Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

This thread is NOT about Sylvia's legitimacy. It is about Robert Lancaster, and how he distorts information.
In order for Lancaster to have distorted information, Sylvia must be legitimate. Ergo, you must prove her legitimacy in order to substantiate your claim of distortion.

Mr. Lancaster only just recently posted a video of Browne on a television show. On this show, Browne was asked to do a reading for a German man. This man knew practically NO English. Browne did her best to do the reading. It was impossible to verify whether Browne got her answers right or not. But Mr. Lancaster claims that "All of them spoke English." This is simply not true. Watch the clip. The man only knows how to say he doesn't speak English, but Mr. Lancaster counts this against Browne!?
If she's talking to one of his "loved ones" (I'm assuming here as I have not watched the video in question), why wouldn't she answer him in German?
 
Browne chose the German guy. She wasn't asked to read him. So why didn't Francine tell Browne that the guy was German?
 
She was telling him about his future.. My English is pretty good and I don't even know what I would answer in this situation.

Brown: [turns to a man behind her] Let's go, let's go to you. There is a two-year, two and a half-year period in which it looks like you are going to be - I don't want to say without a job, but there's a flat period in which you're not doing what you want to do. [the man is smiling] And that's going to cause you a lot of dissension. And it's a two-and-a-half-year period, then you're going to get into a lot of marketing and sales work. And this marketing and sales work has to do with three other men that you're going to be training.


How could anyone answer that stuff? No wonder he looked confused.
 
:popcorn1

Well, that's entertainment... I can't add anything that hasn't been said by the rest of the forumites already, but I must say that I'm amazed over the civility (from the majority - the GRAND majority I might add) showed in a very touchy subject.

That said, I do think I want to add a few words to SylviaRox:

I'm not an American and have no experience of Sylvia Browne. In fact, it was on this board I learned about her for the first time. Therefore, I could take a stand for or against her without any bias from the beginning.

That said, I like proofs. And when scouring the web for information about ms Browne, I found nothing that substantiated the claims of success apart from the claims saying "she really helped me." And I do believe that people have felt helped by her, and that is good - anything that floats your boat and so on. However, people can get help from doctors, mental coaches, psychiatrists, their moms or anyone they feel comfortable with. Some people feel comfortable with Sylvia Browne.

What I did NOT lie was the fact that nothing was backed up by hard evidence. I couldn't find anything that would back up her as a psychic, and, as I read on, I couldn't stand the fact she was making money out of something that couldn't be proven. That was something that really cut deep and I found this more disturbing than anything else. She uses people's dreams and hopes for profit and entertainment. :mad: That really pisses me off.

But since I'm very liberal, I'm prepared to give her and you the benefit of the doubt. PLEASE present some evidence of your claims.

Because, since this is about Lancaster (in the equation according to you: Lancaster= wrong) and you claim he lies about ms Browne (in the equation according to you: Browne= right) you have to present evidence in order to falsify his claims. If Browne is right then Lancaster is wrong; if Browne is wrong, Lancaster is right. Right?

Very simplified, I know. But I would still like to see this addressed. Thank you.
 
A lot of people believe Sylvia Browne has real powers, for the same reason most people do not know how most magic tricks are done.

SylviaRox, I recommend you read some good books on the subject of Cold Reading. Perhaps it will help you understand how psychics are able to pull off convincing shows.
(Also understand that, occasionally, psychics may throw in a few Hot Readings, where they already spoke with someone, to inflate the accuracy of their "divinity".)

When one wants to learn about how the old "cups and balls" magic trick is done, they read how to do it, from a magic guide that describes it.

When one wants to learn how psychics are able to trick people into believing they are conversing with spirits, they should read a good guide book to show them how that is done.

The only difference is that the "cups and balls" magician does not claim to have supernatural powers, and is only providing entertainment; whereas psychics, such as Sylvia Browne, choose to claim they have real powers, and interfere with people's lives and minds. (A very dangerous thing, I hope you recognize.)

Even if you don't like that last paragraph, I ask that you still consider reading up how the tricks are done.
 
Sylviarox...this can be easily settled...

Sylvia takes Randi's million dollars by proving that she has "psychic powers", and those of us, here, who are critical of her will shut up forever.

I'm sure even Robert would agree to that.

So with such an easy solution to this "problem", I fail to understand what the "hold-up" is...after all Sylvia HAS ALREADY AGREED to the challenge, and if she doesn't want to keep the money she can donate it to her favorite charity.

Well???
 
I apologize for not reading this whole thread. Did SR point out anything at all that RL got wrong?
 
Given that everything Sylvia Browne does can easily be replicated outdone by mentalists (who admit to not being psychic) and can also be explained through cold reading then why should anyone believe that she is what she claims she is?

Fixed it for you.
 
I apologize for not reading this whole thread. Did SR point out anything at all that RL got wrong?



There was a suggestion that RSL misrepresented what it means to "speak English". A suggestion that has been opposed by others, I might add. Other than that, you didn't miss much.
 
There was a suggestion that RSL misrepresented what it means to "speak English". A suggestion that has been opposed by others, I might add. Other than that, you didn't miss much.
Thanks. I did notice a horrible, malicious, libelous, and patently untrue comment about the saintly Banachek.

The suggestion that Banachek does not actually read minds, but is playing a trick of some sort, is beyond the pale and should be retracted immediately. Look at this evidence:

 
Last edited:
No, that is not a minor error. I admit that. But the fact remains Larry King verified Sylvia Browne was SPOT ON in her description of Michael Devlin. Browne's testimony was just as valid, because they would have wanted to catch Devlin regardless of whether the Hornbecks' son was alive or dead, and could use her accurate description.

Could you define "spot on" for us? I take it to mean absolutely accurate and error-free.

Here is Sylvia's description of Hornbeck's abductor: Browne told the Akers that it was her vision that Shawn was taken by a "dark-skinned man, he wasn't black -- more like hispanic." She said he had long, black hair that he wore in dreadlocks and was "really tall."

Here is the mug shot of Michael J. Devlin, the (accused) abductor:

montel_shawnhornbeck2_4.jpg


Please reconcile the two and tell us in your own words how this is a spot on match.
 
Does anyone else think that the German dude looks just like Norm MacDonald?
 
Can someone who speaks German watch that video? At about 3:23 into it, the man says:

I'm [unintelligible] speak English, and I understand your words.

Can anyone guess the [unintelligible] word?

My best guess is that he is saying that he has to think a lot when he speaks English. (To be fair, I am not even certain if he sais he understands Sylvia's words. He might be saying that he doesn't understand all of them? I found that bit hard to pick up.)

Judging from experience, he's at a stage where he is far from fluent, obviously. He probably understands a lot - as long as people speak somewhat slowly and carefully and don't use too many words that he doesn't know. Such a speaker would often find it much more difficult to say what they want to say than understand what others are saying.

But he did speak some English. I've had conversations with many, many people who were far, far worse than him.

Of course it really doesn't matter: He only mentioned he was German after the prediction was made. His being German has nothing to do with the fact that the guy couldn't have possible confirmed if he was going to be in a bad job for several years at any time in the future.
 
SylviaRox has left the building.

Hopefully, he/she will actually take the time to read the thread again, and learn something from it.
 
SylviaRox has left the building.

Hopefully, he/she will actually take the time to read the thread again, and learn something from it.

You have strong eyes.

I just say that because every time I see your posts, they're staring at me. :D

Not that I'm complaining.
 
No, I have been listening to everything that has been said. I am not oblivious or stupid.


I'm glad you've been listening, SR. But you've also been talking. You've made many, many allegations and, except for an argument over the meaning of speaking English, you haven't actually provided any evidence for anything you've said. You started by saying you thought you'd be censored for your opinion. This board doesn't censor opinion generally. It does demand that opinion be supported with evidence.

Why isn't Sylvia's word accepted by the people here? Primarily, it's because she has not provided any evidence that she has the powers she claims. When that evidence is offered, I will be the first to admit my mistake.
 
The man only spoke a few words, in an attempt to say he couldn't speak the language. So Mr. Lancaster is lying when he says the man spoke English. I cannot get any clearer Lisa. I can say "I cannot speak French" in French (je ne peux pas parler français), but this does NOT mean I can SPEAK FRENCH.

I can say "Hello, how are you?" in French ("Bonjour, ça va?"). Does this make me a French speaker? Would you describe me as such to a friend or business partner? Yes or no?

If I said, "Je comprends vos mots" ("I understand your words") do you think that would mean I understood what you said?

If I said, "Entiendo sus palabras" ("I understand your words") do you think that would mean I understood what you said?

If I said, "Ich verstehe Ihre Wörter" ("I understand your words") do you think that would mean I understood what you said?

If I said, "Eu compreendo suas palavras" ("I understand your words") do you think that would mean I understood what you said?

If I said, "Ik begrijp uw woorden" ("I understand your words") do you think that would mean I understood what you said?

Oh please. All you 'skeptics' have done so far is personally attack me and harp on this 85% success rate issue, which has nothing to do with this thread.

I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.

Prewitt, I will state AGAIN that it is NOT my duty to DEFEND BROWNE'S track record. This thread is about LANCASTER, it is NOT another "let's attack Sylvia Browne and her followers" thread like the hundreds of others you people revel in.

How can you say that you shouldn't have to defend Browne's accuracy when that is exactly what RSL's website is about? If he's wrong, then she's right and it should be possible to show it. It should also be easy. Let's have examples of hard evidence. (Not, "thousands of people say she has helped them.")

"Alive or dead" is a 50/50 choice. She should be able to get it right half the time simply by guessing. As far as I can tell, her performance record is worse than you would expect from simple chance.

The ignorant passer-bys have already made their way to this discussion and are actively participating in it. The type of people who visit this forum are people-hating, religion-hating, humanity-hating, belief-hating nihilists. I do not care if I impress these sickos.

Oh, look, he owns a thesaurus.
 
Thanks. I did notice a horrible, malicious, libelous, and patently untrue comment about the saintly Banachek.

The suggestion that Banachek does not actually read minds, but is playing a trick of some sort, is beyond the pale and should be retracted immediately. Look at this evidence:




Dude, you are such a shill......





:)
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.

Ok then, you claim she has an 87% success rate. She got his name right. Although others have pointed out it would be an easy guess, given the populrity of the name Micheal, let's give Sylvia that one. So that's one detail about the abductor (not murderer) she got right. That works out to about 17% on that one case. Can you explain this? And is the fact that Hornbeck was alive when Sylvia said he was dead a minor detail?

And yes, fifty million French Sylvia Browne fans most certainly can be wrong. History books are chock full of ideas that people believed with utter conviction that we now know to be wrong. Phlogisten, phrenology, ether, the inferoirity of some races just to name a few. Fifty million people believing in a false idea does not make it correct.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom