So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
If I were going to be there, I know I wouldn't be getting on any elevators with any men, if only so I wouldn't take the chance of being subjected to some misplaced "humor" about it. Some have already bragged that they're going to seek out Rebecca and do this to her.

No, I'm glad I can't go. This would make me cancel. Climbing stairs is painful for me, you see.

Wise decision. I think it's best you not go.
 
OMG. In the name of all that's funny, please do not invite Rebecca to your room for coffee during TAM or otherwise jokingly proposition her. The joke is *already* tired, and I bet she's had to endure it a dozen times a day for a week. (And will continue to do so for the next six months.)

Or even better, don't bring the situation up at all.

I fear there will be a "Hal Bidlack"-style nerd swarm whenever she comes into the bar.

For those who don't know, or were never at TAM, Hal believed in (a) god (he would probably be most accurately described as a deist). For some bizarre reason, some of the dorks couldn't accept this, and leave it alone. Because they're "skeptics", don't you know. He hated being asked about it, and he made it quite clear to anyone who did ask that he didn't want to discuss it. But that didn't stop the creepers from swarming all over him on those occasions that he came into the bar just to relax and have a drink. Gosh darn it, they just needed to know how he could believe in god and still call himself a skeptic. And they always had "just one question" they needed to ask him, as if they had come up with some particularly clever question and his inability to answer it would cause him to reevaluate his entire belief system, and when he explained that he had heard all the questions before, they went ahead and asked their clever question, and it turned out....he had heard it before. Hundreds of times.

So creepers, don't swarm around Rebecca to make your "one unique and interesting observation" about the situation, because you'll find that it's 1) not unique and 2) not interesting, and will most likely result in her just leaving the bar. Discuss football scores, or science or the weather, just not "elevatorgate".
 
Creepers gonna creep. Perhaps your advice is intended for people that don't wish to be? :)
 
Or even better, don't bring the situation up at all.

I fear there will be a "Hal Bidlack"-style nerd swarm whenever she comes into the bar.

For those who don't know, or were never at TAM, Hal believed in (a) god (he would probably be most accurately described as a deist). For some bizarre reason, some of the dorks couldn't accept this, and leave it alone. Because they're "skeptics", don't you know. He hated being asked about it, and he made it quite clear to anyone who did ask that he didn't want to discuss it. But that didn't stop the creepers from swarming all over him on those occasions that he came into the bar just to relax and have a drink. Gosh darn it, they just needed to know how he could believe in god and still call himself a skeptic. And they always had "just one question" they needed to ask him, as if they had come up with some particularly clever question and his inability to answer it would cause him to reevaluate his entire belief system, and when he explained that he had heard all the questions before, they went ahead and asked their clever question, and it turned out....he had heard it before. Hundreds of times.

So creepers, don't swarm around Rebecca to make your "one unique and interesting observation" about the situation, because you'll find that it's 1) not unique and 2) not interesting, and will most likely result in her just leaving the bar. Discuss football scores, or science or the weather, just not "elevatorgate".

Sorry if this is a bit off topic, but-- I never cornered Hal in a bar, or spoke to him at all that I can recall, but he did get up before 800 people at the first TAM I attended and gave a "Why I'm a Deist" speech. That doesn't exactly give off an "I don't want to discuss it" vibe.
 
Last edited:
Sorry if this is a bit off topic, but-- I never cornered Hal in a bar, or spoke to him at all that I can recall, but he did get up before 800 people at the first TAM I attended and gave a "Why I'm a Deist" speech. That doesn't exactly give off a "I don't want to discuss it" vibe.

I know I've already opted out of this thread...

But I've spoken to Hal about his self-labelled Deism on a couple of occasions. He was very open and willing to discuss it. And, I was far from judgmental, I was curious about why someone would construct such an elaborate (and defensible) belief system.

So - again, another example of 'USE YOUR HEAD'. You wouldn't (or shouldn't) go up to someone and get in their face because they have a belief system you don't share. Polite inquiries to find out more about it, is most likely going to be quite acceptable.

And you probably shouldn't go up to a woman at a strange hour of the day, in a slightly strange location, without at least having the decency of introducing yourself first, and proposition them for a sexual interlude - or something that sounds like such a proposition.

Not an admonition - but if you do violate these sorts of norms of behaviour, then it is not unexpected that you get someone upset. And, except when posting on internet forums and being deliberately poignant, we generally don't run around trying to upset people.
 
Is there anyplace you are 100% safe from anything?

If you are this paranoid about rape, how do you get through the day?

There is no place that I am 100% safe from rape. This doesn't mean that I walk around bug-eyed with paranoia. Only that I keep a very low-grade watchfulness on all the time. It is habit and I am mostly unaware of it. If I am traveling alone (most of the time, btw) or in unusual circumstances, it might be a little more pronounced. If I'm being followed down a dark street, it might be kicked into high gear.

Sometimes it is influenced by outside events. When I was a bartender, there was a serial rapist who attacked 3 women in my neighborhood. I stopped walking home alone at 4 AM and got rides from co-workers.

If we look at statistics, that was silly of me because I live in a densely populated area and 3 out of roughly 100,000 people isn't a big enough number to get paranoid about, right?

You can't say that any specific circumstance is 100% safe because you can't find enough significant news reports. Statistics don't help.
 
...So here goes - I was thinking, if you're going to defend Elevator guy for just wanting a bit of fun and then being misunderstood and objectified, you can't really hold Watson's past against her.

Sorry, been off for a couple of days so catching up on a dogged thread which seems to have comfortably bedded down, more or less, and which perhaps I ought to let lie; however, bad, bad man prince ;) that I am, I feel I have to respond to this.

First, I haven't been defending [or attacking] Elevator Guy [not that you're saying I was, specifically] based on his past. Why? Because I know nothing about him, nothing about his past or his character. However, if I did, I would of course include it in the discussion. Past is always relevant in judging character. After all, that's what resumes are for.

The second bit: can we really "hold Watson's past against her"? Yes, of course we can. How else are we supposed to determine her character, the credibility of her claims [to now be a feminist]? While I'll concede that past isn't an absolute reference and that people can change, it's often a very good yardstick.

My past: I was a fan of the Skepchicks. Not a rabid fan. Tepid, maybe; though I did try to join their site about a year ago to express some misgivings I had with their "Bordello"-themed party, how it might be perceived whatever their intent was. However, when, as directed to by a member, I went to the site, since the relevant thread had been locked down and no further comments were possible, I didn't (and left with an extra misgiving about a seeming stifling of discussion once it had become critical). But still, no big deal; maybe just a glitsch. What did I know and who was I to question. I don't know them personally, don't really care that much, I'm not going to TAM. Let 'em sort it out themselves.

In this thread, I was unsure what to think at first. Made a few very lame jokes. Made a supportive point about the skepchick calendar not necessarily being a representation of the skepchicks themselves; that, outside of the context of the sexually-objectifying calendar, it was, imo, unfair to assume they always wanted to be sexually objectified. It's okay to be sexy sometimes and serious at others (I hope, else the propagation of the species is in serious trouble). Commercially sexy? Well, that's a bit risky. But people should be able to distinguish calendars from conventions, was my thought, as long as you don't intentionally go out of your way to blur the lines.

Then I watched the promo video, which I had never seen before, Tatyana and Professor Yaffle linked to. With the tag-line (among others): "hot chicks hit on drunk nerds". That put things in a, slightly and then some to say the least, different light. Way too many mixed messages. Even if it's 100% tongue-in-cheek -- and who's to say? -- they had chosen to market, not just some cheesecake shots in a calendar, but their site and themselves, as hot chicks who hit on drunk nerds. As if something like that has no consequences.

Well, guess what. It does. Your statements, your images, your past follows you around. And if you choose to live in the public eye, a thousandfold. The claim is now being made, apparently, that they've changed, that their leader has had a change of heart and in a breastmilkcurdling display of feminist solidarity the entire group has too. "Hey, drunk nerds, don't hit on us anymore, okay? And no more sexual objectification, either. It's not cool. Forget the promotional vids. Forget the images of us in butt-floss and push-ups telling you we're going to hit on you. We're all hard-core feminists now. Do not come near us in an elevator after drinking with us; we're uncomfortable just being approached by you; and terrified of being raped by you. So quit it."

Well, I'm finding this claimed transformation, this new... marketing strategy[?], quite remarkable. Maybe some others are too. Certainly, there must be some very confused and heartbroken drunk nerds out there. Can people change? Of course. But what should we think about the claim, especially as skeptics; how should we judge it? How: by the past record of those making the claim, of course. How else. Are the claimants accurate, honest, deluded, hypocrites? That's how we judge woo. And that's how we judge this.

Speaking ot past records, here's an interesting exchange from a year ago, from a forum community thread asking whether the Bordello theme was appropriate for a group which some had at least assumed to be skeptical feminists, a label that was variously shrugged or laughed off by those friendly with and speaking for the group. (apologies if it's not ok to link to FC threads in the public section!) It's interesting to go back and read it in the light of this whole affair, as proof of just how much people change, I guess. The thread was started by Noblecaboose, who had posed for the Skepchick calendar; her husband athon -- one the very best contributors this site ever had, imo, and who sadly hasn't posted since -- joined in. athon comments that Noblecaboose's feelings about the way the Skepchicks market themselves have changed; mr. ottle, a [male] Skepchick (and married to a Skepchick? apologies if that's wrong; congrats, otherwise), responds about how credible he finds Noblecaboose's claim to have changed:
You're assuming this [criticism of the Skepchicks' marketing strategy] is new. For some (such as Noblecaboose) it was a final straw.
This is the same Noblecaboose that posed semi-nude on the last Skepchick calendar?

So do we, as skeptics, ignore this because it's past, a whole year ago? Does it say nothing, just a minor event, as minor maybe as being trapped in an elevator with a coffee-serving nerd at 4 AM in Dublin, that we should gloss over? Or does it speak rather pointedly and unflatteringly to the credibility of those now claiming this radical change in outlook and attitude?

At least for this skeptic, that's not a hard question to answer.
 
Last edited:
Sorry if this is a bit off topic, but-- I never cornered Hal in a bar, or spoke to him at all that I can recall, but he did get up before 800 people at the first TAM I attended and gave a "Why I'm a Deist" speech. That doesn't exactly give off an "I don't want to discuss it" vibe.

That's way different than being swarmed by nerds who won't go away when you tell them you don't want to talk about it.
 
There is no place that I am 100% safe from rape. You can't say that any specific circumstance is 100% safe because you can't find enough significant news reports. Statistics don't help.

You would be 100% safe from rape, if you and I were in a room together. I would probably be slightly offended if you didn't feel that way.
 
Don't come near on us in an elevator after drinking with us; we're uncomfortable just being approached by you; and terrified of being raped by you. So quit it.
You would have a stronger point if you relied less on straw. This point of view has not been expressed--in fact it has been specifically disclaimed with detailed discussion. So why make it a centerpiece of a commentary that has some actual salient points in it? Disappointing.
 
Never attempt to have sex with a woman you don't know whom you've never spoken to before the attempt. I think it's a reasonable prediction that if you walked into the house of a woman who doesn't know you and asked her for sex, she would likely be "creeped out".

Exactly! The argument on all these threads is that some people get laid with very little or no previous introduction. Therefore (huge leap) it is always a good thing to do. Being called a creep for it is bad because at some point it has, according to anecdotal evidence, worked on a few occasions. The times that it did not work are inconsequential.

It's the numbers game (Keep hitting on random people until one is drunk, desperate, and/or horny enough to go for it.) except that most people who play the numbers game will accept some negative reaction as collateral damage. In this thread, they are adamantly denying even that much responsibility.
 
You would be 100% safe from rape, if you and I were in a room together. I would probably be slightly offended if you didn't feel that way.

Let's say we are both at TAM. We meet for the first time in the elevator. We are wearing name badges that have only our actual names and not our JREF avatars. You've been drinking, messing around with the guys and therefore act completely out of character when you jokingly say say "Oh look, I'm standing by all the buttons!"

Because it's still you, you see the look on my face, explain it's a joke and introduce yourself. I find out that you're Antiquehunter and immediately relax. *Whew!* The whole situation becomes funny and everything is ok.

For a split second, even though I could tell by your tone that you were joking about the buttons, adrenaline would flow. My muscles would tense, my fists would clench. Because I am working with a low-grade constant warning system, I would have an involuntary physical reaction to the perceived threat before I could rationalize it. This doesn't feel very nice. It makes me edgy.

It's akin to the feeling you get when somebody jokingly throws a fist at your face and then says "You flinched!" You know they are a friend, you know intellectually that they would never actually punch you in the nose, but you react. Afterward, you're a little pissed because the leftover chemicals from the event make you tense, it was a needless thing to do, and mocking you for a perfectly normal and expected reaction is stupid.
 
You would have a stronger point if you relied less on straw. This point of view has not been expressed--in fact it has been specifically disclaimed with detailed discussion. So why make it a centerpiece of a commentary that has some actual salient points in it? Disappointing.

Yes, good point. That's an impression from some of the exaggerated discourse spun off from the outcry over the elevator incident; definitely shouldn't be mixing it in if no one in the organization has. If that's the case, withdrawn.
 
Let's say we are both at TAM. We meet for the first time in the elevator. We are wearing name badges that have only our actual names and not our JREF avatars. You've been drinking, messing around with the guys and therefore act completely out of character when you jokingly say say "Oh look, I'm standing by all the buttons!"

Because it's still you, you see the look on my face, explain it's a joke and introduce yourself. I find out that you're Antiquehunter and immediately relax. *Whew!* The whole situation becomes funny and everything is ok.

For a split second, even though I could tell by your tone that you were joking about the buttons, adrenaline would flow. My muscles would tense, my fists would clench. Because I am working with a low-grade constant warning system, I would have an involuntary physical reaction to the perceived threat before I could rationalize it. This doesn't feel very nice. It makes me edgy.

It's akin to the feeling you get when somebody jokingly throws a fist at your face and then says "You flinched!" You know they are a friend, you know intellectually that they would never actually punch you in the nose, but you react. Afterward, you're a little pissed because the leftover chemicals from the event make you tense, it was a needless thing to do, and mocking you for a perfectly normal and expected reaction is stupid.

Well - seeing as we've met before (I think...?) that is why I said you should feel perfectly safe in a room with me. Notwithstanding my whacked-out JREF forum posts.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom