So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Tragically so.

But there's a pretty clear dynamic at work behind the failure to understand, and it's a simple lack of empathy. The complainant requested that men whom she doesn't know not follow her alone into an elevator and proposition her for sex because it makes her uncomfortable. This is a rather simple request, it was worded amiably, and simply complying with it would in practice inconvenience no one...considering that we're talking about not some complete random stranger, but ostensibly a like-minded person who wants to attend the same skeptic and atheist meetings we do.

But this didn't happen; what we got instead was a whole litany of special reasons and rationalizations for why complying with Watson's request would place an undue hardship on us:

- The scenario makes only a minority of women uncomfortable, so their concerns can be safely ignored (argument from popularity; remember this one next time you read an news item about a school having a prayer during a graduation commencement).

- The scenario wouldn't make me uncomfortable, therefore the ones who are uncomfortable must be thinking unreasonably, so they can be safely ignored. (non sequitur)

- If we agree to refrain from following women who don't know us alone into elevators and propositioning them for sex, logically we somehow therefore are forced to also NEVER ride alone with women in elevators at any time, and/or NEVER talk to any women ever, and/or NEVER ask for sex from any woman under any circumstances whatsoever (yes, people actually made these assertions, and yes they are all excluded middle fallacies)

- The complainant's discomfort reveals what I consider to be a less-than-enlightened view of human sexual politics, no matter how widely held; therefore, her discomfort can be safely ignored (argument from authority)

- The payoff of a possible sex act in case a woman accepts the proposition, however unlikely, is desirable enough to offset the risk of causing any number of women who take offense to avoid me entirely in the future; therefore the fact that anyone feels uncomfortable is irrelevant (argument from a douchebag)
The objection was not to RW's personal request to men regarding herself.

The question was posed, how was EG supposed to know that? And while a number of people thought everyone should know that, another number of people felt EG was polite and non-threatening and it would not have bothered every woman to the degree it bothered RW.
 
The question was posed, how was EG supposed to know that?

Perhaps he wasn't; which may be why Watson did not bawl him out in the elevator, or call the police, or name and shame him all over the net. She chose instead to use the incident (not the person, who was never named) as a teaching example - so that the EG's of the world can "know that" next time and avoid the situation.
 
And here's a crazy idea - when the assumption is that women should be approached in elevators, the science indicates that using a throw-away line to pick up women has a very low chance of success. While the responses to Watson's rather mild video suggest that doing so might even offend. Offended people who have just rejected you are less likely to give you a chance in the future.

This tactic has a better chance of permanently reducing your accessible dating pool by one then it does at providing any mutually beneficial relationship. A different approach might be in order.

That's one way to look at it, here's another.

Guy catches same elevator as woman. Knowing he will never have another chance to ask this woman out, because he will probably never see her again in his life, he asks himself, "what are the chances?"

If he doesn't ask - 0%

Asking and getting shot down - < 100%

Asking and having her say "yes" - > 0%

Clearly the only thing to do is ask.

And having had more than one woman sleep with me on the first date, I can understand why he did it.

What I don't understand is her bizarre reaction to something so mundane as being asked out. I think the woman has some issues.
 
Perhaps he wasn't; which may be why Watson did not bawl him out in the elevator, or call the police, or name and shame him all over the net. She chose instead to use the incident (not the person, who was never named) as a teaching example - so that the EG's of the world can "know that" next time and avoid the situation.

Watson is now the spokesperson for all women now? I hadn't heard she was elected.
 
Watson is now the spokesperson for all women now? I hadn't heard she was elected.

No; in her video explanation of the incident, she explicitly tells those watching not to follow her alone into an elevator and hit her up for sex when she's never even met you before because it will not happen and it makes her uncomfortable.
 
That's one way to look at it, here's another.

Guy catches same elevator as woman. Knowing he will never have another chance to ask this woman out, because he will probably never see her again in his life, he asks himself, "what are the chances?"

If he doesn't ask - 0%

Asking and getting shot down - < 100%

Asking and having her say "yes" - > 0%

Clearly the only thing to do is ask.

And having had more than one woman sleep with me on the first date, I can understand why he did it.

And now everyone knows the consequences. If you tell the dealer to hit, you play with what you get.
 
Tragically so.

But there's a pretty clear dynamic at work behind the failure to understand, and it's a simple lack of empathy. The complainant requested that men whom she doesn't know not follow her alone into an elevator and proposition her for sex because it makes her uncomfortable. This is a rather simple request, it was worded amiably, and simply complying with it would in practice inconvenience no one...considering that we're talking about not some complete random stranger, but ostensibly a like-minded person who wants to attend the same skeptic and atheist meetings we do.

Watson's original comment is actually not the subject of discussion. Nobody is saying "She was wrong to make that request" (okay, there's probably someone, somewhere on the Internet saying that, but it's not a major thrust of the debate.)

Rather, what people are saying is "Why is this simple question of tact suddenly presented as a major example of misogyny, sexism and rape culture? That's just silly."
 
Last edited:
Perhaps he wasn't; which may be why Watson did not bawl him out in the elevator, or call the police, or name and shame him all over the net.

"Arrest this man, officer! He asked me out for a cup of coffee and he's totally creepy!"
 
No; in her video explanation of the incident, she explicitly tells those watching not to follow her alone into an elevator and hit her up for sex when she's never even met you before because it will not happen and it makes her uncomfortable.

And he watched the video?
 
And now everyone knows the consequences.

They do? It seems to me that this is just one outcome of many possible outcomes and it was already known. You trying to say this will happen 100% of the time is absurd.
 
Perhaps he wasn't; which may be why Watson did not bawl him out in the elevator, or call the police, or name and shame him all over the net. She chose instead to use the incident (not the person, who was never named) as a teaching example - so that the EG's of the world can "know that" next time and avoid the situation.
So everyone who sees RW's video knows not to proposition RW in an elevator. But if you think her advice is suppose to apply to all women in elevators, there are many here who don't agree it does apply.
 
In order to consider it a proposition we must assume he ignored her commentary, lied about just wanting to talk and further disguised his intent by suggesting coffee instead of the usual nightcap offer. Tell me again who was sexualized. It's quite possible his only mistake was not realizing how prejudiced some people are.
 
ASD isn't it though. I mean maybe for elevator guy but it takes a quick five second Google search to find that a large part of it is male self entitlement in general. I've seen a forum literally blow up in on itself because multiple people called out its owner and moderators for literally letting someone make a game out of raping women and try to justify it in a weird and bizarre way. Then we have someone who in response to actually chasing women away from their software package named pantyshot and upskirt sneakily decided to name it after something slightly better than animated child porn and then got self indignant after someone realized his snide little trick.
http://www.zdnet.com/blog/violetblue/when-software-offends-the-pantyshot-package-controversy/509

I'm actually responding to TraneWreck's well crafted post where he points out why we can't use our own experiences to decide how Rebecca, or anyone else, ought to respond to being propositioned.

I'm not even suggesting we ought to understand exactly how Rebecca, or anyone else in that situation, feels: just that we should hold it as a possibility that whatever they feel does not have to correspond to what we, ourselves, think we would feel in a similar situation.

I.e: us - the people discussing it. Not the guy in the lift. Whatever his excuse is.

That I bring ASD (and Trisomy 21) into it is because some of the people discussing it may have an ASD and that may be why they don't understand that Rebecca's (or anyone else's) reaction might not be identical to their own. As I also point out, it is still more common to have developed this ability, than not and if you haven't, it can still be received information where someone unable to grok it on an emotional level, can still have a grasp of its existence. If you know you have an Autism Spectrum situation and you don't belong to the 75% who still develop Theory of Mind then it may help understand the other people's arguments, and frustration with you, if you accept on a theoretical level that other people react differently to you to the same stimuli, and that you are not the ideal for everyone else to strive for.

Validation is an important part of healing and people insisting that someone put in a bad position should have reacted differently can be very painful. While Rebecca can probably handle herself, there may be people reading this who get the idea that there is no help in telling someone as all they can expect is judgement of their own reactions.

So, for anyone who didn't understand this: the Theory of Mind parenthesis was in connection to the people discussing the issue. Not elevator boy.

I repeat: not elevator boy.
 
In order to consider it a proposition we must assume he ignored her commentary, lied about just wanting to talk and further disguised his intent by suggesting coffee instead of the usual nightcap offer. Tell me again who was sexualized. It's quite possible his only mistake was not realizing how prejudiced some people are.

Clearly you don't understand how the world works. Apparently the reality is that (a) men lie and always have having sex before the meeting is over as an underlying motive when asking to talk to women they find interesting and (b) a woman should automatically be assumed to be an innocent victim in a violent altercation with a man.
 
Clearly you don't understand how the world works. Apparently the reality is that (a) men lie and always have having sex before the meeting is over as an underlying motive when asking to talk to women they find interesting and (b) a woman should automatically be assumed to be an innocent victim in a violent altercation with a man.

I think what winds me up most is the fact that, according to a number of views here, when meeting women for the first time, I must act as if she thinks I'm going to rape her. I must respect her damning, offensive and, above all, utterly incorrect assumption that I am a threat.
 
He wanted to stay in the US as the spouse of a citizen. We had been friends and roommates for a year and could answer all the questions as if we were married. At the time he was my best friend, the person who sat on the roof talking Kerouac and social injustice. I was too young to understand how hard it is to actually be deported and I didn't want him to be sent home. So I married him.

I still have the photos of our wedding. We were all paranoid about needing them so we staged some stuff even though it was just in an office building with two witnesses. There's even a picture of me kissing him, on the cheek.
Although that does put the incident you related into an entirely different perspective, doesn't it?

Of course, my now wife and I shared a flat for fours year completely platonically, before we unexpectedly got together....
 
Last edited:
In the elevator situation, why must the empathy favor RW? Is it possible EG is the one who was reasonable, polite, and unthreatening while RW was expressing a bit of narcissistic over-reacting?

I'll give Rebecca the benefit of the doubt about how she felt. I can even agree that it wasn't the best of places to approach her. But now some say it becomes a matter of empathy ? I don't buy it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom