Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing.

Saying this after 30-some-odd posts defending SB pretty clearly indicates what kind of person Gary is.

Pants on fire.
 
Sylviarox, let's get to the substance of the matter.

You claim that Robert is manipulating the truth. You have only been willing to argue this minor point about how well the guy spoke German, yet are not addressing the fact Sylvia said all of them spoke German. It was you who brought the 85% success rate into the argument by saying Robert ignored this. If you think he should include this information on his site, then where is the evidence of this success rate?

Your criticism of Robert and his site cannot be considered anything but a personal attack based on opinion only until you have something substantial to bring to the table. And your criticisms can only be taken seriously if you concede that Sylvia said they all were German, and even IF Robert "lied" (which he didn't), that wouldn't make a drop in the bucket of a difference based on all the articles on his site.

Please start presenting and debating the facts of his claims.

ETA: I had been debating whether I would undertake my own debunking project on this subject. I think now you have pushed me off the fence. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.

:rolleyes: Now I'm just waiting for SylviaRox to Godwinize this thread.

:popcorn1:
 
Saying this after 30-some-odd posts defending SB pretty clearly indicates what kind of person Gary is.

Pants on fire.

He thinks this will allow him to make accusations without any supporting evidence (here), that fantasy should be evaporating by now.
 
You're both missing it....

" Because he was picked up in a--in a blue-colored sedan by a guy by the name of Michael, and the last name sounds like (censored)."

We have no idea what she said his last name is or sounds like, unless you have another, uncensored source.

Hmm... I seem to be getting a "J"... "Jason"? ... "Jack"? ... :D

M.
 
No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.

Hey, what about SkepticReport?

I've written some pretty devastating articles about Sylvia Browne, too.

Sylvia Browne: Fast-Food Psychic
Past Li(v)es
The Cost Of Verifying Past Lives
Cell Memory

Don't I get a little (mis)credit here?

Other people, have too:

Dodgeball Deluxe: The Sylvia Browne Chronology
California's "Haunted" Highway
11 Techniques To Talk To The Dead, Part 3
Browne, Sylvia Prophecies For Dummies
Sylvia Browne: Predictions For 2000-2100
Sylvia Browne: Failed Prophet in 1998
Is Courtesy Used To Defend Ignorance?
 
All right, I'm coming out of the closet. I was one of the members from JREF who posted on the GoSylviaBrowne site. There was indeed a thread here about the site but it was not started by Robert Lancaster. Within a few minutes after the thread was started, some of our members said they had posted there.

I joined and made a very polite post asking what Sylvia would say to someone to whom she had given inaccurate information. One post. One polite post. I was immediately banned.

It was several hours later when I came back to JREF I saw the post by Robert Lancaster urging people not to spam or even sign up on Sylvia's site. I never contacted them again.

So it is true that there were a number of people who are members here who posted to the GSB site, but it is not true that they spammed them. They were not allowed to. They were not allowed to speak at all, not harshly or politely.

It is quite obvious that the owner of the StopSylviaBrowne site is completely intolerant of any criticism of Ms. Browne. It is also apparent that the JREF forum allows a great deal of latitude for posters to make inflammatory accusations about its members and even about Randi himself. I can point you to specific threads if you like.
 
It would be the webmaster of GSB's case, you are right that Sylvia herself would not have a case, unless she owns the site as some of you have suggested.


But that's not what you said. You said, emphasis added:



Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys.



You said that Robert was pretending not to have asked people to spam the site because he was afraid of Browne's attorneys. Now you admit that Browne would have no cause of action. Since you have gained no new knowledge between those posts, I contend that you deliberately conflated the GSB website and Browne herself. In fact, in the very post where you talked about Browne's attorneys, you admitted that Browne and the webmaster of GSB were different. You said:


He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.


I believe you deliberately conflated Browne and the webmaster after earlier maintaining that the website was a fan site with no connection to Browne. You did so to confuse the issues.

You continue to confuse the issues here:


If I'm not mistaken widespread spam is illegal and just recently a major spammer was busted and is now imprisoned and being prosecuted.


Are you mistaken? Well, you did absolutely no research before making your accusations so chances are yes. Let's see what I can find out in, oh, ninety seconds. Go ...

The Federal CAN-SPAM law "requires unsolicited commercial e-mail messages to be labeled (though not by a standard method) and to include opt-out instructions and the sender's physical address." (source). Since none of the messages left in the guestbook at GSB are "emails," there is no possibility Robert violated the Federal Act even if everything you say is true.

That took thirty seconds to find. I've got one minute left.

Okay, I just reviewed the anti-spam legislation of all fifty states here and those with laws outlaw unsolicited commercial email or bulk email. Since nothing qualifies as email in your little accusation, Robert could not have violated any state's law. Also, both stopsylviabrowne and gosylviabrowne are non-commercial sites so nothing could be considered a commercial message. Robert wins on this point as well.

I still have nineteen seconds left. Were there any other baseless accusations you wanted to make?
 
How do you know it wasn't explained to them in the beginning, or they didn't have to sign a form?

I don't know and neither do you.

All show guests must sign a form that states they will hold Montel and his show harmless, regardless of what is said or done as a result of being a guest.

I was a guest and I signed the form.
 
Here's a video of Sylvia Browne's appearance on Montel's show, where she gives her description of the abductor:




Sylvia's description of the suspect begin around 1:02 in the video. Gary, please comment on the accuracy of Sylvia's statements. I am more interested in your opinion of Sylvia's accuracy than I am in Larry King's.
 
If you are going to tell someone that their child is dead you better be 90% correct or better.

IMO she figured she had a better than 50-50 shot that he was gone, since statistically it was likely he was dead. Especially after so much time had passed, with no new leads. There are no miraculous powers being displayed, she's playing the odds and depending on people to overlook or not notice her mistakes. A trained criminal profiler would have given a more accurate picture of who to look for and how to catch them (I don't know if one was consulted on the case or their findings).
 
Last edited:
And a photo of the suspect for comparision...



ETA: For comparision with the description in bjb's linked video.
 
The good thing about all this is that this thread is a perfect instructional tool to those on the fence. It is a textbook example of the Browne modus operandi:

Make a false claim.

Get caught in your lie.

Change the parameters to make your claim unfalsifiable/unprovable.

Shoot, this is well beyond "on the fence." I think that even a lot of SB supporters would be horrified by the actions of SylviaRox. Not all of them are that completely off the wall crazy.

I would love to have this entire thread archived and sent to all the SB supporters. Heck, publish the thing in her church-thingy newsletter. Even some of them (who are, of course, the most ardent supporters) would probably lose faith.
 
I think we have worn out poor SylviaRox.

But I wonder, is SylviaRox walking away thinking, "geez, maybe these people are right" or, "wow, what a bunch of closed minded fools that will never learn a thing"?

I hope he's searching for that one example of an accurate Sylvia reading. I hope his inability to locate it tells him something.
 
Had a feeling this thread would have exponential growth...

It does always amaze me how followers of sylvia and her ilk are always willing to give her a free pass no matter what mistake she makes. The Shawn Hornesby incident alone should be enough to raise doubt. Add up the other mistakes and anyone should realize that she is just cold reading. People demand perfection from doctors, police, teachers, etc...However, no matter what sylvia does, they let her slide and send her checks. Wrongly tell a familiy their son is dead, their daughter is in slavery and it is OK. And she doesn't equivocate when she makes these statements. What would it take Sylviarox???? How about selling fake diamonds? How about a prediction Bob Hope would die 4 years before he actually did??? Predict a bunch of hurricanes that didn't arrive last summer? Would that change your mind?

think about it...

glenn
 
All right, I'm coming out of the closet. I was one of the members from JREF who posted on the GoSylviaBrowne site. There was indeed a thread here about the site but it was not started by Robert Lancaster. Within a few minutes after the thread was started, some of our members said they had posted there.

I joined and made a very polite post asking what Sylvia would say to someone to whom she had given inaccurate information. One post. One polite post. I was immediately banned.

It was several hours later when I came back to JREF I saw the post by Robert Lancaster urging people not to spam or even sign up on Sylvia's site. I never contacted them again.

So it is true that there were a number of people who are members here who posted to the GSB site, but it is not true that they spammed them. They were not allowed to. They were not allowed to speak at all, not harshly or politely.

It is quite obvious that the owner of the StopSylviaBrowne site is completely intolerant of any criticism of Ms. Browne. It is also apparent that the JREF forum allows a great deal of latitude for posters to make inflammatory accusations about its members and even about Randi himself. I can point you to specific threads if you like.

Just want to add this:

Within about an hour of the begining of that thread, Robert made his first post into it. Here is what it said:
For the record guys, I do not encourage anyone to give that site problems.

The webmaster is doing what i am doing, which is expressing his or her viewpoint. I will be adding a link to the site from my Links page, in the "Pro Sylvia" section.

It is an odd feeling to have a sort of "satire site" of one of my own!
 
Sylviarox can PM me here for my own personal story of what happens when someone goes to see a psychic, and the horror and tragedy for all involved. What you do NOT see are the stories of those, those I believe that are the majority, that suffer from her actions.

Sylvia Browne would have been burned as a witch in a different more enlightened age.
 
Straw man argument. I'm not attacking a claim of 100% accuracy, but rather the claim you yourself made of 85% accuracy or even "right most of the time".

I think I've figured it out: she has an 85% success rate, but only once in a while.

I'm still chuckling on his gripe that Lancaster appears to have a bias against Sylvia Browne. I mean, the website is only called "StopSylviaBrowne." And the webmaster is bias against her? Shocked, I say! Completely shocked!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom