So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Even though, in this particular case, the "foreign country" in question is - by so many measures - many times safer than the affroted person's country of origin? I mean, really, isn't it time people stopped emphasising the "foreign country" aspect in the way that they have? It's Ireland, not Somalia (or even France)!
I did note that much earlier in the thread. :)
 
Okay, I'll now be scared if I meet you. You're anxious, armed and dangerous.

Anyone have any suggestions what precautions I should take if I bump into a woman such as Bookitty?

You're screwed. By which, I mean, you're not screwed.

Linda
 
Huh?

How is this response helpful?

Remie said it well in the other thread - people are arguing against positions that the other side never offered. What's the point in doing that? Surely if you have something useful to say, it doesn't have to devolve into nonsense when you face opposition.

Linda

HAHAHAHA!

We've gone past 40 pages. Anything useful I have to say can not be heard. There is no freaking chance of getting through, ever. No matter what I say or how I phrase it. Because, face it, the skeptics of this board are more akin to lawyers than scientists. (C'mon, the word "we." It actually went there.)

Let's break this down. Some of you guys are seriously arguing against paying attention to the context in which you hit up a total stranger. That's it. That's what this whole damn thing is about.

Oh and I love, like luuuuuurve the way you're now trying to dictate how I communicate because suddenly civilized discussion is a good thing. Delicious irony! Spread like jam on toast.
 
Well, the "obviously gay" bit was a nice touch.

Linda

(I'd add a winkie, but I'll get in trouble if it looks like I'm flirting.)


Then allow me, with a "Please don't take this the wrong way, but..." :xwink
 
Last edited:
Well, you and Bookitty are much easier to impress than me, then. Two lines of conversation or even five minutes worth still feels the same as an immediate proposition. He could have easily started with the request to come to his room and I (and anyone else) would have felt the same way - an unremarkable request, but still not something I'd be comfortable doing.

Linda

Why do you assume, because I think RW has the right to be offended, that I would be?

I don't want to change it because I already posted it but I also want to say I read that first line wrong.
 
Last edited:
I doubt not talking about it will help much there. I got my impression that some ( but not all ) women are easily scared by the infamous tall, dark stranger from events like a woman refusing my offer to give her a lift to a suburb after a garden party because she didn't know me ( until the hostess pointed out to her that the other guy in the car was my bf, which apparently rendered me harmless in her view), from women speeding up their steps when I happened to get near them in dark alleys because we both wanted to catch the last bus and from similar events, not from discussions.

But that's only special cases. I also got a socialization which included not hitting girls ( except in self-defense ), and generally being nicer to them than to random guys, because they are more sensitive and can't defend themselves as well.

Discussing it only reiterates what is deeply ingrained, at least in the kind of socialization I got.
Treating women as weak and being nice to women are two different things.
 
Faulty analogy. People shouldn't be creepy of course (although it's not really a legal issue, defined in terms of rights). But if being hit on in certain situations creeps you out, then you probably shouldn't have advertised yourself as, paraphrasing slightly, "the hot girl who hits on drunk nerds". Right? The parallel analogy would be:

If Hooters advertised with the slogan "Well-endowed Waitresses Grope Drunk Patrons", and then waitresses began to complain about being groped by drunk patrons, well, would many people not begin to wonder if Hooters management was... to put it bluntly... bright enough to pick its nose, let alone slogans for a restaurant chain?
Exactly. No one is saying promoting the Skepchick brand as sexy gives EG the right to expect a certain answer to his proposition. But it does say, no one says you shouldn't ask.

I'm pretty sure the waitresses at Hooters know why they get good tips. But no one expects the act to include more than flirting.
 
I'm curious what the lovely ladies here have to say about this latest gem from Rebecca Watson:

EDIT: Commenter karenx just posted something that I failed to address, and she did it in a better way than I would have. So here it is as #11:

Hitting on stranger in an elevator–creepy

Criticizing (and vilifying) the woman who says not to creepily hit on strangers in elevator for having the nerve to suggest guys change their behavior–sexist

Defending the prerogative of all men to hit on any woman at any time no matter how it might make women feel, even at the expense of women feeling safe in their environment, because it’s “just how men work”–misogynist

I'd link it but apparently I need to have over 15 posts. Is she making the claim that a group of Skeptics are sexist merely by criticizing her?

Is she saying that defending a man's freedom of speech (prerogative to hit on women is a freedom of speech issue IMO), when approaching unknown women without having in their minds the potential fears of women as misogynist?

I'm an egalitarian, so it baffles me that women can demand all of their thoughts, wishes, and demands to be known to a man prior to propositioning her, while completely disregarding the thoughts, wishes, and demands a man might have, no matter how harmless it is if they disagree with eachother.

If I'm way off I'd love to be shown the light. I just don't know if I can see any light through this sea of hyperbole. When did skeptic mean bowing to one person's anecdotal evidence, emotional pleas, and prejudice.

I have read this entire thread, and this place seems to be the only place not completely ridden in irrational diatribe. So I'm hoping if I'm wrong that maybe someone here can point me in the right direction. Perhaps reading all of the comments on Skepchick have just made me jaded.

EDIT: Just to be clear, I think Rebecca has every right to feel creeped, and I think a lot of other women would too. I disagree with the way she's labeling men, and how she's bullying dissenters into broad generalizations that can be easily dismissed and hated with pejoratives.
 
Last edited:
Treating women as weak and being nice to women are two different things.

See if a woman says "Hey this makes me uncomfortable" and a lot of other women chime in with "Yeah, me too." Don't listen to them! You will be treating them as weak!

But if other women say "Screw those uptight b*****, Women are strong enough to be hit on whether they like it or not!" Then you totally have to listen, you know, to be nice.
 
No she's merely pointing out that you are still playing armchair quarterback. You can say how you think you would react but the situation was different. Your EG asked you to his room after conversation, you may have felt differently had he started out with, "Hey! you want to come back to my room?"
Linda is asking how EG was supposed to know RW would be "uncomfortable" with the polite request?

There's no consensus here that the situation would have intimidated all women. That RW felt "uncomfortable" is not the issue. It's her expectation EG should have been able to predict her discomfort would occur that is at least part of the problem.
 
I'm curious what the lovely ladies here have to say about this latest gem from Rebecca Watson:



I'd link it but apparently I need to have over 15 posts. Is she making the claim that a group of Skeptics are sexist merely by criticizing her?

Is she saying that defending a man's freedom of speech (prerogative to hit on women is a freedom of speech issue IMO), when approaching unknown women without having in their minds the potential fears of irrational women as misogynist?

I'm an egalitarian, so it baffles me that women can demand all of their thoughts, wishes, and demands to be known to a man prior to propositioning her, while completely disregarding the thoughts, wishes, and demands a man might have, no matter how harmless it is if they disagree with eachother.

If I'm way off I'd love to be shown the light. I just don't know if I can see any light through this sea of hyperbole. When did skeptic mean bowing to one person's anecdotal evidence, emotional pleas, and prejudice.

I have read this entire thread, and this place seems to be the only place not completely ridden in irrational diatribe. So I'm hoping if I'm wrong that maybe someone here can point me in the right direction. Perhaps reading all of the comments on Skepchick have just made me jaded.

EDIT: Just to be clear, I think Rebecca has every right to feel creeped, and I think a lot of other women would too. I disagree with the way she's labeling men, and how she's bullying dissenters into broad generalizations that can be easily dismissed and hated with pejoratives.

Hitting on women is a freedom of speech? Wooooooow.

Hey don't let anyone trample your freedoms in the name civility!
 
Oh when I said lovely ladies I wasn't being sarcastic. I think if read the wrong way it could be seen that way. I'm being honest here. The ladies in this thread have been a breath of fresh air in all of the crap I've had to wade through on Skepchick's website.
 
Huh?

How is this response helpful?

Remie said it well in the other thread - people are arguing against positions that the other side never offered. What's the point in doing that? Surely if you have something useful to say, it doesn't have to devolve into nonsense when you face opposition.

Linda

It's about as helpful as your elevator story and how unremarkable it was to you. I mean, considering that you don't doubt that Rebecca's reaction was reasonable and all.
 
Treating women as weak and being nice to women are two different things.

I'd like to differ in this regard. Treating people as weak and being nice to people would be two different things.

Giving women special treatment, as opposed to men, like not hitting them, because they can't hit back as well, and respecting their fears implies a greater need for protection and consequently 'weakness', and this is pretty much what I - in my capacity as a man - was socialized to do.
 
This makes me think of something that happened to me when I was between 13-14 years old. I was at a party that my parents went to. I do not really enjoy large groups of people so I went outside with my book and was reading on the porch swing. A guy comes out who is in his late 20's and tells me he wants fresh air and stands on the porch with me. I bring up that I saw some heat lighting and am a bit lost on how there is lighing without rain.
He explains a bit to me but I am only getting parts of the info because of the music back in the house and that with my Add music messes me up if I am trying to understand something. So I ask this "old" dude if he would like to walk around the block with me and expain this again to me because the music is messing me up. He tells me I am too young. :confused:I look at him and say well we will not cross the street if thats what you are worried about. Moral of my story sometimes a walk is just a walk and sometimes coffee is just coffee.
 
Linda is asking how EG was supposed to know RW would be "uncomfortable" with the polite request?

There's no consensus here that the situation would have intimidated all women. That RW felt "uncomfortable" is not the issue. It's her expectation EG should have been able to predict her discomfort would occur that is at least part of the problem.

Are we really back to the fact that he started off with, "Don't take this the wrong way..." which kind of indicates that he knew it had to the potential to be taken the wrong way.
 
Hitting on women is a freedom of speech? Wooooooow.

Hey don't let anyone trample your freedoms in the name civility!

Talking to a woman in a public space is okay unless she asks you to leave her alone right?

Let me use an example. I completely loathe the Wesboro Baptist church with every fiber of my being. They disgust me more than just about anything else I've witnessed. Yet I will say they have the freedom of speech to say the stupid things they say in public, no matter whose feelings they hurt.

Freedom of speech comes with the guarantee of being able to speak your mind even if it offends or hurts people's feelings. It only becomes harrassment or assault if it is in someone's face, with aggravation, or if they've said no and you ignore their request.

Bookitty you come off as presuming to tell men that they should already know that a woman in an elevator doesn't want to be asked to have coffee and conversation. Explain to me how that isn't civil. We've already seen that not all women would take offense to that. Sure some would, but you're asking men to assume they would be offended and not even bother trying or risk public ridicule and embarrassment (which is real harm by the way).

So take a minute and think about what you're saying, instead of jumping to straw-men and hyperbole and emotional pleas. We're skeptics right? I'm trying to bring rational dissent with my concerns. I'm not doing this to create an argument. My goal is that we can have discourse and come to a rational conclusion. I don't see your conclusions as rational, and you haven't provided me with any evidence on why I should.

We can talk about make believe hypothetical situations all day, while you dismiss real situations that counter your made up stuff, but we've been running in the same circle for pages now and you're accusing us of not getting it. Show me the facts on why I'm wrong. I'm receptive to facts and not subjective feeling.
 
Last edited:
Talking to a woman in a public space is okay unless she asks you to leave her alone right?

Let me use an example. I completely loathe the Wesboro Baptist church with every fiber of my being. They disgust me more than just about anything else I've witnessed. Yet I will say they have the freedom of speech to say the stupid things they say in public, no mater whose feelings they hurt.

Freedom of speech comes with the guarantee of being able to speak your mind even if it offends or hurts people's feelings. It only becomes harrassment or assault if it is in someone's face, with aggravation, or if they've said no and you ignore their request.

Bookitty you come off as presuming to tell men that they should already know that a woman in an elevator doesn't want to be asked to have coffee and conversation. Explain to me how that isn't civil. We've already seen that not all women would take offense to that. Sure some would, but you're asking men to assume they would be offended and not even bother trying or risk public ridicule and embarrassment (which is real harm by the way).

So take a minute and think about what you're saying, instead of jumping to straw-men and hyperbole and emotional pleas. We're skeptics right? I'm trying to bring rational dissent with my concerns. I'm not doing this to create an argument. My goal is that we can have discourse and come to a rational conclusion. I don't see your conclusions as rational, and you haven't provided me with any evidence on why I should.

We can talk about make believe hypothetical situations all day, while you dismiss real situations that counter your made up stuff, but we've been running in the same circle for pages now and you're accusing us of not getting it. Show me the facts on why I'm wrong. I'm receptive to facts and not subjective feeling.

No, I will not "Show you facts" because it would be a waste of time. Plus, freedom of speech! Mine.

You phrased the encounter as a zero-sum game. Either you win or she does. So you are not receptive to facts. Period.
 
Oh when I said lovely ladies I wasn't being sarcastic. I think if read the wrong way it could be seen that way. I'm being honest here. The ladies in this thread have been a breath of fresh air in all of the crap I've had to wade through on Skepchick's website.

Ginger, fls - this one is all yours. Enjoy!
 
See if a woman says "Hey this makes me uncomfortable" and a lot of other women chime in with "Yeah, me too." Don't listen to them! You will be treating them as weak!
This is a straw man. It seems like straw men are the only things you are debating here.

But if other women say "Screw those uptight b*****, Women are strong enough to be hit on whether they like it or not!" Then you totally have to listen, you know, to be nice.
This is another straw man.

For review, a straw man is a fallacious argument in which an opponent's points are overstated or misrepresented in order to be attacked or refuted. It appears you are misinterpreting many of the opposing viewpoints in this discussion. Have you thought about perhaps re-reading a few posts to see if maybe you are misreading them in the first place? More than one person has told you now that you are misreading what's being said.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom