So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sorry CM, but that's definitely not the direction the discussion took once RW replied to RD.

Once again, I've only been talking her first video. RD (or someone else) eventually turned it into a row over "feminism", but it didn't start that way. It started out as a very simple personal request.
 
I haven't had a significant opinion on any of this, but something has really been bothering me about this debacle.

Rebecca's encounter was unfortunate and distressing, I don't deny it and I am sorry she had had to deal with that. Dawkins pretty much brushed off her point about how men should avoid doing that. . .and so on.

Here's what bothers me. She specifically called Dawkins out as not knowing what the heck he's talking about because he's too rich, white, and male to have an opinion.

Full stop.

Dawkins was sexually assaulted as a child. He did experience the kind of horrible sexual abuse that Rebecca Watson feared.
 
LoL! That's true. But sometimes people are not free to act that way. Unless the "old dude" was a good friend of your family and you had both taken care to let your parents know you were both taking a break from the party and going for a walk -- its likely that people would have assumed the worse and "old dude" would have gotten a bad reputation.

Your innuendo vocabulary probably got expanded that day and considering that we have to be able to fit in and understand the communities we live in, that's a good thing.

Oh yeah going for a walk with me would not have been the correct move for him. But I was not flurting with him lol so I was so lost at the time what he was talking about.
 
Once again, I've only been talking her first video. RD (or someone else) eventually turned it into a row over "feminism", but it didn't start that way. It started out as a very simple personal request.

I'm pretty sure PZ and RW followers turned it into a big feminism deal way before RD got involved, and I'm pretty sure RD was responding to that. It was a request, but she also said the guy sexualized her, and it was in the context of her misogyny talk. In context it wasn't just asking guys not to do that. That's why people got worked up over it.
 
I dislike any claim that involves the phrase "You can't possibly understand, because you're not a ___."

I may not be a ___, but I'm not stupid and I'm not entirely lacking in empathy. If your claim is valid and true, I imagine you should be able to persuade me.
 
Based on reading all the blogs and actually interviewing Elevator "Guy" via Skype, I have created a forensic animation reconstructing what really happened.
 
Dawkins was sexually assaulted as a child. He did experience the kind of horrible sexual abuse that Rebecca Watson feared.

I didn't know this about Dawkins until earlier today, which isn't surprising as I've never read any of his material. It does put another interesting perspective on his reaction though. To someone who has actually been sexually assaulted, complaining about how being hit on in an elevator, plainly no less, being sexualization and objectification, is flat out insulting. Let's not go too overboard the way Dawkins did however; someone always has it worse so that's no reason to completely dismiss a complaint. I remember in college people sitting around talking about the abuse they went through, always starting the next sentence with, "That's nothing, listen to this..." as if it were a contest to see who hurt the worst.

In that light, it isn't surprising that it would push his button so, or that he would remain relatively silent after. This isn't to excuse his tone or dismissive manner, or the other flaws in reasoning.
 
That wasn't exactly the issue. RW said, "what I was saying on the panel" and we don't know he saw or listened to the panel.

Right. We don't know for sure. All we have is Watson's claim, "except for the one man who didn’t really grasp, I think, what I was saying on the panel." If he hadn't seen the panel, then "grasp" would seem to be a funny word for a native speaker of English to use. I don't "grasp" the conversations in the house next door, but that's because I wasn't there and didn't hear them.

In addition RW said, "after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner.." but another member in the bar conversation didn't mention the discussion was about RW's being sexualized.

Nor is it clear to me, from looking at the video, that this is really what her presentation was about.

Now, of course, I can and have missed things. It is entirely possible that Watson wrote something later that clarifies it, but I've found it difficult to keep track. Without such clarification, though, the anecdote seems, at best, highly ambiguous.

So some of us were just questioning RW's assumption that EG paid any attention to her panel discussion or heard her talk about not wanting to be "sexualized in that manner". In addition, even if he had heard the relevant content, he may not have perceived his relatively polite request to be "sexualizing" her.

Quite true. By the same token, it is possible to question many, many other assumptions that are being made.

I did make an error in my statement, however. I failed to quote the statement by @bookitty that I was thinking about. Here it is:

I decree and am able to fully enforce a new rule - No one is allowed to proposition anyone without first introducing themselves and taking five whole minutes to explore mutual interests outside potential sexual availability. Yes, this rule is extremely fascist but I am queen of the whole friggin world and that is my law.

What if he did take "five whole minutes" exploring mutual interests outside potential sexual availability? Or more? We don't know that he did, and we don't know that he didn't. Somebody, obviously, does know, but that information isn't generally available.

The only source of information (since EG hasn't responded to the best of my knowledge) is Watson, and as far as I can tell, she hasn't made it clear.

He could have seen the panel or not. He could have participated in the bar discussion anywhere from not at all to just listening to getting a few words in edgewise to fairly elaborate communication. He could have deliberately followed her to the elevator or just left at the same time because the bar was no longer interesting, or for some reason. He could have deliberately been looking for some conference nookie or not. He could have been straight, gay, bisexual, or pansexual. I don't know, and I don't think that most of the participants in this thread know.

The strong impression I get is that people are just making assumptions in wildly divergent directions and, in many cases, simply projecting their own personal experiences or political opinions onto an event without any real evidence that they are even similar.
 
Once again, I've only been talking her first video. RD (or someone else) eventually turned it into a row over "feminism", but it didn't start that way. It started out as a very simple personal request.
I think RW contributed more than a token amount to making this about feminism. She felt this simple come on was objectifying her. RD tried to say the complaint was bigger than the crime.
 
Last edited:
I haven't had a significant opinion on any of this, but something has really been bothering me about this debacle.

Rebecca's encounter was unfortunate and distressing, I don't deny it and I am sorry she had had to deal with that. Dawkins pretty much brushed off her point about how men should avoid doing that. . .and so on.

Here's what bothers me. She specifically called Dawkins out as not knowing what the heck he's talking about because he's too rich, white, and male to have an opinion.

Full stop.

Dawkins was sexually assaulted as a child. He did experience the kind of horrible sexual abuse that Rebecca Watson feared.
Interesting.
 
Dawkins was sexually assaulted as a child. He did experience the kind of horrible sexual abuse that Rebecca Watson feared.

This one?

Happily I was spared the misfortune of a Roman Catholic upbringing (Anglicanism is a significantly less noxious strain of the virus). Being fondled by the Latin master in the Squash Court was a disagreeable sensation for a nine-year-old, a mixture of embarrassment and skin-crawling revulsion, but it was certainly not in the same league as being led to believe that I, or someone I knew, might go to everlasting fire. As soon as I could wriggle off his knee, I ran to tell my friends and we had a good laugh, our fellowship enhanced by the shared experience of the same sad pedophile. I do not believe that I, or they, suffered lasting, or even temporary damage from this disagreeable physical abuse of power. Given the Latin Master's eventual suicide, maybe the damage was all on his side.
 
I think RW contributed more than a token amount to making this about feminism. She felt this simple come on was objectifying her. RD tried to say the complaint was bigger than the crime.

But her initial "complaint" was hardly a cry of rape and oppression. How can a calm "please don't do that" be considered an overreaction to anything?
 
It does put another interesting perspective on his reaction though. To someone who has actually been sexually assaulted, complaining about how being hit on in an elevator, plainly no less, being sexualization and objectification, is flat out insulting.

I don't think that's it.
 

As an aside:

"8. A black person and a white person in the elevator is not analogous to my situation, unless you’re talking about a strange white person following a black person onto an elevator and then inviting him/her to his/her hotel room for fried chicken. In that instance, yes, I do believe that the black person is well within his/her rights to politely ask the privileged white majority of skeptics/atheists to not do that."

Hmmm....
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom