So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
blobru, count me among those who have changed. In that thread (whoa, eye opener!) I'm all for a bit of ribald fun. Now I'm all - no fun! no where! no how!

The weird thing is that Watson is also saying that. And a lot of the women who posted in that thread are no longer members of the forum. Some of the same women who wrote "Goin' to a bordello party at TAM this year! Awesomeness!" on their blogs/in comments have also hopped aboard the no fun bus.

It's almost like the last year has turned a lot of previously fun people into grumpy defensive people. So what happened?
 
I hesitate beating this dead horse, but there's a nagging need in me to get this subtle sexism recognized, if not by you, TW, then perhaps by one more person reading the thread who hadn't considered what I see that you don't.
You just can't look at this issue without shaving away relevant evidence.

No, the elevator is not dangerous on its own. It's not a panty-stealing aluminum monster. If you happen to be in the elevator with someone seeking to cause you harm, however, the elevator is a detail that enhances that danger vs. standing in the hall or being in a bar with lots of people present.

Why on Earth are you having so much trouble with this concept?
I told you from the beginning, your belief about women in elevators in foreign countries contains slivers of a sexist attitude that I recognize and you deny. RW only said she felt uncomfortable. That could be anything from awkward to afraid. You have attached "afraid" to her meaning. That alone is subtly sexist.

I understand you were not saying all women would be intimidated by such an elevator encounter. I understand you are, in your mind, only saying it was a legitimate consideration, and not saying women should fear elevator rides.

Sexist attitudes can be very subtle. People often know it when they experience it, but less often recognize when they express it themselves. You spent a lot of time trying to walk back your initial comments saying you only meant RW was justified in her reaction, yadda yadda. What I'm telling you is, you have a subtly sexist attitude that you don't recognize, even as you continue to explain your original meaning.

I'm trying to tease out the elements that made your comments sound sexist to me. Had you just said certain encounters might cause reasonable fear, that would have made sense. Had EG been threatening, we would be having a different conversation. But you identified a place that should not have any more of a special contribution of fear to the encounter than most other places.

You accept Rebecca's version of a woman's 'feeling about the elevator incident', but when I tell you that I perceive sexism in your view of the vulnerable woman in the elevator you don't get why I do. Instead of thinking about why I perceive that sexism, you deny you have it and go on and on justifying your view.

Once you experience this kind of 'expectation sexism', you become more attuned to recognizing it. There are real physical differences between men and women. But then there are the implications of those real differences where the prejudice can be wrongly injected. And if that prejudice is subtle, it isn't always easy to recognize. I can't tell you how many times someone was certain I was embarking on a venture that, as a woman, I should fear only to find nothing different than I'd normally find anywhere that was not considered worrisome.

You have not established that hotel elevators (in particular an elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin) are dangerous places for women. You are basing your conclusion strictly on empirical evidence, meaning it seems logical to you but you've not examined the hypothesis beyond that. We agree a person can be assaulted just about anywhere and assaults have occurred in elevators. We agree women are often at a disadvantage physically should a man assault a woman. Where we don't agree is you singling out this hotel elevator at 4 am in "a foreign country" as a particularly worrisome place for a woman. That is an implication you are assigning to female vulnerability which is not warranted by the evidence.

I know you don't think I understand your position. Typically when any of us meets disagreement, we think, the other guy just doesn't understand what we are saying. And sometimes that is true. I'm not sure if you don't get what I'm saying or you dismiss it. I lean toward you dismissing it. You don't see yourself as having a subtly sexist attitude in this case. You see yourself having an attitude that evidence would support is valid.

But you've not established that elevators are especially risky places where women should be particularly wary of being cornered by predators. My experience with hotel elevators in foreign countries as well as in the US makes me doubt your hypothesis and instead I see your whole 'dangerous isolated cornered woman in the elevator' to be subtly sexist. Women in elevators are not in any more danger than women in office buildings or wherever. Walking alone down a deserted street at 4 am adds additional vulnerability to me as a woman. Taking a hotel elevator in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4am, does not add additional vulnerability to me as a woman. And given the words RW related EG said, she could be as annoyed as she wanted to be, but experiencing fear as you perceive it was not warranted given the information about the encounter we have.

And if you add to this, the fact RW didn't find the hotel bar at 4am was worrisome, going on to claim the EG encounter should make RW fearful is a contradiction.


It's a detail that heightens the apprehension of someone inside with a person causing them to be wary.

Why do you think so many victims of abuse are concerned about this issue? Are all of these people just irrational idiots that don't understand how totally safe an elevator is?
Unwarranted prejudice is not confined to minority opinions nor determined by vote. It should be based on evidence, not speculation. A woman can be assaulted anywhere. It's sexist of you to assign special vulnerability to the setting in this case. A deserted street at 4 am, yes, there is special vulnerability. Based on actual evidence, a 5 star hotel elevator at 4am in Dublin, the realistic additional contribution to fear should be minimal.


I asked before and you never answered: Do you believe it is possible for someone to have a perception of the world that is at the same time 1) different from your own and 2) still legitimate?
It is my belief not a single one of us has the same perception of the world as any other of us. Our perceptions of the world fall on a continuum of being very close to reality to being very far from reality. How close those perceptions are to the real Universe is based on our experiences, our education and our critical thinking skills.

I have a unique perspective of this particular prejudice because I've frequently ignored what was expected of me as a woman and tested the waters for myself. I've traveled extensively by myself in this country and in many other countries. Like I said, I have heard, "that is dangerous", time and time again from people who merely anticipated something was dangerous but didn't really have an evidence based reason for their anticipated danger.

I've stumbled into a few dangerous situations. I'm not saying they don't exist. But for the most part, the best way I can describe it is, most of the world is a normal place. It's just like the world the average person is familiar with. People are people. With the exception of high crime neighborhoods, war and actively oppressive dictators, people go about their daily lives the same, over much of the world. There are not rapists hiding in very many hotel elevators. Every guy that hits on a woman is not out to assault her. Human nature just is not that bad.

So yes, of course my version of reality is not perfect. But you'll not be able to convince me I don't know enough about this subject making my perception of the world wrong by very much. As a critical thinker of course, should you find valid statistics demonstrating hotel elevators are the location for more assaults on women than say an office elevator, or the hotel bar, I would look at the data. But I suspect it is like much of the danger we hear about on the news, the frequency of reported assaults, murders and rapes without the perspective of a denominator often makes the world look way more dangerous than it actually is.

I fear being killed or injured in a vehicle crash much much more than I fear an assault. That's based on what the data shows. How about you? Do you take vehicle dangers for granted while thinking how vulnerable women are with all those dangerous men in the world?
 
Last edited:
blobru, count me among those who have changed. In that thread (whoa, eye opener!) I'm all for a bit of ribald fun. Now I'm all - no fun! no where! no how!

The weird thing is that Watson is also saying that. And a lot of the women who posted in that thread are no longer members of the forum. Some of the same women who wrote "Goin' to a bordello party at TAM this year! Awesomeness!" on their blogs/in comments have also hopped aboard the no fun bus.

It's almost like the last year has turned a lot of previously fun people into grumpy defensive people. So what happened?


Thanks very much for your reply, bookitty. (btw, I just figured out your moniker isn't just boo_kitty; also book_itty [you being a book dealer, you mentioned]; clever that!) :c1: :book:

As for the big change, I'm viewing it from afar; close up, must be even stranger, even more serious and, pardon me, just a bit hilarious. Maybe this year's TAM theme, instead of Don't Be A Dick, can be Don't Have A Dick? :duck: (maybe not)
 
I'm more a book than a boo and TAM 8 was my first. Sadness. I would have liked to have met IRL.

Hmz. OK - there was (I'm sure - unless the booze has finally gotten to me) a female poster here called 'Boo' and I met her at a TAM or a 'Skeptic Cruise'. Or at least I did in my mind...

Anyways - still not the point. You would be 100% safe from rape in a room with me. I was just pointing out that you implied you could 'NEVER' feel 100% safe from a rape - and I really think that is a little outrageous. Being in a room with a small person whom you could easily overpower. Being in a room with a relative. Being in a room with someone you know very well. I don't think it is healthful to continually feel threatened by something - especially when there are loads of situations where there is more risk of being struck by lightning or an earthquake. (No - I'm not saying ALL rapes are as rare as those two occurences - I'm saying that there are loads of situations you can be in, where rape is far less likely than those two things.)
 
Presumably. Would you consider bookitty, changing your name to prevent such confusion in the future? ;)
 
Hmz. OK - there was (I'm sure - unless the booze has finally gotten to me) a female poster here called 'Boo' and I met her at a TAM or a 'Skeptic Cruise'. Or at least I did in my mind...

Anyways - still not the point. You would be 100% safe from rape in a room with me. I was just pointing out that you implied you could 'NEVER' feel 100% safe from a rape - and I really think that is a little outrageous. Being in a room with a small person whom you could easily overpower. Being in a room with a relative. Being in a room with someone you know very well. I don't think it is healthful to continually feel threatened by something - especially when there are loads of situations where there is more risk of being struck by lightning or an earthquake. (No - I'm not saying ALL rapes are as rare as those two occurences - I'm saying that there are loads of situations you can be in, where rape is far less likely than those two things.)

I believe you. I believe that I would be perfectly 100% safe in a room with you and if I get weirded out at TAM 10 and I know where you are, I'll probably go stand next to you.

But until I know who you are, how would I know that you are safe?

PS: I know people who were in a room with a close friend or relative and now have the scars to prove it.

Here's an example that's kinda funny. When I was 19, I married my best friend, an English guy. We were roommates for about a year and there had never been anything between us. No flirting, no accidental lonely sex, nothing.

One night he comes home drunk, completely blitzed, crawls into my bed while I'm asleep and starts grabbing on me. I freak out, leap out of bed and start yelling at him. He yells back "Yer me wife, it's me right!" (which was weird because he had previously exhibited proficiency in positive pronouns)

I run into the living room, he chases me, trips, flips over the sofa like an ironing board going over a stair-rail, bashes his head on the jade Buddha my grandmother gave me and starts bleeding all over the place. Which calmed him down enough that I was able to boot him out the front door.

Yer me wife! is the catch phrase my galpal and I still use. ("Sorry, I can't make it to your BBQ." "But yer me wife!")
 
Thanks very much for your reply, bookitty. (btw, I just figured out your moniker isn't just boo_kitty; also book_itty [you being a book dealer, you mentioned]; clever that!) :c1: :book:

As for the big change, I'm viewing it from afar; close up, must be even stranger, even more serious and, pardon me, just a bit hilarious. Maybe this year's TAM theme, instead of Don't Be A Dick, can be Don't Have A Dick? :duck: (maybe not)

Funny, yes. Discussing this IRL has lead to much laughter. I've been calling it "Please, somebody think of the dorks!" and my husband is seriously wondering if skeptical guys are really that pathetic.
 
\
Here's an example that's kinda funny. When I was 19, I married my best friend, an English guy. We were roommates for about a year and there had never been anything between us. No flirting, no accidental lonely sex, nothing.

Out of curiosity, that sounds like an interesting story right there--if you don't mind saying, how is it you wound up married when (it sounds like you're saying) there had been no romance beforehand?
 
How do we know Bookitty is safe to be alone with? She may be a total nutter who whacks drunk men over the head with jade Buddhas for all we know.

Or are women less dangerous / more sane than men?
 
Out of curiosity, that sounds like an interesting story right there--if you don't mind saying, how is it you wound up married when (it sounds like you're saying) there had been no romance beforehand?

He wanted to stay in the US as the spouse of a citizen. We had been friends and roommates for a year and could answer all the questions as if we were married. At the time he was my best friend, the person who sat on the roof talking Kerouac and social injustice. I was too young to understand how hard it is to actually be deported and I didn't want him to be sent home. So I married him.

I still have the photos of our wedding. We were all paranoid about needing them so we staged some stuff even though it was just in an office building with two witnesses. There's even a picture of me kissing him, on the cheek.
 
How do we know Bookitty is safe to be alone with? She may be a total nutter who whacks drunk men over the head with jade Buddhas for all we know.

Or are women less dangerous / more sane than men?

Do you seriously think I would whack people with jade Buddhas? My grandmother gave that to me! I'm lucky it didn't get damaged the first time.

But let's say it's you and me and I have a more common weapon - the purse. You decide to kill me, I decide to not die. Who is most likely to win?
 
Do you seriously think I would whack people with jade Buddhas? My grandmother gave that to me! I'm lucky it didn't get damaged the first time.

I have no idea. You may be emotionally disturbed and only a few missed doses of medication short of having a violent psychotic fit for all I know.

I'm therefore going to be weary around you until I have 100% cast iron proof that you're not mentally disturbed and have no homicidal tendencies towards me.

But let's say it's you and me and I have a more common weapon - the purse. You decide to kill me, I decide to not die. Who is most likely to win?

If I'm bigger and heavier than you then that would be an advantage for me. However, there are many things which could swing the odds in your favour. E.g, you may have taken self-defense classes and be lethal at 20 paces with that purse and the contents.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom