So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
You are using your example - After a short conversation, a man who was not propositioning you asked for coffee - to negate Watson's - After zero conversation coffee was offered in a way that felt like a proposition. I'm happy that you had a pleasant, non-threatening encounter. it is not related to what Watson experienced.

You and ginger have been beating the hell out of the "Do whatever you like, I can take it!" drum. I'm saying is "Why the hell should I take it? It's ineffective, it's rude and frankly, I expect better of men."

That wasn't what I was saying. The message has been that men need to be sensitive to situations where women feel vulnerable and alter their behavior to be less threatening. Rebecca's incident was used as an example - don't ask women back to your room when they are alone with you on an elevator and you've just met them. It is held up as an example so obvious that sensible men and women should see the reasonableness of it. Yet I can find an example of exactly that situation where not only did it not occur to me to find his behavior offensive or worrisome (and I also am on alert in situations which have the potential for harm which include when I am in an elevator alone with a man, and I felt uncomfortable with the idea of going to a strange man's room (or having him come to mine)), but had I described the incident fully in some other context, it wouldn't have occurred to anyone else to chastise him for his behavior or create a blogosphere storm. Yet the elements which made it dangerous were exactly the same, only the conversation was different (which realistically would only make it worse, since only a really dumb rapist would put a woman on guard by making a creepy proposition prior to trying to over-power her).

Linda
 
I'm curious - what could EG say now that would make his actions in the elevator seem safer to Watson then?

What does that have to do with what I said ? Watson was made uncomfortable, that's a fact. But we only know her side of the story, that's all. I'd like to know what he was thinking, myself.
 
What if someone doesn't enjoy casual sex? Is it fair to presume someone does for the purposes of trying to pick them up, and to call them unreasonable when they politely take exception?

I think it's fair to ask, fair to refuse, and fair to take no for an answer. Hey, guess what ? That's exactly what happened !
 
What does that have to do with what I said ? Watson was made uncomfortable, that's a fact. But we only know her side of the story, that's all. I'd like to know what he was thinking, myself.

What are the odds he was thinking much of anything?

It was 4 AM, ferfoxache! :cool:
 
What if someone doesn't enjoy casual sex? Is it fair to presume someone does for the purposes of trying to pick them up, and to call them unreasonable when they politely take exception?
If that "polite exception" includes, "should have known not to do that" when the guy had no way of knowing without politely asking, well, yeah. What's wrong with politely declining without being annoyed the guy didn't meet your expectations?
 
It's not a matter of "all guys" knowing something or "all women" agreeing on anything. It's a matter of us as a community that tends to meet, knowing that there are a number of people amongst us who are made uncomfortable by a certain action, and thus simply not doing that thing when we're together. Despite the shockingly idiotic hypothetical inventions some people have come up with when arguing here, simply not hitting on strangers in the elevator doesn't in reality create a burden on anyone's part; not even on the part of those who enjoy casual flings.
You put a lot of parameters in there which we don't know are true about EG. I don't know if he is even in the skeptical and/or atheist community. No one has established that RW's assumptions about EG are correct that he heard her panel discussion. And even if he had, I know from my experience teaching that you can never assume the audience hears what you are saying. They might take something completely different away from your lecture or discussion.
 
That wasn't what I was saying. The message has been that men need to be sensitive to situations where women feel vulnerable and alter their behavior to be less threatening. Rebecca's incident was used as an example - don't ask women back to your room when they are alone with you on an elevator and you've just met them. It is held up as an example so obvious that sensible men and women should see the reasonableness of it. Yet I can find an example of exactly that situation where not only did it not occur to me to find his behavior offensive or worrisome (and I also am on alert in situations which have the potential for harm which include when I am in an elevator alone with a man, and I felt uncomfortable with the idea of going to a strange man's room (or having him come to mine)), but had I described the incident fully in some other context, it wouldn't have occurred to anyone else to chastise him for his behavior or create a blogosphere storm. Yet the elements which made it dangerous were exactly the same, only the conversation was different (which realistically would only make it worse, since only a really dumb rapist would put a woman on guard by making a creepy proposition prior to trying to over-power her).

Linda

So you wouldn't have said anything because it didn't bother you, therefore it should not bother Watson. (again!)

I understand that you have an "anything goes" approach when it comes to men hitting on women. You feel that asking a man to be aware of context means that women are weak. So be it. But if you're so hung up on women being not weak, why castigate Watson for being strong enough to state her opinion?

Why are women expected to just shut up and take it?
 
What are the odds he was thinking much of anything?

It was 4 AM, ferfoxache! :cool:

My thoughts exactly.

If someone played a reel of everything I have ever said between 3:45AM and 4:15AM I would guess that less than 1% of it would show any evidence of thinking. Most of it would likely get me slapped. Again.
 
You feel that asking a man to be aware of context means that women are weak. So be it. But if you're so hung up on women being not weak, why castigate Watson for being strong enough to state her opinion?

Why are women expected to just shut up and take it?

If she sees Watson's behavior as whining (and many do), that's not seen as "strong" at all -- it's seen as weak.
Shutting up and taking it is exactly what one does, in society, to prove how "tough" one is. Getting butthurt is whining; shutting up and taking it is proving personal resilience.
And yeah, it's just as stupid when applied to men (which, in our sexist society, it is all the time, every day). I physically recoil whenever somebody says "man up". But there you go.
 
She should get to know you a little and then take reasonable precautions based on what she has learned.

What could she learn about me that would make it less likely I was the type of man who was going to rape and/or murder her at some point in the future?

What precautions could/should she take?

Why would you expect all women to be immediately comfortable with the idea of getting in your car, if they have no prior experience with you?

Because it's highly unlikely I'm a rapist or murderer.

Do you think female hitchhikers are reckless?
 
So you wouldn't have said anything because it didn't bother you, therefore it should not bother Watson. (again!)

No. I'm saying that it wouldn't have bothered anyone, including Watson. I can relay the conversation to you and even you will agree that it wouldn't have occurred to anyone to get all over his ass about how insensitive he was.

I understand that you have an "anything goes" approach when it comes to men hitting on women.

Huh? Where are you getting this from?

You feel that asking a man to be aware of context means that women are weak.

No, I feel that telling men that they need to be aware that women are weak gives the impression that women are weak.

So be it. But if you're so hung up on women being not weak, why castigate Watson for being strong enough to state her opinion?

Where did I ever castigate her for stating her opinion? Where are you getting this stuff?

Why are women expected to just shut up and take it?

They can talk all they want. I'm looking at whether they are making sense.

Linda
 
Somehow this whole discussion reminds me of Schrödinger's cat ...

So many interpretations. I mean, when does a case of possible sexual harassment stop existing as a superposition of states and become one thing or the other?
 
...
You and ginger have been beating the hell out of the "Do whatever you like, I can take it!" drum. I'm saying is "Why the hell should I take it? It's ineffective, it's rude and frankly, I expect better of men."
And yet another exaggeration making another a straw man.
 
A couple of months ago I went through the same situation which has been described here. I was alone with a guy in a hotel elevator, a stranger I had never met before, in a new city. After a short conversation, he invited me to come to his hotel room (or he would come to mine). He didn't ask for sex. I considered it briefly and then declined.

The incident was unremarkable - anyone would find it so. I didn't get offended, nor did I blog about it.

:blush: Btw, thanks. (And honestly, I've been kicking myself ever since. If I'd offered you some coffee? A stick of gum?)

This thread makes me aware that I seem to inhabit an entirely different world than some (hopefully not "many") women. I don't want men to see me as weak and vulnerable, but now I'm starting to understand why they sometimes try to. I didn't realize it was other women doing this to me.

Linda

Well, you see, what you're failing to grasp, mizzy -- and it's perfectly ok when you, a woman, fail to grasp things; it's kind of cute, even -- is that they're just "chicks", fresh out of the egg, still cute and fuzzy and feeling their way about the barnyard, apparently. If they want to market themselves with the tagline "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" for years, not realizing it might contribute to an atmosphere of "sexualization" and "objectification" at cons, which seem to be their main shtick, which they're now complaining about, well how could they? There may even be some men who can't cross that cognitive chasm, make the daunting causal leap from "hot girls hit on drunk nerds" to being sexual objectified. So if they now want to complain about being objectified by nerds who offer them coffee on elevators in the wee hours and the like, we should give their cries of "sexual objectification!" all the attention they deserve; like the muslim girl who complains about her dad chewing gum while he pours gasoline on her; yes, being set ablaze by your father is a serious feminist issue; but the muslim girl has every right to complain about her dad's gum-chewing, which was only making a bad situation worse; and dismissing her one plight to concentrate on the other is a purely arbitrary choice that reflects our rich white male privilege and selfish genome. A woman who okayed a calendar that sexualized women and very very likely contributed to an atmosphere of sexualizing women is now uncomfortable (uncomfortable! dammit) about being sexualized, especially where it involves coffee on elevators at 4 AM from a creeper nerd after they've been drinking. This is SERIOUS business!!!

But then, you're only a woman, so we don't expect you to understand it all at once. Statistically speaking, your gender, or at least that fraction that labels itself "chicks", is not real good at understanding cause-and-effect, it seems. And needs the entire skeptical movement to rally round and babysit it while they slowly and painfully figure things out. {You know, you chicks are so darn cute when you're trying to figure things out. Not that you ever do. Which is what's so adorable.} *sigh* :lovestruck:
 
Last edited:
What could she learn about me that would make it less likely I was the type of man who was going to rape and/or murder her at some point in the future?

What precautions could/should she take?



Because it's highly unlikely I'm a rapist or murderer.

Do you think female hitchhikers are reckless?

Here's a report of a very sick individual, a dog walker who molested dogs, including one that he adopted for that purpose.
http://www.examiner.com/dogs-in-national/dog-sexually-abused-by-owner?CID=examiner_alerts_article

Most people aren't dogbotherers, in fact a microscopically small portion of the population engages in bestiality. But I'm still going to check references before hiring a dog-walker.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom