So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm a victim of trying to keep up with all the jillion threads on this topic, so I haven't read all of this one.


Given up trying to keep up. Just starting at today's now.

(You know that feeling you get, when you're lost and you start to think 'I'm sure I've seen that before. Recently...)
 
Oops.



I think we're so used, as "skeptics", of calling woo-woos dishonest that it's become a knee-jerk reaction.

The "conversation" part of your post was not in direct response to Sadhatter's question. If you rely on body language, then you don't actually say anything. In fact, that was the entire point. You then went on to say "that's why it's important to talk", but again, this is not relevant to the question. The relevant bit didn't mention conversation, as expected, so I don't see why I should acknowledge it.

Body language and communication are not mutually exclusive. When I said body language and then followed it with conversation, it's because I meant you can read a person's body language, while they are exchanging words with you.
 
All right folks - while its been an immeasurably fun and enjoyable 1500+ posts here, and in other threads, I hereby call a close to my participation. I haven't read anything new, exciting or controversial here that hasn't already been discussed ad nauseum. So... see y'all in TAM.

I will be holding viewings of some lovely etchings in my room. You may ask me for an invitation. If you dare.

But will there be coffee? :D
 
Body language and communication are not mutually exclusive. When I said body language and then followed it with conversation, it's because I meant you can read a person's body language, while they are exchanging words with you.

Of course. But again, that wasn't the point of Sadhatter's question, was it ? You can't know for sure without asking.
 
How about we just condemn cold propositions with no prior contact when a woman is alone in an elevator?

If we did that, at least 95% of the bruhaha, including this thread, would cease to exist. Which might be a good thing, but still...
 
Is this still going on? I'll bet RW is having multiple orgasms just from knowing we are talking about her for this long.
While I sincerely hope RW has many multiple orgasms whenever possible, I think it suitable at this point to the whole of the JREF skeptical community to please

NOT TURN THIS INTO ANOTHER FREAKIN' AMANDA KNOX THREAD!

Think of the bandwidth, folks. :deadhorse

By the way, my heart is still racing over Hope Solo. Thanks, Tatyana, for encouraging my early demise.
I will be holding viewings of some lovely etchings in my room. You may ask me for an invitation. If you dare.
Only if the coffee is top shelf, and served as Café Corretto.


Italian espresso with grappa, sambuca, or brandy.
 
I've stopped reading Pharyngula and Bad Astronomer. I can't take anything either of those men says seriously anymore after seeing them blow this out of proportion. I was never a fan of the skepchick stuff or Rebecca Watson because it seems like she is more about the chick than the skep, and I dread catching up on the last couple episodes of SGU for fear that this nonsense will have crept into that as well. If I have to hear Steve Novella say anything about male privilege or misogyny I'll puke and unsubscribe.
 
So the take home message for such men is to not talk to women at all because they will be thought of as "creepy" for being in an environment where they do have enough courage to express interest in a woman.

Which is the conclusion I came to around ten pages back.
 
Of course. But again, that wasn't the point of Sadhatter's question, was it ? You can't know for sure without asking.

I am starting to wonder if I am reading the question wrong. You can't know what? I got the impression that Sadhatter was talking about asking for sex, in general. In that case, I have never been in a situation where the intentions were unclear. He shows special interest in me, I show special interest in him. At some point, though he never asked for explicit permission, he would move in for physical contact and my physical response would say it's okay. At other times, the same thing, only I am the instigator. Maybe I am just not understanding the need to ask.
 
I have tried -- off and on -- to read the thread, but will admit I have not followed everything closely.

However, I think there is one major question -- the elephant in the room -- that everyone is ignoring: Where was Scrut when all this was happening? Does he have an alibi?
 
I am frustrated by the continued repetition that the very specific circumstances being spoken of in this instance must represent a blanket rule to avoid perfectly reasonable social interactions in elevators or elsewhere.

The only lesson I take from the original instance is that if you're going to lead with a request for someone to come into your room, that's personal enough that you might want to make sure they can walk away if they find that creepy.

If you're not jumping to a room invite as a first approach, it's difficult to get into trouble with this idea, even if you have trouble grasping it.

Why does it have to be considered more difficult than that?
 
Last edited:
Is there ever a time when that black or gay person plays their discrimination card when it is not justified? Do we assume it is justified based solely on their perception, meaning if you feel objectified (in this case) is that all the evidence we need to agree you must have been?

I'd go it a step further and say that straight folks have the same problem. THink if a gay man were to ask a straight man he didn't know was straight back to his room. And the straight man reacted like this, we would be rolling our eyes and saying " It was just a question man, get over it. ".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom