So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Been busy and away the last few weeks and came back to this thread and have only just managed to work my way through it. I doubt there is much to add that hasn't been said but why should that stop me adding my 2p worth?

For the record, my comments:

On EG: On the face of it, taking the information as presented to me doesn't seem to have done very much if anything wrong. Of course the devil is in the detail and there are multiple ways the situation could have occured that would have seen him at fault. In the absence of evidence though I'm going to have to afford him the benefit of the doubt.

On RW: Never heard of her before this and have no real desire to hear much more about her in the future if this is the level of her contribution. I'm still unclear exactly what her issue was as she seems to have conflated feeling uncomfortable, feeling threatened and being sexualised in one complaint.

For the record, the pedant in me also feels compelled to point out that her rape threat didn't actually contain a rape threat though that's neither here nor there in this discussion.

She comes across to me as a bit self-obsessed and attention seeking.

Her follow ups to me suggest that her main emotion here was not fear, or being creeped out but rather annoyance that 1) someone had the temerity to not treat her in the way she wanted to be treated and 2) that others would question her right to throw a minor hissy fit in response to 1.

On RD: I agree with the intent of his message though it was probably a bit of an unfortunate artistic choice to express it the way he did. Its one of those responses that triggers 'oh my God he's saying something bad' reactions in people even if they can't quite put the finger on what or where the bad thing is. There was some quite subtle goal-post shifting to somehow work this into a sense that RD was doing more than telling RW to get over herself but was actually attacking women.

On any of the 4 million blogs following the event: it's just amazing how people can pick up and run with something so insignificant and mould it to suit whatever agenda they want to push.

On the positive side, the one person who comes out of this with improved credibility (at least for me) is our very own fls who I think has shown a level-headed response in this thread.

2p-worth endeth here.
 
Talking to a woman in a public space is okay unless she asks you to leave her alone right?

Depends on what you mean by "talking" and "okay." I'm sure you can think for a moment about things you could say to a woman in public that would be "okay" and those that wouldn't.

Let me use an example. I completely loathe the Wesboro Baptist church with every fiber of my being. They disgust me more than just about anything else I've witnessed. Yet I will say they have the freedom of speech to say the stupid things they say in public, no matter whose feelings they hurt.

Yes, and we will say to them, "Wesboro guys, don't protest at a sevicemember's funeral. It's really an awful thing to do." I would think everyone sees this as a valid request.

When they go ahead and protest, we call them ********. Freedom of speech is not the same as freedom from criticism.

Freedom of speech comes with the guarantee of being able to speak your mind even if it offends or hurts people's feelings. It only becomes harrassment or assault if it is in someone's face, with aggravation, or if they've said no and you ignore their request.

Freedom of speech also comes with the possibility that someone will notice that what you say makes you an *******.

Bookitty you come off as presuming to tell men that they should already know that a woman in an elevator doesn't want to be asked to have coffee and conversation. Explain to me how that isn't civil.

It's been explained roughly 45,000 times on this thread, but I notice that you, like all the other people that have been attempting to defend EG guy, have to shave away all the relevant facts to make it look like nothing more than a polite encounter. That this ridiculous approach is still being used almost 50 pages into the thread shows 1) how useless it is to defend EG. There are about 3 silly things you can say, which is why we get the same nonsense over and over, and 2) absolutely no one will change their mind on this.

We've already seen that not all women would take offense to that. Sure some would, but you're asking men to assume they would be offended and not even bother trying or risk public ridicule and embarrassment (which is real harm by the way).

Yeah, we have a word from someone who chooses to make another person feel uncomfortable rather than take a personal risk: coward.

But what an idiotic canard. Does he have to tap his wine glass, quiet the people in the bar, and say, "Rebecca Watson, come back to my room for coffee?"

Or can he, like 99% of people in the world, talk to her in the bar. If she likes him, their conversation will lead to an intimate moment, even in the midst of all those people.

If you can't do it that way, the lurking around until she's alone will have a very, very low success rate, anyway, and makes you really creepy.

So take a minute and think about what you're saying, instead of jumping to straw-men and hyperbole and emotional pleas. We're skeptics right? I'm trying to bring rational dissent with my concerns.

Well, maybe you have a different meaning of "rational" than I'm familiar with. You're just repeating the same misguided nonsense that's been bubbling up for 50 pages.

I'm not doing this to create an argument. My goal is that we can have discourse and come to a rational conclusion. I don't see your conclusions as rational, and you haven't provided me with any evidence on why I should.

What sort of evidence do you want?

We can talk about make believe hypothetical situations all day, while you dismiss real situations that counter your made up stuff, but we've been running in the same circle for pages now and you're accusing us of not getting it. Show me the facts on why I'm wrong. I'm receptive to facts and not subjective feeling.

Again, what sort of facts do you want? We can over all the facts of this particular situation you've ignored, we can talk about the horrifying abuse statistics that made Rebecca Watson's apprehension very legitimate, what do you want to see?
 
Last edited:
I read the first ten pages or so as they were written, then stepped away from the thread and have now read the last two. Like others on this thread I find the few possibilities for rational discussion buried in the avalanche of emotion, hyperbole, and irrationality.

For the record, I find that fls is the person with whom I am most in agreement in this thread, and like her I find that the missed opportunity to actually discuss the broader topics of underrepresentation of women at skeptic events and of sexism in the skeptic community is sad.

Along those lines I am interested in the recently announced guidelines for the current TAM, specifically this bit:

Please respect your fellow attendees by not disparaging them based on unfair grounds such as race, gender, sexual orientation, and disability; and by not making uninvited sexual comments toward others.

This seems to me to unreasonably prescribe one of two alternatives:

1. No sex between TAM attendees at all

or

2. Those willing to have sex must advertise it in some way and wait to be asked for it by those who see the advertisement. Perhaps a special nametag? Hi, I'm Garrette, and you can ask me for sex even though I might say no.
 
This seems to me to unreasonably prescribe one of two alternatives:

1. No sex between TAM attendees at all

or

2. Those willing to have sex must advertise it in some way and wait to be asked for it by those who see the advertisement. Perhaps a special nametag? Hi, I'm Garrette, and you can ask me for sex even though I might say no.

I have no idea how you would get around the issue of 'uninvited' sexual comments since inviting someone to make a sexual comment is of itself an uninvited sexual comment.

I think I know what they mean which is basically 'exercise common sense in interacting with people and don't go out of your way to be annoying or unpleasant' How on Earth did we all ever get along before that had to be spelled out in proscriptive memoranda?
 
I have no idea how you would get around the issue of 'uninvited' sexual comments since inviting someone to make a sexual comment is of itself an uninvited sexual comment.

I think I know what they mean which is basically 'exercise common sense in interacting with people and don't go out of your way to be annoying or unpleasant' How on Earth did we all ever get along before that had to be spelled out in proscriptive memoranda?
Those are pretty much my thoughts, and I think it actually encapsulates what most people are trying to say on this thread.

We know in general how to behave, so behave that way.

There are at least two negative consequences of this. First, there will be times when someone crosses an unclear line and makes someone else uncomfortable or frightened without that being the intent. Second, there will be times when someone will not make a pass for fear of a negative reaction when in fact the pass was wanted.

As I don't see a perfect world in which passes will only occur in exactly the right time and place, I don't see either of the above consequences as something to be feared.
 
<snip>

Again, what sort of facts do you want? We can over all the facts of this particular situation you've ignored, we can talk about the horrifying abuse statistics that made Rebecca Watson's apprehension very legitimate, what do you want to see?

Please present them. I'm pretty sure stranger rape is much less common than acquaintance or partner rape, and that rapists more often pick up their victims in bars and clubs after chatting to them than inviting them out of the blue back to their hotel rooms under the pretense of wanting coffee and conversation.
 
No, it wasn't. However, she's written more since then.

http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/

You're joining my argument in the middle, and thus without context. Richard Dawkins' comment that Watson was overreacting (or his support of others complaining that Watson was overreacting, whichever the case may be) was made after Watson's first video. Therefore, they can only have been referring to her first video as an overreaction. The "more she's written since then" didn't come until afterwards, and were responses not to the original incident but to those suggestions that asking strangers not to hit on her was "needless drama" or what have you.
 
Let me illustrate: Even if an attractive woman shows up in FMP, mini and tight top ( or a cute guy in tight-laced leather jeans and fishnet-shirt ) to a party you attend, and even if they behave as a complete cock tease there, they have no obligation to deliver on the teasing, and nobody is allowed to stalk or corner them, if they don't want to. It may sound mean, but that's how I learned it, and I actually think it is a better solution than ( to go to another extreme ) running around in burkhas to not accidentally incite passion.

I think we're about to reach a critical mass of straw, here.

The point is, this hypothetical woman you speak of might be respected, but she should expect people to look at her body, not her brain, because this is what she is showcasing. This was Ivor's point, I believe.
 
1. No sex between TAM attendees at all

or

2. Those willing to have sex must advertise it in some way and wait to be asked for it by those who see the advertisement. Perhaps a special nametag? Hi, I'm Garrette, and you can ask me for sex even though I might say no.

Three days without stranger-banging - outrageous!

I don't know how you manage to survive spending a full third of every weekday in a place where these guidelines aren't voluntarily imposed by your employers but actually mandated by law.
 
Been busy and away the last few weeks and came back to this thread and have only just managed to work my way through it. I doubt there is much to add that hasn't been said but why should that stop me adding my 2p worth?

For the record, my comments:

On EG: On the face of it, taking the information as presented to me doesn't seem to have done very much if anything wrong. Of course the devil is in the detail and there are multiple ways the situation could have occured that would have seen him at fault. In the absence of evidence though I'm going to have to afford him the benefit of the doubt.

On RW: Never heard of her before this and have no real desire to hear much more about her in the future if this is the level of her contribution. I'm still unclear exactly what her issue was as she seems to have conflated feeling uncomfortable, feeling threatened and being sexualised in one complaint.

For the record, the pedant in me also feels compelled to point out that her rape threat didn't actually contain a rape threat though that's neither here nor there in this discussion.

She comes across to me as a bit self-obsessed and attention seeking.

Her follow ups to me suggest that her main emotion here was not fear, or being creeped out but rather annoyance that 1) someone had the temerity to not treat her in the way she wanted to be treated and 2) that others would question her right to throw a minor hissy fit in response to 1.

On RD: I agree with the intent of his message though it was probably a bit of an unfortunate artistic choice to express it the way he did. Its one of those responses that triggers 'oh my God he's saying something bad' reactions in people even if they can't quite put the finger on what or where the bad thing is. There was some quite subtle goal-post shifting to somehow work this into a sense that RD was doing more than telling RW to get over herself but was actually attacking women.

On any of the 4 million blogs following the event: it's just amazing how people can pick up and run with something so insignificant and mould it to suit whatever agenda they want to push.

On the positive side, the one person who comes out of this with improved credibility (at least for me) is our very own fls who I think has shown a level-headed response in this thread.

2p-worth endeth here.

:bigclap
 
I have a few points I would like to address. First, the accusations against Bookitty for getting so emotional about this that she's lost the point. I feel terrible for watching it happen but as it was, I could only watch it after the fact, because my time for participating sporatic. What I saw, though, was Bookitty being quoted by numerous people who all seem to have similar but not identical points, each one pointing out what the real issue is and at times, just responding with pure hyperbole. Read back over just the last ten pages and see how many different point of views she was attempting to discuss. It would be difficult for anyone to maintain any level of consistency.

Now, one thing I noticed about RW, before she confessed to doing it herself is she rambles. She starts off with one point and then derails herself by going on side point, and never actually finishes her original point. On the panel, I saw her beginning to address the sexism she experiences at conventions and then moved onto the emails. The sexist , she explains, is when she wants to talk about women's reproductions rights, which does fall in the catagory of secularism; both men and women discuss this issue, in great detail, at our monthly atheists meetings; she gets negative responses from people she says, identify as skeptics/atheists who agree with her on other issues but roll their eyes when she brings up women's issues. The objectification, she explains, is the detailed sexually descriptive emails she gets. She uses misogyny, a lot. I don't always agree with her application, there is some level of misogyny present, at least in the responses to the video posted of the conference, but they are typically juvenile comments that offer zero to the discussion. I suspect they are just trolls trying to be funny/ironic/inflammatory. They are there though, ranging from Dawkins needs to rape Rebecca to, the three guys on the panel should gangbang Rebecca. Those issues came up first and claiming that the elevator incident is proof of that is a stretch, in logic, but I have not noticed her claiming such (though I will stand corrected if I am shown evidence).

She calls them [the responses] out, in her first blog after the incident. She says thanks for proving my point. Like it or not, they did. She says she gets nasty comments and people post nasty comments to that video, responding to her claim. Then, her second point gets proven, again. The elevator incident was not, IMHO, intended to be taken as a moral lesson. It was a short blurb of irony. So there I was, talking about getting hit on through emails when I am trying to be taken seriously, during the panel. I go back to the bar and hang out till four in the morning. I just finish talking about how being objectified makes me uncomfortable and this guy joins me in the elevator and invites me back to his room. It was a brief anecdote. She finishes with "...it makes me uncomfortable...don't do that..." and it has since evolved into Rebecca has single handedly outlawed casual sex.

She has since been called whiney, an attention whore, paranoid, and accused of attempting to speak for all women. Quite honestly, it's not a matter of who should feel threatened, anywhere. One person said that being hit on, at 4 am, in an elevator, isn't cool. How many places you've been or how many elevator encounters you have, adds nothing, nor takes anything away from how that incident makes RW feel.

No but the real issue is how is RW is assuming that he was hitting on her, it was just coffee, back in his hotel room. Coffee isn't code for sex. No, you are right, it isn't but "back to my room," tends to be. I agree and have maintained that it is ambiguous but I am not shocked that Rebecca took it the way she did, either.

On the other hand, had she gone and he raped her, in his hotel room, she would have been accused of engaging in risky behavior.
...but he just said coffee and talk.
...going back to a stranger's room is risky. This isn't blaming the victim but she put herself at risk by assuming his invitation was innocent, despite the fact that she didn't know him.
So without a blatent level of threat and the fact that he did turn out to be a non-threat, she is supposed to know in advance that he is a not threat. However, without a level of threat, should he turn out to be a threat, she should have known he was a threat. This attitude was evident through out the countless pages in the 11 year old gang raped, thread.

Oddly, though, the same people who claim that his invitation was just coffee and talk are also the same that feel that casual sex is somehow at risk. So how is this guy supposed to know if Rebecca was or was not down with casual sex, without asking?
For starter, casual sex is objectifying (from a purely neutral use of the term) a person. You are not interested in their wants and needs, who they are, where they've been, what they've experienced; you want sex. That's cool, we are sexual beings and sometimes following your most basic primal urge is hot, it's a good time and both parties willing, no one gets hurt. I have nothing against that. You are right, you wouldn't know unless you asked. Just throwing it out there but if your hope is for success, you might not want to start with the girl that just said that she doesn't like being objectified.

Now it's morphed into a First Amendment issue, a man's perrogative to hit on women. If I were a hypersensitive feminist, I would see that as blatent sexism but I will give you the benefit of the doubt and assume that what you really meant was an individual's perrogative to hit on another individual. Sorry but the alternative does kind of make us sound like life support systems for vaginas, waiting to be picked. To be fair, I am going to assume that it is just a poorly worded statement. After all, it's 2011, women hit on men, too. On that topic, however, I personally, from the bottom of my heart, would not want to live in a society with laws constructed regarding manners. With that freedom comes the knowledge that not I, or anyone else, has the right not to be offended. I am fully aware that I have to live with the risk that someday, someone might give me unwanted attention. With that same risk, I would like to feel that these same First Amendment rights also gives me the right to say, after the fact, "don't do that."

Oh you have that right, just don't run home and blog about such an unremarkabke event! Why not? Take a look at the community forum. It's riddled with stories that range from seemingly unremarkable but funny/ironic to the absolute absurd, I can't believe someone did that! My tale of my experience with a seedy car salesman was certainly not newsworthy. People commented and went about their lives and the thread died out, rather quickly. It was expected, the story wasn't that gripping. In all honesty, neither was the elevator incident. What made Rebecca's story explode into an internet phenomenon? I suspect because nerves were already raw because she cried sexism, first. Rather than opening a dialogue to see if there really is sexism within the community, people reacted by twisting the story into something completely unrecognizable from what it was at the start to prove that RW is just a whiney, paranoid, attention whore. It was, in fact, the reaction that turned this into what it is, yes?
 
Last edited:
Please present them. I'm pretty sure stranger rape is much less common than acquaintance or partner rape, and that rapists more often pick up their victims in bars and clubs after chatting to them than inviting them out of the blue back to their hotel rooms under the pretense of wanting coffee and conversation.

Only if you can provide the stats for rape in isolated environments with a strange man propositioning a woman.

If we're going to start modifying the stats with facts, we should probably include all of them.
 
Three days without stranger-banging - outrageous!
If that is the intent, then by all means have the new guidelines say so:

Rule 1: No sex between strangers at TAM.

Is that their intent?


Checkmite said:
I don't know how you manage to survive spending a full third of every weekday in a place where these guidelines aren't voluntarily imposed by your employers but actually mandated by law.
Let me understand you properly: Are you saying that you are in support of these restrictions at the workplace and conventions like TAM and nowhere else?

Or are you suggesting that these restrictions should obtain elsewhere? Say, perhaps, if I go to Vegas on my own, hear some people talking in a bar, follow one woman from the bar to an elevator, and then proposition her. Is that okay if I'm not a TAM attendee?
 
On any of the 4 million blogs following the event: it's just amazing how people can pick up and run with something so insignificant and mould it to suit whatever agenda they want to push.

That's funny, I was thinking the same thing about a three week debate sparked by a single woman who said, "Don't do that...it makes me uncomfortable." Sounds rather reasonable not much like a hissy fit. Ironic, though, isn't it?
 
I have no idea how you would get around the issue of 'uninvited' sexual comments since inviting someone to make a sexual comment is of itself an uninvited sexual comment.

But an invitation to make a comment (in general) isn't necessarily sexual. And so the following comment could then be both sexual, and invited.

This is when it's very important to have a wingman. Their role is to invite you to make a comment, at which point you're free to make a sexual comment to whomever you like.

Also, at the end of lectures/talks it's often the case that the attendees are invited to ask questions/make comments. This the opportunity for the entire audience to congratulate the hotel receptionist on her bazoombas.
 
Only if you can provide the stats for rape in isolated environments with a strange man propositioning a woman.

Isolated? It was a 5 star hotel with dozens if not hundreds of rooms!

How was this man supposed to get an unwilling woman from the elevator to his room without the risk of her screaming her head off and waking lots of people?

As a pick-up technique it was poor; as a strategy to commit rape it was abysmal.

If we're going to start modifying the stats with facts, we should probably include all of them.

http://www.911rape.org/campus-rape/what-students-need-to-know/stranger-rape-vs-acquaintance-rape

Rape by strangers and acquaintances

Most college students who are sexually assaulted are victimized by someone they know. Although stranger rapes occur, acquaintance rape is by far the most prevalent form of sexual violence among college students.In the "Rape in Amercia" study, 80% of the girls and women who were raped were assaulted by someone they knew. Similarly, in a report in "Violence Against Women" published by the Department of Justice, 82% of the victims were raped by someone they knew (acquaintance/friend, intimate, relative).

Seems like a better strategy would have been to gain her confidence and lower her defences by chatting to her in the bar and then suggested a private meeting later on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom