So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Really? Are you really going to break it down to an interpretation of of three words? Are we really supposed to get into a discussion of whether or not "we" refers to all those who were later at the bar, or specifically Watson and EG? Really?

Really, she reports him as wanting to talk more.

And, yes, really. I don't know what happened, for sure. You seem absolutely certain. Why is that?
 
I box and own a gun but can't speak for anyone else.
Of course, one could make a point here about the different perception of risk by peoplw who live in a country where the latter is - or is seen as - necessary to any significant degree, compared to that of people who live in a country where the vast majority of the population don't....
 
Wow.

For those wondering, Rebecca's use of sex to promote her site is irrelevant. That doesn't give guys (and some women, apparently) the right to be creeps, anymore than it gives you the right to grope a Hooter's waitress because she has big boobs and wears a low cut tank top.


Faulty analogy. People shouldn't be creepy of course (although it's not really a legal issue, defined in terms of rights). But if being hit on in certain situations creeps you out, then you probably shouldn't have advertised yourself as, paraphrasing slightly, "the hot girl who hits on drunk nerds". Right? The parallel analogy would be:

If Hooters advertised with the slogan "Well-endowed Waitresses Grope Drunk Patrons", and then waitresses began to complain about being groped by drunk patrons, well, would many people not begin to wonder if Hooters management was... to put it bluntly... bright enough to pick its nose, let alone slogans for a restaurant chain?
 
Last edited:
Okay, I'll now be scared if I meet you. You're anxious, armed and dangerous.

Anyone have any suggestions what precautions I should take if I bump into a woman such as Bookitty?

You could treat me like a human being. That's worked for 100% of the people who tried it.
 
Faulty analogy. People shouldn't be creepy of course (although it's not really a legal issue, defined in terms of rights). But if being hit on in certain situations creeps you out, then you probably shouldn't have advertised yourself as, paraphrasing slightly, "the hot girl who hits on drunk nerds". Right? The parallel analogy would be:

Not to nitpick but if she is advertising that she hits on drunk nerds, you don't have to worry about, "how will you know?" if she wants you, she'll hit on you :D <--------to indicate I am being playful
 
If you replace fls with Watson and you have a little chit-chat first and there is not even the hint of a sexual proposition.

Holy moly! There's context again! Almost like it's important or something.

Are you seriously suggesting that a woman need not fear rape unless her attacker starts out propositioning her? She'd never be attacked by someone who is silent or talks about the weather?

I thought your buddy TraneWreck offered up a bunch of small talk rapists. Those stories were falsified?

Linda
 
You're continuing to be sarcastic in place of actual discussion. Do you at least understand my point ?

Yes, your point is that a guy might get lucky if he hits on enough women. The fact that some of those women will be offended or feel threatened is just necessary collateral damage.
 
Are you seriously suggesting that a woman need not fear rape unless her attacker starts out propositioning her? She'd never be attacked by someone who is silent or talks about the weather?

I thought your buddy TraneWreck offered up a bunch of small talk rapists. Those stories were falsified?

Linda

No she's merely pointing out that you are still playing armchair quarterback. You can say how you think you would react but the situation was different. Your EG asked you to his room after conversation, you may have felt differently had he started out with, "Hey! you want to come back to my room?"
 
Are you seriously suggesting that a woman need not fear rape unless her attacker starts out propositioning her? She'd never be attacked by someone who is silent or talks about the weather?

I thought your buddy TraneWreck offered up a bunch of small talk rapists. Those stories were falsified?

Linda

No, I was sarcastically suggesting that the two events were dissimilar. On top of that, I make my own points. And unlike ye strong fems, I feel no need to make the men's points for them.

Actually, I don't really feel the need to make any point. You guys wanna hit on each other without so much as a hello, go for it. Just don't do it to me.

How will you know that it's me? You won't. But if it happens, I am going out of my way to make sure that you are made emotionally uncomfortable and quite probably the laughingstock of anyone nearby.

So you feelin' lucky, punks?
 
Last edited:
No she's merely pointing out that you are still playing armchair quarterback. You can say how you think you would react but the situation was different. Your EG asked you to his room after conversation, you may have felt differently had he started out with, "Hey! you want to come back to my room?"

Well, you and Bookitty are much easier to impress than me, then. Two lines of conversation or even five minutes worth still feels the same as an immediate proposition. He could have easily started with the request to come to his room and I (and anyone else) would have felt the same way - an unremarkable request, but still not something I'd be comfortable doing.

Linda
 
Well, you and Bookitty are much easier to impress than me, then. Two lines of conversation or even five minutes worth still feels the same as an immediate proposition. He could have easily started with the request to come to his room and I (and anyone else) would have felt the same way - an unremarkable request, but still not something I'd be comfortable doing.

Linda


blobru takes notes for next chance encounter... :chores033:
 
No, I was sarcastically suggesting that the two events were dissimilar. On top of that, I make my own points. And unlike ye strong fems, I feel no need to make the men's points for them.

Actually, I don't really feel the need to make any point. You guys wanna hit on each other without so much as a hello, go for it. Just don't do it to me.

How will you know that it's me? You won't. But if it happens, I am going out of my way to make sure that you are made emotionally uncomfortable and quite probably the laughingstock of anyone nearby.

So you feelin' lucky, punks?

So you still didn't bother reading what I said and are making it about something else, all while throwing in the Uncle Tom card for good measure.

Linda
 
blobru takes notes for next chance encounter... :chores033:

Well, the "obviously gay" bit was a nice touch.

Linda

(I'd add a winkie, but I'll get in trouble if it looks like I'm flirting.)
 
Last edited:
I've gone through this thread and I'm trying to get worked up one way or another about this story but I can't.
Sure, sounds like the guy was creepy. Yes, don't blame this Rebecca person for getting creeped out.
Gotta wonder why Dawkins felt compelled to go off on her though.
 
So you still didn't bother reading what I said and are making it about something else, all while throwing in the Uncle Tom card for good measure.

Linda

Ohhh...like lasers, your focus. You got me! I mean I was going for lapdog but that works too.

I was serious. I've given up. I fought the good fight but gosh dern! It aint right, me trying to get between two skeptics who have never met and really want to bone each other right there in an elevator. Breaks the heart really.
 
All I'm saying is that "Nice shoes, wanna ****?" Works better on the internet than it does in real life.

I have opined that propositioning a woman with no other introduction is not likely to work. I have offered a study that also implies this. I have agreed with Watson when she said this. I have tried to explain why this may be so. To no avail.

Let's pretend that I, Bookitty: Concerned Feminist, have just been made Queen of The Whole Friggin World and my word is actually absolute. After tackling poverty and the environment, I turn my all-powerful (but benevolent!) gaze upon the skepticism movement and the sexism within.

I decree and am able to fully enforce a new rule - No one is allowed to proposition anyone without first introducing themselves and taking five whole minutes to explore mutual interests outside potential sexual availability. Yes, this rule is extremely fascist but I am queen of the whole friggin world and that is my law.

To what degree would this interfere with the possibility of casual sex?
I'm not sure how you got on to this sidetrack.

You quoted my reply to Darth with a non sequitur. Perhaps if you explained where you were going with this.


EG asked to share coffee and conversation. We don't know if he had sex in mind, most people think the circumstances indicated he did. Regardless, the thread is not to my knowledge about guys asking women if they'd like to do it.

I said there were women who enjoyed casual sex as much as the next guy. I'm still not seeing how this is relevant to your sidetrack.
 
No she's merely pointing out that you are still playing armchair quarterback. You can say how you think you would react but the situation was different. Your EG asked you to his room after conversation, you may have felt differently had he started out with, "Hey! you want to come back to my room?"

I think I've already mentioned that I don't doubt that Rebecca's reaction was reasonable - if she felt uncomfortable that there's no reason to think it wasn't a discomforting situation. I'm not suggesting that I would have found her incident unremarkable had I been there. I'm suggesting that these blanket condemnations aren't as useful as they are made out to be, as they cover situations which wouldn't be perceived as discomforting anyway.

Linda
 
Ohhh...like lasers, your focus. You got me! I mean I was going for lapdog but that works too.

I was serious. I've given up. I fought the good fight but gosh dern! It aint right, me trying to get between two skeptics who have never met and really want to bone each other right there in an elevator. Breaks the heart really.

Huh?

How is this response helpful?

Remie said it well in the other thread - people are arguing against positions that the other side never offered. What's the point in doing that? Surely if you have something useful to say, it doesn't have to devolve into nonsense when you face opposition.

Linda
 
Last edited:
Here's a transcript from Watson's video:



Now, she says "we were at the hotel bar," and she said that he said he wanted to "talk more."

I'd like to know why some are so damn-fire sure that they hadn't talked at the bar and had no other introduction.
That wasn't exactly the issue. RW said, "what I was saying on the panel" and we don't know he saw or listened to the panel. In addition RW said, "after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner.." but another member in the bar conversation didn't mention the discussion was about RW's being sexualized.

So some of us were just questioning RW's assumption that EG paid any attention to her panel discussion or heard her talk about not wanting to be "sexualized in that manner". In addition, even if he had heard the relevant content, he may not have perceived his relatively polite request to be "sexualizing" her.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom