Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

According to James Randi, the man spoke English well enough. Considering Randi's description has been more accurate, I tend to believe him over Sylvia.

Sorry to respond to this so late in proceedings, but I'm working my way through all the posts.

I just watched the video again, and my take on it, although I don't know what the German guy said that the transcript showed as [unintelligible], is that the man was ironically saying he didn't understand SB's gibberish that preceded his statement; i.e., he was having a little laugh at her.

M.

ETA: German is my first language, although I learned English from a very young age.
 
She got his first name right--sort of. (Remember, she thought she was talking about a murderer--so pretty much the whole reading is no good.)

Robert is willing to concede the first name. (I'm not--since the statement it was in was wrong.) Based on that, her success rate on the Shawn Hornbeck case, using Robert's summary table, is 1 right out of 13 attempts which is a 7.7% hit rate. We could remove the 4 unknowns and make it 1 out of 9 which brings it all the way up to 11.1%. This assumes that having a first name is of equal value to thinking the child is dead when he is not.

So again, where do you get 85% from? Or where do you get the repeated all capitals claim that Sylvia is right most of the time?

Was Sylvia's overall reading in the Shawn Hornbeck case accurate? Certainly not. Was it in anyway useful? Certainly not. Was it in fact damaging and wasteful? Certainly.

Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.
 
You have no idea what evidence is.

By the way:

Have you looked at what Lancaster said at the following posts?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...56#post2409856

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...95#post2410595

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...10#post2410610

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...49#post2410649

Will you then retract what you said about Lancaster directing the forum to spam GSB, and admit that you were lying/mistaken?
 
How silly of you. Browne had no idea how old Hornbeck's kidnapper was WHEN SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. He could have been murdered by one of his peers, for all she knew. The fact that Michael is a popular name (in '65 or whenever) is not enough, it's one of many popular names. AND FOR ALL OF YOU ASKING FOR EVIDENCE: SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. Larry King also confirms she got his appearance right.

Larry King is wrong. But you're ignoring all the evidence others have quoted to you about that, so forget that.

As for the age of the attacker: Michael has been number 1 or number 2 from 1954 to the present. It was number 1 from 1954 to 1998, with the exception of 1960. Violent sex offenders are usually under the age of 46 (the age a man named Michael born in 1954 would have been at the time of the abduction).

There is no question that the guess that the offender was named "Michael" is more likely to be correct by chance than ANY OTHER NAME. Period. If I were trying to guess the name and could only rely on chance "Michael" would be BY FAR the best choice. Micheal is even the most likely name for one of Shawn's peers!
 
In order to be considered someone who speaks English, you must know more than to be able to say you don't speak English well. That German man did not, as noted by Sylvia. Lancaster lied and claimed that he did, libeling Sylvia Browne.



I'll see your "as noted by Sylvia Browne" (and I'll just ignore all the other lies she told while she was noting it), and raise you a Randi Quote:


Robert: re the Bixby/Browne video, it should be said that I mixed with that section of our audience following the incident, and as far as I could tell, all of them spoke English quite well – as did the German tourist, who was just confused by what Browne was saying/asking him, a not unlikely situation. The tourist even asked Bixby and me for our autographs...

James Randi.


You ignored this quote once before. Will you explain why we should give more credit to SB's opinion of the man's English skills, than we do to Randi's opinion? Particularly in light of SB's other lies on the subject?
 
I just watched the video again, and my take on it, although I don't know what the German guy said that the transcript showed as [unintelligible], is that the man was ironically saying he didn't understand SB's gibberish that preceded his statement; i.e., he was having a little laugh at her.

That's what I thought, that he was saying "I don't understand [what the heck you are on about]" rather than "I don't understand [the English language]. I thought the [unintelligible] word might be German, but the only German words passed down from my German great-grandparents are swear words. It doesn't sound like one of those words.

Of course, regardless of the man's ability to speak English, it doesn't justify Sylvia's statement that the whole audience spoke German, when several people were shown to be speaking perfectly good English.
 
The ignorant passer-bys have already made their way to this discussion and are actively participating in it. The type of people who visit this forum are people-hating, religion-hating, humanity-hating, belief-hating nihilists. I do not care if I impress these sickos.



This from the man who was earlier whining about being attacked.


What is it with woos and their thin skin/vicious attacks methodology?
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.

Argumentum ad numerum. At one time millions believed the earth was the center of the universe. It didn't make it right, though.

Try again.
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.

1) Her success as we've shown is approx 0%. Guessing one name correctly out of all the crap she's spewed is hardly anything to get excited about.
2) Millions of people supporting her is only evidence of the number of deluded/fooled people.

Please provide an example of 1 reading where she was substantially correct. We are still waiting.
 
You have no idea what evidence is.

By the way:

Have you looked at what Lancaster said at the following posts?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...56#post2409856

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...95#post2410595

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...10#post2410610

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.p...49#post2410649

Will you then retract what you said about Lancaster directing the forum to spam GSB, and admit that you were lying/mistaken?

Note how he says 'for the record'. Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys. You guys are a very close community, and it would be easy for him to direct people to spam the guestbook. He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.
 
Note how he says 'for the record'. Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys. You guys are a very close community, and it would be easy for him to direct people to spam the guestbook. He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.

Please provide evidence that he has done so.
 
Mr. King is sharp as a knife, and one of the top journalists in broadcasting today.
I simply have to respond to this. I can't speak to Mr. King's level of intelligence, but I can say that he is an awful interviewer. Simply atrocious. King's almost complete lack of interviewing skill is made even more apparent when you watch folks who can conduct good, strong interviews. Folks like, say, Charlie Rose or Tim Russert.

How Larry King became this supposed paragon of interviewing prowess is beyond me.
 
Note how he says 'for the record'. Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys. You guys are a very close community, and it would be easy for him to direct people to spam the guestbook. He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.

You take the fact that RSL told people not to spam the GSB site as evidence that he did ask people to spam the site?
That is both a libelous and paranoid claim. Perhaps you could provide some evidence?
 
I simply have to respond to this. I can't speak to Mr. King's level of intelligence, but I can say that he is an awful interviewer. Simply atrocious. King's almost complete lack of interviewing skill is made even more apparent when you watch folks who can conduct good, strong interviews. Folks like, say, Charlie Rose or Tim Russert.

How Larry King became this supposed paragon of interviewing prowess is beyond me.

I liked how he didn't know the difference between ESPN and ESP. HI-larious.
 
Note how he says 'for the record'. Lancaster publicly denied that he is directing people to spam GSB because he knows that he may be being watched by Browne's attorneys. You guys are a very close community, and it would be easy for him to direct people to spam the guestbook. He has every desire to try and make the webmaster's life miserable.

W00t, he spins a conspiracy theory.
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.

If a million people say a foolish thing, it is still a foolish thing.
Anatole France

Also see logical fallacies: Appeal to Popularity
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.

I am sorry, but that is just Propoganda that Sylvia and her team spew out.

How many people are members of her "church", Novus Spiritus? Not millions.

How many people have had inaccurate readings? A lot.

How many people have had accurate readings? She won't say.

I can do cold readings and hit names right, and maybe she did pick that up by intuition, but when you look at her history, look at how her "church" was funded upon a felonious fraud, look at how she treats her staff, her ministers, her fans, look at the enormous wealth she has garnered while publicly claiming that all of her money goes to support a "church" that she doesn't, when you look at the lies that she tells over and over, it can't get any clearer that that.

James Randi was at the show where the German man was, and he stated that he spoke to him, he had conversational English, so get over that part, because everything else was a failure, and the entire audience was not Germanic.

Again, I ask the same questions I did before. What is your experiences/connections with Sylvia, along with the other questions.
 
Sylvia does not have a 100% success rate, obviously. She gets things wrong, all psychics do. That is the exception, most of the time she is right. Evidence? She got his name right. Evidence? Millions of people support her, including those who have had personal predictions done for them. It's like that old song, fifty million Frenchmen (Sylvia Browne fans) can't be wrong.

Yes, she had the first name right, BUT what about the most important fact of all? Shawn was ALIVE, not DEAD.

BTW, I am a faithful Catholic and spend 60+ hours a week working on a humanitarian cause/nonprofit agency with no monetary compensation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom