Skeptic Ginger
Nasty Woman
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2005
- Messages
- 96,955
The objection was not to RW's personal request to men regarding herself.Tragically so.
But there's a pretty clear dynamic at work behind the failure to understand, and it's a simple lack of empathy. The complainant requested that men whom she doesn't know not follow her alone into an elevator and proposition her for sex because it makes her uncomfortable. This is a rather simple request, it was worded amiably, and simply complying with it would in practice inconvenience no one...considering that we're talking about not some complete random stranger, but ostensibly a like-minded person who wants to attend the same skeptic and atheist meetings we do.
But this didn't happen; what we got instead was a whole litany of special reasons and rationalizations for why complying with Watson's request would place an undue hardship on us:
- The scenario makes only a minority of women uncomfortable, so their concerns can be safely ignored (argument from popularity; remember this one next time you read an news item about a school having a prayer during a graduation commencement).
- The scenario wouldn't make me uncomfortable, therefore the ones who are uncomfortable must be thinking unreasonably, so they can be safely ignored. (non sequitur)
- If we agree to refrain from following women who don't know us alone into elevators and propositioning them for sex, logically we somehow therefore are forced to also NEVER ride alone with women in elevators at any time, and/or NEVER talk to any women ever, and/or NEVER ask for sex from any woman under any circumstances whatsoever (yes, people actually made these assertions, and yes they are all excluded middle fallacies)
- The complainant's discomfort reveals what I consider to be a less-than-enlightened view of human sexual politics, no matter how widely held; therefore, her discomfort can be safely ignored (argument from authority)
- The payoff of a possible sex act in case a woman accepts the proposition, however unlikely, is desirable enough to offset the risk of causing any number of women who take offense to avoid me entirely in the future; therefore the fact that anyone feels uncomfortable is irrelevant (argument from a douchebag)
The question was posed, how was EG supposed to know that? And while a number of people thought everyone should know that, another number of people felt EG was polite and non-threatening and it would not have bothered every woman to the degree it bothered RW.