So there was this female speaker on an elevator

Status
Not open for further replies.
If someone was trying ruin your clothes by marking them with a permanent marker and you were doing your best to avoid them, rank the following areas in order from easiest setting to elude the ruining blemish to hardest:

1) a hallway
2) the playing field of Yankee Stadium
3) the inside of a sarcophagus
4) an elevator

Is your point that when the doors open there's a way out? That certainly changes everything, why, I'm sure any potential threat would gladly stand out of the way, let you hit the button, and kindly wait for the elevator to stop at a floor, let the doors open, then move away from the small exit to let you get away. They would then say, "time in," as they chased their target down the hallway.

No, it's an environment that doesn't restrict movement at all.
My point was clear, you are exaggerating the danger because it suits your version of reality. Now you are trying to justify the exaggeration. You needn't bother. Those of us who think an elevator (I'm going to make my description more precise) in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4 am is no more dangerous than the elevator in the average office high rise are unimpressed by your attempt to make the lift scary. And those who see the world as you do are already in the choir.
 
Indeed. On this I agree with you. There isn't a sure, quick exit from a moving elevator.
Perhaps we need escorts for women in elevators then. :rolleyes:


There is an exit. TW says "no exit". He didn't say no instantaneous exit. If you have to open a door, there is no exit by TW's definition.
 
My point was clear, you are exaggerating the danger because it suits your version of reality. Now you are trying to justify the exaggeration. You needn't bother. Those of us who think an elevator (I'm going to make my description more precise) in a 5 star hotel in Dublin at 4 am is no more dangerous than the elevator in the average office high rise are unimpressed by your attempt to make the lift scary. And those who see the world as you do are already in the choir.

You just can't look at this issue without shaving away relevant evidence.

No, the elevator is not dangerous on its own. It's not a panty-stealing aluminum monster. If you happen to be in the elevator with someone seeking to cause you harm, however, the elevator is a detail that enhances that danger vs. standing in the hall or being in a bar with lots of people present.

Why on Earth are you having so much trouble with this concept? It's a detail that heightens the apprehension of someone inside with a person causing them to be wary.

Why do you think so many victims of abuse are concerned about this issue? Are all of these people just irrational idiots that don't understand how totally safe an elevator is?

http://almostdiamonds.blogspot.com/2011/07/letter-to-professor-dawkins-from.html

I asked before and you never answered: Do you believe it is possible for someone to have a perception of the world that is at the same time 1) different from your own and 2) still legitimate?
 
Last edited:
I'm a victim of trying to keep up with all the jillion threads on this topic, so I haven't read all of this one. I'm not sure how anything in the original post by RW is controversial.

My summary of the original issue is that IF we want to create an environment where more women feel welcome, maybe it would be appropriate to dial back the flirting to only those you're pretty sure are game for it. If that cuts into your entertainment, tough. I care more about giving space to women than your desire to get laid.

On the topic of strident feminism, what-about-the-menz etc, this link pretty much summarizes my feelings (no, it's not my blog)
http://nojesusnopeas.blogspot.com/2011/07/three-reasons-why-gnus-especially.html

Basically, give feminists some leeway. They're the gnu atheists of the women's rights movement. And some of them have cookies.
 
Wait? People are still arguing that no woman should ever feel uncomfortable on an elevator with a strange man? Seriously?

You can get weird out by people. Being stuck in an elevator might make that worse.
 
*minor nitpick - you quoted me from Sadhatter, not Starthinker

Oops.

is flat out dishonest.

I think we're so used, as "skeptics", of calling woo-woos dishonest that it's become a knee-jerk reaction.

The "conversation" part of your post was not in direct response to Sadhatter's question. If you rely on body language, then you don't actually say anything. In fact, that was the entire point. You then went on to say "that's why it's important to talk", but again, this is not relevant to the question. The relevant bit didn't mention conversation, as expected, so I don't see why I should acknowledge it.
 
Perhaps we need escorts for women in elevators then. :rolleyes:


There is an exit. TW says "no exit". He didn't say no instantaneous exit. If you have to open a door, there is no exit by TW's definition.

Seriously, do you view this as a reasonable line of argumentation? I honestly had you pegged for someone capable of having a discussion without this kind of stubborn literalism. If you legitimately thought it was unclear and weren't just looking for a point to bicker about, you're welcome to ask for clarification.

Let me modify my statement: when an elevator is moving, there is no immediate exit. Even when it is stopped, a person can easily block access to the buttons, keep the door closed, stand in front of the lone means of escape. It is an environment that severly limits mobility.
 
Perhaps we need escorts for women in elevators then. :rolleyes:


There is an exit. TW says "no exit". He didn't say no instantaneous exit. If you have to open a door, there is no exit by TW's definition.

My point is that this exit, assuming you're alone with a rapist, is probably not going to help you, seeing as how he has all the time in the world to block your path, amongst other options. It's like saying a locked door is an exit.

I agree with most of what you said in this thread (a rare occurance, I know), but let's not take those statements too far.
 
<snip>

Let me modify my statement: when an elevator is moving, there is no immediate exit. Even when it is stopped, a person can easily block access to the buttons, keep the door closed, stand in front of the lone means of escape. It is an environment that severly limits mobility.

Right, so rapists lurking in elevators should keep their mouths shut so their potential victims don't get creeped out, try to escape and make the whole crime more difficult to commit.
 
All right folks - while its been an immeasurably fun and enjoyable 1500+ posts here, and in other threads, I hereby call a close to my participation. I haven't read anything new, exciting or controversial here that hasn't already been discussed ad nauseum. So... see y'all in TAM.

I will be holding viewings of some lovely etchings in my room. You may ask me for an invitation. If you dare.
 
I'm sure there are people who would be freaked out by any approach in an elevator. Shouldn't we accommodate them by simply condemning all interaction between men and women in elevators and similarly confined spaces, just in case?

Personally I can't stand elevators. To me, riding one with one or more other persons essentially forces me to abide other people standing in my personal space - a kind of space I value very much. That's not to say I don't like hugs, handshakes, temporary situations where I'm in close proximity or contact with other people for sundry reasons; there's just something about the forced intimacy and confinement of elevators that makes me uncomfortable about the situation in particular - not in an "am I about to be attacked" kind of way; just in a "Jesus, this sucks" kind of way. But if there's something I dislike more than riding in elevators with strangers, it's those strangers trying to talk to me during the ride. If I'm not already in conversation with a person when I enter the elevator, my riding experience consists of me staring up at the pretty floor number lights in stone motionless silence. Please don't try to talk to me until the doors open.
 
Right, so rapists lurking in elevators should keep their mouths shut so their potential victims don't get creeped out, try to escape and make the whole crime more difficult to commit.

We're drifting so randomly...

Recall that this advise is directed at men who don't want to be rapists and sexual assailants, like Elevator Guy, but are behaving in a way that makes a woman apprehensive.

Obviously these words are pretty irrelevant to someone angling for a rape.
 
We're drifting so randomly...

Recall that this advise is directed at men who don't want to be rapists and sexual assailants, like Elevator Guy, but are behaving in a way that makes a woman apprehensive.

Obviously these words are pretty irrelevant to someone angling for a rape.

" Would you care to join me in my room for coffee ? "

" No thank you ... "



Did anything really transpire beyond this ?
 
Wait? People are still arguing that no woman should ever feel uncomfortable on an elevator with a strange man? Seriously?

You can get weird out by people. Being stuck in an elevator might make that worse.

Here's the thing. If the person on the seat next to you on an airplane starts praying out loud you might be annoyed and feel uncomfortable. If might even bring to mind religious fanatics and terrorist attacks and make you feel anxious and threatened. It is not, however, religious intolerance or oppression, and it would be quite silly to discuss it as if it was an example of such.
 
Last edited:
Here's the thing. If the person on the seat next to you on an airplane starts praying out loud you might be annoyed and feel uncomfortable. If might even bring to mind religious fanatics and terrorist attacks and make you feel anxious and threatened. It is not, however, religious intolerance or oppression, and it would be quite silly to discuss it as if it was an example of such.

Providing examples of situations where a person's apprehension is either not justified or is not sufficient to request an altering of behavior from the party placing them in apprehension says very little about justified apprehension when a cessation request is perfectly legitimate.

Perhaps I've misunderstood your analogy, but no one is claiming an assault took place just like your example is not one of actual religious intolerance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom