Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.

It wasn't a lie though. The guy spoke English.

I believe that you are trying to say the RSL underplayed the language difficulty. It is clear that Browne overplayed the language difficulty. In fact, Browne lied when she said no one spoke English. This might be dismissed as harmless exaggeration for effect, but Browne herself would have to clarify that.

How would you have rewritten Robert's article? Your goal is to say that while everyone did speak English, there was one audience member who did have some problems understanding Browne. I however got that out of Robert's article, so I personally see no need to rewrite it. Robert is trying to be completely objective. But reasonable criticisms of his presentation are not unwelcome.

To reiterate: Browne lied. Lancaster did not. Lancaster has attempted to present the truth in all its subtleties. Browne has not. Lancaster has shown a willingness to clarify and correct.
 
As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.

"Browne, a woman who has brought an immeasurable amount of comfort and assistance to men and women across the country, as well as help to police departments, has been treated in a fashion completely and utterly shocking to any civilized person."

This sounds like a defense to me, or perhaps your definition of defense is different than that of most people, just as your definition of "spot on" is apparently different.

If I may, let me ask you your personal opinion. Aside of SB and Robert Lancaster and this entire discussion, do you think it is right to tell the family members of a missing person that that person is dead or alive without having proof of that fact?
 
She got "Michael" right. What were the odds? Note that she didn't come within a zillion miles of getting "Devlin."

M.

As far as I know, whatever Sylvia said for the last name was bleeped out by the Montel show. Although I think it's fairly safe to assume that if Sylvia came anywhere close to the name Devlin, she would be shouting it from the rooftops.
 
Actually, mostly I note that she didn't even TRY for a last name....

You're both missing it....

" Because he was picked up in a--in a blue-colored sedan by a guy by the name of Michael, and the last name sounds like (censored)."

We have no idea what she said his last name is or sounds like, unless you have another, uncensored source.
 
"Browne, a woman who has brought an immeasurable amount of comfort and assistance to men and women across the country, as well as help to police departments, has been treated in a fashion completely and utterly shocking to any civilized person."

This sounds like a defense to me, or perhaps your definition of defense is different than that of most people, just as your definition of "spot on" is apparently different.

If I may, let me ask you your personal opinion. Aside of SB and Robert Lancaster and this entire discussion, do you think it is right to tell the family members of a missing person that that person is dead or alive without having proof of that fact?

It is wrong if you don't explain to the person that you are not always right. It's also wrong if you lie and have no actual power.
 
As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing.

Come on. You don't really expect anyone to believe that, do you?

You come on this forum, immediately defending Sylvia Browne's record.

Don't make the mistake to think that people here are stupid.
 
It is wrong if you don't explain to the person that you are not always right. It's also wrong if you lie and have no actual power.

I have no comment. I just want to quote this. In fact, I might put it into my sig. This is probably the most profound, most intelligent, most touching thing I've read on this thread so far.

Give it some thought, my friend.
 
As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.

Based on fact, and experience, Lancaster does not manipulate information, and it seems that you have caused all of this by picking apart whether a person who speaks German as a first language could understand English.

Again, read what James Randi, who was there, said:

Robert: re the Bixby/Browne video, it should be said that I mixed with that section of our audience following the incident, and as far as I could tell, all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

James Randi.
http://www.stopsylviabrowne.com/articles/exploringpsychicpowerslive.shtml

Sylvia is more apt to use manipulation and lying to attack those who shes sees as enemies, Dark, or Evil, not Lancaster.
 
You're both missing it....

" Because he was picked up in a--in a blue-colored sedan by a guy by the name of Michael, and the last name sounds like (censored)."

We have no idea what she said his last name is or sounds like, unless you have another, uncensored source.
Yep, sorry, it wasn't until after I posted that that I discovered she had possibly made an attempt....
 
It is wrong if you don't explain to the person that you are not always right. It's also wrong if you lie and have no actual power.


So then, it was wrong of SB to do what she did to the Hornbecks, based on your opinion, as no where in the transcript does SB state that she is not always right.

Thank you.

Her "powers" have as yet to be proven in my opinion.
 
Success rate at what? and... care to prove it at all?

She was 85% unhelpful in the cases cited on Anderson Cooper, gave no material benefit to either, and it was her publicist who chose the cases so imagine if they where chosen at random how unhelpful her help would be.
 
So then, it was wrong of SB to do what she did to the Hornbecks, based on your opinion, as no where in the transcript does SB state that she is not always right.

Thank you.

Her "powers" have as yet to be proven in my opinion.

How do you know it wasn't explained to them in the beginning, or they didn't have to sign a form?
 
Just finished this whole thread in essentially one sitting. It's extremely fascinating, but it also contains a definite tinge of sadness as well. Notice how much energy SylviaRox expends on the German guy. It's as though if he can prove Robert even arguably wrong about a single point, then the entire StopSylviaBrowne site can be summarily dismissed. Conversely, look at how big a deal he's making of the "Michael" thing. It seems like if he can prove Sylvia even partially correct about one prediction, then all her other mistakes can be completely ignored.

I hope I never want to believe something so badly that 1% accuracy is enough to sustain my beliefs, and 1% inaccuracy is enough to dismiss its critics.
 
Last edited:
Good golly Miss Molly! I’m away for the day and BLAM!

Ok…I’ve read most, though not all, of this thread. It all seems to boil down to SylviaRox (Gary Richardson) claim that Robert Lancaster has made “hostile and concerted attempt to slander, libel and defame Sylvia Browne”.

If there are errors in the content on the “StopSylviaBrown.com” site, point them out for all to see. If there is content that you feel should be included, but is not, provide it.

However, in either case (errors, content) it is important to remember this is a “skeptics” site; that is to say with each claim there should be factual reference/documentation supporting it.

Emotional debate, without supporting reference/documentation, by either side does nothing but cloud the truth.
 
Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys.


You haven't answered any of my other posts, so I doubt you'll respond to this one but let's give it a shot:

Assume for the moment that Robert has been asking people to spam GSB. He has sent emails to all of his friends and everyone else he knows begging that they sign on and leave all sorts of nonsense in the guestbook. Assume that he has, in fact, sent 400,000 such emails and made 12,000 personal phone calls. Assume that his lawyers have irrefutable proof of all of it. Here is my question:

What cause of action would Sylvia Browne have against him? What charges should Ms. Browne's lawyers file? What crimes or torts has Robert committed?

In order for your accusation to make any sense, there must be something illegal or harmful about Robert's supposed activities. You claim that the lack of evidence of Robert's campaign against GSB is really evidence of that campaign. So what if it is? What has Robert done wrong in that case?

I really am asking for my own edification. I personally have opined on this very issue and I want to make absolutely sure my legal opinion is completely correct. Please, take me to school.
 
Emphasis added:


Oh you mean minor details like Shawn was dead when he was actually alive? Or that Opal Jennings was alive when she was actually dead? :rolleyes: Those seem like awful major errors for someone who has a direct pipeline to the spirit realm.

That is the problem with the spirit world, it is so boring, that when they get the chance to play any kind of practical joke they can't help themselves.
 
You haven't answered any of my other posts, so I doubt you'll respond to this one but let's give it a shot:

Assume for the moment that Robert has been asking people to spam GSB. He has sent emails to all of his friends and everyone else he knows begging that they sign on and leave all sorts of nonsense in the guestbook. Assume that he has, in fact, sent 400,000 such emails and made 12,000 personal phone calls. Assume that his lawyers have irrefutable proof of all of it. Here is my question:

What cause of action would Sylvia Browne have against him? What charges should Ms. Browne's lawyers file? What crimes or torts has Robert committed?

In order for your accusation to make any sense, there must be something illegal or harmful about Robert's supposed activities. You claim that the lack of evidence of Robert's campaign against GSB is really evidence of that campaign. So what if it is? What has Robert done wrong in that case?

I really am asking for my own edification. I personally have opined on this very issue and I want to make absolutely sure my legal opinion is completely correct. Please, take me to school.

It would be the webmaster of GSB's case, you are right that Sylvia herself would not have a case, unless she owns the site as some of you have suggested. If I'm not mistaken widespread spam is illegal and just recently a major spammer was busted and is now imprisoned and being prosecuted.
 
How do you know it wasn't explained to them in the beginning, or they didn't have to sign a form?

You're missing your one chance to really score a point in this thread. If you look, you can find many instances where SB says quite plainly that she is not always correct. It could be reasonably assumed that anyone sitting before SB would be familiar with that info. If you made that arguement, I'd have to grant it to you.

None the less, her track record is approximately 0%. Any claims to higher accuracy than that (she does bandy about that 85% figure, regularly) are a major problem for her credibility.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom