Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

I will (and have many times) conceded that the man did not speak English well. However, that does not change the fact that Robert did not lie. The man spoke some English. Therefore, when his article stated "they all spoke English" it was not a lie.

Exactly. And I stick by my much earlier post where I ventured the opinion that to my eyes, the man was bemused by SB's presumptuousness (in picking on him -- not something one does to a German) and that he may have feigned his lack of English skills to get rid of her. She did seem to leave him rather quickly.

Out of the words he did speak, all but one were perfectly good English, which doesn't surprise me, since a very large part of the German population has learned English as part of their normal schooling. The one word that was unintelligible may have been English as well, but neither me nor the CNN transcriber was able to decipher it.

M.
 
Where do you think he says that (the minute, second of the YouTube clip)? I have watched it a few times and don't see it.


Approximately 3:23. It's also in the transcript Robert has on his site.

I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words.

BTW, your example of A and B is called a false dichotomy. Either he speaks enough English to be an English speaker or he doesn't. Language is much more fluid than either/or.
 
2. Lancaster says the man speaks English.
.

Lancaster said the mans speaks REASONABLE ENGLISH on the site, and links to the video so people can see for themselves. And he does say, "I understand your words."

This is not lying. Saying the entire audience was German, that none of them spoke English, and that it was all a big setup is lying. I would never maintain that the man was fluent, but, if someone answers in English "I understand your words", I would guess that he got the gyst of what she was saying.

This is a classic forest and tress scenario. Robert did not write an article about how well one man spoke English. He created an article exposing that Sylvia lied about the incident. That is clear, and you have admitted as much.

If this is the only arguable criticism you have to make about the content of his site, then, I'd say it's a great testament to just how credible the content is.
 
Then you believe in the a) definition of what it means for somebody to speak English as I presented in my post a while back?

There seems to be a simple disagreement as to whether or not the guy spoke English. You want to interpret what RSL said as "they all spoke fluent English." Many of the rest of us read "they all spoke English (enough to understand their readings)." Now, you are saying RSL misrepresents the facts or lies. The real problem with your accusation is that RSL presents the facts first, and then writes his opinions about those facts. We can read the transcript because it's presented. We can see how well the guy speaks English and come up with our own conclusions as to Sylvia's statement that none of them spoke English. If RSL was to lie or misrepresent facts, would it not be the dumbest thing in the world to present all of the raw data to us regarding those facts?

So you can disagree with the statement that "they all spoke English." It is probably a matter of opinion, although yours is very much in the minority. I highly doubt that RSL is telling lies or manipulating data for his cause because of the reasons stated above. Another thing to note is that there is no need to manipulate data or lie in order to point out how consistently wrong Sylvia Browne is.
 
Last edited:
Just for SRs' information -and others - and because of experience with low level readers/listeners (and this is a standard I would hold a person not heavily into language mastery study). It is quite possible for a person who speaks english to be able to understand the words being used but not understand the meaning of the overall written/spoken material (they can decode the words but not the message).

Second, if SR is changing opinion, that is great! However, just for clarity - my first post on this forum is my firm educated opinion on the initial post and on Browne. Note also that the comments I made refer to the post not to SR. My initial concerns with SR - not stated - may now be mitigated. My opinion of Browne and the post against Lancaster remain perfectly steady and on target.
 
For Lancaster to not have been lying/mistaken, you must believe in that definition.

For Lancaster not to have been mistaken, you need to play a semantic game.

For Sylvia to not have been lying or mistaken you have to live in an entirely different reality.

In fact, most of what Sylvia says is a lie, mistaken, misleading, obfuscating, open to interpretation, and readily twisted by her groupies. If you apply the standards you are demanding we place on Robert to Sylvia Brown, you would readily see how silly you sound. Everything Sylvia says is twisted so it's not exactly a lie--and everything Robert says is twisted to make it sound as "wrong" as possible.
 
Approximately 3:23. It's also in the transcript Robert has on his site.



BTW, your example of A and B is called a false dichotomy. Either he speaks enough English to be an English speaker or he doesn't. Language is much more fluid than either/or.

Lisa, could you possibly embed that video here? If everyone who listens that clip and at approx. the 3:23 mark hears the German man say clearly "and I understand your words". Then I will concede that you are right. I, personally, cannot understand it and hear something like "what" (definitely a t sound) where the word "words" is supposed to be in Lancaster's transcript. I also don't hear the "your" part, it sounds vaguely like "and I understand a little what"
 
Last edited:
The German guy understood her (Browne's) words - he says this clearly in english. When he says "I understand not so good", he's saying that he doesn't understand what she's talking about. e.g. her predictions have no meaning for him. He understands the words, but they make no sense to him as a prediction.
 
first, well done SR for listening to the arguments and to start to change your position.

i feel you are grasping at the "english spoken" as a face saving exercise ....i know because I use this tactic with my husband all the time!!

You have conceded some points so you want someone to concede something to you...I understand,you are only human.

secondly,apart from the odd nasty comment,well done forumites for a decently conducted debate.

Many people will find their way here..by accident,when looking up SB,and if they have the strength to read this thread,they will find useful facts,reasoned debate...and Roberts web site.

It is in this way that we can have the most impact on the woo...brick by brick,word by word,fact by fact.
Not by being rude and nasty to people,who genuinely believe this stuff.I know its hard to be patient with such people,especially when they seem incapable of answering any questions put to them(although SR,has taken on board quite a lot imho)
so onwards and upwards....
 
The German guy understood her (Browne's) words - he says this clearly in english. When he says "I understand not so good", he's saying that he doesn't understand what she's talking about. e.g. her predictions have no meaning for him. He understands the words, but they make no sense to him as a prediction.

I finally watched the actual video and it seemed to me that the guy was more embarassed than anything else. To me it was painfully obvious tha he didn't want to be focused on and wanted to get the whole thing over with as fast as possible.
 
Still on this one point? And this is the ONLY THING that SR can point to as a possible mistake by RL, who has pointed out numerous mistakes, false predictions, and lies told by Sylvia Browne?

Wow. Maybe time to step back and get some perspective here, SR.
 
If you watch the video, which is embedded in Robert Lancaster's story, it is clear the guy understands what SB is saying. As Lisa Simpson and others have pointed out, in the video at the 3:32 mark he does in fact say he "I understand your words".

Add to this, Randi's comments that he "mixed" with the folks afterward and it was his impression all spoke English well...including the guy in question.

It is also worth mentioning that post WWII English is a required second language in Germany though the High School level. While I won't say that EVERY Germany speaks perfect, fluent English...I will say the time I spent in Germany I never found anyone I could not carry on a conversation with in English.

Overall this seems to be a rather pointless debate. On one hand, you have SB who claims there were all German and "they couldn't understand a word I said!".

On the other hand, you have the video which clearly proves SBs contentions wrong, Randi's first hand account of the event, and the fact English is a required language in Germany.
 
If you watch the video, which is embedded in Robert Lancaster's story, it is clear the guy understands what SB is saying. As Lisa Simpson and others have pointed out, in the video at the 3:32 mark he does in fact say he "I understand your words".

Add to this, Randi's comments that he "mixed" with the folks afterward and it was his impression all spoke English well...including the guy in question.

It is also worth mentioning that post WWII English is a required second language in Germany though the High School level. While I won't say that EVERY Germany speaks perfect, fluent English...I will say the time I spent in Germany I never found anyone I could not carry on a conversation with in English.

Overall this seems to be a rather pointless debate. On one hand, you have SB who claims there were all German and "they couldn't understand a word I said!".

On the other hand, you have the video which clearly proves SBs contentions wrong, Randi's first hand account of the event, and the fact English is a required language in Germany.

Having spent time in Germany, I can honestly say I never had any issues or problems carrying on conversations in English with German citizens.

I am asking people to click that video and watch it in YouTube (the time runs backward when embedded). Look at the point we mentioned (3:23), and see if you really hear "I understand your words" pronounced in any intelligible way (try and forget your memory of the transcript on SSB). I do not hear it.
 
1. The man demonstrates he does not speak or understand English on the level of what we generally consider an 'English speaker'.

2. Lancaster says the man speaks English.

3. I find that questionable.

I don't really see how you can't at least acknowledge that I am using logic on some level, even if you disagree with my general conclusion. I am hardly saying pigs fly.

According to James Randi, someone who was there:

Robert: re the Bixby/Browne video, it should be said that I mixed with that section of our audience following the incident, and as far as I could tell, all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

According to Browne on the show:

I don't care whether you're German, you still work or not work, don't you?

Acording to the man in question:

I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words.

Source: http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml

Randi said he understood english, the man said he understood english, and Browne said it doesn't matter for the reading.

You are playing semantics. "He is a native speaker" DOES NOT equate to he "understands/speaks" the language.

It would give me satisfaction that this is a multi-layered discussion and not a "you're either with us or against us" sort of thing. I am not even trying to prove Lancaster is a liar (which I don't believe at the moment) or Sylvia is right anymore, I am just dealing with this issue in and of itself.

Since you seem to be making a big deal with rather a small point and you hold (at least in this thread) a minority interpretation of "speaks" that is rather idiosyncratic, could we address the numerous times Sylvia is PROVED wrong? I think that would be more helpful at this point.

Regarding your belief about the man not speaking English, you are going against the facts of the man's claims and Randi's interaction with him. If you still want to hold that belief with little reason to do so fine. Let's move past it. You won't conceede you are wrong on that point, and neither will anyone else.

No offense to Robert, but the issue here is Browne not having the abilities she claims and not telling the truth (as with her claim that it was a "set up" with "Germanic people").
 
According to James Randi, someone who was there:



According to Browne on the show:



Acording to the man in question:



Source: http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml

Randi said he understood english, the man said he understood english, and Browne said it doesn't matter for the reading.

You are playing semantics. "He is a native speaker" DOES NOT equate to he "understands/speaks" the language.



Since you seem to be making a big deal with rather a small point and you hold (at least in this thread) a minority interpretation of "speaks" that is rather idiosyncratic, could we address the numerous times Sylvia is PROVED wrong? I think that would be more helpful at this point.

Regarding your belief about the man not speaking English, you are going against the facts of the man's claims and Randi's interaction with him. If you still want to hold that belief with little reason to do so fine. Let's move past it. You won't conceede you are wrong on that point, and neither will anyone else.

No offense to Robert, but the issue here is Browne not having the abilities she claims and not telling the truth (as with her claim that it was a "set up" with "Germanic people").

He does not say "I understand your words". I challenge someone to make an audio file of that exact moment and upload it, and let's see if other people nearby hear "I understand your words". Please respond directly to the audio of the video file itself, Randi's testimony is based on exactly what we see in the video, he knows no more than we do.
 
SR - What can I say, seems very clear to me he says "I understand your words" with "your" sounding more like "ver".

You are of course welcome to your opinion...but seems quite a up-hill battle on your part to convince folks here regarding your point of view.

SB was wrong about everyone being German, and about nobody being able to understand her and has no proof of these claims. The video, and other first hand "testimony", and the education system within Germany seems to indicate otherwise.
 
My opinion is that he speaks passable english. After watching yet again, he seems to even be a fairly fluent speaker of english, to me.

And, as has been repeatedly pointed out by others, James Randi's (someone that has historically been extremely honest/reliable) first hand account indicates he spoke English well enough, as well.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom