Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

By the way, this thread may explain why Robert has not been very active in defending himself here.
As of today Bob is a married man.

After having the pleasure of Bob Lancaster's friendship for at least the past seven years, I have come to love, respect and admire him.

I wish he and Susan a life time of love and happiness.

And Robert. If you're pissed at me for starting this thread - deal with it.

I love you.

Julia
 
I hope that what I said back on page 7 or so (if anyone even noticed) wasn't taken as sarcastic (although I am from Sarcastica).

Lots of us who were once so convinced that Sylvia/Novus deserved to be defended went through the stages of anger, denial, acceptance, etc. but unlike the stages of death we recovered and listened to logic and can move forward and continue learning.

I'm continually impressed by how this group handles this sort of thread and I bet it's not the last one as there will be others who will react in defensive anger only to find that what they suspected all along was true and what they defended all along shouldn't be.

I'm a logical spiritualist. (don't laugh) I believe in some spiritual stuff but I like logic to back it up. Just because I walked away from Novus doesn't make me unspiritual and just because I joined JREF doesn't mean I'm 100% skeptical.

I'm learning!! I love it!!

I hope that SR isn't just saying that they understand to get out of something that they started. I hope they go through the stages that we all went through and know that they are not alone...they're in good company.

TBT
 
I hope that what I said back on page 7 or so (if anyone even noticed) wasn't taken as sarcastic (although I am from Sarcastica).

Lots of us who were once so convinced that Sylvia/Novus deserved to be defended went through the stages of anger, denial, acceptance, etc. but unlike the stages of death we recovered and listened to logic and can move forward and continue learning.

I'm continually impressed by how this group handles this sort of thread and I bet it's not the last one as there will be others who will react in defensive anger only to find that what they suspected all along was true and what they defended all along shouldn't be.

I'm a logical spiritualist. (don't laugh) I believe in some spiritual stuff but I like logic to back it up. Just because I walked away from Novus doesn't make me unspiritual and just because I joined JREF doesn't mean I'm 100% skeptical.

I'm learning!! I love it!!

I hope that SR isn't just saying that they understand to get out of something that they started. I hope they go through the stages that we all went through and know that they are not alone...they're in good company.

TBT

And thanks for your post, too. It's humbling to see the courage of others.

M.
 
I hope that SR isn't just saying that they understand to get out of something that they started. I hope they go through the stages that we all went through and know that they are not alone...they're in good company. TBT

"Not A Republican" seems to think the original poster is Linda. If she's referring to Linda Rossi, Sylvia's business manager, then it may have all been a set up.

ST
 
I will not give him the benefit of the doubt until he belies his neutrality because I do not see this supposed neutrality in the first place, but I will refrain from posting on this subject until he clarifies his position.

Fair enough?
You are not paying attention to what I'm saying. What harm is there? Just answer my questions. What do you lose?

ETA: Never mind.

And on this note, I withdraw any objections I had/have.
 
Last edited:
I hate to point this out, SylviaRox, but you’re exhibiting signs of that dreadful, evil monstrosity loathed by millions of Sylvia fans the world over -- skepticism.

Questioning your beliefs, weighing evidence, distinguishing fact from fiction. Pretty soon, if you’re not careful, you’ll pick up the secret handshake.

Seriously, though, congrats on the progress so far. I don’t know how deep it runs, but if you’re reconsidering your screen name, as scotth brought up, may I suggest SylviaSux?

Just a thought.
 
1. I was possibly wrong about the GSB guestbook issue. It seems unlikely it was Lancaster who planned or directed it, although it is probable that Lancaster's article and posts were what brought the site to the attention of some here. I apologize.

2. I do not know for sure whether or not Lancaster has violated any copyright issues. It is possible he hasn't but I would think that Lancaster has a very liberal conception of fair use. I apologize.

3. Sylvia got Devlin's first name right, which is still unlikely despite the fact it is a popular name, but she did not get his physical appearance and King was confused/mistaken.

4. Lancaster is wrong to claim that all of the guests on Exploring Psychic Powers Live spoke English, but this is only the phrasing of one sentence as part of the larger article whose general message is honest.

5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.

7. I have falsely linked in my mind certain people and things which are not fair to link: specifically the investigations that Lancaster has done into Sylvia/Novus with the attitude towards religion that people in the skeptical community like Dawkins, Randi and some of the posters here have. I apologize then for any general rudeness.

8. Thank you angrybeliever, DJM, randfan and kittynh.
Not a problem. I've been there. Good form sir.
 
5. It is also wrong to make false predictions or statements to a victim's family if one is not absolutely sure of their correctness. If Sylvia is not genuinely confident about her predictions to these people then there is a problem.

6. I cannot verify or prove the 85% success rate. It is possibly not true.


SRox,

As others have said you are to be commended for this post, I think the two points I have quoted above are where you should focus your efforts in further examination of what RSL is trying to accmplish with his site. They comprise the core of the issue regarding SB and 'psychics' in general.

There is a difference in speaking with conviction and being convinced of the truth in what you say. One can speak with conviction without necessarily being convinced in the truth of what they are saying. The only person that can address that is the speaker and it requires that they be honest with themselves.

This leads directly into your next point. For the sake of discussion I would offer that it maybe possible that 'psychics' are correct in that they cannot 'control' their gift and thus cannot be replicated under labratory conditions. Ms. Browne, however, has been providing readings for enough years that there should be documented occaisions where she has made statements on individual cases that demonstrate the 85% - 87% success rate she claims.

For example, a statement " Your father, Henry, died of a heart attack and he wanted you to know that the book you are looking for was given to your great aunt Myrtle and is in a box in her attic." has information that is specific enough to be verified as true. There are at least seven specific pieces of information, if five of them are verified as true then the success rate is 71% which is better then random chance though below that stated 85% success rate.

The opposite of this is "A male family member, starts with an 'H'." at this point they wait for the individual to provide that it was indeed a family member or perhaps a close friend that 'was like a member of the family', that it was a first name, middle name or nickname that had an 'H' in it. This followed by, "I'm getting something about the chest," again there is usually followed by a pause where the individual fills in the specifics, i.e. heart attrack, lung disease, gun shot wound, etc. "He wants you to know he is happy and loves you." which is what most people who are grieving want to hear. There is no specific information provided other then what the individuual provides in response to generalized statements. This called cold reading and it compromises most of the readings that 'psychics' do. There are no specific pieces of information that can be verified and used to determine a success rate.

If you go back and read the articles that Mr. Lancaster has written, he takes readings that Ms. Browne has done and have been recorded, looks at each specific piece of information that she provides and compares it to the known facts regarding the case. He then calculates the percentage of correct hits. All he is asking for is that anyone that can provide documentation of a reading where the percentage of correct specific information is what Ms. Browne claims her success rate to be.


SRox, over the last day you have been shown repeatedly information that contradicts what you belived to be true. You spoke with conviction in the beginning, soon you will need to ask your self if you are convinced in what you say.


Boo
 
SylviaRox, if you're ever in Norway, look me up. I'll buy you a beer :)
 
Don't shout.

And does it excuse it? No.

But it's a step forward. ..

I think that's a very positive thing, and should be commended.[/size]

I agree. When it comes to believers, I'll take an admittance of reality, even without an apology, any day.
 
In order to be considered someone who speaks English, you must know more than to be able to say you don't speak English well. That German man did not, as noted by Sylvia. Lancaster lied and claimed that he did, libeling Sylvia Browne.

what a double standard

i've studied japanese for 10 years. I can read and write it like i was a native.

HOwever, even after 10 years, the best that I can do in my speaking ability for japanese is next to piss-poor. Why? because i was never taught to "speak" it . I grew up in a home where my grandparents spoke "broken-japanese" meaning, since they were farmers , they didn't have the education themselves to speak it formally and CORRECTLY



If someone spoke japanese to me, I'd have no problem understanding them; my answers would be however, equivalent of a 6 year old in japan.


I work with japanese co-workers. In japan, they are taught english from when they first enter school. Some of them can speak english fine. some of them can barely speak a word of it; however, THEY UNDERSTAND IT.

When i went into the toursim industry for Hawaii, the first thing our Japanese coordinator stressed to us is TO NEVER EVER speak in english, ill of any of the japanese tourist. Just because they dont speak english, doesn't mean they didn't understand what we were saying!


your continued claim that because the person didn't speak "good" english (ie like a native speaker) shows your ignorance. Please stop embarrassing yourself.
 
Wow, I step away from the forum for a couple days and look what happens! I still need to go through all the posts but to have SR go from the OP to her post #474 in a couple of days is awesome. Koodos to you, SR. And I am so proud to be a member of this forum that was able to fairly deal with SR's statements and use truth to correct them.

SR, stick around...there is more truth out there.
 
well and I agree with what Randi has said, some psychics do believe they have "powers", but they often feel they have to "jazz it up". Pretty soon, the "jazz" works better than whatever "feelings" they had in the past. They can justify their behavior by thinking "well I gave these people closure" or "wow, they were crying, but felt really better". Still, they take the money. And money and power can be a deadly drug.

The surviving child that "saw" Mary at Fatima became a nun. I like to think that means that at least SHE really felt she had a religious experience.

You can believe these things are for real, but honestly think how you would react if you could talk to the dead. What would you do? Selling jewelry and looking for ways to make a profit at all times does not come to mind.

Anyway, NOT believing in Sylvia Browne does not mean you have to NOT believe in anything. It's just that you have to ask yourself, do I believe in her powers more than she does.
 
"Not A Republican" seems to think the original poster is Linda. If she's referring to Linda Rossi, Sylvia's business manager, then it may have all been a set up.

ST

Without disclosing any personal information, there's no evidence on my end to believe that SylviaRox is someone within Sylvia's headquarters.
 
Whether SR is Linda is irrelevent. Think about it.

BTW - I highly suggest that SR take up Ryokan's (nihongo ga hanaseru?) offer. Norway rocks. SKOL!
 
SylviaRox states his name in his first post. Since posting under a false name is a bannable offense on this forum, and there is no real evidence that he is anyone other than he claims to be, I'm going to take him at his word.
 
How silly of you. Browne had no idea how old Hornbeck's kidnapper was WHEN SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT.

Wrong. Its a common tactic amongst cold readers to rarely give a last name becaue then the information becomes too specific. They are "educated" in any means necessary to lull people into believing what they say are true; so throwing out common names is one way they "assert" their credibility.

all it takes for a cold reader to do is a little research and you can find all the information you want, to make sure you are statistically correct:

The most popular names chosen for baby boys and girls over the past 120 years

Especially if you want to throw names out and quickly. All it takes for you to is to memorize the top names through the decades, and you notice a pattern

it does help to know that "michael" as a common name amongst males, has been in the top 5 since the 60's



Just to give you an idea, my elementary school 4th grade class consisted of 87 students ; 26 of them were named michael (of various spellings). that's 1/3rd of my class.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom