Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

Can't you read, Lisa? I explained why I am unable to provide evidence. Lancaster could have been conducting it through phone, PMs or e-mails.

Yes, I can read and you accuse US of being rude? Sheesh.

You have no evidence. Therefore, you are the one making false attacks and are possibly committing libel.
 
You guys are a very close community, and it would be easy for him to direct people to spam the guestbook. He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.

I sat next to him for a couple hours at an informal dinner a few weeks ago, and never once heard him even mention the guestbook, much less suggest spamming it.
 
Can't you read, Lisa? I explained why I am unable to provide evidence. Lancaster could have been conducting it through phone, PMs or e-mails.
By that logic:
I could be the guy who direct the chinese goverment in all their policies.
 
Can't you read, Lisa? I explained why I am unable to provide evidence. Lancaster could have been conducting it through phone, PMs or e-mails.

Or you could be full of crap.

In the end, you are making an accusation of wrongdoing on his part for which you have no evidence--and in fact, there is ample evidence to the contrary.

And you have the sheer gall to accuse others of engaging in slander and lies!
 
Note how he says 'for the record'. Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys. You guys are a very close community, and it would be easy for him to direct people to spam the guestbook. He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.

You might want to rethink this statement. It should be possible to trace at least some of the spammers, and if the members of this community who did spam were to swear in court that RSL did NOT direct them to go there, and did in fact direct them otherwise, you could be found liable for libel.

Everything on StopSylivaBrowne has been checked and double-checked, and Robert has promptly corrected any mistakes pointed out to him. You haven't been able to back up your opinions with any hard facts; the only thing you've come up with is "speaking English implies speaking English better than that German gentleman" and "Larry King is highly regarded, therefore what he says is likely to be true." Your opinions on these two subjects may be valid, but they are out of step with the majority and certainly do not constitute legal proof.

Of course if you are simply claiming that it is possible that RSL asked friends to spam GSB, then it's also possible that Browne spammed GSB all by herself. Unlikely, but possible.
 
Another example of extreme rudeness. I cannot imagine anything more hurtful or condescending than implying: "your opinion is so stupid that you couldn't possibly hold it". I imagine that you use this same style of debating against Christians. "You believe in God? Wow, no one could really believe that. You must be kidding."

At reading your opening post, I genuinely thought it was parody. That sort of stuff happens around here. I don't apologize for the "moronic" statement because I consider your defense of the indefensible to be moronic behavior. For all I know you might be a very intelligent person, but you're not displaying that here.

M.
 
By that logic:
I could be the guy who direct the chinese goverment in all their policies.

No, because you don't have the power, influence or desire to do so. Lancaster has the desire to make the webmaster of GSB miserable, because he hates Sylvia. He also has the power, because you all respect him and he knows you. There is nowhere these skeptics could be coming from except for the JREF.
 
Note how he says 'for the record'. Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys. You guys are a very close community, and it would be easy for him to direct people to spam the guestbook. He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.



So, no actual evidence then. Just your suspicions.

And meanwhile, you're ignoring the fact that RSL has actually gone out of his way to help the GSB site avoid the very problems you accuse him of promoting:



SylviaRox, your assumption skeptics wrecked the guestbook are wrong. I even wrote a blog entry about the GSB comment spam hysterics. Robert was kind enough to forward the solutions to Heather, so she could stop the spamming.


What was that about being a liar?
 
You might want to rethink this statement. It should be possible to trace at least some of the spammers, and if the members of this community who did spam were to swear in court that RSL did NOT direct them to go there, and did in fact direct them otherwise, you could be found liable for libel.

Everything on StopSylivaBrowne has been checked and double-checked, and Robert has promptly corrected any mistakes pointed out to him. You haven't been able to back up your opinions with any hard facts; the only thing you've come up with is "speaking English implies speaking English better than that German gentleman" and "Larry King is highly regarded, therefore what he says is likely to be true." Your opinions on these two subjects may be valid, but they are out of step with the majority and certainly do not constitute legal proof.

Of course if you are simply claiming that it is possible that RSL asked friends to spam GSB, then it's also possible that Browne spammed GSB all by herself. Unlikely, but possible.

I rescind the statement. Robert S. Lancaster did not direct anyone to spam GSB nor did he spam it himself.
 
No, because you don't have the power, influence or desire to do so. Lancaster has the desire to make the webmaster of GSB miserable, because he hates Sylvia. He also has the power, because you all respect him and he knows you. There is nowhere these skeptics could be coming from except for the JREF.

Evidence? He actually contacted Heather after I posted the solution to avoid comment spam. Don't blame Robert for Heather's poor computer skills.
 
The good thing about all this is that this thread is a perfect instructional tool to those on the fence. It is a textbook example of the Browne modus operandi:

Make a false claim.

Get caught in your lie.

Change the parameters to make your claim unfalsifiable/unprovable.
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do.
Straw man argument. I'm not attacking a claim of 100% accuracy, but rather the claim you yourself made of 85% accuracy or even "right most of the time".

You just made up the number, right?

That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right.
Restating the claim is not proof. As I showed you, getting his name right is at best, in this one reading, 11.1% accuracy (and that only if you really give her the benefit of the doubt).

Do you think Sylvia would have a great following if she claimed "up to 11.1% accuracy"?

Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.
Yes they can. (So can Larry King.) Read what The Vampire wrote.
 
No, because you don't have the power, influence or desire to do so. Lancaster has the desire to make the webmaster of GSB miserable, because he hates Sylvia. He also has the power, because you all respect him and he knows you. There is nowhere these skeptics could be coming from except for the JREF.

Nevermind. I see he "apologized".
 
SylviaRox

I think it showed courage to use your real name (assuming it is) and come on a skeptics board to defend Sylvia Browne. I don’t think you’ve represented yourself very well beyond that, but I imagine you feel otherwise.

What I’m wondering is whether you are the Gary Richardson of telephone astrologer fame?

Really, just curious. If you don't want to acknowledge/deny, no harm done.
 
No, because you don't have the power, influence or desire to do so. Lancaster has the desire to make the webmaster of GSB miserable, because he hates Sylvia. He also has the power, because you all respect him and he knows you. There is nowhere these skeptics could be coming from except for the JREF.

That's manifestly false. First of all, lots of skeptics are not on the JREF. Secondly, some JREF members did spam the board and Robert asked them to stop. I can't say whether or not they did all stop, but you can't blame Robert if they didn't. And far from making Heather miserable, Robert has been helpful to her, a fact that she herself acknowledges.

If you can identify someone who continued to spam after RSL asked him to stop, you can say bad things about him, so long as you follow the general forum rules about civility. I for one wouldn't blame you for doing so.
 

The JREF now contains all the Sylvia Browne-critical skeptics of the world?

No, but I have come to believe that Randi, Lancaster and JREF have a personal gripe against Sylvia which transcends anything that I have ever seen before. It is similar to the hatred that many racists have for those of other races.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom