upload it...."

While easy to do, seems like a unreasonable request. Why?

Let me put on my official Sylvia Browne Secret Psychic Hat and Decoder Ring...ah yes, of course...you'd claim the audio file was somehow manipulated/altered.
 
What do you hear him say, SRox?

It sounds sort of like "I understand a little what". That makes no sense, but neither does "I understand you well" given the context. There is DEFINITELY a 't' sound.
 
"I challenge someone to make an audio file of that exact moment and upload it...."

While easy to do, seems like a unreasonable request. Why?

Let me put on my official Sylvia Browne Secret Psychic Hat and Decoder Ring...ah yes, of course...you'd claim the audio file was somehow manipulated/altered.

I have listened to section of the clip about 25-30 times. I do not hear those words and I do not believe they are there.
 
OK, I put the passage in question on a loop and listened to it over and over until I got dizzy and almost fell over.

I can't be sure that he's saying "I understand your words". The 'your' could quite possibly be 'more'. This would also make sense if the unintelligible part was 'learning to'. This would make his sentence something along the lines of; "I'm learning to speak English and then I'll understand more words."

If this is in fact what he says, then I take it to mean that he couldn't quite catch everything Browne was telling him because his vocabulary is not extensive.

But the whole point is that he and Browne managed to communicate with each other using English words. Therefore, the German guy spoke English.
 
He does not say "I understand your words". I challenge someone to make an audio file of that exact moment and upload it, and let's see if other people nearby hear "I understand your words". Please respond directly to the audio of the video file itself, Randi's testimony is based on exactly what we see in the video, he knows no more than we do.

Quibble all you like over what the exact words spoken by the German gentleman were, but it is exceedingly clear he spoke English, and that everyone else in that video clip who spoke did so, too. I fail to see what argument you are pursuing here. The clip itself utterly puts the lie to Browne's weasel words.

M.
 
"I have listened to section of the clip about 25-30 times. I do not hear those words and I do not believe they are there."

SR - As I said, you are welcome to your opinion but I'd have to say you are by far in the minority. As such, I'd say the "burden of proof" is on you in terms of providing documentation of your claim.
 
OK, I put the passage in question on a loop and listened to it over and over until I got dizzy and almost fell over.

I can't be sure that he's saying "I understand your words". The 'your' could quite possibly be 'more'. This would also make sense if the unintelligible part was 'learning to'. This would make his sentence something along the lines of; "I'm learning to speak English and then I'll understand more words."

If this is in fact what he says, then I take it to mean that he couldn't quite catch everything Browne was telling him because his vocabulary is not extensive.

But the whole point is that he and Browne managed to communicate with each other using English words. Therefore, the German guy spoke English.

Thank you for putting in the effort.

The German guy spoke English, just like I can say "Bonjour, ça va, ma voisine?" to my French neighbor and 'speak French'. But she would never say in article about me that "Gary speaks French." At the very least admit that "they all spoke English" could potentially be misinterpreted as saying the man was fluent if read out of context. (Apparently Gravy does not understand that I am not trying to prove Lancaster is a liar anymore, I am just trying to defend one of my original points which I do not feel is totally invalid).
 
Quibble all you like over what the exact words spoken by the German gentleman were, but it is exceedingly clear he spoke English, and that everyone else in that video clip who spoke did so, too. I fail to see what argument you are pursuing here. The clip itself utterly puts the lie to Browne's weasel words.

M.

No one seems to have listened to my repeated statements that I am not using this German issue against Lancaster anymore, I am just defending a point in and of itself which was re-raised several times after I reassessed my original post. I am not trying to make a case against Lancaster, so stop asking "where is this leading to" and similar questions.
 
He has also insulted and questioned the honor of Montel Williams, a navy hero, who is currently suffering with multiple sclerosis.
- Gary Richardson, admirer of Sylvia Browne
Gary, Montel Williams as Navy Hero would need to be supported by citations for heroism from his service record.

Do you have any? (Also, IIRC it was Hal Bidlack who so called Mr Williams on the matter of his honor, or lack thereof.)

I think you will find that Montel has no citations for heroism in the Navy, and that having MS is not a criterion for heroism, though I personally admire Montel's battle against MS, and his advocacy for MS programs through is public persona and his position in the media. I also am pleased with his support for Disabled Vets, and his use of his public persona as an advocate for that cause.

Hero?

Show me.

DR
 
Thank you for putting in the effort.

The German guy spoke English, just like I can say "Bonjour, ça va, ma voisine?" to my French neighbor and 'speak French'.

Clearly, these are not parallel or equivilant positions.

That guy clearly understood significant amounts of English.
 
Right, this is my final word on the whole 'speaking English' point.

Thank you for putting in the effort.

Don't mention it, it's what we do here.

The German guy spoke English, just like I can say "Bonjour, ça va, ma voisine?" to my French neighbor and 'speak French'. But she would never say in article about me that "Gary speaks French." At the very least admit that "they all spoke English" could potentially be misinterpreted as saying the man was fluent if read out of context.

He did not say enough (in your opinion) while on camera, to be regarded as being able to speak English Ok, we all see that. But please consider what happened OFF camera. The German guy asked Randi and Bixby for their autographs. Randi says the guy spoke English fairly well. So. Either you accept that the German guy actually could speak English, or you think that Randi is a liar. Considering that Browne lied about everything on that show (as shown by the clip), I put it to you that the German guy could speak English fairly well, but just didn't display that on camera. All he did on camera was communicate for a few seconds with Browne. In English.
 
Wow--I was away for some pretty dramatic stuff.

Hats off to you, SylviaRox, for opening your mind.

I still think you're wrong in regards to 3 points--Robert's statement on the audience Sylvia said was composed entirely of people who didn't understand English, Robert's fair use of copyrighted clips, and the chances of getting the name Michael right.

I'd like to stick with just the last one. Again, if you could count up the number of names (and initial letters and "sounds like" and "something like" names) that Sylvia makes psychic readings for, she is almost certainly to get some hits sometimes based purely on chance. (And, I have to go along with the crowd, that picking the name "Michael" rather than "Jebediah" greatly increases her odds from pure chance.)

She plays the odds game often--sometimes to her own detriment. In one case on Montel (QG has the details, I'm sure), a distraught and tearful mother tells Sylvia that her daughter has been gone for a couple of years. She wants to know what happened. Sylvia, assuming this is a missing child case and playing that odds that anyone gone that long is mostly likely dead (same thing she did in the Shawn Hornbeck case--it is almost unheard of for a missing child to turn up alive after so long). She tells the woman that her daughter was shot. (Again, a safe bet, since chances are in missing child cases this old, no body will ever be found. Telling the mother that her daughter died by gunshot is less upsetting than saying she was sexually assaulted for weeks, then starved to death.) Actually, though, the daughter dropped dead in her bedroom. The woman was asking Sylvia to solve a medical mystery, not a crime. Sylvia quickly backpedalled and re-defined "she was shot" to "she was hit in the chest" so she could shoehorn it to fit any number of medical conditions (heart attack, respiratory arrest, etc.) JFK and Lincoln were both shot to death--neither was hit in the chest, so the statements are not in the least equivalent.

If you add in all the other psychic guesses that Sylvia makes (not just names), the number of possible hits is staggeringly huge. Again, it would be more outrageous if she NEVER got something right by chance (and by increasing her chances with just a bit of knowledge about normal outcomes of missing child cases).

More than that, most believers in psychics listen to more than one psychic. The tabloids print LOTS of psychic predictions. A few hits here and there are certain.

Please, if you can, read this very nice essay on coincidence or the law of very large numbers from the Skeptic's Dictionary:

http://skepdic.com/lawofnumbers.html

After your initial emotional attacks, you seem to have calmed down and become a reasonable and thoughtful person. Again--hats off to you.
 
Last edited:
(Apparently Gravy does not understand that I am not trying to prove Lancaster is a liar anymore, I am just trying to defend one of my original points which I do not feel is totally invalid).
My bad. Thanks for the clarification. I'll repeat my suggestion that you take a step back and look at the big picture here.
 
SR,


You are arguing semantics based on what you think Mr. Lancaster means when he wrote something based on the exact usage and wording of what he stated. As has been pointed out repeatedly, while what Mr. Lancaster said can be inferred to mean many things, what he actually states is factually correct.


When listening or reading what Ms. Browne says, it is often left up to the individual to pull specific meaning from her words. When reading or listening to Mr. Lancaster or Randi they are very precise in the language they use to state exactly what they mean. There is no need to try and infer meaning.

It can be difficult to change from one style to another, if you are in the habit of needing to infer meaning due to the ambiguous nature of a statement then you will do so automatically, regardless of whether it is necessary.

You are making assumptions and seeking to get others to make the same assumptions you did. Many of the people here no longer try to guess at what the writer or speaker is trying to say, they will take their words at face value and if a claim is made they will seek evidence as to the truth of that claim. '


Ms. Browne stated "And they were all German, and they couldn't understand one word I said. And that was a setup, as you well know."

Mr. Lancaster in reviewing the tape notes : " Only one she spoke with was German."


Ms. Browne: "...they couldn't understand one word I said."


Mr. Lancaster: "With the one exception, everyone she read seemed to understand her fine."


Finally, Ms. Browne: "...they couldn't speak English."

Mr. Lancaster: "All of them spoke English."


The direct quote from the transcript is: "I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words."


There is no amibiguity in what is said. There is no need to try and infer meaning on what was said. The man stated he understood her words, even if the unintelligble word is 'don't' he states he understands her words.

This is not the crux of the issue though. Ms. Browne stated "all" were German and did not speak English. The women and other man on the tape are clearly fluent English speakers. This makes her statement a lie.

In continuing to pursue this matter you are undermining any chance of having readers take any other claims you wish to make seriously. You are only hurting yourself and it is becoming painful to watch. Please just let it go.



Boo
 
OH yeah--also, to the larger claim that Sylvia helps police: she and her supporters will claim "Michael" as evidence. In fact, everything else in her reading in this case was dead wrong. The name Michael did not help police. In fact, the reading sent investigators and police on a wild goose chase (wasting time and money) and sent the parents on a terrible emotional rollercoaster ride.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom