So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
And here's a crazy idea - when the assumption is that women should be approached in elevators, the science indicates that using a throw-away line to pick up women has a very low chance of success. While the responses to Watson's rather mild video suggest that doing so might even offend. Offended people who have just rejected you are less likely to give you a chance in the future.

This tactic has a better chance of permanently reducing your accessible dating pool by one then it does at providing any mutually beneficial relationship. A different approach might be in order.

How come we're now talking about elevator guy calculating his chances of success based on science rather than just "going for it" ? What does this have to do with the question of empathy ? Or with whether or not it was creepy ? Or whether or not he was mysoginistic ?
 
I think what winds me up most is the fact that, according to a number of views here, when meeting women for the first time, I must act as if she thinks I'm going to rape her. I must respect her damning, offensive and, above all, utterly incorrect assumption that I am a threat.

Hum, yes. Although I fully agree that being asked in an elevator might be stressful, how about in a hallway ? Would it have been _less_ stressful in an empty corridor with no witnesses ?
 
I think what winds me up most is the fact that, according to a number of views here, when meeting women for the first time, I must act as if she thinks I'm going to rape her. I must respect her damning, offensive and, above all, utterly incorrect assumption that I am a threat.

Well yes the simple fact is that lots of women are scared of strange men in unsafe situations. I learned to fold my personal space around me, to look inoffensive and to avoid eye-contact longer than necessary to acknowledge their presence, when I am alone with women in dark alleys or confined spaces, simply because the body language of some of them tells me that they see me as a predator.

Is this fair? No, of course not. I am in fact the victim of a sexist prejudice here. All the more, because I am not that interested in women. Unfortunately they don't know this, and looking at the amount of cautioning a friend's daughter gets from their parents, as opposed to her older brother, this reaction doesn't surprise me in the least.

Now, the question is whether this degree of cautioning is necessary, and whether we - as men - should accommodate to it, and bear the minor discomfort of being unfairly viewed as dangerous, to not make those women uncomfortable.

Statistics say that one out of 6 men is a rapist, but that depends on the statistic. If we go all Dworkin and include situations where you sleep with a guy, because you can't figure out how to say 'No.' or succumb to relentless seductive efforts, despite not actually being in the mood or wanting to actually sleep with this guy, I might be able to count myself as a victim in two or three cases from my youth too.

So the statistic might be inflated (correct me if I am wrong, please).

One out of 10 would still be a scarily high number though. And I think it isn't the same for women as for men. For me it turned only one time bad, because the guy was a little possessive, my social standing didn't suffer much from one night stands, it would have required someone fairly well trained to actually force me and I can't become pregnant, and as a man, I think it is my problem if I can't deny a guy. And the danger of a 'No' not being accepted , or being read as playing hard to get, were always negligible for me.

So there are a few differences and from this the degree of cautioning might indeed be reasonable.

To me it looks as if women face a few more dangers in this regard than I did, and suffer heavier consequences in such cases. Therefore I am prepared to suffer the minor discomfort of being not immediately trusted. It is a little annoying, but lots of things are.
 
Hum, yes. Although I fully agree that being asked in an elevator might be stressful, how about in a hallway ? Would it have been _less_ stressful in an empty corridor with no witnesses ?



In a crowded room full of people, I'm still considered to be a threat and a potential rapist soleley because I have a penis.

In a crowded room what changes is my perceived opportunity for attack, not my perceived level of threat.

Wherever I go, whatever I do when dealing with women I haven't met, I am supposed to consider that she will consider me a potential rapist and a threat out of all proportion to the threat I actually represent. The vast, vast majority of men are not given to attacking women. Even those perceived as 'creepy'
 
Wherever I go, whatever I do when dealing with women I haven't met, I am supposed to consider that she will consider me a potential rapist and a threat out of all proportion to the threat I actually represent.

If that's what you want to do, by all means, go for it.
 
Do you always do what you're told? (Even if that is indeed what you're being told to do?)


I'm not sure what you're getting at here.

I'm expressing offence at being instantly perceived as a potential rapist because I sit in the same demographic as others who have raped.

I don't think the point you've made here is relevant at all, could you expand?
 
I'm not sure what you're getting at here.

I'm expressing offence at being instantly perceived as a potential rapist because I sit in the same demographic as others who have raped.

I don't think the point you've made here is relevant at all, could you expand?

I think you're reading WAAaaaay too much into things (as did Rebecca...) Its been implied that some people don't like certain types of approaches, and would prefer it if you take that under consideration.

So - either do, or don't. Its not like there is some LAW out there. But, I also think that the suggestions made are by and large reasonable, and taken without a sensationalized view, are pretty logical. If you make creepy advances, then I would expect poor results. But - smoke 'em if you got 'em.
 
I'm not sure what you're getting at here.

I'm expressing offence at being instantly perceived as a potential rapist because I sit in the same demographic as others who have raped.

I don't think the point you've made here is relevant at all, could you expand?

I think you're reading WAAaaaay too much into things (as did Rebecca...) Its been implied that some people don't like certain types of approaches, and would prefer it if you take that under consideration.

So - either do, or don't. Its not like there is some LAW out there. But, I also think that the suggestions made are by and large reasonable, and taken without a sensationalized view, are pretty logical. If you make creepy advances, then I would expect poor results. But - smoke 'em if you got 'em.
 
In a crowded room full of people, I'm still considered to be a threat and a potential rapist soleley because I have a penis.

In a crowded room what changes is my perceived opportunity for attack, not my perceived level of threat.

Actually no. Your choice of context is another data point, stacking the odds on the side of "not a threat".
Conversely, if the woman has been saying she doesn't like people sexualizing her, any proposition will come with the data point of "ignores what I'm saying in favour of what he wants". This is not a good sign.

And yes, the demand here is that you consider that she has no idea whether you're a sensible, caring human being or someone who might hurt her very badly. The world isn't perfect, and you have to take up some of the burden of that, even though it's none of your fault. Ever wonder how women feel about that?

The woman you're interested in doesn't know. She can't know. So give her some :rule10-ing data points to go on.
 
Who told you that?

It is the impression (perhapsa false one, I admit) that I get from some comments in this thread. The tone I get was "Don't approach women on their own as you might be a rapist" Do approach women in company because then, even if you are a rapist, you won't attack them when people are about.

The fundemental of this point is that I am perceived by (some) women as a potential rapist. I'm not. I'm very offended that I'm viewed that way solely because I'm male.


I admit, I may have it wrong. I also admit that this has drifted so far from the original event that it's a completely different topic of conversation.
 
I'm not sure what you're getting at here.

I'm expressing offence at being instantly perceived as a potential rapist because I sit in the same demographic as others who have raped.

I don't think the point you've made here is relevant at all, could you expand?

As I see it, I don't think that you are automatically perceived as a potential rapist at all. That sounds like an excluded middle fallacy-- situations that make some women nervous about being alone with a man aren't necessarily potential rape or other predator scenarios. Anyhow, the point isn't that you are responsible for the woman's perception of nervousness or risk (you are not)--the point is that there are ways to avoid magnifying any such perception and that it's helpful to know about them.

Isn't there a difference between "here's some tips that can make a lot of women more comfortable if they don't know you" and "all men heed or we'll think you're a potential rapist"?
 
Last edited:
As I see it, I don't think that you are automatically perceived as a rapist at all. That sounds like an excluded middle fallacy-- situations that make some women nervous about being alone with a man aren't necessarily potential rape or other predator scenarios. Anyhow, the point isn't that you are responsible for the woman's perception of nervousness or risk (you are not)--the point is that there are ways to avoid magnifying any such perception and that it's helpful to know about them.

No, fair points all. And I think my indignant rage has subsided somewhat.

I just hate having to modify my actions because there are tossers in the world. I hate that the actions of tossers reflect on me for whatever reason. I understand it happens, I just don't like it.
Isn't there a difference between "here's some tips that can make a lot of women more comfortable if they don't know you" and "all men heed or we'll think you're a potential rapist"?

Why would they be uncomfortable?
 
Last edited:
No, fair points all. And I think my indignant rage has subsided somewhat.

I just hate having to modify my actions because there are tossers in the world. I hate that the actions of tossers reflect on me for whatever reason. I understand it happens, I just don't like it.

I would be willing to bet a substantial sum of money, based on reading your comments alone, that you won't have to modify your behavior in the least. Absent the stupid stuff we all did in high school and college, I would be willing to bet you've never put a woman in the position EG guy did.

I think people are making unfortunate analogies between their own behavior and that of EG guy eliminating a hugely crucial step in the process. Yes, we've all talked to women (or men) in situations where they're alone, and that's often when we ask them on dates or suggest other types of extracaricular activities.

The MAJOR difference is how you ended up in that conversation. If you had to lurk around, ambush, or surprise the woman without ever having conversed with her, then you may need to be concerned about your behavior.

If you were talking to the woman, and the conversation led to the point you were alone with her, then there's a 0% chance you are making the same error that EG guy did and that the woman in question ran over to the hair salon the next day and put your name on the official "Creep List."
 
I'm not even suggesting we ought to understand exactly how Rebecca, or anyone else in that situation, feels: just that we should hold it as a possibility that whatever they feel does not have to correspond to what we, ourselves, think we would feel in a similar situation.

I think this is a really important point. A lot of the discussion has focused on "empathy." While certainly important and helpful, empathy is not necessary to the process of respecting someone else's view of the world.

I do not empathize with NASCAR fans in the least. I cannot, for the life of me, understand why they like watching cars drive around in circles. It's truly baffling, I will never get it. Yet they're welcome to enjoy the sport, I'm glad they do something they like, inscrutible as I find it.

I suppose we could get into a regressive argument and broaden the subject matter until some notion of empathy emerges: I empathize with the process of "enjoying sports" or "having fun," however it's instantiated, but that's not really the process I go through when considering NASCAR. I hear someone tell me that they're going to spend the weekend at a rally, and I shrug my shoulders and think, "that sounds absolutely awful." Nevertheless, that's totally cool. I understand they perceive the event differently than I do.

Again, sometimes these perceptions of the world conflict--they cannot both be tolerated. Islam's restrictions on female behavior, for example, conflict directly with a woman's basic rights. We cannot accept both views at once, so we need to decide which wins out.

Notice that we can also empathize or understand the perspective of another human being and still prohibit their actions based on that worldview. We can look at EG, understand that he was acting out of shyness and awkwardness (assuming the most charitable reading of his actions), and still point out that his behavior was inappropriate.

Which is why this discussion quickly morphed into a analysis of the empirical reality of the situation, even though no abuse occurred. Watson's apprehension on that elevator was based on the reality of sexual assault. Unlike "buttons" or the myriad dumbassed analogies people have concocted to mock abuse victims, the statistics show, for example, that a woman is 14x as likely to be raped as she is to die in a car accident.

Thus, the perception in question, whether or not you empathize with it, is a rational one. A more or less necessary condition of being sexually assaulted is being in a vulnerable position to the assailant. That condition was met in Watson's case, meaning that her apprehension was justified, even if someone else would have felt differently in similar circumstances.

And finally, no one "considers EG a rapist," no one has said that you can never flirt with a woman, no one has said that women need to wear kevlar and chastity belts into elevators, or any of the endless bizarre crap that's been conjured throughout this discussion. The only burden placed on men is that they consider how their actions could be perceived by women and modify their behavior in a very specific spectrum of circimstances. If this is beyond you as a man, you probably need to seek professional help, and I mean that very non-humorously. This is a basic notion of adulthood.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

And finally, no one "considers EG a rapist," no one has said that you can never flirt with a woman, no one has said that women need to wear kevlar and chastity belts into elevators, or any of the endless bizarre crap that's been conjured throughout this discussion. The only burden placed on men is that they consider how their actions could be perceived by women and modify their behavior in a very specific spectrum of circimstances. If this is beyond you as a man, you probably need to seek professional help, and I mean that very non-humorously. This is a basic notion of adulthood.

Why only "a very specific spectrum of circumstances"?

Any of my actions to woo a woman could be perceived as part of a ploy to get her alone so I can physically assault her.

ETA: If Ms. Watson does speak for the majority of women, then it seems women need to recalibrate their creep-dar because they are still going to bars and clubs, chatting to and dating / marrying non-creeps and then being physically assaulted and raped by them.
 
Last edited:
Watson's original comment is actually not the subject of discussion. Nobody is saying "She was wrong to make that request" (okay, there's probably someone, somewhere on the Internet saying that, but it's not a major thrust of the debate.)

Rather, what people are saying is "Why is this simple question of tact suddenly presented as a major example of misogyny, sexism and rape culture? That's just silly."

I think we would have to go back and find the first person who actually presented it as such, and ask him or her. I don't know who it was, but the deed was done sometime after Watson's first comment on the issue and before Watson's second comment on the issue.

And he watched the video?

He didn't need to; he now knows firsthand how Watson will react. But thanks to the video, no one else needs to learn firsthand, because the video tells them such an approach will not work with Watson.

They do? It seems to me that this is just one outcome of many possible outcomes and it was already known. You trying to say this will happen 100% of the time is absurd.

Rebecca Watson has indicated that approaching her this way will fail 100% of the time. I see no reason to suspect this may not be true.

So everyone who sees RW's video knows not to proposition RW in an elevator. But if you think her advice is suppose to apply to all women in elevators, there are many here who don't agree it does apply.

I think I've said Watson's comments apply only to her enough times by now that you should at the very least strongly suspect that I don't think they apply to all women.

I wonder how the Garda would have reacted to such a summons...?

Impatiently, I imagine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom