So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
The one who was actually in the elevator.

I think we all agree not to invite Rebecca Watson for coffee when in an elevator. It's her desire to speak for all women on the subject that some women objected to.

And that Watson subsequently tried to bully.
 
Should a female member of the forum be wary about getting in my car with me if I suggest we go out for the day together?

Given that from her point of view there's a non-zero probability I may be a rapist and/or murderer, what precautions should she take because she's a woman? For example, should she trust me to get her a drink or food? Should she even get in my car?

What I find wonderfully ironic about this discussion is that some of the people who have criticized and mocked me in threads prior to this one for making tentative assumptions about women's preferences from statistics and economics are now saying men should use statistics when considering how they approach women they're interested in.
 
I think we all agree not to invite Rebecca Watson for coffee when in an elevator. It's her desire to speak for all women on the subject that some women objected to.

Only after others made an argument point out of comparing her situation to other women's. She was essentially trolled into reacting that way.
 
Once again, the argument that not approaching strangers alone with requests for sex because some women have complained about it, would mean we'd have to never approach any woman for any reason whatsoever. You're excluding the middle.
What middle and how do you plan to determine the common knowledge all guys are supposed to know and all women are supposed to agree is the baseline?
 
So women are not supposed to enjoy casual sex? Or should the ones who do just pretend they don't?

What if someone doesn't enjoy casual sex? Is it fair to presume someone does for the purposes of trying to pick them up, and to call them unreasonable when they politely take exception?
 
What middle and how do you plan to determine the common knowledge all guys are supposed to know and all women are supposed to agree is the baseline?

It's not a matter of "all guys" knowing something or "all women" agreeing on anything. It's a matter of us as a community that tends to meet, knowing that there are a number of people amongst us who are made uncomfortable by a certain action, and thus simply not doing that thing when we're together. Despite the shockingly idiotic hypothetical inventions some people have come up with when arguing here, simply not hitting on strangers in the elevator doesn't in reality create a burden on anyone's part; not even on the part of those who enjoy casual flings.
 
I feel the exact same way. I've been telling guys my whole life that hitting on women in an abrupt and rather impersonal fashion doesn't work. That some women might enjoy a bit of conversation beforehand. Or, at the very least, have a pleasant little moment that says "You're more than just life-support for gash." Also, that some women might find it uncomfortable or even threatening. Given the amount of women who have had some type of bad experience in the past, it's a bit rude.

But those guys just don't listen. Show them the science, point out how rarely this has actually worked for them personally, etc, etc. They still come back with "There's nothing wrong with it. Besides, one day it might work!"

I had no idea it was women giving them the go-ahead. Weird.

Was it? I thought the experiment showed that no women took men up on a cold proposition.

ETA: What you said had nothing to do with my story, though. As I said, the guy didn't ask for sex (even indirectly).

Linda
 
Last edited:
And that Watson subsequently tried to bully.

That's the part that got my attention.

I don't really care much about a feminist blogger's perception of a guy's invite to coffee at 4AM. I care that when another blogger disagreed with her Watson put on the bully suit as quickly as possible. Way to create a tempest in a teapot!

If this comes up on the SGU and they support her reaction that may be it for me. I have a lot for respect for Stephen Novella, but I can read his blog for most of the meaningful info on the SGU.
 
A couple of months ago I went through the same situation which has been described here. I was alone with a guy in a hotel elevator, a stranger I had never met before, in a new city. After a short conversation, he invited me to come to his hotel room (or he would come to mine). He didn't ask for sex. I considered it briefly and then declined.

The incident was unremarkable - anyone would find it so. I didn't get offended, nor did I blog about it.

This thread makes me aware that I seem to inhabit an entirely different world than some (hopefully not "many") women. I don't want men to see me as weak and vulnerable, but now I'm starting to understand why they sometimes try to. I didn't realize it was other women doing this to me.

Linda

I'm not sure I understand: are you saying that because you are privileged your reaction is the only acceptable?

I'm sure you are a wonderful person. You wouldn't repeat it so often if you didn't fervently believe it, after all. But maybe there are more ways than one to be an acceptable person? One that doesn't mean being a clone of you?

I know, it's a really weird concept - given a choice EVERYONE in the world would want to be you, of course, but then there's that whole "diversity" thing and people having different backgrounds and experiences and whatnot. You will just have to carry the burden of being the paragon of all human endeavor. Maybe you could hold classes? If only everyone could have your privilege there would be no division, after all!

So. Let's start from the beginning: when we choose our parents, disposition, place of birth, physical appearance and the people we will be surrounded with for our formative years...

... wait - why does that sound familiar?
 
I'm not sure I understand: are you saying that because you are privileged your reaction is the only acceptable?

No. I'm saying that even though I was in the same, apparently vulnerable position as Rebecca, had I recounted all the details of this episode, no one would have been all over the guy for his behavior or considered any of it remarkable, despite the fact that he was exhibiting exactly the same insensitivity to how vulnerable women might feel when in elevators alone with men.

I'm sure you are a wonderful person. You wouldn't repeat it so often if you didn't fervently believe it, after all.

Wow. How rude of you.

But maybe there are more ways than one to be an acceptable person? One that doesn't mean being a clone of you?

I know, it's a really weird concept - given a choice EVERYONE in the world would want to be you, of course, but then there's that whole "diversity" thing and people having different backgrounds and experiences and whatnot. You will just have to carry the burden of being the paragon of all human endeavor. Maybe you could hold classes? If only everyone could have your privilege there would be no division, after all!

I didn't even remotely say or imply any of this. What is your problem?

Linda
 
Was it? I thought the experiment showed that no women took men up on a cold proposition.

ETA: What you said had nothing to do with my story, though. As I said, the guy didn't ask for sex (even indirectly).

Linda

You are using your example - After a short conversation, a man who was not propositioning you asked for coffee - to negate Watson's - After zero conversation coffee was offered in a way that felt like a proposition. I'm happy that you had a pleasant, non-threatening encounter. it is not related to what Watson experienced.

You and ginger have been beating the hell out of the "Do whatever you like, I can take it!" drum. I'm saying is "Why the hell should I take it? It's ineffective, it's rude and frankly, I expect better of men."
 
Should a female member of the forum be wary about getting in my car with me if I suggest we go out for the day together?

Given that from her point of view there's a non-zero probability I may be a rapist and/or murderer, what precautions should she take because she's a woman? For example, should she trust me to get her a drink or food? Should she even get in my car?

What I find wonderfully ironic about this discussion is that some of the people who have criticized and mocked me in threads prior to this one for making tentative assumptions about women's preferences from statistics and economics are now saying men should use statistics when considering how they approach women they're interested in.

She should get to know you a little and then take reasonable precautions based on what she has learned. Why would you expect all women to be immediately comfortable with the idea of getting in your car, if they have no prior experience with you?
 
If this comes up on the SGU and they support her reaction that may be it for me. I have a lot for respect for Stephen Novella, but I can read his blog for most of the meaningful info on the SGU.

It already has come up, and the other participants were supportive. Feel free to start your boycott.
 
Interesting because I hadn't even seen that thought put quite that way. It made me think. I snipped the rest of his post as the bickering isn't what caught my eye. That thought did.
Isn't one's life experience how we all come to our conclusions (be that experience an education or a first hand experience) and isn't such experience at times relevant?
It is an input, our life experience, yes.
Some life experiences are relevant, yes.

But if I recall a few discussions on the R & P forums, experiential evidence is frequently rejected out of hand by skeptics.

Oh, wait, is me sharing that a form of experience based argument, based on 5 years of reading stuff on R & P? Man, it's easy to get caught in the vortex! :eek:
So women are not supposed to enjoy casual sex?
Says who?
Or should the ones who do just pretend they don't?
The year is 2011.
 
Last edited:
I think we all agree not to invite Rebecca Watson for coffee when in an elevator.
What the most interesting man in the world would do, in the elevator scenario, is let one of his bevy of pretty lady friends invite Rebecca up for some Dos Equis.

Odds are
the offer might just be
accepted


Elevator, Guy
Elevator, Guy
You've been aced out by Dos Equis
Since your coffee is too lame


Stay thirsty, my friend. :D

By the way, blobru, you are soooooooo nommed for that parody tune. :)
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom