Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Some people are not amenable to rational discourse, so huge is their emotional investment in the utterly irrational. It is really very, very sad.

M.
 
Somewhere we had a long discussion of the 85% claim. It seems to come down to a survey she gives clients after readings which is phrased in such a way that it is impossible to give a negative result, except in the open comments section.
 
Some people are not amenable to rational discourse, so huge is their emotional investment in the utterly irrational. It is really very, very sad.

M.

No, I have been listening to everything that has been said. I am not oblivious or stupid.
 
Just finished this whole thread in essentially one sitting. It's extremely fascinating, but it also contains a definite tinge of sadness as well. Notice how much energy SylviaRox expends on the German guy. It's as though if he can prove Robert even arguably wrong about a single point, then the entire StopSylviaBrowne site can be summarily dismissed. Conversely, look at how big a deal he's making of the "Michael" thing. It seems like if he can prove Sylvia even partially correct about one prediction, then all her other mistakes can be completely ignored.

I hope I never want to believe something so badly that 1% accuracy is enough to sustain my beliefs, and 1% inaccuracy is enough to dismiss its critics.

Seconded. I also wondered what the point was regarding that German guy. Sylvia made nothing but vague "predictions" anyway. So who cares if he understood exactly what she said or not.

It does not change her success failure rate a great deal, whatever this guy understood or didn't understand.

Sylvia's outright lie that nobody at all of the studio audience understood her or knew English does not bother SylviaRox?
 
No, I have been listening to everything that has been said. I am not oblivious or stupid.
Given that everything Sylvia Browne does can easily be replicated by mentalists (who admit to not being psychic) and can also be explained through cold reading then why should anyone believe that she is what she claims she is?
 
Some people are not amenable to rational discourse, so huge is their emotional investment in the utterly irrational. It is really very, very sad.

M.

If I have learned nothing else in coming to the site as a "former Novus person", it's that all of you make me think. You present your points rationally, logically and then throw the ball back into my court to do likewise. Once I took off the rose colored glasses and really did some deep soul searching (yes, I believe in a soul and no, I can't prove it), I realized that I was indebted to each of you who have shared your logical, rational minds with me. As a Gnostic I prided myself on thinking outside of the box. It took a trip through the many discussions in JREF to realize that I wasn't. So I thank you.

ST
 
No, I have been listening to everything that has been said. I am not oblivious or stupid.

Then I don't understand why you keep repeating that SB was right on the first name of Michael Devlin. Even if we assume she reached that information by supernatural means, she was wrong on all other points! How can that be any help at all? Given that she's repeatedly so wrong, which part of her information should the police regard as true? If they directed manpower to look for a Hispanic looking man, it would be wasted. If they directed manpower to look for a man build like a basket ball player, it would be wasted. If they directed manpower to look for a man with dreadlocks, it would be wasted. If they directed man.... OK, I hope you get the picture.
 
I think SR's problem is that he thought Robert made it seem like the German is literally an English speaker. But it's obvious according to this part in the article that it's not the case:

"He seemed to speak reasonable English, but could not validate anything Browne said, since it was all future-related."

A person who "seems to speak reasonable English" is much different than saying that he's an English speaker.

Maybe SR missed that part in the article, and the confusion came from that.
 
Last edited:
How silly of you. Browne had no idea how old Hornbeck's kidnapper was WHEN SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT.

I never said that name was common for one year only, I said that the year he was born fell into the range of the era of the name "Michael's" popularity. In fact, she didn't need to know his age. Look at this survey:

http://www.ssa.gov/cgi-bin/babyname.cgi

Michael was the most popular name from 1954 to 1998. "Michael" covered a majority of names from babies to 50 year olds. I acknowledge she got the first name right, but I also see Sylvia's chances of being wrong were less than her chances of being right.
 
I awoke this afternoon (worked the 2300-0700 shift last night) to find this thread and was reminded of Zeno's Paradox. For as I read through all the posts, more posts were added and it seemed as if I would continue this journey for eternity.

I have two things to add:

1) SR, please, will you show us any evidence to back your claims?

and since Curnir brought this up:

Sooooo.... Time for kittens?

2) I like oatmeal cookies.
 
Well, since you asked nicely and this thread has slowed down, here we go:

23084661daf354ec2.jpg
 
I think SR's problem is that he thought Robert made it seem like the German is literally an English speaker. But it's obvious according to this part in the article that it's not the case:

"He seemed to speak reasonable English, but could not validate anything Browne said, since it was all future-related."

A person who "seems to speak reasonable English" is much different than saying that he's an English speaker.

Maybe SR missed that part in the article, and the confusion came from that.

I've just finished the whole thread, so I don't feel up to going back and finding the SR's exact post, but there's no "confusion" on SR's part. The claim is that RSL lied, because he wrote "all of them spoke English" in response to SB's claim that "...they couldn't speak English."
 
No psychic can guarantee 100% success.
Why not?

That is the nature of psychics.
Post hoc rationalizing.

They can at most guarantee an 85% success rate
Why?
, in the case of Browne, or in the case of one of the greats like Edgar Cayce, slightly more.
Evidence of said success rate?
It is sad when Browne makes a mistake, but we are talking about a few mistakes in a sea of correct readings.
Please provide one specific example of a "correct reading" that is not a matter of subjective interpretation.
 
Well, since we're down to this part of the thread, here's one cat plotting the demise of the other....


94904660bb84e1764.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom