So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
As women are playing the larger role in being assaulted and raped, do you feel they should face as much or more jail time than their attacker? Or perhaps they could be given some leniency in sentencing because the rape/assault could be seen as time served? Do you feel that rapists should serve any time at all?
How are these straw man arguments useful in this discussion? Is that really how you perceive Ivor's comment? He's suggesting if women go to bars they are asking to be raped? Your reaction is incredibly distorted considering what Ivor posted.
 
Ah well, all my good works have been for naught.

My parents, unbeknownst to me, were markedly progressive on gender issues. I didn't realize that women were meant to be treated differently until well after I went out into the real world. And upon discovering this, I always thought that the tendency to treat woman as though they couldn't take care of themselves, as though they were weak and vulnerable and generally less competent, was a vestige of sexism. So I, quite foolishly as it turns out, made an effort to demonstrate that it was okay to consider me competent and strong. I realize now that I shouldn't have been annoyed at the salesman who explained that I could get my husband to put together the desk I bought (after all, it had 4 screws to be screwed into pre-dilled holes). Rather I should have cheered his sensitivity to feminist goals whereby it is important to recognize that we don't have control over our emotional reactions, nor do we have the strength, mentally or physically, to overcome the least adversity. Sorry for screwing up the message, guys.

Linda
 
I think he means that it's biased to use one's own imagined reaction as the meter stick for whether or not someone else is overreacting. To someone with a flat affect, most people's responses to anything seem like overreactions. At most, you can say that it would be an overreaction for you.
I repeat then, so one can never judge someone else is overreacting? Hypocritical?

If RW had started screaming and called for help, could we call that overreacting? If she pulled out a gun and said, "get away from me", could we call that overreacting? Is saying she didn't overreact any less judgmental than saying she did overreact?

Of course it is an opinion. D'uh! Everyone here is expressing how they perceive the situation. If one says RW's reaction was legit because any reaction she has is legit to her, that is also no more than opinion.

I conclude RW overreacted and was hypocritical given the use of sex to promote the Skepchick brand and the mildness of EG's request if it was as RW reported. Of course I'm going to use my view of the world here, just as everyone is. This is a judgement call as there is no empirical evidence presented such as evidence of the true risk to women in elevators compared to TraneWreck's perceived risk. (Since RW used the term, "uncomfortable", not "fearful" and uncomfortable can also mean awkward, I'm singling out TW who has posted the most about the vulnerable women on elevators.)
 
I'm guessing we won't be seeing TAM Italy anytime soon.

But seriously, guys need to behave themselves. In any given situation, he should always ask himself: What would The Most Interesting Man in the World do?
 
Last edited:
I conclude RW overreacted and was hypocritical given the use of sex to promote the Skepchick brand and the mildness of EG's request if it was as RW reported. Of course I'm going to use my view of the world here, just as everyone is. This is a judgement call as there is no empirical evidence presented such as evidence of the true risk to women in elevators compared to TraneWreck's perceived risk. (Since RW used the term, "uncomfortable", not "fearful" and uncomfortable can also mean awkward, I'm singling out TW who has posted the most about the vulnerable women on elevators.)

Why on Earth would I respond to this ridiculous gibberish? I've posted in detail, you ignore everything I write, and repeat these malicious, misguided rants.

You make an obnoxious post accusing me, personally, of all sorts of nasty things. I reply in detail. You ignore it, wait a couple of pages, then post the exact same obnoxious, personally-directed hogwash.

You have proven yourself to be someone incapable of having a rational discussion on this topic. It's unfortunate, I've enjoyed your writing and your opinions on a number of subjects. I am quite surprised at not just the position you've taken here, but the method by which you've chosen to argue.
 
Ah well, all my good works have been for naught.

My parents, unbeknownst to me, were markedly progressive on gender issues. I didn't realize that women were meant to be treated differently until well after I went out into the real world. And upon discovering this, I always thought that the tendency to treat woman as though they couldn't take care of themselves, as though they were weak and vulnerable and generally less competent, was a vestige of sexism. So I, quite foolishly as it turns out, made an effort to demonstrate that it was okay to consider me competent and strong. I realize now that I shouldn't have been annoyed at the salesman who explained that I could get my husband to put together the desk I bought (after all, it had 4 screws to be screwed into pre-dilled holes). Rather I should have cheered his sensitivity to feminist goals whereby it is important to recognize that we don't have control over our emotional reactions, nor do we have the strength, mentally or physically, to overcome the least adversity. Sorry for screwing up the message, guys.

Linda
I suppose I made the same mistake traveling alone so much and taking all those hotel elevators I didn't know I should be frightened of. Maybe I shouldn't have gloated when I gave the check for the full price of my new car to the younger salesman after the older salesman sized me up as not a likely 'real' customer. And perhaps I should have just let the car mechanics rip me off over the years because I wasn't supposed to know enough about cars to catch them in their scams. I did have to come back once with my dad to get satisfaction but I can see now that shouldn't have annoyed me. I should have been flattered the mechanics saw me as so feminine.

:D
 
I repeat then, so one can never judge someone else is overreacting? Hypocritical?

If RW had started screaming and called for help, could we call that overreacting? If she pulled out a gun and said, "get away from me", could we call that overreacting? Is saying she didn't overreact any less judgmental than saying she did overreact?

Of course it is an opinion. D'uh! Everyone here is expressing how they perceive the situation. If one says RW's reaction was legit because any reaction she has is legit to her, that is also no more than opinion.

I conclude RW overreacted and was hypocritical given the use of sex to promote the Skepchick brand and the mildness of EG's request if it was as RW reported. Of course I'm going to use my view of the world here, just as everyone is. This is a judgement call as there is no empirical evidence presented such as evidence of the true risk to women in elevators compared to TraneWreck's perceived risk. (Since RW used the term, "uncomfortable", not "fearful" and uncomfortable can also mean awkward, I'm singling out TW who has posted the most about the vulnerable women on elevators.)

Okay, think what you want; but given that we are all now acutely aware of RW's tendency to overreact, and the fact that at least some women have said that they would react similarly to the same situation, does it not make sense to avoid approaching unknown women for sex when alone in an elevator, simply as a means of avoiding dealing with such an overreaction?

From a strictly game-theory-based analysis of this business, when you choose the ambush-stranger-for-sex tactic, you have essentially two choices: either ask and be turned down without having offended the woman, or ask and be turned down whilst offending the woman (the only actual data we've seen so far, in the form of bookitty's study, indicates this approach was rejected 100% of the time; thus far nobody has claimed success in achieving a sexual encounter using the elevator trick). This makes approaching unknown women for sex out of the blue a strictly dominated strategy; it is never the best choice whether the woman overreacts or not, because even when the woman doesn't overreact she will probably reject the invitation.
 
I suppose I made the same mistake traveling alone so much and taking all those hotel elevators I didn't know I should be frightened of. Maybe I shouldn't have gloated when I gave the check for the full price of my new car to the younger salesman after the older salesman sized me up as not a likely 'real' customer. And perhaps I should have just let the car mechanics rip me off over the years because I wasn't supposed to know enough about cars to catch them in their scams. I did have to come back once with my dad to get satisfaction but I can see now that shouldn't have annoyed me. I should have been flattered the mechanics saw me as so feminine.

:D

I don't know why I should buy, or be compelled to buy, car insurance; I've never in my life been in an accident.

I've never called 911 either; I don't think I should have to pay the tax.
 
Ah well, all my good works have been for naught.

My parents, unbeknownst to me, were markedly progressive on gender issues. I didn't realize that women were meant to be treated differently until well after I went out into the real world. And upon discovering this, I always thought that the tendency to treat woman as though they couldn't take care of themselves, as though they were weak and vulnerable and generally less competent, was a vestige of sexism. So I, quite foolishly as it turns out, made an effort to demonstrate that it was okay to consider me competent and strong. I realize now that I shouldn't have been annoyed at the salesman who explained that I could get my husband to put together the desk I bought (after all, it had 4 screws to be screwed into pre-dilled holes). Rather I should have cheered his sensitivity to feminist goals whereby it is important to recognize that we don't have control over our emotional reactions, nor do we have the strength, mentally or physically, to overcome the least adversity. Sorry for screwing up the message, guys.

Linda

Nobody has control over their emotional reactions, they have control over how they proceed. They can learn to control some emotional responses through careful attention but much of it is involuntary.

If I am walking down the street and some nimrod yells an obscenity from a car, I don't have control over my reaction to that. If I'm in a good mood, I might ignore it. If the comment is particularly gross or states a threat, I may tense up. I have no choice in that. I can choose how I respond. Whether to ignore it completely or to tell said nimrod that he is a POS and that his father might be a POS but, as he is a mystery to both of us, we'll never know.

Everyone has the occasional illogical emotional response to situations that are actually benign. Two days ago, the cat leaped onto my lap while I was distracted by some weird conversation about elevators and I jumped. My cat is no threat. My reaction was immediate and illogical. I saw Jaws when I was 11 years old and avoided mud-puddles on the walk home. Humans have reactions to non-threatening circumstances.

Being strong and competent means that I can take care of myself. Taking care of myself means being aware of what is around me and avoiding circumstances in which I might be physically overpowered. Believing that I'm a tough b**** who can take on anyone who wants to harm me wold be more dangerous. In order to take care of myself, I rely on being alert. This alertness creates the low-grade warning system. Not because I think I'm weak but because it best uses what talents I have to avoid danger.

Not all women feel this way, of course. My original statement was too general and I thank you for pointing that out. It should have been an explanation and/or empathy for those women who are creeped out by these lesser threats or more casual intrusions
 
How are these straw man arguments useful in this discussion? Is that really how you perceive Ivor's comment? He's suggesting if women go to bars they are asking to be raped? Your reaction is incredibly distorted considering what Ivor posted.

ETA: If Ms. Watson does speak for themajority of women, then it seems women need to recalibrate their creep-dar becausethey are still going to bars and clubs, chatting to and dating / marrying non-creeps and then being physically assaulted and raped by them.

Women are going to bars, meeting/dating/marrying non-creeps who then magically turn into rapists, after being around these women. So yes.

Also, that was sarcasm (rhetoric that uses mockery or irony to make a point), not strawman (a sham argument meant to be dismantled). *sigh* Nobody makes a study of the bombastics anymore.
 
I think I can answer this one similarly as I have elsewhere--the issue at hand is not whose feelings matter more. It is how one might best proceed when they don't know someone's specific preferences--there are tendencies worth being aware of.

That, I can agree with. There's just a whole lot of speculation here about how elevator guy should've proceded and how creepy he really was. None of us was there, so we'll have to take Rebecca's word for it.

But to equate that behaviour with anti-fermale sentiments...
 
If that's all you got from it,

Nah, I get her point. It really is pretty much the same point as some commenters here have made, and unlike you I don't agree that she said it any better than, for example, TW has. Or Watson herself in her anti-Dawkins post (which I found very eloquent).

I was just disappointed. Her endorsement of that terrible misandrist piece of crap, first of all, and also bringing that up in this context (which I had not seen anyone else do so far).
 

1310581658416.jpg


1310581530003.jpg


1310581324656.jpg


1310581085966.jpg


1310580333194.jpg


1310581812493.jpg


1310580241913.jpg


1310580284571.jpg


You can see more, and make your own, here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom