So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
ETA: Just for fun, please tell me how you think the story really went.

It was a dark and stormy night. Bookitty, returning home after trawling all the deadbeat bars in her town, opens the door to find the innocent 19 year old hitchhiker she has duct-taped to the headboard. He looks up at her with terrified, limpid pools of watery eyes, fearfully begging to be set free - released from this harrowing den of inquity.

Bookitty slaps him firmly across the face with the flat of her hand 'That! Is for all the women you have ever deigned to approach in elevators!' *Smack!* 'That! Is for all times you made me feel uncomfortable merely by looking at me!'

He whimpers, unable to articulate that he never meant to sexualize or objectify anyone. Merely, he is socially awkward and regularly uses that as his excuse for his ill-thought out and creepy advances.

Bookitty searches across the room and seizes upon an antique imperial jade carved Buddha, signed by Xing-Tzu, a famous jade carver from the Wu-Tang dynasty. Her grandmother had presented this to Bookitty several years ago, explaining that the density of the jadeite crystals in the imperial jade Buddha were not only more pleasing to the eye, but were much more efficient for braining hopeless dorky men than the lesser-valued muttonfat jade versions.

Taking aim, hoping merely to mock a bit of sense into him and draw only a faint spatter of blood (so as not to damage her 1200 thread count Eygptian Cotton sheets from Bed Bath & Beyond) she deftly swings the jade buddha at the hapless man's head. A perfectly timed blow, merely knocking some sense into him and giving him a jaw that will crack at inopportune times later in life.

Ripping the duct tape from his face & head, Boo throws the stumbling geek out into the rainy bleak streets of small town California. Her parting words: 'Next time, make it a Caramel Macchiato, punk.'

The End.

Did I nail it? Or am I perhaps reading in too much?

(Not inserting an ironic smiley - although you can treat this reply with the same seriousness as you would the picture of a kitten, or a tollhouse cookie recipe).
 
[...snipped wall of awesome...]

And again, my perception in this means very little. I recognize that my life experience is very different from that of women who would express concern in that situation. One sign of maturity and intellectual competence is the ability to evaluate someone elses argument without perpetual reference to oneself.

First of all: thank you.

Second: what you are describing in your last paragraph, as I'm sure you are aware, is called "theory of mind" and most people develop it around the age of 4.

People with ASD or Asperger's are excused to some extent because it is one of the things that can be a challenge with an ASD (although ca 75% of people with ASDs develop it normally and most others can understand the concept on a theoretical level - my autistic nephew understands that other people don't feel or think like him all the time, the same way he understands how a radio transmitter works or that Pluto isn't a planet any more, even though to him it still is.)

Interestingly, people with Trisomy 21 (Down's syndrom) develop it as well as, or marginally better than "neurotypical" children even if they have other developmental issues.

Not being able to apprehend that other people's experiences, expectations, agency and/or feelings can differ from one's own, when there is no ASD to explain it, should be a cause for concern.

As always in these discussions, let's not forget that men can be, and are, sexually assaulted and can feel just as intimidated or uncomfortable in triggering situations as well. Equally valid feelings. Granted, we are talking about Rebecca's situation specifically here but I would prefer it if this, valid, discussion doesn't marginalize anyone who has to deal with such an experience.
 
It's hopeless. Don't accept my story. However, if your point is that men are in just as much danger as women, your bitterness is not proof. You will need to start by proving that the majority of women would have the strength to fight off a male attacker. Biology is against you on this one.

There's plenty of objects around the home that can be used as improvised weapons. Also, many self-defense courses teach techniques on how to escape or subdue an attacker.

BTW, why am I accused of being bitter? Bamboozled and defeated would be more accurate.

As for being on your guard, I would suggest it. I am brutally honest in speech sometimes.

I'll make a mental note of that.

Also, a small thing, perhaps you could learn the difference between wary and weary? I know that my writings are full of typos and scattered with malapropism but that one just bugs me.

:o

My excuse: I am quite weary. I shall try to be more wary against making that mistake in the future.

ETA: Just for fun, please tell me how you think the story really went. ETA 2: Because I seriously want to know how I was not an innocent victim.

I have no idea. I was suggesting there's a non-zero probability that you or any other woman would react violently and dangerously against a man.

It therefore seems sexist to assume the only person who can reasonably fear for their safety in an interaction similar to EG and Ms. Watson is the woman.
 
There's plenty of objects around the home that can be used as improvised weapons. Also, many self-defense courses teach techniques on how to escape or subdue an attacker.

BTW, why am I accused of being bitter? Bamboozled and defeated would be more accurate.



I'll make a mental note of that.



:o

My excuse: I am quite weary. I shall try to be more wary against making that mistake in the future.



I have no idea. I was suggesting there's a non-zero probability that you or any other woman would react violently and dangerously against a man.

It therefore seems sexist to assume the only person who can reasonably fear for their safety in an interaction similar to EG and Ms. Watson is the woman.

No you were saying that, based on that story, I should be seen as dangerous. Shall we recap? I was asleep, my drunk roommate came in and attempted to have sex with me, I yelled then fled, in following me he flipped himself over a couch and was subdued.

But you think I must be lying, that I could not have been the innocent victim. So you must have some idea of where I went wrong. Please elaborate.
 
It was a dark and stormy night. Bookitty, returning home after trawling all the deadbeat bars in her town, opens the door to find the innocent 19 year old hitchhiker she has duct-taped to the headboard. He looks up at her with terrified, limpid pools of watery eyes, fearfully begging to be set free - released from this harrowing den of inquity.

Bookitty slaps him firmly across the face with the flat of her hand 'That! Is for all the women you have ever deigned to approach in elevators!' *Smack!* 'That! Is for all times you made me feel uncomfortable merely by looking at me!'

He whimpers, unable to articulate that he never meant to sexualize or objectify anyone. Merely, he is socially awkward and regularly uses that as his excuse for his ill-thought out and creepy advances.

Bookitty searches across the room and seizes upon an antique imperial jade carved Buddha, signed by Xing-Tzu, a famous jade carver from the Wu-Tang dynasty. Her grandmother had presented this to Bookitty several years ago, explaining that the density of the jadeite crystals in the imperial jade Buddha were not only more pleasing to the eye, but were much more efficient for braining hopeless dorky men than the lesser-valued muttonfat jade versions.

Taking aim, hoping merely to mock a bit of sense into him and draw only a faint spatter of blood (so as not to damage her 1200 thread count Eygptian Cotton sheets from Bed Bath & Beyond) she deftly swings the jade buddha at the hapless man's head. A perfectly timed blow, merely knocking some sense into him and giving him a jaw that will crack at inopportune times later in life.

Ripping the duct tape from his face & head, Boo throws the stumbling geek out into the rainy bleak streets of small town California. Her parting words: 'Next time, make it a Caramel Macchiato, punk.'

The End.

Did I nail it? Or am I perhaps reading in too much?

(Not inserting an ironic smiley - although you can treat this reply with the same seriousness as you would the picture of a kitten, or a tollhouse cookie recipe).

Actually I think Ivor's version goes something like

After living in the same house for over a year, the poor lad, driven crazy by the nearness of unattainable vagina realized that marital rights meant something. As she was not respecting those rights, he gently reminded her. Because she (and every other woman and goddammit these whores are expensive!) are poon-withholding tramps, she did not take well to his suggestion that he just let her borrow it for a few minutes.

So she set up a Rube Goldberg contraption (Rope across the doorway, couch angled just so, Jade Buddha of doom [handed down to generations of muffdeniers] placed on carefully painted bulls-eye. Across the room, a mannequin dressed provocatively and flashing a engorged vulva. [because she wouldn't even use her own, amiright? like its lined with gold I tell you]) The fiendish trap set, she called to him gently with the well-known Tennessee hog call "Soooo-eeeee."

He fell, the rest is history.
 
No you were saying that, based on that story, I should be seen as dangerous. Shall we recap? I was asleep, my drunk roommate came in and attempted to have sex with me, I yelled then fled, in following me he flipped himself over a couch and was subdued.

But you think I must be lying, that I could not have been the innocent victim. So you must have some idea of where I went wrong. Please elaborate.

I'm pretty sure I implied you might be lying.

Anyway, I'm off to bed. Have a pleasant evening.

Goodnight.
 
Actually I think Ivor's version goes something like

After living in the same house for over a year, the poor lad, driven crazy by the nearness of unattainable vagina realized that marital rights meant something. As she was not respecting those rights, he gently reminded her. Because she (and every other woman and goddammit these whores are expensive!) are poon-withholding tramps, she did not take well to his suggestion that he just let her borrow it for a few minutes.

So she set up a Rube Goldberg contraption (Rope across the doorway, couch angled just so, Jade Buddha of doom [handed down to generations of muffdeniers] placed on carefully painted bulls-eye. Across the room, a mannequin dressed provocatively and flashing a engorged vulva. [because she wouldn't even use her own, amiright? like its lined with gold I tell you]) The fiendish trap set, she called to him gently with the well-known Tennessee hog call "Soooo-eeeee."

He fell, the rest is history.

Well at least now we're getting nearer to the truth.

:D
 
Hey look, science!

Stuff this nonsense! Men must be allowed to expect to be able to preposition women they don't know for sex in any situation, regardless of women's feelings. And if the women are creeped out, they should keep it to themselves at least!
 
Not being able to apprehend that other people's experiences, expectations, agency and/or feelings can differ from one's own, when there is no ASD to explain it, should be a cause for concern.

I don't think we're discussing the ability of people to be empathic or not, but to what degree our "reading" of the situation is reliable. From personal experience, people are very, very often wrong about their assumptions concerning what other people feel / think.
 
People with ASD or Asperger's are excused to some extent because it is one of the things that can be a challenge with an ASD (although ca 75% of people with ASDs develop it normally and most others can understand the concept on a theoretical level - my autistic nephew understands that other people don't feel or think like him all the time, the same way he understands how a radio transmitter works or that Pluto isn't a planet any more, even though to him it still is.)
ASD isn't it though. I mean maybe for elevator guy but it takes a quick five second Google search to find that a large part of it is male self entitlement in general. I've seen a forum literally blow up in on itself because multiple people called out its owner and moderators for literally letting someone make a game out of raping women and try to justify it in a weird and bizarre way. Then we have someone who in response to actually chasing women away from their software package named pantyshot and upskirt sneakily decided to name it after something slightly better than animated child porn and then got self indignant after someone realized his snide little trick.
http://www.zdnet.com/blog/violetblue/when-software-offends-the-pantyshot-package-controversy/509
 
Last edited:
Stopped using your mobile phone while driving yet?

:)
I rarely ever use my cell while driving. I only use it when there is no traffic near my car and I'm really tight on time.

When I was 16, my boyfriend was killed in a car accident. I've been a fanatic about vehicle safely ever since. The crash tests are the first thing I consider when buying a new car. I have gotten in a car in Mexico City and Lima Peru that didn't have seat belts but that's one of those trade offs if you want to travel in foreign countries. So I do consider the tradeoff when making risk decisions.
 
I rarely ever use my cell while driving. I only use it when there is no traffic near my car and I'm really tight on time.

When I was 16, my boyfriend was killed in a car accident. I've been a fanatic about vehicle safely ever since. The crash tests are the first thing I consider when buying a new car. I have gotten in a car in Mexico City and Lima Peru that didn't have seat belts but that's one of those trade offs if you want to travel in foreign countries. So I do consider the tradeoff when making risk decisions.

That is utterly ridiculous. There's no reason to be worried about cars for goodness sake. I travel a lot and I don't drive, so I've been in many, many cars where I had no control over the situation and it was no problem. I've been in taxis in Italy, Morocco, bad parts of US cities. If they drive poorly, I just laugh it off. I'm telling the women reading this post, don't believe it. I've been in hundreds of cars in foreign countries and it is not something to fear.

The bottom line remains, you have a perception of how dangerous cars are that I'm telling you is inconsistent with my experience. You aren't the only one with your perception. Lots of people think the world is scarier than it is as well.
 
I don't think we're discussing the ability of people to be empathic or not, but to what degree our "reading" of the situation is reliable. From personal experience, people are very, very often wrong about their assumptions concerning what other people feel / think.
There is the issue of empathy, but empathy is not the best response for every situation. As an extreme example, I don't think I need to have empathy for serial murderers.

In the elevator situation, why must the empathy favor RW? Is it possible EG is the one who was reasonable, polite, and unthreatening while RW was expressing a bit of narcissistic over-reacting?
 
I don't think we're discussing the ability of people to be empathic or not, but to what degree our "reading" of the situation is reliable. From personal experience, people are very, very often wrong about their assumptions concerning what other people feel / think.

And here's a crazy idea - when the assumption is that women should be approached in elevators, the science indicates that using a throw-away line to pick up women has a very low chance of success. While the responses to Watson's rather mild video suggest that doing so might even offend. Offended people who have just rejected you are less likely to give you a chance in the future.

This tactic has a better chance of permanently reducing your accessible dating pool by one then it does at providing any mutually beneficial relationship. A different approach might be in order.
 
Last edited:
That is utterly ridiculous. There's no reason to be worried about cars for goodness sake. I travel a lot and I don't drive, so I've been in many, many cars where I had no control over the situation and it was no problem. I've been in taxis in Italy, Morocco, bad parts of US cities. If they drive poorly, I just laugh it off. I'm telling the women reading this post, don't believe it. I've been in hundreds of cars in foreign countries and it is not something to fear.

The bottom line remains, you have a perception of how dangerous cars are that I'm telling you is inconsistent with my experience. You aren't the only one with your perception. Lots of people think the world is scarier than it is as well.

I see what you did there.
 
And here's a crazy idea - when the assumption is that women should be approached in elevators, the science indicates that using a throw-away line to pick up women has a very low chance of success. While the responses to Watson's rather mild video suggest that doing so might even offend. Offended people who have just rejected you are less likely to give you a chance in the future.

This tactic has a better chance of permanently reducing your accessible dating pool by one then it does at providing any mutually beneficial relationship. A different approach might be in order.

It's sad that you have to explain this.
 
It's sad that you have to explain this.

Tragically so.

But there's a pretty clear dynamic at work behind the failure to understand, and it's a simple lack of empathy. The complainant requested that men whom she doesn't know not follow her alone into an elevator and proposition her for sex because it makes her uncomfortable. This is a rather simple request, it was worded amiably, and simply complying with it would in practice inconvenience no one...considering that we're talking about not some complete random stranger, but ostensibly a like-minded person who wants to attend the same skeptic and atheist meetings we do.

But this didn't happen; what we got instead was a whole litany of special reasons and rationalizations for why complying with Watson's request would place an undue hardship on us:

- The scenario makes only a minority of women uncomfortable, so their concerns can be safely ignored (argument from popularity; remember this one next time you read an news item about a school having a prayer during a graduation commencement).

- The scenario wouldn't make me uncomfortable, therefore the ones who are uncomfortable must be thinking unreasonably, so they can be safely ignored. (non sequitur)

- If we agree to refrain from following women who don't know us alone into elevators and propositioning them for sex, logically we somehow therefore are forced to also NEVER ride alone with women in elevators at any time, and/or NEVER talk to any women ever, and/or NEVER ask for sex from any woman under any circumstances whatsoever (yes, people actually made these assertions, and yes they are all excluded middle fallacies)

- The complainant's discomfort reveals what I consider to be a less-than-enlightened view of human sexual politics, no matter how widely held; therefore, her discomfort can be safely ignored (argument from authority)

- The payoff of a possible sex act in case a woman accepts the proposition, however unlikely, is desirable enough to offset the risk of causing any number of women who take offense to avoid me entirely in the future; therefore the fact that anyone feels uncomfortable is irrelevant (argument from a douchebag)
 
That is utterly ridiculous. There's no reason to be worried about cars for goodness sake. I travel a lot and I don't drive, so I've been in many, many cars where I had no control over the situation and it was no problem. I've been in taxis in Italy, Morocco, bad parts of US cities. If they drive poorly, I just laugh it off. I'm telling the women reading this post, don't believe it. I've been in hundreds of cars in foreign countries and it is not something to fear.

The bottom line remains, you have a perception of how dangerous cars are that I'm telling you is inconsistent with my experience. You aren't the only one with your perception. Lots of people think the world is scarier than it is as well.
I'm guessing the concept of real risk vs risk perception is a new concept for you. Is that correct?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom