Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

I agree. If you want to know just how many Germans can speak/write and understand English then do some research.

My German's not crash hot, so several times each weak when I chat with relatives in Germany via Yahoo messenger it is always in English. Kids learn it in school over there. They like chatting with me because they can practice their skill.

M.
 
I'm going to try to refocus this again. It would seem that the the main thrust of the article is still lost in semantics.

Sylvia said: They were ALL german, NONE of them spoke English.

We can argue day and night about how good this one person's English was. Is this nitpicking really productive?

The greater issue is that Sylvia lied.

Again. Sylvia lied.

Were they all German, or as far as we could tell, was only one German? Did it appear to be "an obvious set up?" He spoke enough English to utter a few words. So while you can debate how much English that was, it doesn't really matter. Mountain, meet Mole Hill.

Sylvia lied about the audience.

And as you move away from this basic little disagreement about how well the guy spoke English, perhaps we can move to the other articles on Robert's site.

The debate was re-raised by many other people and I feel I must defend my point. What bothers me is that no one will concede that my viewpoint is even at the very least slightly reasonable. That goes against the general tone of "we are rational, open-minded thinkers". You are right, however, that Sylvia either forgot, 'distorted' her own memory over time, or lied in regards to all of them being German.
 
I just want to point out that way back in the middle of page 12 I said that I think this is a setup and that SylviaVox is a woman. Just want to remind everyone.

Also what is this all about....(QUOTE) As of today Bob is a married man.

After having the pleasure of Bob Lancaster's friendship for at least the past seven years, I have come to love, respect and admire him.

I wish he and Susan a life time of love and happiness.

And Robert. If you're pissed at me for starting this thread - deal with it.

I love you.

Julia (END QUOTE)

Was this whole thread written as a tribute to Robert getting married? Wanted to show how we would all come to his defense?

The other Susan
 
I will (and have many times) conceded that the man did not speak English well. However, that does not change the fact that Robert did not lie. The man spoke some English. Therefore, when his article stated "they all spoke English" it was not a lie.
 
I agree. If you want to know just how many Germans can speak/write and understand English then do some research.

My German's not crash hot, so several times each weak when I chat with relatives in Germany via Yahoo messenger it is always in English. Kids learn it in school over there. They like chatting with me because they can practice their skill.

M.

This is not some sociological issue, we are dealing with one specific man. The man himself admitted that he understood 'not so good' because he is a German. This implies he would be formally considered an English speaker. Most people around the Western world know at least one or two basic phrases in English, this does not mean they speak English.
 
I will (and have many times) conceded that the man did not speak English well. However, that does not change the fact that Robert did not lie. The man spoke some English. Therefore, when his article stated "they all spoke English" it was not a lie.

Then you believe in the a) definition of what it means for somebody to speak English as I presented in my post a while back?
 
Furthermore, the man even said he understood 'not so good', indicating he cannot understand English well either.

Not necessarily. He may simply not understand Sylvia well. I don't have the ability to watch the video at the present time, but if her pronunciation or syntax is lacking, it may be difficult for someone who is otherwise relatively at ease with the language to understand her.

Do you have a second language? I ask this honestly, because you seem relatively clueless as to the level of comfort non-native speakers have with a language. You see me typing in English, and though my grammar and syntax are far from perfect, I think I have a rather good grasp of English as a second language. At work, I regularly have to speak with native English speakers. And there are some of those who make me want to pull my hair out as I can't understand a word they're saying! A native speaker wouldn't have that problem (or at least, would have an easier time than me) because he would be accustomed to various accents, casual 'twisting' of syntax and grammar, and so on. I still define myself as bilingual, despite not being able to fully understand every word uttered by every English speaker in the world.

(dang, even as I type, I see I've been beaten to the punch again! Oh well...)
 
I just want to point out that way back in the middle of page 12 I said that I think this is a setup and that SylviaVox is a woman. Just want to remind everyone.

Also what is this all about....(QUOTE) As of today Bob is a married man.

After having the pleasure of Bob Lancaster's friendship for at least the past seven years, I have come to love, respect and admire him.

I wish he and Susan a life time of love and happiness.

And Robert. If you're pissed at me for starting this thread - deal with it.

I love you.

Julia (END QUOTE)

Was this whole thread written as a tribute to Robert getting married? Wanted to show how we would all come to his defense?

The other Susan

I assure you that I am not Sylvia's manager, an internet troll, or someone trying to draw out support for Lancaster or anything else of that nature. I have been completely above board with you all.
 
What bothers me is that no one will concede that my viewpoint is even at the very least slightly reasonable. That goes against the general tone of "we are rational, open-minded thinkers".
What bothers me is that no-one will admit that pigs even at the very least slightly fly. That goes against the general tone of "we are rational, open-minded thinkers".
 
What bothers me is that no-one will admit that pigs even at the very least slightly fly. That goes against the general tone of "we are rational, open-minded thinkers".

1. The man demonstrates he does not speak or understand English on the level of what we generally consider an 'English speaker'.

2. Lancaster says the man speaks English.

3. I find that questionable.

I don't really see how you can't at least acknowledge that I am using logic on some level, even if you disagree with my general conclusion. I am hardly saying pigs fly.
 
For Lancaster to not have been lying/mistaken, you must believe in that definition.


It comes down to this, when we say someone speaks English, do we mean:

a) that person spoke at least some English words at some point in the past (apparently, Lisa's notion) or

b) that person can speak English on a relatively comfortable level (beyond the 'I understand not so good' phase)

Or:

c) someone speaks good enough to English to "understand your words" as the man said himself.
 
You are being logical. It is not your conclusion that we disagree with, it's actually with:

1. The man demonstrates he does not speak or understand English on the level of what we generally consider an 'English speaker'.

As I've stated above, it may very well be that he didn't understand Sylvia well for a number of reasons (stress, pronunciation, syntax, vocabulary...). I speak English well enough to be considered bilingual, yet I still meet native English speakers who make me look like I have never completed my English grade school classes.

Since we have to rely on two second-hand competing accounts (Randi vs Sylvia) as to just how well this man understood English, I'll default to using the one from the party who isn't known for, you know, lying repeatedly.
 
This is not some sociological issue, we are dealing with one specific man. The man himself admitted that he understood 'not so good' because he is a German. This implies he would be formally considered an English speaker. Most people around the Western world know at least one or two basic phrases in English, this does not mean they speak English.

Not that we would, but if we were to concede that we were wrong, and that the man was NOT a speaker of English, what does that change?

If Robert and everyone else was wrong on this, does that mean Sylvia's success rate is 87%? Does it mean that she does speak to the dead? Does it change the fact that Hornbeck is alive and well? Does it suddenly make all her predictions correct?

An argument typical of a conspiracy theorist. They keep chipping away at one tiny detail, thinking that if they can topple it then everything will come crashing down.
 
The only thing consistent is the denial of evidence on your part Sylvia. Lancaster has lots to back up his claim. It is well documented and presented in a factual manner. Please support your claim with facts. Blind faith can blind you to the truth.
 
Not that we would, but if we were to concede that we were wrong, and that the man was NOT a speaker of English, what does that change?

If Robert and everyone else was wrong on this, does that mean Sylvia's success rate is 87%? Does it mean that she does speak to the dead? Does it change the fact that Hornbeck is alive and well? Does it suddenly make all her predictions correct?

An argument typical of a conspiracy theorist. They keep chipping away at one tiny detail, thinking that if they can topple it then everything will come crashing down.

It would give me satisfaction that this is a multi-layered discussion and not a "you're either with us or against us" sort of thing. I am not even trying to prove Lancaster is a liar (which I don't believe at the moment) or Sylvia is right anymore, I am just dealing with this issue in and of itself.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom