So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would be willing to bet a substantial sum of money, based on reading your comments alone, that you won't have to modify your behavior in the least. Absent the stupid stuff we all did in high school and college, I would be willing to bet you've never put a woman in the position EG guy did.

I think people are making unfortunate analogies between their own behavior and that of EG guy eliminating a hugely crucial step in the process. Yes, we've all talked to women (or men) in situations where they're alone, and that's often when we ask them on dates or suggest other types of extracaricular activities.

The MAJOR difference is how you ended up in that conversation. If you had to lurk around, ambush, or surprise the woman without ever having conversed with her, then you may need to be concerned about your behavior.

If you were talking to the woman, and the conversation led to the point you were alone with her, then there's a 0% chance you are making the same error that EG guy did and that the woman in question ran over to the hair salon the next day and put your name on the official "Creep List."

This.

And guys, if this post doesn't make sense to you, then you are Elevator Guy.
 
Why only "a very specific spectrum of circumstances"?

Any of my actions to woo a woman could be perceived as part of a ploy to get her alone so I can physically assault her.

ETA: If Ms. Watson does speak for the majority of women, then it seems women need to recalibrate their creep-dar because they are still going to bars and clubs, chatting to and dating / marrying non-creeps and then being physically assaulted and raped by them.

Consider this post. Then think about the threads you made months ago lamenting your lack of action. Then connect the two.
 
I would be willing to bet a substantial sum of money, based on reading your comments alone, that you won't have to modify your behavior in the least. Absent the stupid stuff we all did in high school and college, I would be willing to bet you've never put a woman in the position EG guy did.

I think people are making unfortunate analogies between their own behavior and that of EG guy eliminating a hugely crucial step in the process. Yes, we've all talked to women (or men) in situations where they're alone, and that's often when we ask them on dates or suggest other types of extracaricular activities.

The MAJOR difference is how you ended up in that conversation. If you had to lurk around, ambush, or surprise the woman without ever having conversed with her, then you may need to be concerned about your behavior.

If you were talking to the woman, and the conversation led to the point you were alone with her, then there's a 0% chance you are making the same error that EG guy did and that the woman in question ran over to the hair salon the next day and put your name on the official "Creep List."

OMG! Stop making so much sense, we'll run out of things to talk about. :D

Reading this as "What would be my reaction?" and it's smiles all the way down. Absent high school high-jinxs, with a little friendly preamble and it's all jake.
 
Guys, even if "you wanna come up to my place so I can show you my etchings?" being the very first words a woman ever hears you say to her shouldn't, in your opinion, be enough to fairly cross you off her "I wanna hang around with" list...don't you think it at least conveys too little information about yourself to let a girl make an educated decision about whether a quick boink with you is a good idea or desirable? There's a reason 100% of the women in the study bookitty spoke of rejected this approach, and I strongly suspect it wasn't because they're all good little Christian virgins.
 
I just hate having to modify my actions because there are tossers in the world.

So do I. And I get your frustration. But here's the thing: women have to do this on a much greater scale than we do.

Women (generally speaking) modify where they go, at what times of day, whether they walk or take a taxi, whether they go alone or have to arrange for an escort, etc. because there are tossers in the world. ("Tossers" being a rather mild way of putting it.)

You and I aren't being asked to do anything on that scale. We're being asked, out of courtesy and respect for women's concerns, to make some relatively mild adjustments like "don't proposition a woman you've never spoken to before at 4 am in an elevator."

Yes, it sucks that considerate, law-abiding people are asked to modify their behavior because other people are willing to rape. But it sucks far far more for women, and us men are just being asked to bear a tiny tiny bit of that burden -- adjust our behavior towards women in particular situations to reduce their stress levels a little. That's it.
 
I think you're reading WAAaaaay too much into things (as did Rebecca...) Its been implied that some people don't like certain types of approaches, and would prefer it if you take that under consideration.

What if I have a dreadful fear of _not_ talking to people in closed spaces ? Should my preferences also be taken in consideration ? At some point, we can't just guess what people like. We have to do with _some_ amount of discomfort.
 
So do I. And I get your frustration. But here's the thing: women have to do this on a much greater scale than we do.

Women (generally speaking) modify where they go, at what times of day, whether they walk or take a taxi, whether they go alone or have to arrange for an escort, etc. because there are tossers in the world. ("Tossers" being a rather mild way of putting it.)

You and I aren't being asked to do anything on that scale. We're being asked, out of courtesy and respect for women's concerns, to make some relatively mild adjustments like "don't proposition a woman you've never spoken to before at 4 am in an elevator."

Yes, it sucks that considerate, law-abiding people are asked to modify their behavior because other people are willing to rape. But it sucks far far more for women, and us men are just being asked to bear a tiny tiny bit of that burden -- adjust our behavior towards women in particular situations to reduce their stress levels a little. That's it.


It's not the behaviour modification that bothers me, if I'm honest. What bothers me is having to modify my behaviour (actually, I don't have to modify my behaviour. I'm very English. I have to wait to be introduced) in response to an unreasonable assumption that I may be an attacker.

Thinking about it a little further, from the point of view of a lady who views herself as in a vulnerable situation, false positives are far less dangerous than false negatives.... I think that has a molifying effect on my indignation.
 
It is the impression (perhapsa false one, I admit) that I get from some comments in this thread. The tone I get was "Don't approach women on their own as you might be a rapist" Do approach women in company because then, even if you are a rapist, you won't attack them when people are about.

The fundemental of this point is that I am perceived by (some) women as a potential rapist. I'm not. I'm very offended that I'm viewed that way solely because I'm male.


I admit, I may have it wrong. I also admit that this has drifted so far from the original event that it's a completely different topic of conversation.

Hmmm...yeah, I can totally see how you would feel that way. And, as it's not true, something has been left out or miscommunicated. I'm going to give it a go, but it's really tricky and full of squishy stuff. Wish me luck. :)

Women don't see all men as rapists. Women live with a low-grade, subconscious warning system that includes the threat of sexual assault. Sexual assault has a huge range. It starts at inappropriate touching and goes to rape/murder. The warning system is set up to catch relatively benign threats like groping, so it may respond to relatively benign actions. Especially when the circumstances are less than ideal.

We have no control over how our bodies react to perceived threat. Heart rate, adrenaline, sweating, muscle tension is involuntary and we are not always consciously aware that it is happening. We are aware of the effects - a change in mood, heightened awareness. This can happen to anyone under the right circumstances and it makes us wary/hostile to the person who caused it.

All of this talk about don't do this, don't do that, isn't because women will see you as a rapist but because even a seemingly benign action can trigger the exact same response as an extremely dangerous one. The only difference will be duration. You will cause her body to react as if you are a rapist until her intellectual mind can assess the actual danger.

So it's not "All you men are rapists!" it's more like "Please be careful. You could be the man who makes me feel as if you are a rapist."
 
:g1: Way back in the days of '45 vinyls, singles used to come with a b- or flip-side; so, here it is for "Smells Like Teen Skepchick": [tune of "Secret Agent Man"] -- all due apologies in advance, any resemblance to persons living or dead or skeptic or sexy or Irish or overcaffeinated purely coincidental, etc. --

Elevator Guy (lyrics actually work pretty well if you just listen to the original and substitute "Elevator Guy" for "Secret Agent Man"; however, that would be too easy...)

There's a guy who's on a lift in Dublin
For everyone he meets got coffee bubblin'
With every spoon he heaps, another chick he creeps
Odds are he just wants a little luvin'

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
Hey I just want some slumber
You creep me out, for shame

Beware of pretty faces you find online
A pretty face can hide an ugly behind
Oh, be careful what they say: "hit on drunk chicks -- hooray!"
Odds are you're an internet sensation

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
They've promised you a hummer
Not now, if it's all the same

(guitar solo -- go PZ go!)

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
They've given you a bum steer
And taken away their blame

Cruisin' on the internet, one night
EG stumbles on ads for a website
"Drunk nerds are where it's at, we'll wear you like a hat"
Odds aren't it's a blurb for Richard Dawkins

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
It's clear that you're a fumbler,
You never will get laid...
 
Last edited:
It's not the behaviour modification that bothers me, if I'm honest. What bothers me is having to modify my behaviour (actually, I don't have to modify my behaviour. I'm very English. I have to wait to be introduced) in response to an unreasonable assumption that I may be an attacker.

If it helps, perhaps think of it as modifying your behavior so as to head off the unreasonable assumption that you may be an attacker, rather than in response to it.
 
Why only "a very specific spectrum of circumstances"?

Any of my actions to woo a woman could be perceived as part of a ploy to get her alone so I can physically assault her.

ETA: If Ms. Watson does speak for the majority of women, then it seems women need to recalibrate their creep-dar because they are still going to bars and clubs, chatting to and dating / marrying non-creeps and then being physically assaulted and raped by them.

As women are playing the larger role in being assaulted and raped, do you feel they should face as much or more jail time than their attacker? Or perhaps they could be given some leniency in sentencing because the rape/assault could be seen as time served? Do you feel that rapists should serve any time at all?
 
What if I have a dreadful fear of _not_ talking to people in closed spaces ? Should my preferences also be taken in consideration ?

Or what if you're a ghost? A ghost from Venus, where the only way to ever get laid is to hit on women you don't know? Shouldn't your cultural background be considered?
 
What if I have a dreadful fear of _not_ talking to people in closed spaces ? Should my preferences also be taken in consideration ? At some point, we can't just guess what people like. We have to do with _some_ amount of discomfort.

I think I can answer this one similarly as I have elsewhere--the issue at hand is not whose feelings matter more. It is how one might best proceed when they don't know someone's specific preferences--there are tendencies worth being aware of.
 
I'm actually responding to TraneWreck's well crafted post where he points out why we can't use our own experiences to decide how Rebecca, or anyone else, ought to respond to being propositioned. ...
So one can never judge someone else is overreacting? Hypocritical?
 
So one can never judge someone else is overreacting? Hypocritical?

I think he means that it's biased to use one's own imagined reaction as the meter stick for whether or not someone else is overreacting. To someone with a flat affect, most people's responses to anything seem like overreactions. At most, you can say that it would be an overreaction for you.
 
Last edited:
:g1: Way back in the days of '45 vinyls, singles used to come with a b- or flip-side; so, here it is for "Smells Like Teen Skepchick": [tune of "Secret Agent Man"] -- all due apologies in advance, any resemblance to persons living or dead or skeptic or sexy or Irish or overcaffeinated purely coincidental, etc. --

Elevator Guy (lyrics actually work pretty well if you just listen to the original and substitute "Elevator Guy" for "Secret Agent Man"; however, that would be too easy...)

There's a guy who's on a lift in Dublin
For everyone he meets got coffee bubblin'
With every spoon he heaps, another chick he creeps
Odds are he just wants a little luvin'

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
Hey I just want some slumber
You creep me out, for shame

Beware of pretty faces you find online
A pretty face can hide an ugly behind
Oh, be careful what they say: "hit on drunk chicks -- hooray!"
Odds are you're an internet sensation

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
They've promised you a hummer
Not now, if it's all the same

(guitar solo -- go PZ go!)

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
They've given you a bum steer
And taken away their blame

Cruisin' on the internet, one night
EG stumbles on ads for a website
"Drunk nerds are where it's at, we'll wear you like a hat"
Odds aren't it's a blurb for Richard Dawkins

Ele vator guy
Ele vator guy
It's clear that you're a fumbler,
You never will get laid...

Earworm!
My husband is going to be so confused. "Why are you singing about...is that elevators? under your breath?"

ETA: and nom'd. Just to spread the joy.
 
Last edited:
I'll give Rebecca the benefit of the doubt about how she felt. I can even agree that it wasn't the best of places to approach her. But now some say it becomes a matter of empathy ? I don't buy it.
I was just pointing out that there was more than one way to view the situation and that one way was not empathy and the other way lacking empathy.

RW has a right to react to EG however she chooses. And it is my position we don't know additional things RW might have such as demeanor and tone of voice. But from there we have two basic reactions from outsiders judging RW's remarks in the first video, exaggerated here for clarity:

One reaction is d'uh, the guy obviously should have known better, he was wrong, it was offensive, rude, the elevator and time of night and location in a "foreign country" added to the discomfort any woman would have felt, yadda yadda.

The other reaction is EG's actions were reasonable, RW overreacted, the guy sounded polite from what RW described, and given all the sex used to promote the Skepchick 'brand' in the past and that this was a single woman comfortable enough to drink in a hotel bar in a "foreign country" until 4am, yadda yadda.

My comment about the empathy was that neither position uniquely lacked it.
 
Last edited:
Here's a good blog post on the subject (via PZ Myers):

[...]

To the men who have been resisting and pushing back against the feminists on this issue, there's a very important thing I want to say to you:

We are trying to help you get laid.

[...]

When women explain to you -- in a calm, nuanced, proportionate way -- that there are some contexts in which your advances are less likely to be well-received than others, and you respond by sticking your fingers in your ears and screaming about ball-busting, man-hating feminists who are hell-bent on eradicating all flirting and sex and eroding your First Amendment right to proposition any woman at any time and place? When you resist hearing that hitting on a woman who's alone in an elevator in a strange city at four o'clock in the morning is not likely to be well-received, that it's likely to be perceived as a potential threat, and that you are likely to be perceived as an insensitive clod at best if you do it? When we explain ten times, a hundred times, a thousand times, that elevators are well-documented as a common place for women to get raped and that it's therefore not an appropriate place to make sexual advances -- and you still reply, "But I don't understand what the problem is with elevators"?

I have to assume that getting laid is not the point.

I have to assume that the point is something entirely different. I have to assume that you will do anything to resist hearing that women experience male advances in a very different context from the way men experience female advances...
http://gretachristina.typepad.com/g...g/2011/07/why-we-have-to-talk-about-this.html

It's almost spooky. I think she's been reading this thread.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom