Stop Robert Lancaster, Slanderer of Sylvia Browne

In order to be considered someone who speaks English, you must know more than to be able to say you don't speak English well. That German man did not, as noted by Sylvia. Lancaster lied and claimed that he did, libeling Sylvia Browne.

He spoke words in English. Therefore, he speaks English. Robert did not declare that he spoke English fluently. Get it?

Now. Did Sylvia state that everybody in the audience spoke German? Yes or no?
 
1. It is not the policy of the JREF to delete posts? You're right. They have plenty of other ways to stifle truth and spread lies and misinformation (I read Randi's weekly column, his intellectual dishonesty astounds me).

I thought you were only here to discuss RSLancaster's site, not that of the JREF or Randi's column? Of course, I do not expect honesty from you...you have already proven that it is not your strong point.

2. You know the statement that you made about the German person who allegedly spoke English is false. Liar.

Actually, a great deal of evidence has been presented to precisely the contrary. Liar. See how that works?

3. You have delibrately ignored any evidence to support Sylvia. Why don't you post some of the posts from GoSylviaBrowne.com about how much Sylvia has helped people? You only post negative things. Obviously I can't prove you have ignored things, but it's a logical deduction.

If you have evidence that supports Sylvia, send it to him. If he ignores it, then you know that he has deliberately ignored it.

By the way, the plural of "anecdote" is not "evidence". Just to deal with that issue in advance. Robert has graciously provided many legally reproduced video clips that demonstrate negative things about Sylvia - if her supporters are not able to provide similar evidence that supports her, that is certainly not the fault of the Stop Sylvia Browne web site.

4. King stated that the description was accurate. SYLVIA GOT MICHAEL DEVLIN BY HIS FIRST NAME. The chances of that happening are very slim (ever picked up a baby name book, Mr. Lancaster?)

Ever studied demographics? Michael is an extremely common man's name. In my last university course, a class of 20 students had no less than 3 men named Michael in it. As guesses go, it's a fairly safe one.

Maybe the problem is with my math. We know that Sylvia got 1 prediction out of 6 correct with regards to her description of the abductor. Can a forum mathematician confirm if that is an 85% success rate?

5. You distorted the Shawn Hornbeck reading in your analysis.

You have failed to provide evidence of where it was distorted. Until you do so, this claim can be disregarded.

6. Your hateful and disdainful attitude is evident in everything you say and do. You are an extremist and radical skeptic who hates and despises anyone who disagrees with him as evidenced by your appearance on Anderson Cooper 360.

Didn't Sylvia Browne's business manager appear on AC360 also? Does that made her an extremist and radical skeptic who hates and despises anyone who disagrees with her?

Can you provide any evidence that he holds this attitude which you slanderously assign to him? NB: dishonestly pruned and presented quotes don't count. Unlike certain other forums, members of this site actually follow up on quotes to verify that they are accurate.

7. The fact that Heather Brown has not posted evidence does not make it true. She probably has bigger fish to fry than to respond to your every desire for evidence.

Bigger fish to fry than the one whom she started an entire web site to fry? How odd...I'm quite certain that you didn't think this point through properly, especially given that she did present evidence that he treated her fairly and politely.

8. You are a liar. You coaxed Dufresne into making a false statement WHICH YOU LATER ADMITTED TURNED OUT, at least partially, FALSE.

Somebody here is a liar, but it is not Robert. He has been extremely open about all of his articles, including when an inaccuracy like that crops up. See how that works? He notices an error, and he corrects it - and not only that, he admits to correcting it. That's called honesty.

9. Where are all the skeptics coming from on the guestbook then? They go there because you told them to go there here on the JREF forum.

Given that you have been provided evidence that he specifically told people not to harass that site, this statement is nothing short of a blatant falsehood. I find it odd that you criticize Robert for alleged lies while consistently lying yourself.

10. You can indeed sign up a site for spam, google 'mugu guymen'.

So you've proven that you know how to spam a site. We've also seen clear evidence that you actively engage in deception and lies. How do we know it wasn't you that signed her site up for spam?

11. I am not joking or parodying anyone. I am completely serious. I admit that I went too far by bringing up Mrs. Demille because I have not read your articles on her.

You'll have to forgive people if they think you are parodying. One of the interesting facets of the internet is that such a diverse array of opinions are presented that you will find people defending positions so utterly absurd and so badly that their defense is essentially indistinguishable from parody.

I don't believe that your posts fall into that category. I believe you are honestly supportive of Browne, and have simply put on a heavy pair of rose tinted lenses to filter out the facts that are presented to you.

12. I know about fair use, and you are stretching it to the breaking point, far beyond a defensible position.

Really? Several lawyers disagree with you - including Sylvia Browne's own lawyers, who have failed to pursue the case after being informed that the site does conform to fair use policies. If you have evidence to the contrary, I'm certain that Sylvia's lawyers would absolutely love to pursue the matter further. In absence of such evidence, however, this seems to be yet another distortion/misrepresentation/lie from you.
 
4. King stated that the description was accurate. SYLVIA GOT MICHAEL DEVLIN BY HIS FIRST NAME. The chances of that happening are very slim (ever picked up a baby name book, Mr. Lancaster?)

Have you? Here's my google result:
http://names.mongabay.com/baby_names/1965.html

It says the most common name for 1965 (the year Devlin was born) was Michael. If that's a slim chance, it's the fattest slim chance possible. Any other name whatsoever would have had a slimmer chance of being right.
 
SylviaRox, please point out the incorrect information on RSL's website so that he can glady correct it.

Also, please provide us with with evidence that supports Sylvia so that we can stop ignoring it.

When you answer, it may help you to know that in general people consider lying to be morally wrong.

Sooooo.... when does accusing someone of slander become slander in and of itself? Those laws are so confusing.
 
1. It is not the policy of the JREF to delete posts? You're right. They have plenty of other ways to stifle truth and spread lies and misinformation (I read Randi's weekly column, his intellectual dishonesty astounds me).
Name one! You're a liar.

3. You have delibrately ignored any evidence to support Sylvia. Why don't you post some of the posts from GoSylviaBrowne.com about how much Sylvia has helped people? You only post negative things. Obviously I can't prove you have ignored things, but it's a logical deduction.
What evidence? Larry King thinks Sylvia was right? That's not evidence that she was right. Sylvia is on Montel every week and people buy her books? That is not evidence that she is right.
4. King stated that the description was accurate. SYLVIA GOT MICHAEL DEVLIN BY HIS FIRST NAME. The chances of that happening are very slim (ever picked up a baby name book, Mr. Lancaster?)
I suggest you learn something about probability. Sylvia spews out a great many names in her readings. How many do you think should be right by pure chance alone? Also, the real claim is that she is helping people. Was the name "Michael" or her overall reading in the Shawn Hornbeck case helpful in any way whatsoever? Didn't it actually just cause wasted effort looking for a body (of a son that is still alive) and uneccessary emotional suffering?

5. You distorted the Shawn Hornbeck reading in your analysis.

How so? Most of his analysis was based on direct quotes from the transcript of this reading. Name one distortion from either of the two pages on Robert's site on the Shawn Hornbeck case. (Or any other page on his site, for that matter.)

You seem to confuse making wild assertions with providing evidence or making arguments.
12. I know about fair use, and you are stretching it to the breaking point, far beyond a defensible position.
You're completely wrong.

Speaking of legal matters, I challenge you to make these same accusations in a non-anonymous way to Robert. Maybe then you'll learn about libel and slander.
 
Have you? Here's my google result:
http://names.mongabay.com/baby_names/1965.html

It says the most common name for 1965 (the year Devlin was born) was Michael. If that's a slim chance, it's the fattest slim chance possible. Any other name whatsoever would have had a slimmer chance of being right.

How silly of you. Browne had no idea how old Hornbeck's kidnapper was WHEN SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. He could have been murdered by one of his peers, for all she knew. The fact that Michael is a popular name (in '65 or whenever) is not enough, it's one of many popular names. AND FOR ALL OF YOU ASKING FOR EVIDENCE: SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. Larry King also confirms she got his appearance right.
 
The ignorant passer-bys have already made their way to this discussion and are actively participating in it. The type of people who visit this forum are people-hating, religion-hating, humanity-hating, belief-hating nihilists. I do not care if I impress these sickos.


Ok, must jump in here.

The type of people who visit this forum are not people-hating, religion-hating, humanity-hating, belief-hating nihilists. There are Novus people here, both past and present, there are a range of ministers here, and people of all different faiths here.

I must ask you what your connection, or experience with Sylvia Browne is?

Have you ever met her, other than sitting in a croweded lecture hall? Have you spent any time one on one with her? Do you even know who you are talking about, or are you just going off of what you think you read in her books and see on Montel?

Many of us on this site know Sylvia, know her people, and can verify every single thing that Lancaster has put on his site, and would be able to stand up in a court of law and do so under oath.

Are you a member of Novus Spiritus? Are you a member of a Study Group? What are you basing your accusations on?

You have come in here and attacked a person who has presented fact based information, and that information can not even be refuted by Sylvia Browne or her staff. She is left with saying "Dark is posting on blogs" because even she knows that this TRUTH keeps coming out.

I have seen the true Sylvia in action. I have heard her lies, heard how she and her people talk about her fans, know how her operation is run, and you really need to investigate more before you make baseless claims.

If you follow the Philosophy of Novus Spiritus, or any form of Gnosticism, then you should know that Gnostics are skeptical by nature, and typically take nothing as fact until it is verified and proven so. Yet, your great "spiritual leader", who is neither, demands complete devotion to her thoughts, her message, her books, her limited view, and casts aside any who question.

I can't tell if you are for real, a rabid fan, or a jokester, but I can tell you that you have no idea what you are trying to defend, and doing poorly while at it.
 
Speaking of legal matters, I challenge you to make these same accusations in a non-anonymous way to Robert. Maybe then you'll learn about libel and slander.

As much as it pains me to do so, I have to defend Rox. In his OP, he gives his name, so is not attacking anonymously.
 
Everyone agrees she got the name right.

Now.

Is Michael Devlin Hispanic?
Does he have long hair?
Worn in dreadlocks?
Did he drive a 1950's car with fins?
Was he tall like a basketball player?

One correct answer. SIX (including the death of Shawn Hornbeck himself) WRONG!
 
Oh please. All you 'skeptics' have done so far is personally attack me and harp on this 85% success rate issue, which has nothing to do with this thread.

You brought it up.

Also, in your original post you said that Gosylviabrowne is a fan site.
You do realize that Heather Brown is hardly just a fan, right? You are aware she admitted on her site she is Chris Dufresne's girlfriend.
 
4. King stated that the description was accurate. SYLVIA GOT MICHAEL DEVLIN BY HIS FIRST NAME. The chances of that happening are very slim (ever picked up a baby name book, Mr. Lancaster?)
Okay let's put Michael to Rest. According to this government site http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/babynames/ in the fifty year span, 1950-1999, the male name "Michael" has never been lower than the fourth most popular for male babies. For 44, yes 44, of those years it was the number one choice for naming male babies. If I were going to give the name of a male I strongly suspect to be born in the USA it would have to be Michael.
 
Last edited:
How silly of you. Browne had no idea how old Hornbeck's kidnapper was WHEN SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. He could have been murdered by one of his peers, for all she knew. The fact that Michael is a popular name (in '65 or whenever) is not enough, it's one of many popular names. AND FOR ALL OF YOU ASKING FOR EVIDENCE: SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. Larry King also confirms she got his appearance right.

1960: 2nd place
1965: 1st place
1970: 1st place
1975: 1st place
1980: 1st place
1985: 1st place
1990: 1st place
1995: 1st place
2000: 2nd place

How did Silvia describe the bad guy?
 
How silly of you. Browne had no idea how old Hornbeck's kidnapper was WHEN SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. He could have been murdered by one of his peers, for all she knew. The fact that Michael is a popular name (in '65 or whenever) is not enough, it's one of many popular names. AND FOR ALL OF YOU ASKING FOR EVIDENCE: SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. Larry King also confirms she got his appearance right.

Standard cold reading trick is to pick common names... and where has Michael been ranked over recent history?

We'll start with 1950, as being < 60 years old or so is a reasonable assumption for this kind of thing.

1950 - 4th
1955 - 1st
1960 - 2nd
1965 - 1st
1970 - 1st
1975 - 1st
1980 - 1st
1985 - 1st
1990 - 1st
1995 - 1st
2000 - 2nd
2005 - 2nd

Wow, Michael is pretty popular. If I was guessing a name, Michael would be a good pick.

ETA: dang, too slow.
 
12. I know about fair use, and you are stretching it to the breaking point, far beyond a defensible position.


Once again, please provide specific examples of Robert's conduct and why you believe it is indefensibly a violation of copyright. Also, please explain which state's laws you are relying on, if not federal, and why. Please remember that I am a lawyer. I believe his actions are defensible and I am prepared to defend them from your attack.

I hate to ruin the suspense, but SR will never directly reply to this post.
 
I think it's ironic...
The Five Stage of Death (of a Brownie):
Denial
Anger
Bargaining
Depression
Acceptance

Sylvia Rox, there are many of us here who can help you get through these stages easier and without making such a ruckus.
We know...we've been there and we are recovering quite nicely without becoming crazed.

Robert Lancaster is one of the most genuinely phenominal human beings I've met through this whole crazy ride I've been on since realizing what an atrocious woman Sylvia turned out to be.
I spread "her" concept for a decade always skeptical but it took Robert and this nice group to help me see through the darkness.

You've come to the right place. Just calm down and breathe!!

Is it me or is it ironic that my search of the Larry King Live Transcript Archives shows that Sylvia has not been on Larry King since 2003 and that on January 19, 2007 when Shawn Hornbeck's parents were on Larry King Live, he was followed by the Anderson Cooper investigation into how Sylvia gave his parents horribly wrong information?
 
How silly of you. Browne had no idea how old Hornbeck's kidnapper was WHEN SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. He could have been murdered by one of his peers, for all she knew. The fact that Michael is a popular name (in '65 or whenever) is not enough, it's one of many popular names. AND FOR ALL OF YOU ASKING FOR EVIDENCE: SHE GOT HIS NAME RIGHT. Larry King also confirms she got his appearance right.

She got his first name right--sort of. (Remember, she thought she was talking about a murderer--so pretty much the whole reading is no good.)

Robert is willing to concede the first name. (I'm not--since the statement it was in was wrong.) Based on that, her success rate on the Shawn Hornbeck case, using Robert's summary table, is 1 right out of 13 attempts which is a 7.7% hit rate. We could remove the 4 unknowns and make it 1 out of 9 which brings it all the way up to 11.1%. This assumes that having a first name is of equal value to thinking the child is dead when he is not.

So again, where do you get 85% from? Or where do you get the repeated all capitals claim that Sylvia is right most of the time?

Was Sylvia's overall reading in the Shawn Hornbeck case accurate? Certainly not. Was it in anyway useful? Certainly not. Was it in fact damaging and wasteful? Certainly.
 
I have already indicated to you that I am not here to defend Sylvia Browne's track record. I am here to show that Mr. Lancaster has lied about it.
But they are very much part and parcel of the same thing. To show Mr. Lancaster has lied, you must provide evidence that the truth is something other than what he has said.* And that evidence is what we are asking you to provide.

Please refer to my comments regarding Mr. Lancaster's deliberate lie about the German man in the Exploring clip being an English speaker as one example.
This obviously came down to semantics. The phrase "I can speak English" can mean at least three things:
1) I can make noises come out of my mouth that correspond to the noises of English words.
2) I understand English phrases and can have rudimentary conversations in English.
3) I am fluent in English.

Obviously the German man in the case in question falls under meaning #2 above, yet Sylvia is representing him as if the only real definition was #3. She is saying that since he wasn't perfectly fluent in English, he didn't understand a word she was saying. And that assessment is in conflict with the reality of the situation.

Mr. Lancaster, in regards to your extremism, I pull this very typical quote from your front page regarding Browne, calling her "a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved".
I'm sorry, you appear to have taken that out of context. The entire quote is:

"Is she a well-intentioned spiritual leader, with actual psychic powers? Is she a fraud, making money by callously manipulating and using the bereaved? Or is she something else entirely?"
​

He is not calling her anything. He is asking three questions. You might as well claim that he is calling her "a well-intentioned spiritual leader, with actual psychic powers". Don't be disheartened by this misunderstanding; people like Sylvia depend on people misinterpreting questions and opinions as statements of fact.

As your research into StopSylviaBrowne.com to find factual errors continues, your knowledge of what evidence and facts look like will increase. This is a good thing, and will only lead to both the site, and yourself, improving.

-----

[*] That, and evidence that Mr. Lancaster knew the truth was other than what he said, of course.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom