Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

... Browne, a woman who has brought an immeasurable amount of comfort and assistance to men and women across the country, as well as help to police departments...
Yeah, sure, "Immeasurable" means there isn't any. It doesn't exist. It has less substance than an ex parrot, which, did in fact, exist at one point in time. but, alas, exists no longer.
 
I don't know. I think the guy deserves the benefit of the doubt. I don't need a pound of flesh. I just want other people to consider my point of view. Let's see how he responds.

I've got to agree with RandFan and Reno. It sounds like he's at least thinking about things. Only time will tell if it's lip service or actual intellectual honesty.

It's not easy to re-examine entrenched beliefs. For most of us there was no "ah-hah!" moment - usually it takes a long time to chip away at our woo beliefs and see the world as it actually is.
 
I've got to agree with RandFan and Reno. It sounds like he's at least thinking about things. Only time will tell if it's lip service or actual intellectual honesty.

It's not easy to re-examine entrenched beliefs. For most of us there was no "ah-hah!" moment - usually it takes a long time to chip away at our woo beliefs and see the world as it actually is.
Can I get in bed with you too? People can change. People are constantly changing. I would hate to think that I had less than one day to fix in stone what everyone thought of me for the rest of my life. I might be having a bad day.

In his first post, SR indicated that he fully expected to be banned and his posts deleted. Now that he has seen that is not the case, it is quite possible he is reconsidering some of the other assumptions he made about this place. We can but hope.

I like hope.
 
I have read every post here...and I do feel I understand what you are saying. I am considering the implications of certain things. I am not delusional. I understand the need for evidence.

I still say that some of you are seeing hope where there is actually nothing but neutralspeak. SylviaRox says he understands what we are saying-this implies that he is thinking about it, but what it really means is that he can read. He than says,"I am considering the implications of certain things." This is not the same thing as saying that he is considering the implications of what opposing posters with evidence has said, or even what any poster on this board has said. The last two sentences mean about the same to me.
Nothing but neutralspeak, designed to be a placating placeholder.
 
I still say that some of you are seeing hope where there is actually nothing but neutralspeak. SylviaRox says he understands what we are saying-this implies that he is thinking about it, but what it really means is that he can read. He than says,"I am considering the implications of certain things." This is not the same thing as saying that he is considering the implications of what opposing posters with evidence has said, or even what any poster on this board has said. The last two sentences mean about the same to me.
Nothing but neutralspeak, designed to be a placating placeholder.
Yep. When you want to disagree, or even insult, without your audience taking offense, use passive-tense.
 
I still say that some of you are seeing hope where there is actually nothing but neutralspeak. SylviaRox says he understands what we are saying-this implies that he is thinking about it, but what it really means is that he can read. He than says,"I am considering the implications of certain things." This is not the same thing as saying that he is considering the implications of what opposing posters with evidence has said, or even what any poster on this board has said. The last two sentences mean about the same to me.
Nothing but neutralspeak, designed to be a placating placeholder.
You might be right but I'm honestly not sure. I'm not sure what harm there is to give the guy the benefit of the doubt. JMO.
 
well sylviarox wanted to hear my story.

I'll give a brief version, very brief.

My friend had her son die. Very tragic, and unexpected.

She is grieving and decides to seek the advice of a psychic. A well known one, but not Sylvia Browne. But I can not but imagine she works the same way.

You get a hint, just a bit, but not anymore than those several really good hits. You forget the misses, the "not quite rights" or "almost right" or "totally wrongs" in the happiness that with those few hits - you may have contacted YOUR CHILD.

sure it costs money, after all the psychic has to EAT.

And sure you have to go back again and again, because she can't be expected to get through clearly and with all the information you want, and you want to share with your dead CHILD in one session. It's very exhausting, and you know you do pay a physician. Sure they get paid less per hour, but this is MORE than an operation. This is talking to and contact with YOUR DEAD CHILD.

One day, you run out of money, or your family cuts you off.

what to do?

$30,000 later, but with nothing left in the bank account, sorry, no more talking to YOUR DEAD CHILD.

Now a psychic would say, "you would gladly pay $100,000 to have your child with you again, even a million would be a bargain" (and yes, they do say this stuff). And gosh knows that psychic HAS TO EAT. She is a PROFESSIONAL.

But we are talking A DEAD CHILD.

what parent wouldn't sell everything, give up everything, just to talk with her child again, and then again. As long as you give that psychic money it's like your child is still with you. Until the money runs out.

If you can talk to the dead, you had better make sure you are getting a clear signal. You had better really weigh everything that comes out of your mouth. If you REALLY believe you are talking with a DEAD CHILD and you charge for it and then refuse to "contact" this child anymore because mommy has run out of money... what kind of immoral monster are you? Does the DEAD CHILD shut up because mommy isn't paying the psychic?

Seriously, don't DEAD CHILDREN just yell in Sylvia's ear 24 hours a day, desperate to reassure their parents that they are fine? She should be out knocking on doors, talking to people, giving the the word from heaven. Doesn't God get pissed that she CHARGES, for what she claims is a heaven sent gift? Did Jesus charge for the fish and loaves? Or "hey I healed your blindness, that will be $300?" She claims to be like Jesus. Heck she wrote a book about Jesus.

She can't believe in Jesus, because if she did she would so fear dying and going to heaven. He would SO be there at the gate waiting for her with a few questions (to say the least).
 
I read SR's last post to mean he's really thinking about and considering what everyone has said. Why not give him the benefit of the doubt, until proven otherwise? As others have said, people can change. If we all come out attacking and doubting him, what incentive does he have to keep thinking?

Several people have mentioned the pages upon pages of comments, making it sound like SR posted much of that. He's only made 39 posts (total, not sure if all of those are in this thread). As I write, there are 429 posts in this thread. Many of those appear to be posts written almost-simultaneously and saying very similar things. (In other words, he was asked the same thing over and over before he could respond.)

Until he comes back and gives some proof that he is still a firm believer in SB, let him be.
 
kittynh - I'll add, from another thread (http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=83252), if talking to the dead is as easy as making a phone call...why is she wrong so often.

I agree...you would think the voices of dead, wanting to reassure people, would be overwhelming. I also agree...lets say, for a moment, she really can talk to the dead...cutting off communications from a dead child, because mommy can't pay...only a evil monster would do that.
 
No psychic can guarantee 100% success. That is the nature of psychics. They can at most guarantee an 85% success rate, in the case of Browne, or in the case of one of the greats like Edgar Cayce, slightly more. It is sad when Browne makes a mistake, but we are talking about a few mistakes in a sea of correct readings.

So this makes it "OK" to tell parents with missing children that their kids are dead, without knowing for certain that it's true? That's just fine in your opinion?
 
I have read every post here...and I do feel I understand what you are saying. I am considering the implications of certain things. I am not delusional. I understand the need for evidence.
Let me get this straight. You need evidence that someone who charges grieving people $700 for a half hour (if that) of clumsily delivered make believe isn't really that sincere, caring, or giving of a human being, but a callous megalomaniac.
 
Last edited:
Yep. When you want to disagree, or even insult, without your audience taking offense, use passive-tense.

What is "passive-tense"? You mean passive voice? If so, there was no passive voice construction in that quote. ("Mistakes were made" is an example of passive voice. You need a form of "be" plus the past participle.)

If SylviaRox is actually considering what has been said, more power to him.

By the way, SylviaRox, despite your conviction that JREF moderators would censor you, the only post deleted in this thread so far were ad hominem attacks against you. I have tried to post sincere comments (nothing like a troll comment, or the scathing and unfounded attacks you made against Robert Lancaster, James Randi and all the visitors to this forum) on the GoSylviaBrowne website, and they never appeared. I think this difference is indicative of which group of people is interested in the free expression of ideas and actually trying to determine what is true.
 
Let's talk for a moment about intellectual honesty.

First, when we are honest with ourselves, we are influenced by facts, not our emotions. As Kittynh has pointed out, it might feel good to "hear" from a dead relation, and there might be something cathartic about it, but the reality remains that you have accomplished nothing. Your relation is still dead, and you're now minus whatever cash the psychic has charged.

Facts are pretty ruthless. They aren't swayed by feelings, they simply are. Your first obligation is dealing with facts as they are. You might not like what the facts reveal, but you can pretty much count on the reality of what you find. It won't be changed by thinking real hard about it, or wishing on some star. It is what it is, and you might as well deal with what you have. It's hard, but that's life.

I've got a friend staying with us over the weekends as he's making a transition to a new job. Will lost his wife, Lonnie, about a year ago. He misses her badly, and would love to spend a few hours talking with her once again. But Lonnie lost her battle with ovarian cancer, and she's not here. Where she is, that's between you and what you believe happens when you die, but the reality remains that there's no way she can talk to Will and tell him how much she loves him. There is NO reliably documented evidence of ANYONE being able to communicate with someone who has died. None.

I would love to talk to my Dad. I miss him, but I've also got a number of questions I need answers to, ones that don't allow for excuses. He's not here. Frankly, I would think that if he loved me, and he were able to communicate with the likes of Sylvia Browne, a way could be found for him to communicate with me directly instead of through some sort of "medium."

Not possible? Then what makes it possible for a medium to "hear" from the dead? Why not test this and find out why? Why are mediums so resistant to being tested? Would this not help their cause rather than harm it? The only assumption is that it does harm them, because what they claim they are doing is not what's actually happening! They are playing us, and working our emotions for their own benefit. We are being scammed.

Second, if we are being intellectually honest, we have got to be willing to challenge what we believe, and why we believe it. You have to be willing to examine the fact that underpin your beliefs, or you're going to be taken, every time.

It's like wetting your pants in public: you might get a nice warm feeling from all of this hokum, but in the end, you wind up embarassed as hell. You damned well deserve to be, but why would you choose that course? It's stupidity.

SylviaRox has yet to truly be intellectually honest with himself. There's no way we can expect him to be so with us now, not after eleven pages of his vitriol. He may not like Robert, but the truth isn't so much that he dislikes Robert, but he hates the facts that Robert has posted.

And let's face it: Robert's record is stellar. In spite of everything that "Kaz DeMille-Jacobsen" (actually Carol Priest) threw at him, in spite of every attempt she made to silence him, Robert simply reported the facts and nailed her sorry backside to the wall. He didn't have to lie, or editorialize, the facts destroyed every fiction she'd been trying to feed every audience she spoke to. The same thing, ultimately, is what's going to happen to Sylvia Browne. SR knows this, and he's fighting it.

And when Sylvia's gone, what then? He lacks the intellectual honesty to deal with real life as it is. He won't rest until he finds a new guru to offer him more platitudes, more feelgood verbalism. He's not willing to accept that he could be wrong. Sylvia Browne offers a simplistic solution, and all he needs to do is listen to her, and his life will be "right." It won't be a good life, but it will be a "right" one.

And, sadly, he'll wind up missing out on a great life.
 
I read SR's last post to mean he's really thinking about and considering what everyone has said. Why not give him the benefit of the doubt, until proven otherwise? As others have said, people can change. If we all come out attacking and doubting him, what incentive does he have to keep thinking?

Several people have mentioned the pages upon pages of comments, making it sound like SR posted much of that. He's only made 39 posts (total, not sure if all of those are in this thread). As I write, there are 429 posts in this thread. Many of those appear to be posts written almost-simultaneously and saying very similar things. (In other words, he was asked the same thing over and over before he could respond.)

Until he comes back and gives some proof that he is still a firm believer in SB, let him be.


I agree. Benefit of the doubt given.

And of course the number of pages is not relevant: what's more pertinent is that in 39 posts, SR's message has changed from "Stop Robert Lancaster!" to "considering the implications about certain things".

I don't know what that means exactly, but it's a much more reasonable position than expressed in the opening post.
 
Hi Everyone!
I'm new here. I have read through this whole thread and while doing so had a thought I would like to share.
If I had the power for real to touch the toy or something of a missing child and for real seen the child was dead, Could I then look in the faces of that child's parents and tell them their child is dead? Could you?
Also if I had that power for real I wouldn't go near Mr. Randi's million bucks. Because then everyone would know what I could do. They would all want me to touch, smell, taste, see and hear the deaths and abuse of their missing loved ones.
The power would be a living curse. I wouldn't be able to get the sights sounds and smells of dead and abused children and adults out of my head.
I wouldn't be able to sleep or work or maintain a healthy relationship with anyone. Such a power would be life shattering!
I would find the deepest hole and crawl into it and never be seen again.
Now in contrast to go on nation wide TV and without hesitation look in the face of parents of a missing child and say "dead" is to me inconceivable.
IMO only a complete sociopath could do such a thing!

Also I wanted to say I read the stop "Kaz" site about a year ago and was very impressed with RSL! Once again IMO what he is doing with SSB I find to be a very good thing! The world needs more people of his character no doubt!
 
\
And let's face it: Robert's record is stellar. In spite of everything that "Kaz DeMille-Jacobsen" (actually Carol Priest) threw at him, in spite of every attempt she made to silence him, Robert simply reported the facts and nailed her sorry backside to the wall. He didn't have to lie, or editorialize, the facts destroyed every fiction she'd been trying to feed every audience she spoke to. The same thing, ultimately, is what's going to happen to Sylvia Browne. SR knows this, and he's fighting it.

And when Sylvia's gone, what then? He lacks the intellectual honesty to deal with real life as it is. He won't rest until he finds a new guru to offer him more platitudes, more feelgood verbalism. He's not willing to accept that he could be wrong. Sylvia Browne offers a simplistic solution, and all he needs to do is listen to her, and his life will be "right." It won't be a good life, but it will be a "right" one.

And, sadly, he'll wind up missing out on a great life.


When someone or something that you truly have come to believe in is unveiled as a ruthless opportunist or whatever the case may be..it is shattering to one's thought processes. Your very core of believing in your own ability to discern between the truth and illusion is tested. It is hard for us to do, but with time SR will come to see what others have discovered.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom