Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

It has definitely been an interesting thread.

I just wanted to add my own anecdote re: Sylvia. Recently, a Wiccan group that I occasionally volunteer for was discussing an upcoming event to be held at the begining of the next decade. Guest speakers are being considered atm and, of course, Sylvia came up.

Amazingly to me, she was outright rejected by everyone of any significance at the meeting, and her track record was discussed - at length. You think skeptics villify SB? Forget it. We're kind and forgiving compared to the Pagan community - which, of course, feels largely betrayed and misrepresented by SB.

And, amazingly, Rob's name was brought up in connection to SB! Well, sort of... I believe the comment was, 'There's even some cynic, what's his name, Ronnie Lanchester, who runs a website to expose that [rule 8]'s fraud! MakeSylviaStop.com or something...'

One of the other people present rolled her eyes and made some comment that they had all known SB was a fake, because her aura is too red. I know for a fact that this woman, ten years ago, was up to her armpits in debt from calling SB and that African lady that was all over TV a while ago... but I chose to say nothing.

Anyway, SR, if your intentions here are honest, I'd like to extend my welcome, and to let you know that not everyone here is a pure, hard-core skeptic. I am, for example, a Wiccan priest - though, personally, I lean towards a form of Deism and a Reality-Nonreality dualism... And though I've definitely witnessed events and experiences that make me believe in psychic powers and magic, every fact, every piece of evidence, tells me that Sylvia is a skilled cold-reader and imaginative fiction narrator whose only interest is getting rich off of people's gullibility.

I hope that, as the weeks progress, you're able to study the available evidence with an open mind and a critical eye, and that, if you DO come to a similar conclusion about SB, that you can quickly move past any sense of outrage, anger, frustration, or betrayal to a sense of forgiveness and hope.

Blessings,

The Rev.
 
I'm a logical spiritualist. (don't laugh) I believe in some spiritual stuff but I like logic to back it up. Just because I walked away from Novus doesn't make me unspiritual and just because I joined JREF doesn't mean I'm 100% skeptical.

Wouldn't laugh at that! I think that would describe most of my dearest and oldest friends. They believe in different things, are all logical, smart and, well, just ordinary nice and decent people. We don't agree on these things, but when we are not directly discussing these matters (and we all have ordinary lives to live and don't go around discussing these things all the time :)) it's never an issue.

For me, I guess, what makes a "woo" is not really someone who believes in things I don't believe in. But someone who just never leaves you alone with their beliefs, or "attacks" you with them even if you don't know them. I would never pounce on people at parties for example and tell them that I am an atheist and then make them listen to my reasons for half an hour :rolleyes: Or people who lives and breathes their beliefs no matter what strange consequences follows and whoever it will hurt around them. Or people who will never stop trying to "enlist you", or, in the worst case, tries to use you and scam you. Those are the ones I have some trouble with.

The Christian friend and her love of Jesus. The friend who loves to watch psychic shows on TV and talks to the ghost in her house. The friend who is a priest. The one who worries about that my aura is black... I don't quite understand any of them in these regards, but we respect each other, and these things have never come between us.

No, I wouldn't laugh at that.
 
I feel like Russell Casse (Randy Quaid) in Independence Day.

"Sorry I'm late Mr. President!"

What can I do to help? Although, a trillion messages in 24 hours is heading for a new record, I reckon!

Suffice it to say, I've just spent more than an hour reading through this, and just to return to the original post..... What a bunch of crap! RS has done everything possible to keep the personal out of this discussion and strains himself remarkably to do so, IMHO. How can you slander someone who makes up BS on the phone, in books, and on the air... for profit?

Puh-lease! Take him to court if you think you can prove such ridiculous claims. Or would that be a bad idea? You'd have to come up with proof of things in a court of law, and couldn't get by with nonsensical made-up statistics (85% accuracy my left gonad!)......

Harrumph. I'll now return to Forum Community to add another post to "Why you should not post after drinking"....
 
Hi Fran,
Thanks...I'm still new here and am a little intimidated.
Afraid to be both skeptical and spiritual and seeming flaky. :redface1
I'm alot like you. I basically live a simple, peaceful life. I don't want to be banged over the head with religion (can't stand that) nor do I really want to have to prove everything like whether my NDE was a spiritual or a scientifically explained event. To me it was both. But, in here it makes for a great discussion, huh? Could it be both? <rhetorical> I think so... :)
 
4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

I applaud your entire post and your sincerity. Others have said it better already.

In the spirit of continuing a topical discussion, I'd like to address the snipped portion above. I'm willing to let go of the semantical issue of the level of English the German man spoke. Instead, I'd like to redirect you to the fact that Sylvia stated they were all German and none of them spoke English. Do you have any thoughts on this aspect?
 
Last edited:
Mr. King is sharp as a knife, and one of the top journalists in broadcasting today. You simply dismiss or insult anyone who disagrees with your opinions.

More irony...

I just love the way the woo are so good at it...the way they notice the imaginary sawdust in the eyes of another while failing to see the humongous log erupting from their own.

It's a game for the whole family. Just underline one of their statements, such as the final sentence above. And see if the evidence makes the statement more applicable to the one who said it, than to the people the insult is directed at. It's great fun.

Of course you need to have an above average I.Q., and it helps if you haven't learned to twist banal platitudes into deep wisdom and/or if you don't buy the notion that faith and feelings are a good way of knowing anything.

And it also helps to know what IS good evidence and what is not. Here's a hint. If you would find it bad evidence for someone you consider woo (Bigfoot believers, Scientologists, cults, whatever)--then it's bad evidence for all claims.
 
For those new to the thread. SR has moderted his position since the OP.

1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.
 
More irony...

I just love the way the woo are so good at it...the way they notice the imaginary sawdust in the eyes of another while failing to see the humongous log erupting from their own.

It's a game for the whole family. Just underline one of their statements, such as the final sentence above. And see if the evidence makes the statement more applicable to the one who said it, than to the people the insult is directed at. It's great fun.

Of course you need to have an above average I.Q., and it helps if you haven't learned to twist banal platitudes into deep wisdom and/or if you don't buy the notion that faith and feelings are a good way of knowing anything.

And it also helps to know what IS good evidence and what is not. Here's a hint. If you would find it bad evidence for someone you consider woo (Bigfoot believers, Scientologists, cults, whatever)--then it's bad evidence for all claims.

In his defense,

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.
 
I applaud your entire post and your sincerity. Others have said it better already.

In the spirit of continuing a topical discussion, I'd like to address the snipped portion above. I'm willing to let go of the semantical issue of the level of English the German man spoke. Instead, I'd like to redirect you to the fact that Sylvia stated they were all German and none of them spoke English. Do you have any thoughts on this aspect?

If someone is talking to dead people or dead relatives, wouldn't the dead people be able to communicate using the correct language and the words with meaning the listener was supposed to understand?-- Isn't that the whole idea of supposedly being able to get advice or communication from "beyond". Even if Sylvia is limited by being "English speaking", the "souls' wouldn't be, would they? But it just seems you can offer up any excuse for "spiritual claims" or dismiss it with "who are we to question god..."
 
If someone is talking to dead people or dead relatives, wouldn't the dead people be able to communicate using the correct language and the words with meaning the listener was supposed to understand?-- Isn't that the whole idea of supposedly being able to get advice or communication from "beyond". Even if Sylvia is limited by being "English speaking", the "souls' wouldn't be, would they? But it just seems you can offer up any excuse for "spiritual claims" or dismiss it with "who are we to question god..."

Well, I'm sure you know where I am with that, but in general, I asked the question the way I did to not cloud the issues. He still has a little bit of this German issue stuck in his craw, and I think the next step is for him to look at what Sylvia actually claimed in regards to this article.
 
Good question.

Popular Baby Names (Social Security Administration):
  1. Jacob
  2. Michael
Second most popular name. State common names and at some point you will get a hit. Never mind all of the misses though.

:)

Partial hits are the stock and trade of psychics.

And if you aren't talking about baby names--Michael is the number one name of people born after 1950. Michael has been on the top of the baby name list more than any other name.
 
And if you aren't talking about baby names--Michael is the number one name of people born after 1950. Michael has been on the top of the baby name list more than any other name.
I'm not sure how significant this really is. If Sylvia only and always used the name Michael in her predictions then it would be a great point but then she would be even more transparent than she already is. As it is she doesn't only use Michael. She does however follow cold reading principles and usually sticks to predictions that are as a group more likely rather than the single most likely in every case.

Still, from a purely statistical stand point her chance of getting a hit with the number 1 name is better than the number 2 name.
 
For those new to the thread. SR has moderted his position since the OP.

Wow! That is a first here, isn't it? It's almost enough to make me want to believe in miracles. I mean it's not a complete turn around...or even an admission of error--but it sure is a softening and it shows a kind of willingness to look at evidence that I have never seen from someone who join the forums to post a "viewpoint" and give the skeptics their comeuppance.

Damn, it's no fun to make fun of people when you start to like them. It's only fun when they come here to preach certain they have something important we must hear, and nothing at all that they can learn.

BTW, Rox-- Compare Roberts claims and Sylvias-- and see who speaks more verifiable truths--and who misspeaks or is just plain wrong more often. Robet aims for honesty--Sylvia aims for obfuscation and "mystery" and "emotionalism". She promises gifts that can't be verified for money and allegiances--and Robert just presents the facts... for free.
 
Well, "Gary",

I certainly hope that your last post was sincere, and that this whole thread hasn't been a game to you. People play games with each other like this on the internet frequently, so forgive me for not being completely swayed by your last post.

If it's not been a game to you, and your response was sincere, then I am glad for you. I'm sure it was not an easy thing to return and make those statements, especially given the tone and content of your first post.

Do forgive me for my unbelief and understand my perspective in the matter. I have had a great deal of pain inflicted upon me by people just like SB. I deal with hundreds of families in the process of my work and I have felt their pain, pain that need not have been added to that which is ever present. Due to this, I also have little tolerance for those who defend persons who needlessly inflict this pain. Defenders of these behaviors contribute to the continued life cycle of these untruths.

Families like mine and those I serve only desire the truth, and nothing less.

Kelly Jolkowski,
Mother of Missing Jason Jolkowski
President and Founder,
Project Jason
www.projectjason.org
Author of Psychics and Missing People
http://voice4themissing.blogspot.com/2006/03/30606-pmp-introduction-to-psychics-and.html
 
what a double standard

i've studied japanese for 10 years. I can read and write it like i was a native.

HOwever, even after 10 years, the best that I can do in my speaking ability for japanese is next to piss-poor. Why? because i was never taught to "speak" it . I grew up in a home where my grandparents spoke "broken-japanese" meaning, since they were farmers , they didn't have the education themselves to speak it formally and CORRECTLY



If someone spoke japanese to me, I'd have no problem understanding them; my answers would be however, equivalent of a 6 year old in japan.


I work with japanese co-workers. In japan, they are taught english from when they first enter school. Some of them can speak english fine. some of them can barely speak a word of it; however, THEY UNDERSTAND IT.

When i went into the toursim industry for Hawaii, the first thing our Japanese coordinator stressed to us is TO NEVER EVER speak in english, ill of any of the japanese tourist. Just because they dont speak english, doesn't mean they didn't understand what we were saying!


your continued claim that because the person didn't speak "good" english (ie like a native speaker) shows your ignorance. Please stop embarrassing yourself.

Sylvia approaches the man. She starts to make her predictions. After it, he says, "I understand not so good. I am a German." All of the words that he speaks are related to him not being able to understand her. His English is very broken. He says finally says 'yes' to get her to move on, which she does. He is embarrassed and uncomfortable and doesn't look her in the eye. I do not consider this man to be an English speaker. Therefore, Lancaster's statement that "All of them spoke English" is incorrect, or at the very least is drawn well into the realm of reasonable doubt.

It comes down to this, when we say someone speaks English, do we mean:

a) that person spoke at least some English words at some point in the past (apparently, Lisa's notion) or

b) that person can speak English on a relatively comfortable level (beyond the 'I understand not so good' phase)

I believe that in the context of Lancaster's statement, b is the correct interpretation. The reason I am even making my point again is due to the rather bizarre statement made by Arus808, who suggested that I am embarrassing myself by even making the above point, which seems perfectly rational to me. It may be true that people exist who can understand a language well but not speak a language, but Lancaster stated quite clearly that the man could speak English. Furthermore, the man even said he understood 'not so good', indicating he cannot understand English well either.
 
Last edited:
Gary.
You really need to do some research.
You have been conned by an expert.
It happens more than you might think.
 
Sylvia approaches the man. She starts to make her predictions. After it, he says, "I understand not so good. I am a German." All of the words that he speaks are related to him not being able to understand her. His English is very broken. He says finally says 'yes' to get her to move on, which she does. He is embarrassed and uncomfortable and doesn't look her in the eye. I do not consider this man to be an English speaker. Therefore, Lancaster's statement that "All of them spoke English" is incorrect, or at the very least is drawn well into the realm of reasonable doubt.

It comes down to this, when we say someone speaks English, do we mean:

a) that person spoke at least some English words at some point in the past (apparently, Lisa's notion) or

b) that person can speak English on a relatively comfortable level (beyond the 'I understand not so good' phase)

I believe that in the context of Lancaster's statement, b is the correct interpretation. The reason I am even making my point again is due to the rather bizarre statement made by Arus808, who suggested that I am embarrassing myself by even making the above point, which seems perfectly rational to me. It may be true that people exist who can understand a language well but not speak a language, but Lancaster stated quite clearly that the man could speak English. Furthermore, the man even said he understood 'not so good', indicating he cannot understand English well either.

I'm going to try to refocus this again. It would seem that the the main thrust of the article is still lost in semantics.

Sylvia said: They were ALL german, NONE of them spoke English.

We can argue day and night about how good this one person's English was. Is this nitpicking really productive?

The greater issue is that Sylvia lied.

Again. Sylvia lied.

Were they all German, or as far as we could tell, was only one German? Did it appear to be "an obvious set up?" He spoke enough English to utter a few words. So while you can debate how much English that was, it doesn't really matter. Mountain, meet Mole Hill.

Sylvia lied about the audience.

And as you move away from this basic little disagreement about how well the guy spoke English, perhaps we can move to the other articles on Robert's site.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom