Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

No, because you don't have the power, influence or desire to do so. Lancaster has the desire to make the webmaster of GSB miserable, because he hates Sylvia. He also has the power, because you all respect him and he knows you. There is nowhere these skeptics could be coming from except for the JREF.

Such venom. Let me guess, you're a psychic, too and that is what makes you feel comfortable making firm statements like the above?

The only people skeptical of Sylvia on earth are at JREF?

I'm still waiting for your facts. Thus far you have proven yourself guilty of what you accuse Robert of. You have not shown that anything he has posted is a lie. You have not provided proof that she is accurate--which, by the way, is what you would need to do to counter the claims she is not accurate. You have maligned Robert, attacked him personally, assumed things about him based on your personal feelings without evidence.

It seems someone hates Robert, and based on personal opinion alone, he's making all sorts of personal attacks and ignoring the facts. Until you have something other than your opinion, you must face the reality that YOU are the one who is behaving in the manner you accuse.
 
The ignorant passer-bys have already made their way to this discussion and are actively participating in it. The type of people who visit this forum are people-hating, religion-hating, humanity-hating, belief-hating nihilists. I do not care if I impress these sickos.

Oh, I see. You get to paint the people here with broad strokes of stereotype and moral judgment, but no one else gets to do the same. Got it.
 
No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.

No, it's similar to the hatred that I have towards psychics that preyed upon my Aunt when her daughter went missing years ago. They didn't help one bit, either.
 
I cross posted. SylviaRox, I too thank you for reconsidering your statement. You are correct in your claim that some members of this forum did spam GSB. You can identify some of them from reading those threads, and see that RSL asked them to stop.

I think no one would object to civil criticisms of these member's behavior. I for one thought it was funny, but I can understand why you did not.

For the record, I have never posted on GSB.
 
No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.

Randi's, or Lancaster's, or even my own dislike for Sylvia is far from prejudice. There was no 'pre-judging', she is disliked for well documented reasons.

To insinuate that there is any parallel between this and typical racist behavior is simply shameful.
 
No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.
This is without basis. I'm deeply offended by what Sylvia has done to people. Telling parents with confidence that their child is dead when you have NO basis whatsoever is a very disgusting and despicable thing to do.
 
It seems someone hates Robert, and based on personal opinion alone, he's making all sorts of personal attacks and ignoring the facts. Until you have something other than your opinion, you must face the reality that YOU are the one who is behaving in the manner you accuse.

Brilliant.
 
The ignorant passer-bys have already made their way to this discussion and are actively participating in it. The type of people who visit this forum are people-hating, religion-hating, humanity-hating, belief-hating nihilists. I do not care if I impress these sickos.

No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.



I'll just let the irony speak for itself on this one.
 
This person is skilled in the modus operandum of Novus Spiritus and Sylvia Browne:

Never Respond, Only Attack. Even if it is false, lies, or misdirection, attack.

Listen, if Sylvia and her staff could not stand up and defend her, then what makes any fan think that they can?

It is sad that these people, and I was once among their numbers, will so blindly lash out at any person who even thinks about pointing out flaws of Sylvia or Novus. And this is how they still make money, keep the ignorant ignorant, don't reply because people can guess that you apologized in private, and on and on and on.

Again, "Gary", what is your connection to Sylvia and/or Novus? What is your personal experience with them? Where are your flawed "facts" coming from, other than the speaking points list?
 
I rescind the statement. Robert S. Lancaster did not direct anyone to spam GSB nor did he spam it himself.

Thank you.

My advice about not being anonymous still stands. (I'm not very anonymous--and I think it makes me think twice, usually, before posting. On the occasions when I have put my foot in my mouth, the fact that a quick google can identify me encourages me to admit when I'm wrong and apologize immediately.)

While you're rescinding, I notice you've abandoned the description of Shawn Hornbeck's abductor as proof of Sylvia's accuracy. Do you admit she was wrong in her description (dreadlocks, skin color, build)? Do you rescind your assertion that she was "spot on"? It's OK, since you were relying on Larry King rather than the actual words of Sylvia's reading.

You'll notice that Robert uses primary sources whenever possible, and is careful about using other sources. (Seriously, carefully read the write up of his interview with the Dufresnes. Robert is extremely cautious in revealing who said what. He does a reasonable analysis of the credibility of those secondary source claims, and is quick to admit when something turns out to be proven wrong. In that case, the larger strokes appear to be true: that Sylvia's claim to have a Master's Degree is unsubstantiated and most likely a lie.)
 
Wow. What a thread. :eye-poppi

More than 300 posts, and still not a shred of evidence about Sylvia Browne's alleged "success rate" of 85%.

In fact, not a shred of evidence that Sylvia Browne is anything but an out and out fraud.
 
Wow. What a thread. :eye-poppi

More than 300 posts, and still not a shred of evidence about Sylvia Browne's alleged "success rate" of 85%.

In fact, not a shred of evidence that Sylvia Browne is anything but an out and out fraud.

You noticed that too?
 
Wow. What a thread. :eye-poppi

More than 300 posts, and still not a shred of evidence about Sylvia Browne's alleged "success rate" of 85%.

In fact, not a shred of evidence that Sylvia Browne is anything but an out and out fraud.

As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.
 
No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.

Have you considered that maybe the "personal gripe" could possibly be based on fact, not emotion?

It is quite dissimilar to racism, in that it is based on the FACT that Sylvia, and others like her, cause real damage to people who are already suffering.

I'm guessing that you don't know who Kelly, the one who mentioned cults and de-programing, is. Perhaps you should read about her, just a bit.

ProjectJason
 
Everyone agrees she got the name right.

Now.

Is Michael Devlin Hispanic?
Does he have long hair?
Worn in dreadlocks?
Did he drive a 1950's car with fins?
Was he tall like a basketball player?

One correct answer. SIX (including the death of Shawn Hornbeck himself) WRONG!

She got "Michael" right. What were the odds? Note that she didn't come within a zillion miles of getting "Devlin."

M.
 
The ignorant passer-bys have already made their way to this discussion and are actively participating in it. The type of people who visit this forum are people-hating, religion-hating, humanity-hating, belief-hating nihilists. I do not care if I impress these sickos.


:shocked: :jaw-dropp

Wow, I am really surprised by your judgement of the people who visit this forum. Since, I am in this forum, and you acknowledge that I was not rude to you, how can you typecast me or anyone like that?

I do not hate people, I may totally dislike/hate their actions; do not hate religion, but do hate/dislike how man has twisted it for their own personal gain; and as far as beliefs go...well, I 100% believe that whatever one wants to believe is fine for them. I don't put my beliefs on anyone, and really respect the right of others to disagree and/or have their own.

Regarding Mr. Lancaster:

Ok, I admit it. When I first went to his site to read the things printed there, I had already decided to dislike him, and write off his ramblings as another person out to get Sylvia.

Funny thing happened though. When I read some of the documents, there was information in there, that I KNEW FOR A FACT was true. I read each article, and honestly came away respecting how he presented them.

Let's be clear here. His site does not say "Pass Go, collect another $750, Sylvia". It says "StopSylviaBrowne". When someone can post these articles, and say, "Read them and make up your own mind", you can hardly fault him for his material.

Much in the same way that Sylvia always says at the lectures, "Don't believe what I say, just because I am saying it....Go and research it yourself!".

I came away really liking Mr. Lancaster, and believing his intent was to educate and inform. It is to each of us to decide whether what is written by him, or anyone for that matter rings true to us.

As for this forum:

The members of this forum have been very fair and respectful to all of the former members of NS and former Sylvia Browne fans. We have come to their forum, and posted honestly, not giving out statements without giving examples or data.

You can not expect people here (who are by the way as skeptical as any gnostic that I know, including myself) to respond in anyway other than how they are indeed approached.

No one doubts that you have sincere feelings for Sylvia, or that the members at GSB also share that feeling. It is all about communication, and how we go about it. Not much different than the complaints we, former NS folks have about communication styles with the office.

It all depends on where your focus is, or if you are open to listening. One of the reasons that the kind folk here are so upset, imho, is that countless documents and statements about very painful, and life-altering comments, statements made by Sylvia to people during public Q&A's are NOT acceptable, by any human standard. Whether you like Sylvia or not isn't the issue, here.

I am noticing that with the immergence of the blog, and these threads, the focus seems to be to look at other's behaviors, actions and hold them accountable for them. Ok, that's fair! So, in the spirit of fair play and all....Sylvia, you go first.
 
As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.

  1. The facts about the German speaking man have been thoroughly dealt with.
  2. Sylvia flat out lied about that affair.
  3. You've not shown that Lancaster has manipulated any information.
  4. If Robert is wrong about something he will correct it. He has done that in the past. He is intellectually honest.
 
As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.

What could possibly make you believe that RSL manipulates information unless you have something that contradicts him. So far, you've had a big fat zero in the regard.

You've failed to convince anyone that German speaking man issue was any kind of lie, let alone a dilberate lie.

Having just 1 example of a substantially true reading by Sylvia would be an excellent place to start. All you've been able to do is split hairs on one tiny, hardly relevant detail of a larger point.
 
As I said many times throughout the thread, I am no apologist or defender of Sylvia Browne, and I do not have the knowledge of her history to even attempt such a thing. I merely believe that Robert S. Lancaster manipulates information, as in his deliberate lie regarding the German speaking man in the Exploring Psychic Powers Live clip.

SylviaRox, this is what Robert wrote in the article:

"He seemed to speak reasonable English, but could not validate anything Browne said, since it was all future-related."

He never claimed that the German is an English speaker, just that that he SEEMED to speak REASONABLE English. From watching the video it seems like the truth.

Robert has posted about 30 articles on his site, and you only have a problem with this one small issue. So maybe he's not that bad after all.
 
She got "Michael" right. What were the odds? Note that she didn't come within a zillion miles of getting "Devlin."

M.

Actually, mostly I note that she didn't even TRY for a last name....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom