Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Thanks for sharing that story, kittynh. Is your friend now recovered both mentally and finanically from the horrid person who did this to her?

I just cannot see how anyone can justify these types of behaviors.
 
Eleven pages with 2 cat pictures and 1 dog picture. Eleven pages of calm, controlled attempts at obtaining evidence and understanding. While there are the occaisional posts that are not directed toward addressing the points made, overall the this thread stands as a beacon of what the JREF and this forum stands for.

SR, if nothing else, please ponder the words of those who have once stood where you are.

Be well.



Boo


Oh yeah, one more thing.... I, too, have met Mr Lancaster and he is one the most honorable, deliberate and discerning people I have ever met. I am proud to have made his acquaintance and call him friend.
 
Eleven pages with 2 cat pictures and 1 dog picture. Eleven pages of calm, controlled attempts at obtaining evidence and understanding. While there are the occaisional posts that are not directed toward addressing the points made, overall the this thread stands as a beacon of what the JREF and this forum stands for.

SR, if nothing else, please ponder the words of those who have once stood where you are.

Be well.



Boo

Sometimes I am very proud to be a member of this community...

I'm going to truly hope that by pretty much everyone deciding at the same time to behave themselves, it's given Rox an opportunity to see that people here are willing to actually read what he had to say, and question him on it, as opposed to argue with him about it, and maybe it's given him something to consider.
 
While I'm late to this party (fashionably...as always...although I did bring cake!) I figured it wouldn't harm matters if I slide my opinion into this foray.

SylviaRox, you've seen a rather wide range of responses here, some vitriolic, most rather polite and helpful. My advice is to ignore (there's an ignore feature in this forum) those who have nothing to say but insults, and really think about the polite - but, admittedly for you, challenging - suggestions. Randfan said it best when he admitted his series of beliefs in his life which were challenged and ultimately changed.

You've admitted that evidence is important in the face of cherished beliefs. Hopefully you've been thinking all the while that maybe some of your claims were based on what you'd heard rather than discovered yourself. Hopefully you've considered the '85%' claim in light of what non-psychics are capable of, and what objective evidence exists in support of Sylvia's claim. Hopefully you've looked at the 'everybody speaks English' claim in light of the German gentleman himself saying he understands Sylvia's words. Robert would be the first to go back and change the statement to 'everybody understands English well enough' in light of the accuracy of the statement, if you argued it.

Look at this as a changing experience, where you're being forced to consider your beliefs not in the light of what another person says, but in light of reasonable analysis. You're smart enough to know that it takes more than one person's words to make something true, no matter how much you like them.

If you have any questions, ask them, and then really think about the answers. Many people here went through the pain of losing cherished beliefs and understand how hard, and seemingly humiliating it is. It's not easy and feels like a weakness when you see you were wrong, but nobody understands more than the folk here.

Cheers.

Athon
 
Wow! This thread exploded into 12 pages in a single day and I skipped around a bit, didn't see all the posts. So maybe this was already raised as a point. But this occurred to me:

If Sylvia Browne was legit - had this power to receive paranormal communications from past, present and future - then what difference would it make if the guy only spoke German? Sylvia does not NEED to communicate in this paranormal manner using the primitive spoken and written languages that we mere mortals employ. Obviously she is receiving these communications via some supernatural conveyance, she translates her impressions into English, and recites her conclusions in a primitive language (thankfully) that we sub-forms can comprehend.

Therefore, Sylvia should be able to go to any country, any audience, any time, and be able to perform her feats of astoundability with equal effectiveness, regardless. Language, Schmanguage.

Right?
 
Amazing! I got off work at 3pm and sat down to catch up on a couple threads that I'm following. I started reading this thread then and could not believe that 11 pages were added in part of a day. I have read everything, and wanted to just mention there were some really great responses from the Skeptics. Problem is I can barely remember them and I don't plan on going back through all these posts.

The German language thing was horrible to read through. Someone did say that wouldn't Sylvia KNOW that he didn't speak good English? That was really clever.

The post by the woman who talked about her friend giving $30K to talk to her dead child was heartbreaking.

Even though I do know a ton of Michaels, even my main man is a Michael, I think it was a good call of Sylvia's to name him as Michael. Thinking it over I do understand that she could have claimed Mike, Miguel, MoJo and just about anything that sorta sounded like Michael. But she did hit it right on.

That's about as far as I would give her. The FACT that she missed the child being dead outweighs the correct hit.

What bothers me the most is that if and when Browne is taken "down town" she will be replaced by thousands more. And this whole event will start over again. It is even possible and likely she will pop up again once people begin to forget. Or maybe she will apologize, her followers will forgive her and then she can say that she has "found her powers" again.

Oh yeah, I also liked the post from someone who said that "Jesus would be pissed to know what she is doing." I also love the avitar of "Jesus is behind the couch."

What really disappointed me is that it is now 8pm here in California and I really really fully expected that by the time I got to the last page (now 12) this SylviaVox would have admitted to being a skeptic all along and was just messing with us. I still suspect that, mainly because the arguments have been well....you know....and this person has done some research on SSB and the Kas site (I read that whole site this week, schools over so I now have some time to catch up) SylviaVox also has been doing lots of post readings, he/she (I do think it is a she) just seems too informed. Reading through everything at one sitting still makes me smell fish.

I am also really hungry!

Thanks for the interesting afternoon

Susan
 
I am not oblivious or stupid.

I'll just have to disagree with you on this point given that:

1. You've claimed RSL lied about the German guy not speaking English. The man clearly did speak English and also said that he understood the reading.

2. You've claimed RSL lies about Sylvia's success rate, yet you haven't even tried to give any evidence that Sylvia's success rate is better than 1%.

3. You believe Sylvia has super powers.
 
Thanks for sharing that story, kittynh. Is your friend now recovered both mentally and finanically from the horrid person who did this to her?

I just cannot see how anyone can justify these types of behaviors.

sadly, the answer is no. she did not recover.

Her family threatened to sue.

It's the reason I'm here at JREF and love the work Mr.Randi does.

It should be noted the Sylviarox did PM me and ask me to share my story. I can't share the total horror of it all, but many of you know.

My friends family has Mr.Lancaster in their prayers everyday. Yeah, they PRAY for this man, because they are so happy he is taking these people on.
 
If Sylvia Browne was legit - had this power to receive paranormal communications from past, present and future - then what difference would it make if the guy only spoke German?

Good point. Also, isn't Sylvia the one with a spirit guide who is Mayan/Incan (yes, two different cultures and languages on two different continents)? If she can understand her guide's pigdin Mayan-Quichua, then doing a psychic reading on someone with adequate English as a second language should be a breeze.
 
You know, a lot of this reminds me of something I keep seeing the Harbor Freight flyers I get. They have this gadget which is nothing more than two magnets and a pair of zip ties. You attach these to your fuel line, and, voila! Your fuel mileage improves!

Well, not really. Gasoline and diesel aren't magnetic, and even if they were, if you could magnetize such fluids, you'd likely cause more problems than you'd solve. The fluid dynamics would go straight to hell. It falls into the territory George Carlin once described: you nail two things together that no one else as thought of to nail together, and someone will buy it.

Problem is, and I've pointed this out to Harbor Freight managers, is that it's nothing more than a waste of money, and for someone to offer it for sale is patently dishonest. They shrug it off, saying they have no say in the matter, and besides, since it's doing no harm, why shouldn't they sell it? And if people want it, who are they to complain?

Except that the money you spend for this junk would have been better spent in other ways. They offer a tire balancing set-up, and with the additional purchase of tire weights, and the appropriate tools, you could balance your own tires and actually do something that would save you in fuel consumption, and save you money on your tires. You could also buy an engine analyzer, (not cheap), which would not only save you money with the one car you own, but with many more that you purchase in the future.

Or, you could even buy the tools to do your own tune-up on your car. Put in a couple of hours changing spark plugs and wires, and spend some time making sure the timing is right, and you'll boost your fuel savings.

Don't have the money to spend? Just remember to shut your engine off when you're going to be idle any longer than five minutes. You'd be surprised how much money you'd save doing that.

But, there are people who are willing to spend good money buying crap which accomplishes nothing. It feels good. They feel as though they're really doing something which helps save them money, and they think they're helping the environment.

But feeling good is not the same as doing good. Doing good requires thought, and it requires effort. Doing good requires results, and it requires those results to be quantifiable. And if you can't provide quantifiable results, it requires that you reevaluate and change what you're doing. It's mechanistic as hell, but ultimately, you wind up DOING GOOD.

It's sad to see people wasting their time on foolishness. The only thing you can do is point out that they're being foolish, and hope that in the end, they learn.

What do you want to bet that Sylvia Browne wouldn't have one of these damn fool devices on her car?
 
But feeling good is not the same as doing good. Doing good requires thought, and it requires effort. Doing good requires results, and it requires those results to be quantifiable. And if you can't provide quantifiable results, it requires that you reevaluate and change what you're doing. It's mechanistic as hell, but ultimately, you wind up DOING GOOD.


Exactly.
 
I agree. Benefit of the doubt given.

And of course the number of pages is not relevant: what's more pertinent is that in 39 posts, SR's message has changed from "Stop Robert Lancaster!" to "considering the implications about certain things".

I don't know what that means exactly, but it's a much more reasonable position than expressed in the opening post.
Please re-read your own last sentence. You don't know what the sentence even means, and yet you consider it to be a more reasonable message.
If you read this sentence very carefully, you will find that it means absolutely nothing.
 
Please re-read your own last sentence. You don't know what the sentence even means, and yet you consider it to be a more reasonable message.
If you read this sentence very carefully, you will find that it means absolutely nothing.

This seems a rather pointless observation. I understand perfectly what Pipirr is saying. We don't know exactly what SR means by his statement, but the tone now seems to be one of quiet introspection rather than angry finger wagging.

Is there something I'm missing? What aren't you understanding?
 
Please re-read your own last sentence. You don't know what the sentence even means, and yet you consider it to be a more reasonable message.

If you read this sentence very carefully, you will find that it means absolutely nothing.
I'm not at all sure why there has to be any deep meaning. I know what it is like to be passionate about my beliefs and then begin to question. I'm not saying that this is what rox is doing I'm only saying that the behavior is entirely consistent with that possibility.

There is nothing whatsoever to be lost with giving a person the benefit of the doubt until he or she makes another post.

I guess because I was once a true believer I like to believe it is possible for people to change. Parsing their words as if they are super sekrit spies seems kind of childish and pointless.

Is it really so serious that we can't let down our guard for one minute to give someone the benefit of the doubt? Really?

Sheesh.

I think we've nothing to lose and something to gain, more than something actually.
 
This seems a rather pointless observation. I understand perfectly what Pipirr is saying. We don't know exactly what SR means by his statement, but the tone now seems to be one of quiet introspection rather than angry finger wagging.

Is there something I'm missing? What aren't you understanding?

I am saying that the sentence is not one of "quiet introspection". It is designed to do one thing and one thing only-placate without actually admitting anything.
 
I am saying that the sentence is not one of "quiet introspection". It is designed to do one thing and one thing only-placate without actually admitting anything.

If that's your gut feeling, that's fine. I personally wouldn't act like I knew for sure off a gut feeling, though.
 
What is to be lost by backing off and giving SR some time? There doesn't seem to be any need to say anything about previous claims, given the serious challenges that have already been made and have not been responded to. If SR comes back with more of the same, so be it. We will all be here. I am a huge fan of being cool-headed and reasonable about this. Wait and see.
 
Another example of extreme rudeness. I cannot imagine anything more hurtful or condescending than implying: "your opinion is so stupid that you couldn't possibly hold it". I imagine that you use this same style of debating against Christians. "You believe in God? Wow, no one could really believe that. You must be kidding."

You hit the nail on the head there! Not that I agree with you on Ms. Brown but you are right about the general attitude of many posters here.

It works like this "I'm smart and I am right. Therefore disagreement is a sign that the person I am arguing with is inferior to me mentally".

For attitudes towards religion just see Mr. Randi's comments in every newsletter as of late.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom