TraneWreck
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2008
- Messages
- 7,929
Oh god.
The elevator is a factor that increases apprehension. When concerned about another person, for whatever reason, being trapped in an enclosed space with them will heighten that concern.
I really, really do not understand why we have to have an argument about this. How is this even controversial?
Right, I'm sexist because I respect the opinion of a woman. THat's a new one.
Recall that I've said multiple times that I also accept and think you're perfectly justified in not feeling upset in such a situation.
I gave you a link to a letter that has been signed by around 100 women (last time I checked). Unlike you, I do not discount their opinion because it doesn't match my life experience.
You are the one dismissing and condescending to women. There is a not at all subtle sexism contained in your persistent victim blaming.
I expect nothing. If you say you aren't scared, I accept it, I don't tell you how you should feel. When a woman describes her apprehension in that situation, I look into it, find that it's a very reasonable position, and defend her perception of the world. I don't ignore people that have different life experiences from my own.
Again, just because you experienced no fear and weren't attacked or whatever you're talking about, that doesn't mean all people will share your experience. THere is a reason why so many abuse victims are supporting Watson.
Why do you feel no shame when you dismiss their opinions so brazenly?
That's because they aren't. An elevator at 5am with a strange man propositioning a lone woman for sex, however, why don't you find me the stats on that?
Again, you just cannot engage in this discussion ethically. You have to PERPETUALLY eliminate relevant facts to make it seem like I'm saying something different.
I don't know why I keep explaining these things, there is a 100% chance you will ignore this as well, but here goes.
1) We start with an interpersonal confrontation. A man walks up to a woman and propositions her, they have no prior contact.
Let's add in the relevant information bit by bit and see how it affects the situation.
2) The proposition takes place an elevator. The woman cannot leave immediately, and even if the door is opened, the man is in a position to hamper her movement if something unfortunate occurs. This increases the apprehension.
3) It's 4 in the morning, and they just left a bar. Now she has to wonder about how much this guy drank, if anyone will wake up if she screams. This adds to the apprehension.
4) This guy was at the bar with her and at her talk where she explicitly said she doesn't like to be hit on at atheist conferences. Probably a strange request, but in addition to the fact that this man already ignored her when she said she was going to bed, he doesn't have a great record of listening to her requests. What will he do if she turns him down on the elevator? Adds to the apprehension.
5) The woman is American, but this is taking place in Dublin. There is nothing uniquely unsafe about Dublin, but her unfamiliarity with the system increases her stress. IF something happens, who does she call? Apprehension increased.
And so on.
All you're doing is ignoring #1 and taking each of the other elements as individuals, for some bizarre reason thinking that I'm making claims about them in isolation. WHAT YOU THINK ELEVATORS ARE DANGEROUS!?!?! YOU THINK DUBLIN IS DANGEROUS!?!?!
These are all factors that alter the perception of the event listed in #1. Everytime you try to engage these factors while ignoring #1, you make a totally pointless argument. This is roughly the 55th example of that.
For once, I would like to see you accurately represent my position when responding to it. If you can do just that, I would be more likely to think you understood it.
You are the one being sexist. You are casually and mockingly dismissing the perception and opinion of women expressing their concern about this and similar situations. Because you have lived a blessed life free of these disgusting incidents, you think everyone has. This isn't true. I refuse to ignore the opinions of victims and other women because someone on the internet says she's never been harmed.
And again, the point is not to suggest that you should FEEL like these other women, just that you should respect their position on this matter.
Nor have I ever suggested such. Notice how you're ignoring #1 again to perpetuate this ridiculous position you've taken?
Yes, if a woman is alone in an office building with a strange man who is propositioning her, I doubt the environment will make much of a difference. There might be a slightly better chance of getting away, or getting behind a closed door, but fundamentally the dynamic will be the same.
Hell, if a stranger walked up to a woman in an office building in some situation where they were isolated and propositioned her, my guess is that, on average, she would have more reason to be scared (same goes with men). We expect to see strangers in hotels (though we do expect they behave better than EG). A random accosting of someone in an office building would reasonably cause a great many people fright.
Again, ignore #1 to make your point.
Let's also notice that the relevant statistics, experts on abuse, abuse victims, and people involved in working on these issues on almost every level disagree with you.
Seriously? So because she wasn't scared in a place where a lot of people were around and EG wasn't approaching her, she shouldn't be scared in a place where no one is around and EG is approaching her.
Just...amazing.
Of which you've provided none, save your personal experience.
Again, notice how you shave away all relevant information to make this case. It wasn't just two people standing in an elevator. Your constant need to create strawmen does not reflect well on your argument.
And if something had happened to you (believe me, I am very glad nothing did), the same people you find yourself allied with in this condemnation of Watson would be condescending and blaming you for whatever happened, like they would be blaming Watson for getting in the elevator if she was assaulted.
Lot's of women go to dangerous places and really bad stuff does happen. That claim was so vague it's impossible to say anything usefull about it. You went to someplace where someone said it was "dangerous," you weren't harmed, therefore Rebecca Watson and the many, many people who have validated her apprehension with their own stories should all be disregarded. Not a powerful claim.
There wasn't a rapist in this case. You're drifting.
You know enough to say, with certainty, that all of these people are sexist fools, like me:
http://almostdiamonds.blogspot.com/2011/07/letter-to-professor-dawkins-from.html
It's really sort of odd to witness an otherwise progressive and clearly very intelligent woman parrotting the "reverse sexism" language of the loathesome Men's Rights Movement. Sometimes it's worth taking a glance to see where you've set up your tent.
But again, you're just shaving away relevant information. That's such a useless comparison that even if there were statistics, they wouldn't be of much use.
What are your odds of being assaulted when you're alone in the elevator with a man you've never met who's coming on to you? Does that even matter?
My chance of being randomly shot on the street is pretty low, but I'm not crazy if I feel apprehension when someone walks up to me late at night with his hand in his pocket and starts behaving oddly.
Right, this is a nonsensical strawman. This entire post of yours is a series of invalid comparisons, poor interpretations of my argument, and flimsy strawmen. But sure, let's check the stats:
And again, my perception in this means very little. I recognize that my life experience is very different from that of women who would express concern in that situation. One sign of maturity and intellectual competence is the ability to evaluate someone elses argument without perpetual reference to oneself.
I'm trying to tease out the elements that made your comments sound sexist to me. Had you just said certain encounters might cause reasonable fear, that would have made sense. Had EG been threatening, we would be having a different conversation. But you identified a place that should not have any more of a special contribution of fear to the encounter than most other places.
The elevator is a factor that increases apprehension. When concerned about another person, for whatever reason, being trapped in an enclosed space with them will heighten that concern.
I really, really do not understand why we have to have an argument about this. How is this even controversial?
You accept Rebecca's version of a woman's 'feeling about the elevator incident', but when I tell you that I perceive sexism in your view of the vulnerable woman in the elevator you don't get why I do. Instead of thinking about why I perceive that sexism, you deny you have it and go on and on justifying your view.
Right, I'm sexist because I respect the opinion of a woman. THat's a new one.
Recall that I've said multiple times that I also accept and think you're perfectly justified in not feeling upset in such a situation.
I gave you a link to a letter that has been signed by around 100 women (last time I checked). Unlike you, I do not discount their opinion because it doesn't match my life experience.
You are the one dismissing and condescending to women. There is a not at all subtle sexism contained in your persistent victim blaming.
Once you experience this kind of 'expectation sexism', you become more attuned to recognizing it. There are real physical differences between men and women. But then there are the implications of those real differences where the prejudice can be wrongly injected. And if that prejudice is subtle, it isn't always easy to recognize. I can't tell you how many times someone was certain I was embarking on a venture that, as a woman, I should fear only to find nothing different than I'd normally find anywhere that was not considered worrisome.
I expect nothing. If you say you aren't scared, I accept it, I don't tell you how you should feel. When a woman describes her apprehension in that situation, I look into it, find that it's a very reasonable position, and defend her perception of the world. I don't ignore people that have different life experiences from my own.
Again, just because you experienced no fear and weren't attacked or whatever you're talking about, that doesn't mean all people will share your experience. THere is a reason why so many abuse victims are supporting Watson.
Why do you feel no shame when you dismiss their opinions so brazenly?
You have not established that hotel elevators (in particular an elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin) are dangerous places for women.
That's because they aren't. An elevator at 5am with a strange man propositioning a lone woman for sex, however, why don't you find me the stats on that?
You are basing your conclusion strictly on empirical evidence, meaning it seems logical to you but you've not examined the hypothesis beyond that. We agree a person can be assaulted just about anywhere and assaults have occurred in elevators. We agree women are often at a disadvantage physically should a man assault a woman. Where we don't agree is you singling out this hotel elevator at 4 am in "a foreign country" as a particularly worrisome place for a woman. That is an implication you are assigning to female vulnerability which is not warranted by the evidence.
Again, you just cannot engage in this discussion ethically. You have to PERPETUALLY eliminate relevant facts to make it seem like I'm saying something different.
I don't know why I keep explaining these things, there is a 100% chance you will ignore this as well, but here goes.
1) We start with an interpersonal confrontation. A man walks up to a woman and propositions her, they have no prior contact.
Let's add in the relevant information bit by bit and see how it affects the situation.
2) The proposition takes place an elevator. The woman cannot leave immediately, and even if the door is opened, the man is in a position to hamper her movement if something unfortunate occurs. This increases the apprehension.
3) It's 4 in the morning, and they just left a bar. Now she has to wonder about how much this guy drank, if anyone will wake up if she screams. This adds to the apprehension.
4) This guy was at the bar with her and at her talk where she explicitly said she doesn't like to be hit on at atheist conferences. Probably a strange request, but in addition to the fact that this man already ignored her when she said she was going to bed, he doesn't have a great record of listening to her requests. What will he do if she turns him down on the elevator? Adds to the apprehension.
5) The woman is American, but this is taking place in Dublin. There is nothing uniquely unsafe about Dublin, but her unfamiliarity with the system increases her stress. IF something happens, who does she call? Apprehension increased.
And so on.
All you're doing is ignoring #1 and taking each of the other elements as individuals, for some bizarre reason thinking that I'm making claims about them in isolation. WHAT YOU THINK ELEVATORS ARE DANGEROUS!?!?! YOU THINK DUBLIN IS DANGEROUS!?!?!
These are all factors that alter the perception of the event listed in #1. Everytime you try to engage these factors while ignoring #1, you make a totally pointless argument. This is roughly the 55th example of that.
I know you don't think I understand your position. Typically when any of us meets disagreement, we think, the other guy just doesn't understand what we are saying. And sometimes that is true. I'm not sure if you don't get what I'm saying or you dismiss it. I lean toward you dismissing it. You don't see yourself as having a subtly sexist attitude in this case. You see yourself having an attitude that evidence would support is valid.
For once, I would like to see you accurately represent my position when responding to it. If you can do just that, I would be more likely to think you understood it.
You are the one being sexist. You are casually and mockingly dismissing the perception and opinion of women expressing their concern about this and similar situations. Because you have lived a blessed life free of these disgusting incidents, you think everyone has. This isn't true. I refuse to ignore the opinions of victims and other women because someone on the internet says she's never been harmed.
And again, the point is not to suggest that you should FEEL like these other women, just that you should respect their position on this matter.
But you've not established that elevators are especially risky places where women should be particularly wary of being cornered by predators.
Nor have I ever suggested such. Notice how you're ignoring #1 again to perpetuate this ridiculous position you've taken?
My experience with hotel elevators in foreign countries as well as in the US makes me doubt your hypothesis and instead I see your whole 'dangerous isolated cornered woman in the elevator' to be subtly sexist. Women in elevators are not in any more danger than women in office buildings or wherever.
Yes, if a woman is alone in an office building with a strange man who is propositioning her, I doubt the environment will make much of a difference. There might be a slightly better chance of getting away, or getting behind a closed door, but fundamentally the dynamic will be the same.
Hell, if a stranger walked up to a woman in an office building in some situation where they were isolated and propositioned her, my guess is that, on average, she would have more reason to be scared (same goes with men). We expect to see strangers in hotels (though we do expect they behave better than EG). A random accosting of someone in an office building would reasonably cause a great many people fright.
Walking alone down a deserted street at 4 am adds additional vulnerability to me as a woman. Taking a hotel elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4am, does not add additional vulnerability to me as a woman. And given the words RW related EG said, she could be as annoyed as she wanted to be, but experiencing fear as you perceive it was not warranted given the information about the encounter we have.
Again, ignore #1 to make your point.
Let's also notice that the relevant statistics, experts on abuse, abuse victims, and people involved in working on these issues on almost every level disagree with you.
And if you add to this, the fact RW didn't find the hotel bar at 4am was worrisome, going on to claim the EG encounter should make RW fearful is a contradiction.
Seriously? So because she wasn't scared in a place where a lot of people were around and EG wasn't approaching her, she shouldn't be scared in a place where no one is around and EG is approaching her.
Just...amazing.
Unwarranted prejudice is not confined to minority opinions nor determined by vote. It should be based on evidence, not speculation.
Of which you've provided none, save your personal experience.
A woman can be assaulted anywhere. It's sexist of you to assign special vulnerability to the setting in this case. A deserted street at 4 am, yes, there is special vulnerability. Based on actual evidence, a 5 star hotel elevator at 4am in Dublin, the realistic additional contribution to fear should be minimal.
Again, notice how you shave away all relevant information to make this case. It wasn't just two people standing in an elevator. Your constant need to create strawmen does not reflect well on your argument.
I have a unique perspective of this particular prejudice because I've frequently ignored what was expected of me as a woman and tested the waters for myself. I've traveled extensively by myself in this country and in many other countries. Like I said, I have heard, "that is dangerous", time and time again from people who merely anticipated something was dangerous but didn't really have an evidence based reason for their anticipated danger.
And if something had happened to you (believe me, I am very glad nothing did), the same people you find yourself allied with in this condemnation of Watson would be condescending and blaming you for whatever happened, like they would be blaming Watson for getting in the elevator if she was assaulted.
Lot's of women go to dangerous places and really bad stuff does happen. That claim was so vague it's impossible to say anything usefull about it. You went to someplace where someone said it was "dangerous," you weren't harmed, therefore Rebecca Watson and the many, many people who have validated her apprehension with their own stories should all be disregarded. Not a powerful claim.
...There are not rapists hiding in very many hotel elevators. Every guy that hits on a woman is not out to assault her. Human nature just is not that bad.
There wasn't a rapist in this case. You're drifting.
So yes, of course my version of reality is not perfect. But you'll not be able to convince me I don't know enough about this subject making my perception of the world wrong by very much.
You know enough to say, with certainty, that all of these people are sexist fools, like me:
http://almostdiamonds.blogspot.com/2011/07/letter-to-professor-dawkins-from.html
It's really sort of odd to witness an otherwise progressive and clearly very intelligent woman parrotting the "reverse sexism" language of the loathesome Men's Rights Movement. Sometimes it's worth taking a glance to see where you've set up your tent.
As a critical thinker of course, should you find valid statistics demonstrating hotel elevators are the location for more assaults on women than say an office elevator, or the hotel bar, I would look at the data. But I suspect it is like much of the danger we hear about on the news, the frequency of reported assaults, murders and rapes without the perspective of a denominator often makes the world look way more dangerous than it actually is.
But again, you're just shaving away relevant information. That's such a useless comparison that even if there were statistics, they wouldn't be of much use.
What are your odds of being assaulted when you're alone in the elevator with a man you've never met who's coming on to you? Does that even matter?
My chance of being randomly shot on the street is pretty low, but I'm not crazy if I feel apprehension when someone walks up to me late at night with his hand in his pocket and starts behaving oddly.
I fear being killed or injured in a vehicle crash much much more than I fear an assault. That's based on what the data shows. How about you? Do you take vehicle dangers for granted while thinking how vulnerable women are with all those dangerous men in the world?
Right, this is a nonsensical strawman. This entire post of yours is a series of invalid comparisons, poor interpretations of my argument, and flimsy strawmen. But sure, let's check the stats:
http://reason.com/archives/2006/08/11/dont-be-terrorizedSo, according to the National Safety Council this means your one-year odds of dying in a car accident is about one out of 6500. Therefore your lifetime probability (6500 ÷ 78 years life expectancy) of dying in a motor accident are about one in 83.
http://www.rainn.org/get-information/statistics/sexual-assault-victims1 out of every 6 American women has been the victim of an attempted or completed rape in her lifetime (14.8% completed rape; 2.8% attempted rape).
And again, my perception in this means very little. I recognize that my life experience is very different from that of women who would express concern in that situation. One sign of maturity and intellectual competence is the ability to evaluate someone elses argument without perpetual reference to oneself.
Last edited:
