So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
What precautions could/should she take?

I'd invite a female friend to join us (I've always wanted to meet Rolfe anyway). And this would have less to do with how creepy I think you and more to do with how embarrassed I'd feel when my passport photo is flashed on the evening news as a missing woman with the words "last seen leaving the hotel with a strange man she met on the Internet."

Linda
 
Interesting because I hadn't even seen that thought put quite that way. It made me think. I snipped the rest of his post as the bickering isn't what caught my eye. That thought did.

It is an input, our life experience, yes.
Some life experiences are relevant, yes.

But if I recall a few discussions on the R & P forums, experiential evidence is frequently rejected out of hand by skeptics.
"Out of hand" is not my criteria for rejection. Single anecdotes do not support many conclusions. Anecdotes collected systematically especially when controls are added comprise a lot of medical and sociological research. The validity of the conclusions depend on the quality of the studies, size of the population studied and so on.

A lifetime (or portion of a lifetime) of personal experience depends on what that lifetime experience was/is, how applicable the experience is to the conclusions being drawn, and on how reliable you find the source.

...
Says who?

The year is 2011.
Says bookitty.
 
So you wouldn't have said anything because it didn't bother you, therefore it should not bother Watson. (again!)....
I know you are having difficulty seeing these straw men. Perhaps I can help using this particular statement.

Neither Linda nor I have said RW should or should not have been bothered. What we've said is EG did not behave so outrageously that it would have been obvious to anyone his behavior crossed the line. That is quite different from "shouldn't have bothered RW".
 
I conclude RW overreacted and was hypocritical given the use of sex to promote the Skepchick brand and the mildness of EG's request if it was as RW reported. Of course I'm going to use my view of the world here, just as everyone is. This is a judgement call as there is no empirical evidence presented such as evidence of the true risk to women in elevators compared to TraneWreck's perceived risk. (Since RW used the term, "uncomfortable", not "fearful" and uncomfortable can also mean awkward, I'm singling out TW who has posted the most about the vulnerable women on elevators.)

Wow.

For those wondering, Rebecca's use of sex to promote her site is irrelevant. That doesn't give guys (and some women, apparently) the right to be creeps, anymore than it gives you the right to grope a Hooter's waitress because she has big boobs and wears a low cut tank top.
 
"Out of hand" is not my criteria for rejection. Single anecdotes do not support many conclusions. Anecdotes collected systematically especially when controls are added comprise a lot of medical and sociological research. The validity of the conclusions depend on the quality of the studies, size of the population studied and so on.

A lifetime (or portion of a lifetime) of personal experience depends on what that lifetime experience was/is, how applicable the experience is to the conclusions being drawn, and on how reliable you find the source.

Says bookitty.

All I'm saying is that "Nice shoes, wanna ****?" Works better on the internet than it does in real life.

I have opined that propositioning a woman with no other introduction is not likely to work. I have offered a study that also implies this. I have agreed with Watson when she said this. I have tried to explain why this may be so. To no avail.

Let's pretend that I, Bookitty: Concerned Feminist, have just been made Queen of The Whole Friggin World and my word is actually absolute. After tackling poverty and the environment, I turn my all-powerful (but benevolent!) gaze upon the skepticism movement and the sexism within.

I decree and am able to fully enforce a new rule - No one is allowed to proposition anyone without first introducing themselves and taking five whole minutes to explore mutual interests outside potential sexual availability. Yes, this rule is extremely fascist but I am queen of the whole friggin world and that is my law.

To what degree would this interfere with the possibility of casual sex?
 
Last edited:
Here's a transcript from Watson's video:

...all of you except for the one man who didn’t really grasp, I think, what I was saying on the panel, because at the bar later that night, actually at four in the morning, we were at the hotel bar. Four a.m., I said I’d had enough, I was going to bed. So I walk to the elevator, and a man got on the elevator with me and said, 'Don't take this the wrong way, but I find you very interesting, and I would like to talk more. Would you like to come to my hotel room for coffee?' Um, just a word to wise here, guys, uh, don't do that. You know, I don't really know how else to explain how this makes me incredibly uncomfortable, but I'll just sort of lay it out that I was a single woman, you know, in a foreign country, at 4:00 am, in a hotel elevator, with you, just you, and--don't invite me back to your hotel room right after I finish talking about how it creeps me out and makes me uncomfortable when men sexualize me in that manner...

Now, she says "we were at the hotel bar," and she said that he said he wanted to "talk more."

I'd like to know why some are so damn-fire sure that they hadn't talked at the bar and had no other introduction.
 
Here's a transcript from Watson's video:



Now, she says "we were at the hotel bar," and she said that he said he wanted to "talk more."

I'd like to know why some are so damn-fire sure that they hadn't talked at the bar and had no other introduction.

Really? Are you really going to break it down to an interpretation of of three words? Are we really supposed to get into a discussion of whether or not "we" refers to all those who were later at the bar, or specifically Watson and EG? Really?
 
Any person who finds it necessary to point out to me that it is highly unlikely he/she is a rapist or murderer is not one I would feel comfortable alone in a car with.

Just sayin'.

I would have said there is zero probability but the pedant in me made me allow for serious brain injury or psychosis.

I think we often take precautions more for their calming effect than for any actual efficacy they may have if the worst does actually happen.

Have the women in the thread who are most concerned about being the victim of rape or other violent assault taken any self-defense courses?
 
The argument that "I've never been sexually assaulted in a foreign country; therefore it's unreasonable for the EG scenario to have made any woman uncomfortable" seems like a non-sequitur to me as well.
Even though, in this particular case, the "foreign country" in question is - by so many measures - many times safer than the affroted person's country of origin? I mean, really, isn't it time people stopped emphasising the "foreign country" aspect in the way that they have? It's Ireland, not Somalia (or even France)!
 
Last edited:
I would have said there is zero probability but the pedant in me made me allow for serious brain injury or psychosis.

I think we often take precautions more for their calming effect than for any actual efficacy they may have if the worst does actually happen.

Have the women in the thread who are most concerned about being the victim of rape or other violent assault taken any self-defense courses?

I box and own a gun but can't speak for anyone else.
 
Apparently, if you replace Rebecca with fls, yes.

If you replace fls with Watson and you have a little chit-chat first and there is not even the hint of a sexual proposition.

Holy moly! There's context again! Almost like it's important or something.
 
So you wouldn't have said anything because it didn't bother you, therefore it should not bother Watson. (again!)

I understand that you have an "anything goes" approach when it comes to men hitting on women. You feel that asking a man to be aware of context means that women are weak. So be it. But if you're so hung up on women being not weak, why castigate Watson for being strong enough to state her opinion?

Why are women expected to just shut up and take it?

Booky, now you're just reacting to posts rather than reading them. Fls disn't say anything of the sort.

The way I see it, if fls thinks it's okay, and Rebecca doesn't, how was EG supposed to know, without asking ? He had two choices: 1) not take a chance and shut up and 2) take a chance. He took door #2 and was denied. No harm done, but to expect that men should always take door #1 is silly.
 
I'd invite a female friend to join us (I've always wanted to meet Rolfe anyway). And this would have less to do with how creepy I think you and more to do with how embarrassed I'd feel when my passport photo is flashed on the evening news as a missing woman with the words "last seen leaving the hotel with a strange man she met on the Internet."

Linda

Well if you ever are in the UK I'd love to meet you for a beverage and talk more whenever, wherever and with whoever you feel comfortable.
 
No, I feel that telling men that they need to be aware that women are weak gives the impression that women are weak.

I doubt not talking about it will help much there. I got my impression that some ( but not all ) women are easily scared by the infamous tall, dark stranger from events like a woman refusing my offer to give her a lift to a suburb after a garden party because she didn't know me ( until the hostess pointed out to her that the other guy in the car was my bf, which apparently rendered me harmless in her view), from women speeding up their steps when I happened to get near them in dark alleys because we both wanted to catch the last bus and from similar events, not from discussions.

But that's only special cases. I also got a socialization which included not hitting girls ( except in self-defense ), and generally being nicer to them than to random guys, because they are more sensitive and can't defend themselves as well.

Discussing it only reiterates what is deeply ingrained, at least in the kind of socialization I got.
 
If you replace fls with Watson and you have a little chit-chat first and there is not even the hint of a sexual proposition.

Holy moly! There's context again! Almost like it's important or something.

You're continuing to be sarcastic in place of actual discussion. Do you at least understand my point ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom