So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
OK, so here's the context: Skepchick: FREQUENTLY ANSWERED QUESTIONS
As an aside:

"8. A black person and a white person in the elevator is not analogous to my situation, unless you’re talking about a strange white person following a black person onto an elevator and then inviting him/her to his/her hotel room for fried chicken. In that instance, yes, I do believe that the black person is well within his/her rights to politely ask the privileged white majority of skeptics/atheists to not do that."

Hmmm....

Coffee is only for white women?
 
No, it wasn't. However, she's written more since then.

http://skepchick.org/2011/07/the-privilege-delusion/

Is it bad that I think that her initial complaints are valid?

Not so much the rape-citation, because if I were to publish a controversial blog, I would fully expect to receive people's bad wishes because I likely trampled one of their sensitivities, ranging from being beaten up over rape, mutilation and murder to more esoteric wishes like various forms of eternal damnation. It is a funny thing about the anonymity of the internet and the fact that people wouldn't have to look into my angelic smile while uttering such things, that I would consider it as an occupation related risk. Not nice, but hopefully nothing I couldn't learn to ignore.

And I admit that I was tempted to read the part against Dawkins and her decision to no longer support the insensitive jerk as 'Sniff, Richard how could you? You were my hero. I hate you.' which wouldn't be the most rational approach, but since when are skeptics above righteous indignation and feeling hurt?

Her complaints about sexual objectification are, in my opinion, valid though. The elevator incident is just not a very fortunate illustration of the problem, and she consequently didn't make much of a drama out of it initially.

See, back when I was a student I jobbed in a bar for a time, and I got to experience some of it. Nothing traumatizing. It comes - depending on the bar - with the job, and if a patron grabs your ass (as one of the worse offenses), you give him a sweet smile and tell him to stop this, and if he doesn't, you kindly ask the manager to have a word with the guy. It works. But over all, it was annoying enough for me, that I dropped the job after a few months and looked for something different. Call me a sissy for being overly sensitive if you want.

The point is of course, that as a man, I have to actually go to places to experience this degree of objectification, and no in my experience the vast majority of women are far less direct in this regard and better at picking up disinterest.

Women though mostly don't have this privilege. The vast majority of guys are interested in them, and express their desire wherever they just happen to meet them. And frankly, if I came to conferences as a lecturer to state my results or merely my opinions, and I would constantly get the impression that people are more interested in my pecs and my ass, than in my thoughts, I guess I would pretty soon stop feeling flattered and become subliminally pissed. I might even overreact, if I get the feeling that my core concern is ignored over a bad example.

So yes, I think there was some overreaction, I don't know whether it was dramatic or emotional or maybe both, but I wouldn't deny it. And yes, the elevator incident has been blown completely out of proportion

But I think we shouldn't ignore her basic concerns over it. I think she has enough supporting votes to show that she isn't alone with it.
 
Darth Rotor said:
Its probably best for everyone, men and women, not to place themselves in a vulnerable situation with a stranger, at least not until a stranger turns into an acquaintance.
Yep. Risk management.

Yet if one takes a look at the statistics, I'm pretty sure far more women are attacked and raped by acquaintances and partners than strangers. This is probably because rapists are intelligent opponents and adapt to the techniques women use to screen men.

It seems many (but not all) of the things women do to reduce risk are akin to a tennis player who always bounces the ball three times before serving on a big point.
 
Is it bad that I think that her initial complaints are valid?

I don't think so. I think her initial statement was valid and moderate.

Her complaints about sexual objectification are, in my opinion, valid though. The elevator incident is just not a very fortunate illustration of the problem, and she consequently didn't make much of a drama out of it initially.

Her initial complaints weren't about objectification, though. They were about sexualization. That seems to me a different thing. The creeping to objectification and then to rape and what all those atheist men do is what bugs me.

The point is of course, that as a man, I have to actually go to places to experience this degree of objectification, and no in my experience the vast majority of women are far less direct in this regard and better at picking up disinterest.

I have a different experience. Just last Friday, a woman came up to me and a girlfriend sitting in a bar and flashed her breasts. Pointing that out in a keynote address wouldn't be ideologically pertinent, though.

But I think we shouldn't ignore her basic concerns over it. I think she has enough supporting votes to show that she isn't alone with it.

Why not? I mean this seriously. Why is there a special reason to care?
 
<snip>

The vast majority of guys are interested in them, and express their desire wherever they just happen to meet them. And frankly, if I came to conferences as a lecturer to state my results or merely my opinions, and I would constantly get the impression that people are more interested in my pecs and my ass, than in my thoughts, I guess I would pretty soon stop feeling flattered and become subliminally pissed. I might even overreact, if I get the feeling that my core concern is ignored over a bad example.

<snip>

So you wouldn't think "why do men keep on behaving this way towards me? Does it have anything to do with the fact I promote myself and organisation by, for example, hosting parties where women dress up as 19th century prostitutes?"

Ms. Watson has embraced Raunch Culture to get a little bit of celebrity and become a big fish in a small pond. She's now whining about men not taking her seriously.

Silly. Little. Girl.
 
Yes, your point is that a guy might get lucky if he hits on enough women. The fact that some of those women will be offended or feel threatened is just necessary collateral damage.

I do think that, at this point, you are emotionally invested in this debate and can no longer understand the points brought forth by other posters. I suggest taking a break, because I haven't seen you get one right in quite a while, now.

And no, that wasn't what I was saying at all, in case you're wondering.
 
Ah well, all my good works have been for naught.

My parents, unbeknownst to me, were markedly progressive on gender issues. I didn't realize that women were meant to be treated differently until well after I went out into the real world. And upon discovering this, I always thought that the tendency to treat woman as though they couldn't take care of themselves, as though they were weak and vulnerable and generally less competent, was a vestige of sexism. So I, quite foolishly as it turns out, made an effort to demonstrate that it was okay to consider me competent and strong. I realize now that I shouldn't have been annoyed at the salesman who explained that I could get my husband to put together the desk I bought (after all, it had 4 screws to be screwed into pre-dilled holes). Rather I should have cheered his sensitivity to feminist goals whereby it is important to recognize that we don't have control over our emotional reactions, nor do we have the strength, mentally or physically, to overcome the least adversity. Sorry for screwing up the message, guys.

Linda

Thank you for this, it's made me realise what bugs me so much about the whole thing.

The attitude you display here is far more reminicent of the attitude of the important women in my life (my mother, my sisters, my close friends) than many others in this thread. That's why 'Please don't talk to me when I may be vulnerable'* just doesn't square with me, it doesn't tally with my life.


(*yes, I'm paraphrasing for brevity)
 
Last edited:
You could treat me like a human being. That's worked for 100% of the people who tried it.

Treat like a human being? 100%? Woo hoo.! I'm tossing my subliminal suggestion manual on how to get women away! (You aren't fooling me are you? -- 100%?)

FYI: The JREF has now released a "Code of Conduct" for TAM which includes the following:

"... respect your fellow attendees... by not making uninvited sexual comments..."

The truth is I'm shy and I live for uninvited sexual comments. I don't make them, I just like to know that if I received one the person offering it wasn't breaking some sort of rule they could get in trouble for.


Well,

2) You obviously haven't been around some of the drunk, aggressive female Rugby players I have.
True, but I'm not dead yet. How do I find such quality women to support in their Internationale goodwill efforts? They wouldn't grope me would they:rolleyes:
4) (ETA) I bet that a man the size of Penn Jillette could probably whoop your butt.
I met him at a magic shop in NYC when I was 13 (pre P&T.) He is a big fellow.
What Rebecca Watson said in the first place (she may have changed her mind later; I find hard to keep track) was quite simple and moderated and reasonable (if possibly futile). She said nothing about being afraid, nothing about fearing violence, nothing about being worried if she turned him down (which she did), and nothing even about being "objectified." She just said that she felt uncomfortable about being "sexualized." The rest (which is most of what is being discussed) consists of projections onto her.
Yes, politely asking to have a cup coffee isn't wrong. Knowing the women was a newlywed may be wrong on some level but not on a level for any of us to judge. Frankly, I believe in this circumstance the "creepy" line wasn't even crossed.

Did you consider how many men have been robbed in elevators?
No, and why would I? I was robbed of my virginity by a beautiful (in more than one way) young woman (in a bed) many years ago. What can a drunk woman rob me of in an elevator?

A couple of months ago I went through the same situation which has been described here. I was alone with a guy in a hotel elevator, a stranger I had never met before, in a new city. After a short conversation, he invited me to come to his hotel room (or he would come to mine). He didn't ask for sex. I considered it briefly and then declined.

The incident was unremarkable - anyone would find it so. I didn't get offended, nor did I blog about it.

This thread makes me aware that I seem to inhabit an entirely different world than some (hopefully not "many") women. I don't want men to see me as weak and vulnerable, but now I'm starting to understand why they sometimes try to. I didn't realize it was other women doing this to me.

Linda

That is the proper way to handle these things. Someone found you attractive and asked to spend quality time with them. You turned them down for whatever reason but realized that being asked means you still have it and didn't find the offer offensive and remembered it enough to include in this discussion.
 
So you wouldn't think "why do men keep on behaving this way towards me? Does it have anything to do with the fact I promote myself and organisation by, for example, hosting parties where women dress up as 19th century prostitutes?"

Or if I had ventured into participating in a pinup-calendar? No, I am like that. I would expect you to recognize that I am there in my capacity as a lecturer, not as a pinup-model. It would be easy to tell the difference from the way I am dressed.

Her initial complaints weren't about objectification, though. They were about sexualization. That seems to me a different thing. The creeping to objectification and then to rape and what all those atheist men do is what bugs me.

Sexual objectification in the sense that one is seen primarily as an object of sexual desire, instead of as a person? The creeping up to rape was initially more a work of the community, I think. While I still think messages like the one displayed in the blog-post are an occupational hazard, I understood it more as an illustration of a kind of distress she experiences, than as an accusation from RW's side.

I have a different experience. Just last Friday, a woman came up to me and a girlfriend sitting in a bar and flashed her breasts. Pointing that out in a keynote address wouldn't be ideologically pertinent, though.

Oh, I rarely got exhibitionism. It wouldn't be pertinent to the topic either thougth, given that a bar and a conference are different settings, but okay our experiences differ apparently.

Why not? I mean this seriously. Why is there a special reason to care?

Aside from lofty ideals like equality and mutual respect? Empathy, I think. I wouldn't like it happening to me.
 
Or if I had ventured into participating in a pinup-calendar? No, I am like that. I would expect you to recognize that I am there in my capacity as a lecturer, not as a pinup-model. It would be easy to tell the difference from the way I am dressed.

<snip>

Ms. Watson decides the exact moment when the party stops (4am after drinking in the hotel bar, apparently) and everyone has to start behaving with the appropriate sense of propriety (again, according to one of Ms. Watson's multiple standards for appropriate behaviour).

Ms. Watson and other "skepchicks" can revel and rave and offend as many people as they like with their behaviour, but when one bloke (politely as far as I can tell) tries his luck in an elevator with one of them we're all supposed to pay attention and take seriously what she has to say about sexualisation and objectification of women?

If she and other "skepchicks" want men to pay more attention to their brains rather than their tits they should stop screaming "look at our tits!"

I would suggest a name change of the organisation if the women associated with it do not want the negative connotations that go along with describing women as "chicks" to be attached to them as individuals.
 
HAHAHAHA!

We've gone past 40 pages. Anything useful I have to say can not be heard. There is no freaking chance of getting through, ever. No matter what I say or how I phrase it. Because, face it, the skeptics of this board are more akin to lawyers than scientists. (C'mon, the word "we." It actually went there.)

Let's break this down. Some of you guys are seriously arguing against paying attention to the context in which you hit up a total stranger. That's it. That's what this whole damn thing is about.

Oh and I love, like luuuuuurve the way you're now trying to dictate how I communicate because suddenly civilized discussion is a good thing. Delicious irony! Spread like jam on toast.

Well, it's possible your last paragraph serves to tell you the reason for your first. You are, of course, free to communicate however you want.

I would like to point out that the whole damn thing is not about the context in which you hit up a total stranger. I do realize that is what you are arguing about. I don't know what the point is of arguing against a position that the opposition hasn't presented, though (other than as a rhetorical device).

Linda
 
... and she links back to the Schrodinger's Rapist post. *sigh*

If that's all you got from it, it sort of proves the "lalalala...I can't heeear you!" portion.

*sigh*

Why is it wrong to dislike that post?

Apparently the one with the podium tells the audience that the one without the podium is a misogynist.

This is acceptable because they both have blogs.

... yeah, I don't understand it either.

I thought that is was acceptable because the one without the podium could have brought it up in the Q&A session afterwards?
 
I'm curious what the lovely ladies here have to say about this latest gem from Rebecca Watson:

I'd link it but apparently I need to have over 15 posts. Is she making the claim that a group of Skeptics are sexist merely by criticizing her?

Is she saying that defending a man's freedom of speech (prerogative to hit on women is a freedom of speech issue IMO), when approaching unknown women without having in their minds the potential fears of women as misogynist?

I'm an egalitarian, so it baffles me that women can demand all of their thoughts, wishes, and demands to be known to a man prior to propositioning her, while completely disregarding the thoughts, wishes, and demands a man might have, no matter how harmless it is if they disagree with eachother.

If I'm way off I'd love to be shown the light. I just don't know if I can see any light through this sea of hyperbole. When did skeptic mean bowing to one person's anecdotal evidence, emotional pleas, and prejudice.

I have read this entire thread, and this place seems to be the only place not completely ridden in irrational diatribe. So I'm hoping if I'm wrong that maybe someone here can point me in the right direction. Perhaps reading all of the comments on Skepchick have just made me jaded.

EDIT: Just to be clear, I think Rebecca has every right to feel creeped, and I think a lot of other women would too. I disagree with the way she's labeling men, and how she's bullying dissenters into broad generalizations that can be easily dismissed and hated with pejoratives.

You make it clear later that you were looking for a comment from me, but I cannot help you. I asked this question on page 1 of this thread and I haven't received an answer (Bookitty may be in the best position to give you one as she seems most familiar with feminism 101 and she was actually helpful for much of the thread). I don't know why they think these labels need be applied. All I can tell is that they are wrong. If the end result is that I am characterized as a misogynist (which is where I would be put), then you are doing something wrong.

Linda
 
.... and was therefore clearly indicating that that's not what he meant?

Hmmm... deja vu...

Don't take this the wrong way is an indicator that he knew it was potentially going to be taken the wrong way. It's just an answer to the question, "How was EG supposed to know?" The question is irrelevant because apparently he already knew. Now, any forewarning that something has the potential to be offensive, doesn't not automatically negate the offensiveness of the statement.
 
Ms. Watson decides the exact moment when the party stops (4am after drinking in the hotel bar, apparently) and everyone has to start behaving with the appropriate sense of propriety (again, according to one of Ms. Watson's multiple standards for appropriate behaviour).

Ms. Watson and other "skepchicks" can revel and rave and offend as many people as they like with their behaviour, but when one bloke (politely as far as I can tell) tries his luck in an elevator with one of them we're all supposed to pay attention and take seriously what she has to say about sexualisation and objectification of women?

I am not sure what you are referring to with 'offend', but I think we have learned different rules there. According to the ones I learned and as far as parties, pinups and possible promiscuity are concerned, she is allowed to do this.

Let me illustrate: Even if an attractive woman shows up in FMP, mini and tight top ( or a cute guy in tight-laced leather jeans and fishnet-shirt ) to a party you attend, and even if they behave as a complete cock tease there, they have no obligation to deliver on the teasing, and nobody is allowed to stalk or corner them, if they don't want to. It may sound mean, but that's how I learned it, and I actually think it is a better solution than ( to go to another extreme ) running around in burkhas to not accidentally incite passion.

I wouldn't have begrudged anyone for going for sex without even bothering with their name, though, in this case, because if you bother with a ****-Me-Outfit and behavior , it is fair to assume that such reactions are tacitly approved. Anything else would seem hypocritical to me.

It becomes worse. If at another opportunity you meet the same person again in a different setting, say a conference, and they are in a more civil outfit with their civil behavior and their diploma, courtesy demands that you don't treat them according to their slut-impersonation from the party, and you are expected to show them a minimum of respect, even if you are secretly convinced that they are the village bicycle.

If you still want to hook up with them, it means in my book that you don't, for example, stalk them into the elevator, but that you try to learn to know them and try to convince them of your qualities in a normal social setting, for example between 2am and 4am at the bar.

And here the rule that they don't have to deliver, even if they flirt outrageously with you for hours, is still valid.

Concerning the elevator-incident, while the stalking into the elevator is a little creepy, at least the main rule was flawlessly observed, and the request itself was actually polite and respectful, so from my perspective it would have been no biggy.

I would suggest a name change of the organisation if the women associated with it do not want the negative connotations that go along with describing women as "chicks" to be attached to them as individuals.

And here we differ too. In my opinion they are allowed to be chicks, and still deserve to be respected.
 
I didn't read through all the comments (it is pretty much the same as this thread). I think this comment is meant to serve as an answer to the question, though:

"It’s sexism because men get to assume that any woman anywhere who they find attractive is fair game to be hit on, and it’s her job to avoid being hit on, but not the men’s job to learn when it’s okay to hit on her.

It’s sexism because men get to have the privilege of not having to learn to read the facial expressions and body language of women to know when it’s okay to approach or not. They get to say, “Well, how was I supposed to know until she said no?”

It’s sexism because it’s sexist that women are forced to constantly be the gatekeepers of our species’ sexuality.

Also, seriously, if you ask a girl to come up to your hotel room for coffee at 4 am, how the **** is that not just a proposition for sex? Don’t you watch Futurama?

“The two of us are going back to his car, for coffee…”"

It also goes along with P.Z. Myers' original blog post.

Unfortunately, while it sounds nice on the surface, it doesn't seem to be a valid argument.

The other thing which worries me is that people are cheering her on for bringing these issues out in the open, but I haven't seen much in the way of discussion of those things she originally brought up in her talk with respect to women's experiences when participating in organized skeptical events - stuff like actual discrimination or harassment. It has mostly been about trying to convince people that this incident serves as a good example, and escalating the stakes when the response is "huh?" Unless Rebecca's incident gets dropped, I don't see how organizers can begin to discover the extent of actual problems and address them.

Linda
 
As Plato wrote:

"It ain't whatchya do, it's the way thatchya do it." (409 BC)

The rest of this thread appears to be mere filler.

(ETA: with the exception of any good points about genuine harassment/discrimination)
 
Last edited:
<snip>

It’s sexism because it’s sexist that women are forced to constantly be the gatekeepers of our species’ sexuality.

<snip>

What is the above supposed to mean in practice?

Should men behave like me, be passive and wait for an explicit offer or request from a women to have sex?

I look around and I see men who are more assertive than I am having a lot more sex than I do, so I'm not convinced this is a majority view amongst women, who often appear to like being desired and (more or less politely) pursued by men.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom