So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
If somewhere since the first two blogs it has changed from, "don't do that, don't be that guy," to it being obscene, I wouldn't defend that sentiment. I don't recall it evolving to obscene status, anywhwere, here. Threatening, on the other hand, you yourself said that we weren't there to experience his tone and demeanor, some pages back. So anything on the side of him being or not being polite is assumption. We have no idea how close he stood to her, if he backed her into the corner of the elevator or if he stood against the opposite wall.

You are correct, though, it wasn't resolved. It still seems like a bit of a contradiction to say, "how was poor EG supposed to know that it might not have been recieved well," considering his opening line makes it clear that he was fully aware of it potentially being taken wrong.
I can only reply to the evidence RW relayed to us in her video. So most of my comments have been with the caveat, "based on the evidence we have". I have said, however, I don't rule out that RW's individual reaction could have included non-verbal cues of EG and other things we have not been made aware of.
 
FWIW -- here's another story about whether to take things at face value or not:

I like to travel. Usually I travel with others but sometimes schedules conflict and I'll travel on my own.

1987 Atlanta, GA: I went there to stand up at a friend's wedding and decided to stay a few more days to see the area. The first night on my own I decided to check out a restaurant. While I was waiting for my dinner, my waitress pointed out another man and said that he had asked if he could join me. I said yes, but decided to make it clear that I wasn't looking for a hookup. (As I had mentioned up thread, I'm conservative in this area. My goal is to stay serially monogamous. ) I can be socially awkward with the worst of them, but I think I managed to get the point across gracefully. :)

We had a great conversation. He was the first Brazilian I had ever met (he was in Atlanta on business) and while I obviously wasn't the first American he met, I had a few amusing stories to tell.

Dinner ended and I was ready to head back as I had a very early day the next day. I hadn't rented a car yet and I was going to take a cab. He offered to drive me back. We had not been flirting but we were two people out of town away from our family and friends and a social cliché was that an offer of a ride back to my motel probably meant "and than lets screw." I thought he was a nice guy but I'm from the school of thought that trust is nice but it needs to be earned. I was ready to go "home" and while he was acting like a nice guy there was no reason for the evening to continue, so I declined. He got very upset and said things like ... not all men are rapists, it's pouring out, I can't leave you in the rain, etc., etc.

So I thought, what the heck. I've lived in NYC for a long time -- perhaps I had become a bit overly paranoid and cynical. I accepted the ride.

I have a great sense of direction and I had memorized large portions of the Atlanta city map. He was not driving in the right direction. I told him this. He told me I was wrong, but he was one of those men that should never play poker. We were on a highway but within the city limits. Luckily it was one of those highways within city limits that had a few stop lights. At the next one I got out and ran.

Even though I was on a highway I was able to catch a cab. The driver confirmed that the man had not been driving towards my motel.

Just another example that when you are dealing with a stranger you can never know for sure what to expect.
 
Last edited:
"Karnex" posted a reply to the blog and RW added the edit:This has been covered here. Not every elevator pass is automatically "creepy". I bet if EG was quite the hunk, RW's reply might have been different. Not saying she'd have gone to the hotel room with the guy. But perhaps she'd have made a breakfast date.

Reading through RW's comments and the edit she added, I cannot speak to this being all straw men since I've not read the discussions RW has been reading. But if this JREF thread is any example, the comments on the Skepchick site are also full of straw men. One might even think if these arguments were made on Skepchick, that bookitty had been reading there and not here.

The alternative explanation is, however, natural human brain filters are at work here. If Camp Rebecca can't really defend their position, perhaps their brains are naturally filtering the arguments they believe they are hearing and making these straw men out of the actual heard arguments because that better rationalizes the Camp Rebecca position. It's an unfortunate product of the human brain to rationalize one's position rather than consider the position is wrong.

I just find it interesting that the straw men are duplicated in two different exchanges. Of course there is more than one explanation for the duplication, like people are reading both exchanges. A skeptic should entertain multiple hypotheses if they exist.

1-9 of RW's blog comments are either straw men or irrelevant. Number 10 is worth addressing:My comment is that it has not been established as far as the evidence I have seen that this really is a significant reason there are more men than women at the skeptic and atheist events. I am not convinced by a few anecdotes this is the case.

Anyone have more evidence than that?

Thanks for sharing your input. I completely agree with what you've said. It just seems to be the most rational position regarding this situation, and I agree about the comments on her site.
 
If that "polite exception" includes, "should have known not to do that" when the guy had no way of knowing without politely asking, well, yeah. What's wrong with politely declining without being annoyed the guy didn't meet your expectations?

Nothing. What's wrong with realizing, after such a situation, that an amiable forewarning to others may prevent a repeat of the incident?

You put a lot of parameters in there which we don't know are true about EG. I don't know if he is even in the skeptical and/or atheist community. No one has established that RW's assumptions about EG are correct that he heard her panel discussion. And even if he had, I know from my experience teaching that you can never assume the audience hears what you are saying. They might take something completely different away from your lecture or discussion.

Rebecca's video blog was addessed to the skeptical and/or atheist community. It was designed to make a request of us, not EG. Rightly or wrongly, she seemed to think EG had heard her talk and didn't "get it"; so she decided to clarify to the community at large. This seems to suggest that she at some point understood a lot of people wouldn't "just know" and felt it was prudent to take steps to inform us for both her sake (so she wouldn't be put on the spot like that again) and ours (so we wouldn't make an effort that, unbeknown to us, would only end in rejection).

This debate is extremely difficult for me to follow; I'm defending both Watson's right to feel uncomfortable about the situation, and also the message and manner of the video she made in an attempt to request that in the future others (who are not EG) not do what EG did. These are two different mini-topics, and the arguments supporting each mini-topic are different; and I feel as if whenever I make an argument that applies to one of them, you rebut it by explaining why it doesn't adequately apply to the other one.
 

Oh wow. Now see that was really scary, and I'm really glad you were able to get out of there before it was too late. That guy is an rearhole and it's because of men like him that women will question whether I'm a rapist if I am even on the same sidewalk as them. Thanks for sharing your story. I hope that guy gets what he deserves.
 
For those wondering, Rebecca's use of sex to promote her site is irrelevant.
Not to her choosing to make a public protest out of this experience. The attention drawing and choosing to present herself in the skepchick venue as a sexual object exposes a touch of hypocrisy.
That doesn't give guys (and some women, apparently) the right to be creeps, anymore than it gives you the right to grope a Hooter's waitress because she has big boobs and wears a low cut tank top.
With that I agree.

Your two points weren't as well connected as you intended, I think.
 
Oh wow. Now see that was really scary, and I'm really glad you were able to get out of there before it was too late. That guy is an rearhole and it's because of men like him that women will question whether I'm a rapist if I am even on the same sidewalk as them. Thanks for sharing your story. I hope that guy gets what he deserves.

I’m glad it turned out well for me also!

But it did have an effect and I was more cautious going forward. For example, another summer I also ended up traveling solo for part of my annual vacation. I went to Lake George, NY with a friend, but continued on my own to Quebec City and Montreal. In Montreal I spent a lot of time with friends, but I was totally on my own in Quebec City.

I had a great time and fully explored the city, but I didn’t always chit chat with people. For example, one night I went to a place just a few blocks away from my bed and breakfast that had a great jazz trio. There was a handsome guy who I’m sure wanted to talk to me, but I ignored him. I knew I was going to leave late, the bar/club had a lot more guys than gals, and the neighborhood was much emptier than I had expected it to be.

So adding all that up, I just felt more comfortable just listening to the trio. If it had been daytime, a more equitable guy/gal ratio, or one of my friends could have ended up traveling with me to Quebec City, a lot more sidewalk traffic -- I probably would have ended up talking to the guy. But given the circumstances and how I felt I didn’t.

They guy may have been a nice guy but I didn’t feel like playing the odds in a neighborhood that was a lot less busy than I had expected it to be.

Was that an overreaction? Maybe, but it was how I felt at the time.


it's because of men like him that women will question whether I'm a rapist

I think trust has to be earned. While its true that gals can get hurt by guys, guys can get hurt by gals too.

Perhaps a woman is more likely to be hurt physically, but a guy could end up with a psycho and a false rape charge.

Neither outcome is that likely, despite the reports on the 6 o'clock news, but it does happen.

Its probably best for everyone, men and women, not to place themselves in a vulnerable situation with a stranger, at least not until a stranger turns into an acquaintance. ;)
 
Last edited:
FWIW -- here's another story about whether to take things at face value or not:

I like to travel. Usually I travel with others but sometimes schedules conflict and I'll travel on my own.

1987 Atlanta, GA: I went there to stand up at a friend's wedding and decided to stay a few more days to see the area. The first night on my own I decided to check out a restaurant. While I was waiting for my dinner, my waitress pointed out another man and said that he had asked if he could join me. I said yes, but decided to make it clear that I wasn't looking for a hookup. (As I had mentioned up thread, I'm conservative in this area. My goal is to stay serially monogamous. ) I can be socially awkward with the worst of them, but I think I managed to get the point across gracefully. :)

We had a great conversation. He was the first Brazilian I had ever met (he was in Atlanta on business) and while I obviously wasn't the first American he met, I had a few amusing stories to tell.

Dinner ended and I was ready to head back as I had a very early day the next day. I hadn't rented a car yet and I was going to take a cab. He offered to drive me back. We had not been flirting but we were two people out of town away from our family and friends and a social cliché was that an offer of a ride back to my motel probably meant "and than lets screw." I thought he was a nice guy but I'm from the school of thought that trust is nice but it needs to be earned. I was ready to go "home" and while he was acting like a nice guy there was no reason for the evening to continue, so I declined. He got very upset and said things like ... not all men are rapists, it's pouring out, I can't leave you in the rain, etc., etc.

So I thought, what the heck. I've lived in NYC for a long time -- perhaps I had become a bit overly paranoid and cynical. I accepted the ride.

I have a great sense of direction and I had memorized large portions of the Atlanta city map. He was not driving in the right direction. I told him this. He told me I was wrong, but he was one of those men that should never play poker. We were on a highway but within the city limits. Luckily it was one of those highways within city limits that had a few stop lights. At the next one I got out and ran.

Even though I was on a highway I was able to catch a cab. The driver confirmed that the man had not been driving towards my motel.

Just another example that when you are dealing with a stranger you can never know for sure what to expect.
I would have found someone trying to 'guilt' me into going to be a red flag. But I also admitted to a couple mistakes I narrowly escaped from. I'm glad you also got away from this one.
 
Nothing. What's wrong with realizing, after such a situation, that an amiable forewarning to others may prevent a repeat of the incident?



Rebecca's video blog was addessed to the skeptical and/or atheist community. It was designed to make a request of us, not EG. Rightly or wrongly, she seemed to think EG had heard her talk and didn't "get it"; so she decided to clarify to the community at large. This seems to suggest that she at some point understood a lot of people wouldn't "just know" and felt it was prudent to take steps to inform us for both her sake (so she wouldn't be put on the spot like that again) and ours (so we wouldn't make an effort that, unbeknown to us, would only end in rejection).

This debate is extremely difficult for me to follow; I'm defending both Watson's right to feel uncomfortable about the situation, and also the message and manner of the video she made in an attempt to request that in the future others (who are not EG) not do what EG did. These are two different mini-topics, and the arguments supporting each mini-topic are different; and I feel as if whenever I make an argument that applies to one of them, you rebut it by explaining why it doesn't adequately apply to the other one.
Are you saying Rebecca was only telling her skeptical colleagues not to hit on her specifically? No, you are saying this applies to all of us. You are repeating that what Rebecca felt applies to all of us in the skeptical community. Clearly it does not.
 
Its probably best for everyone, men and women, not to place themselves in a vulnerable situation with a stranger, at least not until a stranger turns into an acquaintance.
Yep. Risk management.
 
Well I'll just leave these links here and hope that something productive comes from it.

I don't think any of the major players or many commentators come off looking good in this entire thing.

Who would have thought that a group of skeptics would so freely engage in so much ad-hom, appeal to authority, straw man construction, and the ever present excluded middle?
 
Are you saying Rebecca was only telling her skeptical colleagues not to hit on her specifically? No, you are saying this applies to all of us. You are repeating that what Rebecca felt applies to all of us in the skeptical community. Clearly it does not.

No; in her video she clearly says "don't be like that to me". The object of her statement is herself. But the video is addressed to us - the subject of the message is us.

She's asking us to refrain from doing a certain thing when we are alone with her.
 
I’m glad it turned out well for me also!

But it did have an effect and I was more cautious going forward. For example, another summer I also ended up traveling solo for part of my annual vacation. I went to Lake George, NY with a friend, but continued on my own to Quebec City and Montreal. In Montreal I spent a lot of time with friends, but I was totally on my own in Quebec City.

I had a great time and fully explored the city, but I didn’t always chit chat with people. For example, one night I went to a place just a few blocks away from my bed and breakfast that had a great jazz trio. There was a handsome guy who I’m sure wanted to talk to me, but I ignored him. I knew I was going to leave late, the bar/club had a lot more guys than gals, and the neighborhood was much emptier than I had expected it to be.

So adding all that up, I just felt more comfortable just listening to the trio. If it had been daytime, a more equitable guy/gal ratio, or one of my friends could have ended up traveling with me to Quebec City, a lot more sidewalk traffic -- I probably would have ended up talking to the guy. But given the circumstances and how I felt I didn’t.

They guy may have been a nice guy but I didn’t feel like playing the odds in a neighborhood that was a lot less busy than I had expected it to be.

Was that an overreaction? Maybe, but it was how I felt at the time.




I think trust has to be earned. While its true that gals can get hurt by guys, guys can get hurt by gals too.

Perhaps a woman is more likely to be hurt physically, but a guy could end up with a psycho and a false rape charge.

Neither outcome is that likely, despite the reports on the 6 o'clock news, but it does happen.

Its probably best for everyone, men and women, not to place themselves in a vulnerable situation with a stranger, at least not until a stranger turns into an acquaintance. ;)
I don't think too many people are suggesting no situation is ever dangerous. I certainly made a few mistakes which made fortunate lessons instead of tragedies. In general, however, you traveled around alone and managed just fine for the most part. So did I. The world never turned out as dangerous as the people I met ahead of time warned me it would be.

Though there were a couple warnings I never got that would have been nice. I stumbled into a bad situation in Nicaragua that I had no idea was going on until I was in the middle of it. I knew exactly zero about Somoza, the Contras and the oppression of the people in Nicaragua before I arrived there. And a lot of what happened in Guatemala and El Salvador got worse after I left those countries. Best history lesson I never got in school.
 
I would have found someone trying to 'guilt' me into going to be a red flag.

I didn't interpret this as trying to put me on a guilt trip. Growing up in a Jewish family, you really have to lay it on very, very thick for an attempt at a guilt trip to register with me.

But I did wonder why a married guy with kids who was headed back to Brazil in a few days cared all that much if I grabbed a cab. That was not one of my best attempts at sizing up a situation. It did go a long way towards re-enforcing the concept that trust is something not to be given freely but earned.

But I also admitted to a couple mistakes I narrowly escaped from. I'm glad you also got away from this one.

Thanks. And I'm glad you got away safely from your mistakes also.

Luckily for me I usually size things up well -- but one time, I really blew it. Another post for another day in another thread -- perhaps forum community. I'll just say that a girlfriend and I really messed up and ended up spending a night in the women's section at an Israeli army base. I don't recommend it, but the Israeli army was very hospitable.
 
Well I'll just leave these links here and hope that something productive comes from it.

I don't think any of the major players or many commentators come off looking good in this entire thing.

Who would have thought that a group of skeptics would so freely engage in so much ad-hom, appeal to authority, straw man construction, and the ever present excluded middle?
Allison Smith made some worthwhile comments there. I'll have to look at the other link when I get back from walking my dogs.
 
No; in her video she clearly says "don't be like that to me". The object of her statement is herself. But the video is addressed to us - the subject of the message is us.

She's asking us to refrain from doing a certain thing when we are alone with her.
Sorry CM, but that's definitely not the direction the discussion took once RW replied to RD.
 
I didn't interpret this as trying to put me on a guilt trip. Growing up in a Jewish family, you really have to lay it on very, very thick for an attempt at a guilt trip to register with me.

But I did wonder why a married guy with kids who was headed back to Brazil in a few days cared all that much if I grabbed a cab. That was not one of my best attempts at sizing up a situation. It did go a long way towards re-enforcing the concept that trust is something not to be given freely but earned.



Thanks. And I'm glad you got away safely from your mistakes also.

Luckily for me I usually size things up well -- but one time, I really blew it. Another post for another day in another thread -- perhaps forum community. I'll just say that a girlfriend and I really messed up and ended up spending a night in the women's section at an Israeli army base. I don't recommend it, but the Israeli army was very hospitable.
Oh the stories we could probably share. :D
 
Well I'll just leave these links here and hope that something productive comes from it.
I think Alison makes a lot of sense. Thanks for the link to her perspective.
Which is why I think the rape issue was so gladly pounced upon as an excuse for blowing this so far out of proportion that it’s gone beyond caricature. Again – the original issue; the original problem was not rape.
It was discomfort. It was lack of tact. Please, keep saying that to yourself.
---
And, additionally, his {Dawkins'} point was that absolutely nothing actually happened.

“But it could have!” you cry.

“BUT IT DIDN’T,” I say, and then again point out that this is a tact issue and someone might want to start a mailing list for Miss Manners, but there’s no reason to bring vaginas into it
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom