So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is a straw man. It seems like straw men are the only things you are debating here.

This is another straw man.

For review, a straw man is a fallacious argument in which an opponent's points are overstated or misrepresented in order to be attacked or refuted. It appears you are misinterpreting many of the opposing viewpoints in this discussion. Have you thought about perhaps re-reading a few posts to see if maybe you are misreading them in the first place? More than one person has told you now that you are misreading what's being said.

Sorry, you're just not all that good at the snark. Maybe try something else.

You lovely lady, you. ;)
 
No, I will not "Show you facts" because it would be a waste of time. Plus, freedom of speech! Mine.

You phrased the encounter as a zero-sum game. Either you win or she does. So you are not receptive to facts. Period.

Bookitty I presented you with my concerns, then you go on to insult me by saying I'm a waste of time.

You then made up something entirely which I never said or implied in the slightest.

How is it that you so consistently misconstrue everything everyone says to you? I'm starting to believe it's on purpose.
 
Bookitty I presented you with my concerns, then you go on to insult me by saying I'm a waste of time.

You then made up something entirely which I never said or implied in the slightest.

How is it that you so consistently misconstrue everything everyone says to you? I'm starting to believe it's on purpose.

But wait, you seem a bit...offended. What happened to freedom of speech?
 
:eusa_snooty: Well if that's the way you feel about it...

I'm sorry! Anyone could, but reading this entire thread they seemed to stick out the most to me. I didn't mean to offend or exclude anyone. Please feel free to comment, even if it's to call me a blundering misogynist. As long as we can have a discussion about it, or not. Entirely up to people. I just don't see how what she wrote can be seen as rational and reasonable. If I'm wrong please tell me why!
 
I'd like to differ in this regard. Treating people as weak and being nice to people would be two different things.

Giving women special treatment, as opposed to men, like not hitting them, because they can't hit back as well, and respecting their fears implies a greater need for protection and consequently 'weakness', and this is pretty much what I - in my capacity as a man - was socialized to do.
I noted earlier in the thread (which I don't expect anyone to read through as long as it is), women on average are weaker on average physically from men. That is a biological fact. The problem arises when women are presumed to be vulnerable or less capable than the reality of their biology dictates.

I see no reason women would not be capable of saying no to EG. Do you? RW apparently did not have any trouble saying no to EG.

Is it incumbent upon EG to treat RW with kid gloves lest he offend her fragile self? I wonder if you put it that way if RW would object to being coddled because she was a vulnerable woman?

Also, women are not exempt from being sexist against women. When I talked about some women enjoying casual sex bookitty started insulting me for that attitude. Lots of women in this discussion agree women are weaker than I think their biology warrants. It isn't just men expecting women to be unnecessarily weak and vulnerable.

I would hope you wouldn't hit a man half your size either. Is that correct? Actually I don't get the adults hitting each other thing anyway, it seems very primitive and immature to me, but that's a separate discussion. :)
 
Last edited:
But wait, you seem a bit...offended. What happened to freedom of speech?

Freedoms often come at the cost of security.

Freedom of speech often comes at the cost of one's security from being offended. This is why the KKK can march, even if they are a group of low lives. This is why the Westboro Baptist church can go around saying hateful things. I am avidly pro gay rights, but I'm also pro rights to free speech.

You offended me because you put words in my mouth and didn't make any sense out of what I was talking about. I am not telling you to stop it, nor am I calling you a sexist because of it. I embrace dissent. Insult me all you want within the confines of the rules of this board. I won't try to silence you no matter how uncomfortable it makes me feel.
 
I'm sorry! Anyone could, but reading this entire thread they seemed to stick out the most to me. I didn't mean to offend or exclude anyone. Please feel free to comment, even if it's to call me a blundering misogynist. As long as we can have a discussion about it, or not. Entirely up to people. I just don't see how what she wrote can be seen as rational and reasonable. If I'm wrong please tell me why!


Not a problem, PM. :D (While I am neither lovely nor a lady, I don't mind being doubly excluded from commenting on the latest gem from Madame Skepchick's Emporium. From a quick glance and without fuller context, I have to wonder whether it isn't intended ironically; however, on my way out so will leave it for others to parse...) :scarper:
 
Last edited:
Oh when I said lovely ladies I wasn't being sarcastic. I think if read the wrong way it could be seen that way. I'm being honest here. The ladies in this thread have been a breath of fresh air in all of the crap I've had to wade through on Skepchick's website.
Thank you for the compliment.


@Bookitty: not sure what your issue was.
 
Are we really back to the fact that he started off with, "Don't take this the wrong way..." which kind of indicates that he knew it had to the potential to be taken the wrong way.
I don't know what you think was previously resolved that we are now back to.

I've never thought EG was particularly threatening or obscene as described by RW. As quoted, he was polite no matter what his ultimate goal was.
 
Sorry, you're just not all that good at the snark. Maybe try something else.

You lovely lady, you. ;)

I'm not trying to be snarky. I'm trying to be straightforward and not get into a bitch slap with you despite the straw men you keep posting.
 
Skeptic Ginger or fls I was hoping to get your take on this part of the most recent Rebecca Watson post on the issue:

EDIT: Commenter karenx just posted something that I failed to address, and she did it in a better way than I would have. So here it is as #11:

Hitting on stranger in an elevator–creepy

Criticizing (and vilifying) the woman who says not to creepily hit on strangers in elevator for having the nerve to suggest guys change their behavior–sexist

Defending the prerogative of all men to hit on any woman at any time no matter how it might make women feel, even at the expense of women feeling safe in their environment, because it’s “just how men work”–misogynist

If you have any take on it. As a man at this point I don't feel I'm capable of forming an opinion on it without being labelled a sexist misogynist. Is this right? All of this is seriously making me regret being born with a penis, and being white. I'm not rich though! So I only have 2/3 of the privilege points.
 
I don't know what you think was previously resolved that we are now back to.

I've never thought EG was particularly threatening or obscene as described by RW. As quoted, he was polite no matter what his ultimate goal was.

If somewhere since the first two blogs it has changed from, "don't do that, don't be that guy," to it being obscene, I wouldn't defend that sentiment. I don't recall it evolving to obscene status, anywhwere, here. Threatening, on the other hand, you yourself said that we weren't there to experience his tone and demeanor, some pages back. So anything on the side of him being or not being polite is assumption. We have no idea how close he stood to her, if he backed her into the corner of the elevator or if he stood against the opposite wall.

You are correct, though, it wasn't resolved. It still seems like a bit of a contradiction to say, "how was poor EG supposed to know that it might not have been recieved well," considering his opening line makes it clear that he was fully aware of it potentially being taken wrong.
 
Skeptic Ginger or fls I was hoping to get your take on this part of the most recent Rebecca Watson post on the issue:



If you have any take on it. As a man at this point I don't feel I'm capable of forming an opinion on it without being labelled a sexist misogynist. Is this right? All of this is seriously making me regret being born with a penis, and being white. I'm not rich though! So I only have 2/3 of the privilege points.

I'm gonna back out of this lovefest before it gets all sticky. If you're ever sincere about learning something, google feminism 101.
 
This makes me think of something that happened to me when I was between 13-14 years old. I was at a party that my parents went to. I do not really enjoy large groups of people so I went outside with my book and was reading on the porch swing. A guy comes out who is in his late 20's and tells me he wants fresh air and stands on the porch with me. I bring up that I saw some heat lighting and am a bit lost on how there is lighing without rain.
He explains a bit to me but I am only getting parts of the info because of the music back in the house and that with my Add music messes me up if I am trying to understand something. So I ask this "old" dude if he would like to walk around the block with me and expain this again to me because the music is messing me up. He tells me I am too young. :confused:I look at him and say well we will not cross the street if thats what you are worried about. Moral of my story sometimes a walk is just a walk and sometimes coffee is just coffee.

LoL! That's true. But sometimes people are not free to act that way. Unless the "old dude" was a good friend of your family and you had both taken care to let your parents know you were both taking a break from the party and going for a walk -- its likely that people would have assumed the worse and "old dude" would have gotten a bad reputation.

Your innuendo vocabulary probably got expanded that day and considering that we have to be able to fit in and understand the communities we live in, that's a good thing.
 
OK, so here's the context: Skepchick: FREQUENTLY ANSWERED QUESTIONS

"Karnex" posted a reply to the blog and RW added the edit:
EDIT: Commenter karenx just posted something that I failed to address, and she did it in a better way than I would have. So here it is as #11:

Hitting on stranger in an elevator–creepy

Criticizing (and vilifying) the woman who says not to creepily hit on strangers in elevator for having the nerve to suggest guys change their behavior–sexist

Defending the prerogative of all men to hit on any woman at any time no matter how it might make women feel, even at the expense of women feeling safe in their environment, because it’s “just how men work”–misogynist
This has been covered here. Not every elevator pass is automatically "creepy". I bet if EG was quite the hunk, RW's reply might have been different. Not saying she'd have gone to the hotel room with the guy. But perhaps she'd have made a breakfast date.

Reading through RW's comments and the edit she added, I cannot speak to this being all straw men since I've not read the discussions RW has been reading. But if this JREF thread is any example, the comments on the Skepchick site are also full of straw men. One might even think if these arguments were made on Skepchick, that bookitty had been reading there and not here.

The alternative explanation is, however, natural human brain filters are at work here. If Camp Rebecca can't really defend their position, perhaps their brains are naturally filtering the arguments they believe they are hearing and making these straw men out of the actual heard arguments because that better rationalizes the Camp Rebecca position. It's an unfortunate product of the human brain to rationalize one's position rather than consider the position is wrong.

I just find it interesting that the straw men are duplicated in two different exchanges. Of course there is more than one explanation for the duplication, like people are reading both exchanges. A skeptic should entertain multiple hypotheses if they exist.

1-9 of RW's blog comments are either straw men or irrelevant. Number 10 is worth addressing:
Whether or not I continue discussing the topic publicly, the topic will continue to be relevant to me and to many other women who have contacted me to talk about the behavior that drives them away from the skeptic/atheist community. Not talking about it doesn’t make it go away for us, so we go away instead. Don’t get too excited, though: the most annoying of us will probably stick around.
My comment is that it has not been established as far as the evidence I have seen that this really is a significant reason there are more men than women at the skeptic and atheist events. I am not convinced by a few anecdotes this is the case.

Anyone have more evidence than that?
 
I noted earlier in the thread (which I don't expect anyone to read through as long as it is), women on average are weaker on average physically from men. That is a biological fact. The problem arises when women are presumed to be vulnerable or less capable than the reality of their biology dictates.

I agree completely, but I think it is still a social reality. I mainly brought it up because fls mentioned that this discussion would portray women as weak, which seemed a little shortsighted blame to me, because it merely reiterates what we got otherwise.

I see no reason women would not be capable of saying no to EG. Do you? RW apparently did not have any trouble saying no to EG.

Not as such, no. But I see two minor problems. First, a lot of women seem to have problems to articulate an unequivocal 'No.' because they don't want to appear rude or don't want to disappoint. It isn't actually a women specific problem, because I had it too when I was younger, but I think it is more prevalent with girls. It doesn't disable them, but I think it contributes strongly to them feeling uncomfortable with propositions. Blame socialization.

The second problem results, I think, partly from this and partly from men's expectations, and is that an unequivocal 'No' is sometimes read as a 'Maybe'. That's a general point though. EG apparently had no problems accepting a rejection.

Is it incumbent upon EG to treat RW with kid gloves lest he offend her fragile self? I wonder if you put it that way if RW would object to being coddled because she was a vulnerable woman?

Again, not as such, and not so much to avoid offending her ego, but to err on the side of caution, if at all. I mentioned in an earlier post the different amount of cautioning a friend's daughter gets, as opposed to her brother. To me this looks as if the world is portrayed more dangerous to her, than to guys, and I also think that girls are still brought up to be more agreeable than boys. This might lead on the one hand to her being scared of situations were she is alone with a strange man, and on the other hand to her being uncomfortable in denying a request. Both are factors that can't be that easily discarded, once they are ingrained, and I think this contributes heavily to the demands for consideration.

Also, women are not exempt from being sexist against women. When I talked about some women enjoying casual sex bookitty started insulting me for that attitude. Lots of women in this discussion agree women are weaker than I think their biology warrants. It isn't just men expecting women to be unnecessarily weak and vulnerable.

I agree, but that isn't the fault of this discussion. :)

I would hope you wouldn't hit a man half your size either. Is that correct?

I know a 56 years old, five foot nothing woman who probably could beat me up, on account of her having been my kendo sensei for a few years. :D No, I don't hit people except in self-defense, but as a child I was only specifically taught to not hit girls, which was part of my point.

Actually I don't get the adults hitting each other thing anyway, it seems very primitive and immature to me, but that's a separate discussion. :)

I heard it is a very manly way to resolve conflicts and to bond, but I can't confirm it from experience.
 
I think we need Avenue Q in to make up a new song "Everyone's a little bit sexist"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom