So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
Except she was talking about at least a broad spectrum of women as her follow up blog noted, and not everyone agrees EG did "sexualize" her.

I agree whole heartedly, if we include " want to have sex with someone " as a valid definition of sexualizing someone, then every person ever is guilty of it.

Sexualizing someone, and objectifying someone mean you don't care about their feelings. And someone who doesn't care about their feelings does not politely take a " no " answer".
 
Did you consider how many men have been robbed in elevators?

As someone who got into a fistfight with a mother daughter combo who wanted me and my older friend i can say the post your replying to is garbage.

I love, i just love the sexisim used to justify this, they are saying that any woman being around any man should fear. Come on people, either women are equal or get to be put on pedestals, not both. This isn't a Drow society here.

If i fear my neighbourhood, and walking around, i would be expected to take steps to alleviate my fear, move, arm myself, take a self defense class. Yet, the fear that every man could be a rapist requires all men, to react as if every woman is a rampaging fringe feminist , just in case she happens to be one, and would get offended by a simple question.

To everyone promoting this ask yourself a simple question.

If i felt that buttons were scary as hell, and people wearing them freaked me out. Should everyone else stop wearing buttons?

If your answer is yes, well i simply don't agree. If your answer is no, then you can see how one persons unfounded fear should not make everyone else have to change their lives.

This guy could have said a million other things that would have me on watson's side, but the way he said what he said, and the manner in which he said it, is the most polite way possible.
 
Perhaps we need escorts for women in elevators then. :rolleyes:


There is an exit. TW says "no exit". He didn't say no instantaneous exit. If you have to open a door, there is no exit by TW's definition.

And the funny thing is, where else do you talk about sex other than private?

If i am at a woman's house, i could just as easily force myself upon her as in an elevator, if she is at my house, the same thing, there is no need to do it in an elevator. So by this logic men should just never attempt to have sex because it might creep a woman out.

If anything an elevator is safer than most other places, if i were to attempt to force myself upon a woman at her house, after the bar, i could simply give her a fake name and leave. My chances are much less of being caught than if i try the same thing in a public place, let alone one that has a button that sets off an alarm that can be heard through the entire place.
 
Well, we've clearly entered the realm of absurdity (we've been there for a while, I suppose). All we've managed to accomplish is to assure ourselves that we will be asking why there aren't more women involved in the skeptical movement 10 years from now.

If anyone can provide an argument that doesn't involve a retarded analogy or an absurd strawman, someone toss me a PM, otherwise, later.
 
Last edited:
If i am at a woman's house, i could just as easily force myself upon her as in an elevator, if she is at my house, the same thing, there is no need to do it in an elevator. So by this logic men should just never attempt to have sex because it might creep a woman out.

Never attempt to have sex with a woman you don't know whom you've never spoken to before the attempt. I think it's a reasonable prediction that if you walked into the house of a woman who doesn't know you and asked her for sex, she would likely be "creeped out".
 
Never attempt to have sex with a woman you don't know whom you've never spoken to before the attempt. I think it's a reasonable prediction that if you walked into the house of a woman who doesn't know you and asked her for sex, she would likely be "creeped out".

Again , i refuse to believe you have ever been in a bar, sex without knowing the person is as common as nachos. And any guy who wanted to force themselves upon a woman is simply going to lie, asking for sex, in a polite direct manner is in no way indicative of a rapist mentality, and if someone feels this, i can understand they are creeped out by it, but this is not the standard reaction. And due to this asking everyone else on earth to modify their behavior because a small subset is scared by something silly, is simply not a sensible thing to do.

If i found the word " Checkmite" offensive, would you change your sn?
 
How often is it that a woman is assaulted in a lift while alone with a man?

How often is it that a woman is assaulted in a lift while alone with a man woul has just asked for coffee (for instance)

How often is it that a woman is not assulted while alone with a man in a lift?


What I'm getting at is, is the expectation/fear of attack actually justified in terms of numbers? As skeptics, surely we should run the numbers and see if any of this palava is justified.

Of course, obtaining the numbers may be tricky.
 
How often is it that a woman is assaulted in a lift while alone with a man?

How often is it that a woman is assaulted in a lift while alone with a man woul has just asked for coffee (for instance)

How often is it that a woman is not assulted while alone with a man in a lift?


What I'm getting at is, is the expectation/fear of attack actually justified in terms of numbers? As skeptics, surely we should run the numbers and see if any of this palava is justified.

Of course, obtaining the numbers may be tricky.

Please tell me the place where a woman can feel safe from rape 100% of the time, even if there are strangers present or she has been drinking.
 
I think it's a reasonable prediction that if you walked into the house of a woman who doesn't know you and asked her for sex, she would likely be "creeped out".

In that situation she'd likely be creeped out regardless of whether you ask her for sex or not, though, so it's not directly comparable.
 
I am starting to wonder if I am reading the question wrong. You can't know what?

The way I see it, consider the following situation:

A person finds a complete stranger attractive. Doesn't necessarily wants to be involved in an actual relationship, but is considering casual sex.

How is this person to know if the stranger is interested without, some way or another, asking ?

Now, as this scenario is transformed into involving a person you know more and more, sure, conversation might not be required to find out. But assuming that elevator guy was of that mindset, at some point he had to ask if he wanted to know.
 
Please tell me the place where a woman can feel safe from rape 100% of the time, even if there are strangers present or she has been drinking.

Fair enough.

By that logic then, we men can never approach a woman we don't know.


ETA:

I'm told I can't approach a woman for sex when she's in a vulnerable situation.

Now I'm told that all situations are vulnerable.


All I want to know is how rational the fear of being attacked in a lift is based on the frequency of attacks versus the frequency of a woman being alone in a lift with a man and not being attacked.


Does it happen about as often as being hit by a car crossing the road? (and I'll bet not many women are afraid of crossing the road) or is it practically a dead cert and no woman should ever get in a lift with a man.

I'll bet it lies somewhere between the two, but towards which end. How rational, by the numbers, is the fear?
 
Last edited:
Please tell me the place where a woman can feel safe from rape 100% of the time, even if there are strangers present or she has been drinking.

There isn't any. Now to turn that on its head: So what's so particularly bad about elevators?
 
Fair enough.

By that logic then, we men can never approach a woman we don't know.


Yeah, that pretty much sums up my thinking on the issue.

Letting women initiate all sexual contact is the only way to guarantee they're not creeped out by the uncertain and often bumbling advances of men.

However, from my N=1 study over the last 34 years this is not an effective approach, though I suspect other men's success may vary considerably.:)
 
...

If i felt that buttons were scary as hell, and people wearing them freaked me out. Should everyone else stop wearing buttons? ...
Since it is remotely possible to choke on buttons, it is perfectly reasonable that you should fear buttons. That should be obvious to everyone. :rolleyes:
 
What I don't understand is why she went to conference in Dublin to do a talk about how she doesn't like people hitting on her at conferences.
How is that different from this
stones.jpg
 
Last edited:
Please tell me the place where a woman can feel safe from rape 100% of the time, even if there are strangers present or she has been drinking.
Is there anyplace you are 100% safe from anything?

If you are this paranoid about rape, how do you get through the day?
 
Again , i refuse to believe you have ever been in a bar, sex without knowing the person is as common as nachos.

I don't drink; but it hardly matters. An elevator in a hotel is not a bar. EG did not approach Watson in the bar. So what happens in bars is irrelevant to this situation. In brothels, men pay women for sex; does that mean it should be acceptable for men to offer money in exchange for sex at any time in any place?

And any guy who wanted to force themselves upon a woman is simply going to lie, asking for sex, in a polite direct manner is in no way indicative of a rapist mentality, and if someone feels this, i can understand they are creeped out by it, but this is not the standard reaction. And due to this asking everyone else on earth to modify their behavior because a small subset is scared by something silly, is simply not a sensible thing to do.

Then don't modify your behavior, and simply accept that Internet video blogs describing you as a creep are a potential consequence next time you hit a stranger in a hotel elevator for sex

Wow, that was eye roll educing, do you have a real rebuttal?

It turned into a fairly good illustration of how dismissive you are of attitudes toward sex that you don't share, which in turn makes your stance on this issue easier to understand.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom