So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
And upon discovering this, I always thought that the tendency to treat woman as though they couldn't take care of themselves, as though they were weak and vulnerable and generally less competent, was a vestige of sexism.

Well, not necessarily. I think that, in the case of gallantry, sometimes we just like to do a little something extra for the opposite sex.
 
Okay, think what you want; but given that we are all now acutely aware of RW's tendency to overreact, and the fact that at least some women have said that they would react similarly to the same situation, does it not make sense to avoid approaching unknown women for sex when alone in an elevator, simply as a means of avoiding dealing with such an overreaction?
If the control is viewed as at the discretion of the guy, you could say this. But I'm not sure how you'd get the message out to all guys which women would not appreciate this approach, nor expect the guys to refrain from offending the lowest common denominator, meaning they should never approach any woman ever. So it seems to me the response the woman has control over, tell the guy, "no thanks", is the more practical solution.

From a strictly game-theory-based analysis of this business, when you choose the ambush-stranger-for-sex tactic, you have essentially two choices: either ask and be turned down without having offended the woman, or ask and be turned down whilst offending the woman (the only actual data we've seen so far, in the form of bookitty's study, indicates this approach was rejected 100% of the time; thus far nobody has claimed success in achieving a sexual encounter using the elevator trick). This makes approaching unknown women for sex out of the blue a strictly dominated strategy; it is never the best choice whether the woman overreacts or not, because even when the woman doesn't overreact she will probably reject the invitation.
The request in bookitty's link was a direct solicitation for sex. It's crude. While I don't think the true rejection rate with a larger more diverse sample size and in diverse situations would be 100%, I don't doubt this crude approach would not be successful very often. But that says nothing about a more polite request to talk some first and then decide.

I wonder what a poll of women who've ever had sex on the first date would reveal? I'm pretty sure there would be some demographics where the result was quite high.
 
A couple of months ago I went through the same situation which has been described here. I was alone with a guy in a hotel elevator, a stranger I had never met before, in a new city. After a short conversation, he invited me to come to his hotel room (or he would come to mine). He didn't ask for sex. I considered it briefly and then declined.

The incident was unremarkable - anyone would find it so. I didn't get offended, nor did I blog about it.

This thread makes me aware that I seem to inhabit an entirely different world than some (hopefully not "many") women. I don't want men to see me as weak and vulnerable, but now I'm starting to understand why they sometimes try to. I didn't realize it was other women doing this to me.

Linda
 
I don't know why I should buy, or be compelled to buy, car insurance; I've never in my life been in an accident.

I've never called 911 either; I don't think I should have to pay the tax.
Sorry, I'm missing the point here. This seems like a non-sequitur to me.
 
A lot of good ones there.. :)

Actually, I disagree. They're all too long or awkward; they don't have the punch of glibness you can only get from a short phrase.

I was trying to think of something clever. The best I could come up with is...

"SKEPTIC? FEMINIST?"

"PICK ONE".

Still doesn't work.
 
Nobody has control over their emotional reactions, they have control over how they proceed. They can learn to control some emotional responses through careful attention but much of it is involuntary.

If I am walking down the street and some nimrod yells an obscenity from a car, I don't have control over my reaction to that. If I'm in a good mood, I might ignore it. If the comment is particularly gross or states a threat, I may tense up. I have no choice in that. I can choose how I respond. Whether to ignore it completely or to tell said nimrod that he is a POS and that his father might be a POS but, as he is a mystery to both of us, we'll never know.
Wow, I'm sorry this is your experience. It sure isn't mine. I have a lot of choice how I choose to view an interaction be it the guy in the car or some other situation. I can decide not to be bothered or to be outraged. It is not a reflexive reaction as far as I see it.


Everyone has the occasional illogical emotional response to situations that are actually benign.

Being strong and competent means that I can take care of myself. Taking care of myself means being aware of what is around me and avoiding circumstances in which I might be physically overpowered. Believing that I'm a tough b**** who can take on anyone who wants to harm me wold be more dangerous. In order to take care of myself, I rely on being alert. This alertness creates the low-grade warning system. Not because I think I'm weak but because it best uses what talents I have to avoid danger.

Not all women feel this way, of course.
No disagreements here.

My original statement was too general and I thank you for pointing that out. It should have been an explanation and/or empathy for those women who are creeped out by these lesser threats or more casual intrusions
"Too general" is not the issue I have with your comments. The issue I have is your use of extreme absolutes when that was not what was said.
 
Last edited:
4un4.jpg


4ujn.jpg


4ujo.jpg


4uoz.jpg


4ups.jpg


Seems we have some /b/-tards in the sceptical community.. :)
 
A couple of months ago I went through the same situation which has been described here. I was alone with a guy in a hotel elevator, a stranger I had never met before, in a new city. After a short conversation, he invited me to come to his hotel room (or he would come to mine). He didn't ask for sex. I considered it briefly and then declined.

The incident was unremarkable - anyone would find it so. I didn't get offended, nor did I blog about it.

This thread makes me aware that I seem to inhabit an entirely different world than some (hopefully not "many") women. I don't want men to see me as weak and vulnerable, but now I'm starting to understand why they sometimes try to. I didn't realize it was other women doing this to me.

Linda

I feel the exact same way. I've been telling guys my whole life that hitting on women in an abrupt and rather impersonal fashion doesn't work. That some women might enjoy a bit of conversation beforehand. Or, at the very least, have a pleasant little moment that says "You're more than just life-support for gash." Also, that some women might find it uncomfortable or even threatening. Given the amount of women who have had some type of bad experience in the past, it's a bit rude.

But those guys just don't listen. Show them the science, point out how rarely this has actually worked for them personally, etc, etc. They still come back with "There's nothing wrong with it. Besides, one day it might work!"

I had no idea it was women giving them the go-ahead. Weird.
 
Last edited:
If the control is viewed as at the discretion of the guy, you could say this. But I'm not sure how you'd get the message out to all guys which women would not appreciate this approach, nor expect the guys to refrain from offending the lowest common denominator, meaning they should never approach any woman ever.

Once again, the argument that not approaching strangers alone with requests for sex because some women have complained about it, would mean we'd have to never approach any woman for any reason whatsoever. You're excluding the middle.
 
[...]

To the men who have been resisting and pushing back against the feminists on this issue, there's a very important thing I want to say to you:

We are trying to help you get laid.

[...]

When women explain to you -- in a calm, nuanced, proportionate way -- that there are some contexts in which your advances are less likely to be well-received than others, and you respond by sticking your fingers in your ears and screaming about ball-busting, man-hating feminists who are hell-bent on eradicating all flirting and sex and eroding your First Amendment right to proposition any woman at any time and place? When you resist hearing that hitting on a woman who's alone in an elevator in a strange city at four o'clock in the morning is not likely to be well-received, that it's likely to be perceived as a potential threat, and that you are likely to be perceived as an insensitive clod at best if you do it? When we explain ten times, a hundred times, a thousand times, that elevators are well-documented as a common place for women to get raped and that it's therefore not an appropriate place to make sexual advances -- and you still reply, "But I don't understand what the problem is with elevators"?

I have to assume that getting laid is not the point.

I have to assume that the point is something entirely different. I have to assume that you will do anything to resist hearing that women experience male advances in a very different context from the way men experience female advances...

And when one woman tells you it's creepy to ask a woman out on an elevator and another says they see no harm in it, who is right? The one with the podium?
 
And when one woman tells you it's creepy to ask a woman out on an elevator and another says they see no harm in it who is right? The one with the podium?

The one who was actually in the elevator.
 
And when one woman tells you it's creepy to ask a woman out on an elevator and another says they see no harm in it who is right? The one with the podium?

Apparently the one with the podium tells the audience that the one without the podium is a misogynist.

This is acceptable because they both have blogs.

... yeah, I don't understand it either.
 
Sorry, I'm missing the point here. This seems like a non-sequitur to me.

The argument that "I've never been sexually assaulted in a foreign country; therefore it's unreasonable for the EG scenario to have made any woman uncomfortable" seems like a non-sequitur to me as well.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom