Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Why isn't Sylvia's word accepted by the people here? Primarily, it's because she has not provided any evidence that she has the powers she claims. When that evidence is offered, I will be the first to admit my mistake.



I'd dispute the "primarily", in that for several cases (such as the "everybody spoke German" line), we have positive evidence that she's lying. That's what I'd consider to be primary, although it's admitedly a tight race....
 
I never said that name was common for one year only, I said that the year he was born fell into the range of the era of the name "Michael's" popularity. In fact, she didn't need to know his age. Look at this survey:

http://www.ssa.gov/cgi-bin/babyname.cgi

Michael was the most popular name from 1954 to 1998. "Michael" covered a majority of names from babies to 50 year olds. I acknowledge she got the first name right, but I also see Sylvia's chances of being wrong were less than her chances of being right.

As far as SilviaRox has made verifiable claims they have been thoroughly debunked (or shown irrelevant). So I get a chance to nitpick at my fellow skeptics.

The most popular name doesn't mean that it's given to more than half the people. The name micheal gave her the best chance at being right, but it's still significantly lower than her chance for being wrong.

I think it has to be counted as a hit, of course chance demands that we get our fair share of hits from any psychic. One that gets everything wrong all the time is almost as supernatural as one that never gets anything wrong.
 
"Alive or dead" is a 50/50 choice. She should be able to get it right half the time simply by guessing. As far as I can tell, her performance record is worse than you would expect from simple chance.
Actually, it's not a 50/50 chance. Sadly, finding a child alive after they have disappeared for a long time is extremely rare. Usually the news is bad. Sylvia was probably playing the odds, and she lost because this was that rare exception.
 
I'm glad you've been listening, SR. But you've also been talking. You've made many, many allegations and, except for an argument over the meaning of speaking English, you haven't actually provided any evidence for anything you've said. You started by saying you thought you'd be censored for your opinion. This board doesn't censor opinion generally. It does demand that opinion be supported with evidence.

Why isn't Sylvia's word accepted by the people here? Primarily, it's because she has not provided any evidence that she has the powers she claims. When that evidence is offered, I will be the first to admit my mistake.

I have read every post here...and I do feel I understand what you are saying. I am considering the implications of certain things. I am not delusional. I understand the need for evidence.
 
I have read every post here...and I do feel I understand what you are saying. I am considering the implications of certain things. I am not delusional. I understand the need for evidence.

Did you understand this need ten pages ago, or is this a more recent realization?
 
I have read every post here...and I do feel I understand what you are saying. I am considering the implications of certain things. I am not delusional. I understand the need for evidence.

Wonderful! Will you present us with it? That is, evidence of 85% hits fromms Browne for example?
 
I have read every post here...and I do feel I understand what you are saying. I am considering the implications of certain things. I am not delusional. I understand the need for evidence.
Cool. I'm glad to here it. And I don't mean that in any patronizing sense. We are all entitled to our beliefs but we should be willing to consider our beliefs.
 
I am sure an admin will delete this message because it disagrees with the stated goals of the JREF. I feel I must post it anyway.

Stop Robert S. Lancaster, slanderer of Sylvia Browne. Robert S. Lancaster has made a hostile and concerted attempt to slander, libel and defame Sylvia Browne. Browne, a woman who has brought an immeasurable amount of comfort and assistance to men and women across the country, as well as help to police departments, has been treated in a fashion completely and utterly shocking to any civilized person. Browne's success rate of 85% is ignored, Mr. Lancaster, in his sham of a website, obsessively harps on every minor error that Browne makes in her prediction. For example: when Sylvia Browne accurately predicted the nature and appearance of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor, he pretended that she had not, and distorted her actual reading to the Hornbecks. Larry King even SAID that she got it mostly right, but Mr. Randi and Mr. Lancaster have tried to deny it!

Lancaster at first tried to pretend that his analysis was scientific and forthright, but it has become increasingly frenzied and over-the-top with his hatred for Sylvia. With each new appearance of an article on StopSylviaBrowne.com, his attitude becomes more and more extreme, a trend that is disturbing to me, a follower of Browne. Lancaster's main argument seems to be that because Browne is occasionally un-eloquent in her speech, this means that she somehow had faked a master's degree in literature. He hunted down Browne's ex-husband for the express purpose of getting him to lie to that effect (a liar that was later debunked). His other arguments are that because Browne occasionally misses a minor fact (like the hair color of a missing person), she is somehow a fake. This is again IGNORING her 85% success rate. There are thousands of positive testimonials in favor of Browne and it is clear from a simple reading of Amazon.com reviews of her books that she has helped INNUMERABLE people.

Mr. Lancaster has always engaged in a vigorous campaign to attack GoSylviaBrowne.com, a completely innocuous fan website. Mr. Lancaster has been utterly vicious in this, soliciting people from this website, the JREF, to assault and destroy her guestbook. Now it is filled with hundreds of spammers, due to these 'skeptics' (more like Fascists to me) signing up the site with spam companies. Whenever Mr. Lancaster has had interactions with those in the fan community he has been nasty, and never anything short of condescending. This man who has so little positive to contribute to the world has instead set his sights on Mrs. Browne, a great spiritual leader.

Mr. Lancaster has apparently also started a campaign against Dr. Kaz deMille-Jacobsen, a 9/11 survivor and inspirational speaker, and a descendant of famous film director Cecil B. Demille. He has also insulted and questioned the honor of Montel Williams, a navy hero, who is currently suffering with multiple sclerosis. Lancaster is also a vigorous copyright abuser (posting both clips of Montel's show, transcripts, images of Sylvia, quotes from her books, and the Hay House logo), as noted by Browne's lawyers. Let's hope they pursue this case to the fullest extent of the law and stop Robert S. Lancaster's campaign of terror..

- Gary Richardson, admirer of Sylvia Browne
What an incredible pile of fecal material - not unlike the average slime mouthed foul speaking Montel hag-riding thing that inspired this putrescent bilge.

Argue the post not the poster. This thread had managed to be fairly civil up until this point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wonderful! Will you present us with it? That is, evidence of 85% hits fromms Browne for example?
I would find it difficult to believe there is evidence of 10 hits. Not percent actual first speak correct hits. Prior to the pathetic attempts at cold reading.
 
What an incredible pile of fecal material - not unlike the average slime mouthed foul speaking Montel hag-riding thing that inspired this putrescent bilge.

Not untrue, but look at the change of tone in the most recent post:

I have read every post here...and I do feel I understand what you are saying. I am considering the implications of certain things. I am not delusional. I understand the need for evidence.

Could it be that Gary is starting to get the picture?
 
Not untrue, but look at the change of tone in the most recent post:



Could it be that Gary is starting to get the picture?
"I hear what you are saying, and understand your need for evidence." is neutralspeak. It sounds as if he is actually considering the points brought forward, and will bring forth evidence-actually what is being said is,"I see that you have printed something."
No more, and no less.
 
What an incredible pile of fecal material - not unlike the average slime mouthed foul speaking Montel hag-riding thing that inspired this putrescent bilge.

I know that it has only been a matter of hours but I think you are a bit late to the dance. :)

Hell, I was late 2 hours after it started.
 
"I hear what you are saying, and understand your need for evidence." is neutralspeak. It sounds as if he is actually considering the points brought forward, and will bring forth evidence-actually what is being said is,"I see that you have printed something."
No more, and no less.

I don't know. I think the guy deserves the benefit of the doubt. I don't need a pound of flesh. I just want other people to consider my point of view. Let's see how he responds.
 
I don't know. I think the guy deserves the benefit of the doubt. I don't need a pound of flesh. I just want other people to consider my point of view. Let's see how he responds.

After one or two pages, I might give someone the benefit of the doubt, depending on what she/he has posted elsewhere. After ten pages, I doubt that there is any benefit to doing so.
 
"I hear what you are saying, and understand your need for evidence." is neutralspeak. It sounds as if he is actually considering the points brought forward, and will bring forth evidence-actually what is being said is,"I see that you have printed something."
No more, and no less.

Agreed, but there's a definite change of tone here. The confrontational attitude is missing, as is the condescending righteousness. There's no rudeness in this post either. I'm not suggesting that he will bring forth any evidence to support Browne's claims (after all, there is no evidence), but it may be that Gary is following in the footsteps of the newer members we have just gained who are formerly members of NS.
 
After one or two pages, I might give someone the benefit of the doubt, depending on what she/he has posted elsewhere. After ten pages, I doubt that there is any benefit to doing so.
I took years. I was a missionary. I was an ID proponent. I followed Nostradamus and other wacky ideas. I debated my positions with conviction for years.

Anytime an individual is willing to reconsider his or her beliefs is worth our attention, IMO.

But that's just my opinion. We can certainly disagree.
 
After one or two pages, I might give someone the benefit of the doubt, depending on what she/he has posted elsewhere. After ten pages, I doubt that there is any benefit to doing so.

Well if you're not prepared to give anyone the benefit of the doubt after a mere 10 pages of posts, how do you feel about the 10 years some of the XNS members have under their belts? Are you prepared to give them the benefit of the doubt? I know I am.
 
Sylviarox, just a few words of carefully considered advice:

If you can't post one iota of proof against Robert Lancaster, in TEN FRICKIN' PAGES, you might want to reconsider your assault.

I know Robert Lancaster. I know that he's probably one of the most meticulous people I've ever met. If you would have taken five minutes to read through what he did on his "StopKaz" website, you might have realized the man didn't undertake this activity lightly. Sylvia Browne's "85%" accuracy rating is based on her own declarations, and not on any manner of objective evidence. It's not worth considering.
 
Thanks. I did notice a horrible, malicious, libelous, and patently untrue comment about the saintly Banachek.

The suggestion that Banachek does not actually read minds, but is playing a trick of some sort, is beyond the pale and should be retracted immediately. Look at this evidence:


Banachek is, indeed, saintly.

But he tells everyone that was he does is tricks.
 
I must say, this is one of the most interesting threads I have read on this site in some time.

I don't know if you guys are likely to chance his mind, but if anyone IS on the fence and happens upon this, they'll certainly have a lot to consider.

Jim
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom